Leaving EM

Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Get over yourself. What if an HCA grad, who is ABEM, applied? Would you crap on them? What about AOBEM?

We are not an island unto ourselves. Here's an analogy for you: North Dakota and Montana border. They have a lot in common, but, also, an individual character. You are saying they are completely different, and that's just not true.

Does your group have mid-levels?

Ofc we have midlevels. What profitable group doesn't?
 
Unless whoever is staffing the ed has a stream of bodies or wildly, grossly inappropriately admits everyone they see it's just a non-issue to the hospital system at large.
This begs the question

Is the improvement of patient outcomes for ED trained docs over non ED trained docs worth the cost of having ED trained docs?

This may be the fatal flaw with the EM specialty where 80% of our patients don't need to be there at all. 80% of the remaining 20% are simple cases that could be easily taken care of by a 1st year NP. 80% of the remaining 4% are complicated and really need a skilled emergency clinician, but not one who did four years of medical school and then 4 years of EM residency. Of the remaining 0.8%, the cases where it is the advanced skills of the EM doc which MIGHT make or break the case....how many of those are going to have a poor outcome regardless?

It is as the margins where the differences are made, like the early administration of antibiotics in sepsis. But really, how much better is 10 minutes versus 40 minutes?

But what is the cost to the healthcare system to apply that margin (a BC EM doc) to every ED compared to other ED providers (EM fellow trained FM, EM trained PAs, etc), and are the marginal benefits worth that cost?
 
This begs the question

Is the improvement of patient outcomes for ED trained docs over non ED trained docs worth the cost of having ED trained docs?

This may be the fatal flaw with the EM specialty where 80% of our patients don't need to be there at all. 80% of the remaining 20% are simple cases that could be easily taken care of by a 1st year NP. 80% of the remaining 4% are complicated and really need a skilled emergency clinician, but not one who did four years of medical school and then 4 years of EM residency. Of the remaining 0.8%, the cases where it is the advanced skills of the EM doc which MIGHT make or break the case....how many of those are going to have a poor outcome regardless?

It is as the margins where the differences are made, like the early administration of antibiotics in sepsis. But really, how much better is 10 minutes versus 40 minutes?

But what is the cost to the healthcare system to apply that margin (a BC EM doc) to every ED compared to other ED providers (EM fellow trained FM, EM trained PAs, etc), and are the marginal benefits worth that cost?

Most elective cholecystectomies don't need to happen.

Of those that do most could be done by a PA.

Of those that can't, they certainly cant be done by a new grad attending.

Does society need to bear the cost of training general surgeons?

See what I did there?
 
Most elective cholecystectomies don't need to happen.

Of those that do most could be done by a PA.

Of those that can't, they certainly cant be done by a new grad attending.

Does society need to bear the cost of training general surgeons?

See what I did there?
Yeah, ridiculous argument.

“Most people use the ER inappropriately. Therefore, the few people that REALLY need the ER should have to see people of lesser training.”

“Most radiology reads are simple and can be done by PAs. Therefore, the complicated and subtle findings should just be missed since it’s not worth it to have a radiologist find the needle in the haystack.”

You either want a system of excellence, or you don’t.
 
Yeah, ridiculous argument.

“Most people use the ER inappropriately. Therefore, the few people that REALLY need the ER should have to see people of lesser training.”

“Most radiology reads are simple and can be done by PAs. Therefore, the complicated and subtle findings should just be missed since it’s not worth it to have a radiologist find the needle in the haystack.”

You either want a system of excellence, or you don’t.

From your posts it seems like your a fellow SDG enjoyer.

Most people here have been so kucked by CMG / hospital employment that they're at the point where they think FM belongs in the ED, EM training is unnecessary, snd slinging z packs for $25 a pop is worthwhile work.
 
Most elective cholecystectomies don't need to happen.

Of those that do most could be done by a PA.

Of those that can't, they certainly cant be done by a new grad attending.

Does society need to bear the cost of training general surgeons?

See what I did there?
Yeah, you asked a slightly different question, and turned it into an argument.

What IS the difference in patient outcomes between a BCEM physician and other EM providers (Fellow trained FM, FM, EM trained PA, EM trained NP, dermatologist moonlighting, etc)?

I'm not arguing. Just asking a question.

Perhaps asking the same question on a slightly different but related topic: What IS the difference in patient outcomes between a 4 year EM resident trained doc and a 3 year EM resident trained doc?

If there isn't a difference, or isn't much of a difference, then I would argue that we should indeed consider we are overtraining for EM.

We all love Ketamine. But the outcomes show etomidate should be our go-to for intubation in sepsis, despite our concerns for adrenal suppression.

We should follow the data.
 
Yeah, you asked a slightly different question, and turned it into an argument.

What IS the difference in patient outcomes between a BCEM physician and other EM providers (Fellow trained FM, FM, EM trained PA, EM trained NP, dermatologist moonlighting, etc)?

I'm not arguing. Just asking a question.

Perhaps asking the same question on a slightly different but related topic: What IS the difference in patient outcomes between a 4 year EM resident trained doc and a 3 year EM resident trained doc?

If there isn't a difference, or isn't much of a difference, then I would argue that we should indeed consider we are overtraining for EM.

We all love Ketamine. But the outcomes show etomidate should be our go-to for intubation in sepsis, despite our concerns for adrenal suppression.

We should follow the data.

Great research question.

Lets do the same for Neurosurgery, plastics and cardiology. Whats the difference?
 
Yeah, you asked a slightly different question, and turned it into an argument.

What IS the difference in patient outcomes between a BCEM physician and other EM providers (Fellow trained FM, FM, EM trained PA, EM trained NP, dermatologist moonlighting, etc)?

I'm not arguing. Just asking a question.

Perhaps asking the same question on a slightly different but related topic: What IS the difference in patient outcomes between a 4 year EM resident trained doc and a 3 year EM resident trained doc?

If there isn't a difference, or isn't much of a difference, then I would argue that we should indeed consider we are overtraining for EM.

We all love Ketamine. But the outcomes show etomidate should be our go-to for intubation in sepsis, despite our concerns for adrenal suppression.

We should follow the data.
I can only tell you what I see from FM/other types of docs doing EM. They have problems with volume, acuity, balancing multiple critical patients at the same time, understanding Emergency conditions first then benign conditions later, and going the additional mental step to why did something happen.

I am not sure any of this could be quantified in a reasonable way. It would require an immense study (design, sample number, $$$). It would also be seen as inflammatory in the House of Medicine as well.

As for why 4 year vs 3 year, the majority of the 4th year is “elective” style education or ER leadership style education in the setting of a very advanced level ER. The majority of ERs in America are not this advanced. I see no need to “waste” a year of economic output for a doctor in this way. But that is my personal belief.
 
I'm sure your hospital system would benefit.

Will more money flow to the docs because of the savings?

Will you sign up for an NP to do your TAVR?

Just giving you real answers here from the perspective of someone looking out for the interests of a very, very large pie with many stakeholders, both docs and non-docs

"Will more money flow to the docs?" is not a question any healthcare executive asks, ever, in the history of healthcare. Anyone in an admin role can step in and tell me I'm wrong there, I'd love to be challenged on this.

the actual question is, and always will be, "will more money flow?" Of course, ensuring doctors are paid is a proper priority, but you're fully delusional if you think it's anyone's #1 priority.

And the answer to that question is what decides the future.
 
Just giving you real answers here from the perspective of someone looking out for the interests of a very, very large pie with many stakeholders, both docs and non-docs

"Will more money flow to the docs?" is not a question any healthcare executive asks, ever, in the history of healthcare. Anyone in an admin role can step in and tell me I'm wrong there, I'd love to be challenged on this.

the actual question is, and always will be, "will more money flow?" Of course, ensuring doctors are paid is a proper priority, but you're fully delusional if you think it's anyone's #1 priority.

And the answer to that question is what decides the future.

I'm fully aware that "will more money flow to the docs" is neither your's or administration's priority.
 
You're still not getting it

It's no one's priority. But yours. Only docs advocate for docs, in the same way nursing unions advocate for nurses--they don't care about you--and you don't care about them, unless I'm wrong and you go to their union meetings.

I'm not trying to antagonize you, it's just how things work. Be cautious of the hubris of "I'm an irreplicable part of the system", because that's the fastest way to get replaced.

If you feel you have irreplaceable value, you've got to show it.

I say that because I do worry about a future where cost-minded systems DO actually try to fully replace their ED docs with cheaper midlevels/AI and just eat the 0.1% zebra lawsuits along the way. There's a reeeeeal route to that happening, and it worries me.

BTW the best way to demonstrate value is to do what most ED docs would never want to do, and do some admin work/get involved with hospital work outside of ED dynamics/financials. I think one of the biggest weaknesses of EM, having seen it from both sides, is that EM docs love to be so invisible to things outside of their shiftwork they literally become exactly that--invisible
 
You're still not getting it

It's no one's priority. But yours. Only docs advocate for docs, in the same way nursing unions advocate for nurses--they don't care about you--and you don't care about them, unless I'm wrong and you go to their union meetings.

I'm not trying to antagonize you, it's just how things work. Be cautious of the hubris of "I'm an irreplicable part of the system", because that's the fastest way to get replaced.

If you feel you have irreplaceable value, you've got to show it.

I say that because I do worry about a future where cost-minded systems DO actually try to fully replace their ED docs with cheaper midlevels/AI and just eat the 0.1% zebra lawsuits along the way. There's a reeeeeal route to that happening, and it worries me.

BTW the best way to demonstrate value is to do what most ED docs would never want to do, and do some admin work/get involved with hospital work outside of ED dynamics/financials. I think one of the biggest weaknesses of EM, having seen it from both sides, is that EM docs love to be so invisible to things outside of their shiftwork they literally become exactly that--invisible

No. I get it.

I'm aware that everyone except pit physicians are tirelessly attempting to erode the perceived value of our work.

The funny thing is, the second any of these people find themselves in a situation where they need care, they demand a board certified physician, and want it NOW.

Rules for thee but not for me.

I refuse to participate in any effort that further cheapens our value.
 
That's excellent. Because I strongly encourage you--and anyone reading this--to do everything they can to have as much demonstrated value as possible.


I gotta be honest, when I first went into EM the "clock in, clock out" part was a huge sell. But I sincerely didn't know that when you become a cog, you have the value of a cog. When you leave, you don't take a huge patient panel with you. You don't take the entire ED with you in the same way a transplant doctor leaving might shut down the transplant service. They just find a new warm body to fill that chair, or an entire other group to do it if done en masse

So it's incumbent on everyone to show value, because you are 1,000% right that there is very active effort to erode the value of your work.


Of course, I'm well past the "bitch and moan" phase of my life. I'm very much in a "what can I do?" phase. Long term, getting ED physicians off the island that could sink any moment (with few noticing) and join the mainland--where we ALL sink or swim, together--is a priority for me
 
No. I get it.

I'm aware that everyone except pit physicians are tirelessly attempting to erode the perceived value of our work.

The funny thing is, the second any of these people find themselves in a situation where they need care, they demand a board certified physician, and want it NOW.

Rules for thee but not for me.

I refuse to participate in any effort that further cheapens our value.
You see a conspiracy to "erode the value of your work." Could it instead be a simple matter of those around you trying to maximize their own profits while being agnostic to the value of your work?
 
I say that because I do worry about a future where cost-minded systems DO actually try to fully replace their ED docs with cheaper midlevels/AI and just eat the 0.1% zebra lawsuits along the way. There's a reeeeeal route to that happening, and it worries me.
UPMC did it at my old hospital - NPs with no doctor in house. They have medical direction available 100 miles away. Honestly, I don't know what they do when a pt needs a tube or a chest tube, or need a joint reduced.
 
I don't know what they do when a pt needs a tube or a chest tube, or need a joint reduced.
I'm guessing they intubated, put in the chest tube, and reduced the joint.

Over the last 65 years healthcare has expanded and expanded, with our ability to "save" those who were once on the margins of survival growing tremendously. This is PART of the ever-growing expense of healthcare which now stands at $5.3 TRILLION (18% of our GDP) , including $2.18 TRILLION paid directly by Uncle Sam. And to remind you, Uncle Sam's credit card has a $40.5 Trillion balance.

We all know something is going to give somewhere at some time.
 
I'm guessing they intubated, put in the chest tube, and reduced the joint.

Over the last 65 years healthcare has expanded and expanded, with our ability to "save" those who were once on the margins of survival growing tremendously. This is PART of the ever-growing expense of healthcare which now stands at $5.3 TRILLION (18% of our GDP) , including $2.18 TRILLION paid directly by Uncle Sam. And to remind you, Uncle Sam's credit card has a $40.5 Trillion balance.

We all know something is going to give somewhere at some time.
NPs? I think you are giving too much credit!
 
Most of them I would agree with you as they haven't had training/education to do that.

But I know a few who are competent ED providers.

Paramedics do a lot of field intubations.
Uh, yeah, I know that. After all, I have talked at length on SDN how I was a paramedic before med school!

NPs don't get any experience tubing or placing chest tubes. And, I don't think (strongly) that they get any Ortho training.
 
Uh, yeah, I know that. After all, I have talked at length on SDN how I was a paramedic before med school!

NPs don't get any experience tubing or placing chest tubes. And, I don't think (strongly) that they get any Ortho training.
In a world full of absolutely useless NP programs, there are a couple of good ENP (emergency nurse practitioner) programs with reasonably good education.

Only a fraction of MD/EM education, but still pretty good.
 
I don't see any mention of NPs actually performing TAVRs. Only that they need to be aware of treatment options for AS and refer to structural heart team when appropriate.
got wires crossed, here you go


TAVI=TAVR
 
got wires crossed, here you go


TAVI=TAVR
If this can be done by a NP (not trying to start anything here) does it then highlight that maybe our medical education needs to be redone?

Wasn't there a place NPs were doing scopes? Give a 16 year COD player chat GPT and train him/her on scopes for a week at this point. My argument isn't that NPs or PAs are bad; I just wonder is all this training necessary for us then? I think the answer is no. I'd love to retrain into a different specialty because I am bored of EM but the road is long and hard to change track.

Honestly not trying to be edgy, sarcastic, or witty...just thinking about this alot.
 
UPMC did it at my old hospital - NPs with no doctor in house. They have medical direction available 100 miles away. Honestly, I don't know what they do when a pt needs a tube or a chest tube, or need a joint reduced.
NPs in ICU at night here, respiratory intubates, NPs ran SICU at residency did tubes and lines.
 
That's excellent. Because I strongly encourage you--and anyone reading this--to do everything they can to have as much demonstrated value as possible.


I gotta be honest, when I first went into EM the "clock in, clock out" part was a huge sell. But I sincerely didn't know that when you become a cog, you have the value of a cog. When you leave, you don't take a huge patient panel with you. You don't take the entire ED with you in the same way a transplant doctor leaving might shut down the transplant service. They just find a new warm body to fill that chair, or an entire other group to do it if done en masse

So it's incumbent on everyone to show value, because you are 1,000% right that there is very active effort to erode the value of your work.


Of course, I'm well past the "bitch and moan" phase of my life. I'm very much in a "what can I do?" phase. Long term, getting ED physicians off the island that could sink any moment (with few noticing) and join the mainland--where we ALL sink or swim, together--is a priority for me
Bro the cog part hit deep. That was the draw for me and is now the curse. I thought cool this will be great; how I realize what my position/value is.
 
If this can be done by a NP (not trying to start anything here) does it then highlight that maybe our medical education needs to be redone?

Wasn't there a place NPs were doing scopes? Give a 16 year COD player chat GPT and train him/her on scopes for a week at this point. My argument isn't that NPs or PAs are bad; I just wonder is all this training necessary for us then? I think the answer is no. I'd love to retrain into a different specialty because I am bored of EM but the road is long and hard to change track.

Honestly not trying to be edgy, sarcastic, or witty...just thinking about this alot.
Most physicians believe they are special because they spend 11+ years in school.

Medical education is overkill IMO. It should be 2 yrs of prereqs after HS, 3 yrs (18 + 18 months) of med school and 2-6 yrs of residency.
 
Most physicians believe they are special because they spend 11+ years in school.

Medical education is overkill IMO. It should be 2 yrs of prereqs after HS, 3 yrs (18 + 18 months) of med school and 2-6 yrs of residency.
Eh, to my thinking its not the actual hours that matter (although that makes an easy talking point). Its that as a result of that time we know way more and have much more experience.

The knowing more part might not matter for outcomes, that can be tricky to study. The experience is what really matters. We've seen more of the bread and butter and more of the zebras. That matters. Or, it would if we weren't such a litigious society and refer everything to specialists.
 
Eh, to my thinking its not the actual hours that matter (although that makes an easy talking point). Its that as a result of that time we know way more and have much more experience.

The knowing more part might not matter for outcomes, that can be tricky to study. The experience is what really matters. We've seen more of the bread and butter and more of the zebras. That matters. Or, it would if we weren't such a litigious society and refer everything to specialists.
I agree. Back in the day I could understand the need to be there to see it all but with all the resources at our fingertips do you need to be in the hospital to see every complication? I think this mentality of living at the hospital went back to the old days but doesn't make sense anymore. In the real world most complications get referred out. Why can't we learn from the NP/CRNA model and make changes.

I don't see any meaningful changes made by our end; however, I do think the NPs will continue to close the gap with more autonomy and procedures. NPs doing diagnostic caths was studied decades ago with surprisingly better times https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9326997/. Old studies I know but just a safe space to have these discussions. Apparently Nurse endoscopists are firmly established in the UK, with 350 nurses currently in practice as of 2009.

Could I with my MD work with a cardiologist and get trained on diagnostic caths and do this if I wanted to? Just rambling here but thinking about my MD experience and training yet I can't leave to do anything other than urgent care or go get a fellowship to waste more time. My NP left from the ER and now works in cardiology. Doesn't do caths obviously. Did it in a couple of weeks.
 
I agree. Back in the day I could understand the need to be there to see it all but with all the resources at our fingertips do you need to be in the hospital to see every complication? I think this mentality of living at the hospital went back to the old days but doesn't make sense anymore. In the real world most complications get referred out. Why can't we learn from the NP/CRNA model and make changes.

I don't see any meaningful changes made by our end; however, I do think the NPs will continue to close the gap with more autonomy and procedures. NPs doing diagnostic caths was studied decades ago with surprisingly better times https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9326997/. Old studies I know but just a safe space to have these discussions. Apparently Nurse endoscopists are firmly established in the UK, with 350 nurses currently in practice as of 2009.

Could I with my MD work with a cardiologist and get trained on diagnostic caths and do this if I wanted to? Just rambling here but thinking about my MD experience and training yet I can't leave to do anything other than urgent care or go get a fellowship to waste more time. My NP left from the ER and now works in cardiology. Doesn't do caths obviously. Did it in a couple of weeks.

Way too much academic gate keeping in the physician world.

An EM physician cant easily leave the ED to be trained to do endoscopy or cardiac caths but some Jenny McJennerson can go from adult primary care to ortho to oncology to pediatrics.
 
Way too much academic gate keeping in the physician world.

An EM physician cant easily leave the ED to be trained to do endoscopy or cardiac caths but some Jenny McJennerson can go from adult primary care to ortho to oncology to pediatrics.
Agree. In my area one of the NPs runs the largest psych practice with a 6 month waiting list.

Some of the data is interesting for primary care:
  • A Cochrane review updated in 2026 found little to no difference between nurse-physician substitution and physician-led care, but the authors note the evidence is uncertain. mcmaster
  • A systematic review of PAs concluded they delivered the same or better care outcomes as physicians with the same or less cost of care. lboro
  • A consistent signal across studies is more antibiotic prescribing and more test ordering: NP/PA visits were more likely to have an antibiotic prescribed than physician visits. chcf
The bread and butter - anyone can do it. But, for example, with the appy - use a guidebook and it's stepwise. The surgeon is needed when it's NOT run of the mill - when it's retrocecal, or there's a carcinoid. That's when you need the doctor.
This is the thing though, in the community most people do bread and butter; most remotely complicated things get shipped to the big houses.

On a different note Claude has been spot on 100% and sometimes helps provide interesting info that I might not have thought about. I double check it and it hasn't steered me wrong yet. I know the advances in radiology are finally getting some more radiologist seriously talking about the power of AI. All it has to start with is Chest X-rays, then extremity X-rays, move that to head CTs

I see a future where they replace us with AI triage nurses and have the RTs do tube, tele AI ICU do vent/pressor/abx management, and NPs do procedures. Small studies but becomes interesting.

Chest tubes
  • APPs vs trauma surgeons (Bevis, AJCC 2008): the authors concluded that use of advanced practice providers provides consistent and quality tube thoracostomies.
Central lines
  • Nurse-led line insertion, Australia (Yacopetti 2010): a prospective audit of elective CVCs, a nurse consultant versus anesthesia staff.
I guess to summarize everything:

As I sit here with years of experience, practiced in dozens of places; I don't see why 4 years of medical school and 3 years of residency was necessary when the NPs working with me do exactly the same stuff. The studies all point to proficiency is based on volume and how often you do somethin to be good at, not how long you went to school for. I am mad at NPs, but envious. I get it that they make less than me but with the resources at both our fingertips, the consultants available, how we do transfers/admissions/procedures, what is the ultimate difference? Was all this training necessary. I know there will be the "I work with DNP Jenny and you should see the stuff she does..." I get it, but the same variability exists with docs. Some of the docs I am surprised made it through residency.

Sorry about the rambling, not trying to be inflammatory, just been thinking about this stuff alot lately.
 
Agree. In my area one of the NPs runs the largest psych practice with a 6 month waiting list.

Some of the data is interesting for primary care:
  • A Cochrane review updated in 2026 found little to no difference between nurse-physician substitution and physician-led care, but the authors note the evidence is uncertain. mcmaster
  • A systematic review of PAs concluded they delivered the same or better care outcomes as physicians with the same or less cost of care.
Anyone who has worked in ANY ER for more than a month knows how laughable these conclusions are. Bad study and bad data. Like a study that concludes that the sky is green.
 
I think it is plainly obvious that a reasonably simple procedure like a CVL or a chest tube can be taught to anyone regardless of their formal educational background. I am sure we can teach middle schoolers, nurses, or a random EMT to do these. Repetition. Simulation. Hands on learning.

The more complex the procedure, and the more medical decision making branch points during the procedure, the more this falls apart.

The more the procedure has complications that a typical proceduralist needs to fix, the more it falls apart.

The more that you need to consider “should I do X procedure” the more you may need someone else making that call.

I think EM should absolutely be able to retrain into things like IR; I think some procedures that are heavily guarded for obvious financial reasons could clearly be redesigned and opened to others doing them.

Screening colonoscopy? In my brain it makes complete sense that an NP or PA who is trained to do them properly through some 6-12mo program could absolutely safely churn out screening scopes all day. I’m not sure the med school , IM residency, GI fellowship is required for doing a screening colonoscopy, but clearly IS very helpful in other things…
 
Anyone who has worked in ANY ER for more than a month knows how laughable these conclusions are. Bad study and bad data. Like a study that concludes that the sky is green.
I've worked in the ER for a long time. My conclusions on the midlevels aren't the same as yours. We can agree to disagree.
 
I think it is plainly obvious that a reasonably simple procedure like a CVL or a chest tube can be taught to anyone regardless of their formal educational background. I am sure we can teach middle schoolers, nurses, or a random EMT to do these. Repetition. Simulation. Hands on learning.

The more complex the procedure, and the more medical decision making branch points during the procedure, the more this falls apart.

The more the procedure has complications that a typical proceduralist needs to fix, the more it falls apart.

The more that you need to consider “should I do X procedure” the more you may need someone else making that call.

I think EM should absolutely be able to retrain into things like IR; I think some procedures that are heavily guarded for obvious financial reasons could clearly be redesigned and opened to others doing them.

Screening colonoscopy? In my brain it makes complete sense that an NP or PA who is trained to do them properly through some 6-12mo program could absolutely safely churn out screening scopes all day. I’m not sure the med school , IM residency, GI fellowship is required for doing a screening colonoscopy, but clearly IS very helpful in other things…
I agree and this is where I was going with it ultimately. I think overtime as the shortage narrative is played out more while the docs burnout more we will see more scope creep.

We consider ABCs to be the first thing to evaluate and the AB can be now managed by a master's level program that never went to med school or nursing school:
Average salary is 250 with it going all the way up to 400. In order to do this I would have to go get a master's and go through a 28 month program. You would think all this special training, the med school and residency would count for something in medicine if we want to do these other things.
 
Last edited:
I've worked in the ER for a long time. My conclusions on the midlevels aren't the same as yours. We can agree to disagree.
I have worked in the ED for a long time, do consulting work, still work in the ED and do leadership work for my group. If you think MLPs are equal to EM trained docs you either run an urgent care, are married to an MLP or are not seeing things.

There is data on the cost of care being higher when run by mlps. Outcomes will be trickier because there is not exactly equivalent patients being seen but I think the study from Mississippi showed that outcomes are worse at an overall higher cost.

What most rank and file docs dont get and what needs to be hammered to insurers are that MLPs cost them more in the end and if they dont pay docs the only solution will be more MLPs.

There was a saying on another group about how everyone thinks their MLPs are good and everyone elses are the problem. Its comical.

Non EM trained people do not belong in the ED either. I have said this forever. Me getting a transfer from a doc who has a patient with priapism and literally nothing was done. Said doc lets me know "I dont know how to do this". I asked about terbutaline before you know a 3k EMS bill.. "Whats that?". Yeah we are not the same. God only knows how many smaller mistakes got made because this person does not even know. "The eyes do not see what the mind does not know."
 
I have worked in the ED for a long time, do consulting work, still work in the ED and do leadership work for my group. If you think MLPs are equal to EM trained docs you either run an urgent care, are married to an MLP or are not seeing things.

There is data on the cost of care being higher when run by mlps. Outcomes will be trickier because there is not exactly equivalent patients being seen but I think the study from Mississippi showed that outcomes are worse at an overall higher cost.

What most rank and file docs dont get and what needs to be hammered to insurers are that MLPs cost them more in the end and if they dont pay docs the only solution will be more MLPs.

There was a saying on another group about how everyone thinks their MLPs are good and everyone elses are the problem. Its comical.

Non EM trained people do not belong in the ED either. I have said this forever. Me getting a transfer from a doc who has a patient with priapism and literally nothing was done. Said doc lets me know "I dont know how to do this". I asked about terbutaline before you know a 3k EMS bill.. "Whats that?". Yeah we are not the same. God only knows how many smaller mistakes got made because this person does not even know. "The eyes do not see what the mind does not know."
Lol, no association with any MLP or nurse.

We can't say the data is garbage when it shows equivalency in procedures and then turnaround and say it is good data when it shows we save a few more dollars in the grand scheme of things.

The place I work the only things the midlevels don't see are
1) high risk chest pain - what am I bringing to the table? STEMI, NSTEMI, dissection, PE. Serious question, not trying to argue but what has my training prepped here that isn't going to be part of the chest pain algorithm?
2) Stroke - stroke alert, call the stroke team, wait for the recs...same question as above
3) Trauma - AB-CT
4) OB - walks through the door delivering a baby...I'm going to be ****ting bricks.

Maybe I work with really good MLPs and have, they are experienced. But goes back to my original point, its a trainable skill. I know we get defensive on the EM forums about if you aren't EM trained you suck. I've worked with good FM trained docs, surgeons who were grandfathered in, etc. All the data supports the more you do the better you get at it. This is what the data says:
"Most of the evidence comes from older, mostly observational studies, and much of it is collected and promoted by EM’s own organizations (AAEM, ABEM/COBCEP). It points in a consistent direction, but it’s weaker than the confidence it’s usually cited with, and there are null results that rarely get mentioned."

In your example of priapism this is what Claude says. I didn't have to train to learn this. That doctor could have used the same resource:
TreatmentTypeDose / TechniqueRoleCautions / Notes
Dorsal penile nerve block / ring blockIschemicLidocaine 1% or bupivacaine 0.25% (no epi), 10 & 2 o’clock at base or circumferential ringFirst, before any needle workAvoid epinephrine-containing solutions
Systemic analgesiaBothOpioids/IV analgesia as neededAdjunctDoesn’t treat the priapism
Corporal aspirationIschemic18–21G butterfly/angiocath, 2 or 10 o’clock lateral shaft; aspirate until bright red blood ± detumescenceFirst-line, also diagnostic (send blood gas)Avoid 12 o’clock (neurovascular bundle) and 6 o’clock (urethra); one side often enough (septal communication)
Saline irrigationIschemicNS 10–20 mL aliquots in/out through same needleAdjunct to aspiration when clots obstructCan combine with phenylephrine
Intracavernosal phenylephrineIschemic100–500 mcg/mL; give 1 mL q3–5 min, up to ~1 hr. Mix: 10 mg in 100 mL NS = 100 mcg/mL, or 10 mg in 50 mL = 200 mcg/mLMainstay after/with aspirationCardiac monitor; BP/HR between doses; caution with CAD, HTN, MAOIs; lower doses in peds; efficacy drops after ~48–72 hrs
Other intracavernosal sympathomimetics (epinephrine, ephedrine, etilefrine)IschemicPer urology/tox guidanceSecond-line, rarely used in USMore beta/cardiac effects than phenylephrine; not preferred
Oral terbutalineIschemic (prolonged ICI erection)5 mg PO (or 0.25–0.5 mg SC)Only for prolonged erection after intracavernosal injection < 4 hrsNot recommended for established ischemic priapism (AUA)
Oral pseudoephedrineIschemic60–120 mg PONot recommended for established ischemic priapismWeak evidence; may be used for stuttering prevention by urology

Wisdom isn’t knowing everything. It’s knowing what to use.
 
This isn't meant to rage bait or trigger anyone; it's just observations I have made in my time. From outcomes I have had, to the legal cases I have reviewed, to the people I have worked with. Observational and simply wanted a place to discuss with some folks who are crazy.
 
Anyone who has worked in ANY ER for more than a month knows how laughable these conclusions are. Bad study and bad data. Like a study that concludes that the sky is green.
I think there is also a difference in PA training (in person, clinicals usually done alongside medical students) and NPs (large portion are online, clinicals are self-arranged with no quality oversight). Any study should separate the two.

I cancel a lot of CT orders that the screening APPs order (i.e., CT lumbar spine for atraumatic back pain).
 
Lol, no association with any MLP or nurse.

We can't say the data is garbage when it shows equivalency in procedures and then turnaround and say it is good data when it shows we save a few more dollars in the grand scheme of things.

The place I work the only things the midlevels don't see are
1) high risk chest pain - what am I bringing to the table? STEMI, NSTEMI, dissection, PE. Serious question, not trying to argue but what has my training prepped here that isn't going to be part of the chest pain algorithm?
2) Stroke - stroke alert, call the stroke team, wait for the recs...same question as above
3) Trauma - AB-CT
4) OB - walks through the door delivering a baby...I'm going to be ****ting bricks.

Maybe I work with really good MLPs and have, they are experienced. But goes back to my original point, its a trainable skill. I know we get defensive on the EM forums about if you aren't EM trained you suck. I've worked with good FM trained docs, surgeons who were grandfathered in, etc. All the data supports the more you do the better you get at it. This is what the data says:
"Most of the evidence comes from older, mostly observational studies, and much of it is collected and promoted by EM’s own organizations (AAEM, ABEM/COBCEP). It points in a consistent direction, but it’s weaker than the confidence it’s usually cited with, and there are null results that rarely get mentioned."

In your example of priapism this is what Claude says. I didn't have to train to learn this. That doctor could have used the same resource:
TreatmentTypeDose / TechniqueRoleCautions / Notes
Dorsal penile nerve block / ring blockIschemicLidocaine 1% or bupivacaine 0.25% (no epi), 10 & 2 o’clock at base or circumferential ringFirst, before any needle workAvoid epinephrine-containing solutions
Systemic analgesiaBothOpioids/IV analgesia as neededAdjunctDoesn’t treat the priapism
Corporal aspirationIschemic18–21G butterfly/angiocath, 2 or 10 o’clock lateral shaft; aspirate until bright red blood ± detumescenceFirst-line, also diagnostic (send blood gas)Avoid 12 o’clock (neurovascular bundle) and 6 o’clock (urethra); one side often enough (septal communication)
Saline irrigationIschemicNS 10–20 mL aliquots in/out through same needleAdjunct to aspiration when clots obstructCan combine with phenylephrine
Intracavernosal phenylephrineIschemic100–500 mcg/mL; give 1 mL q3–5 min, up to ~1 hr. Mix: 10 mg in 100 mL NS = 100 mcg/mL, or 10 mg in 50 mL = 200 mcg/mLMainstay after/with aspirationCardiac monitor; BP/HR between doses; caution with CAD, HTN, MAOIs; lower doses in peds; efficacy drops after ~48–72 hrs
Other intracavernosal sympathomimetics (epinephrine, ephedrine, etilefrine)IschemicPer urology/tox guidanceSecond-line, rarely used in USMore beta/cardiac effects than phenylephrine; not preferred
Oral terbutalineIschemic (prolonged ICI erection)5 mg PO (or 0.25–0.5 mg SC)Only for prolonged erection after intracavernosal injection < 4 hrsNot recommended for established ischemic priapism (AUA)
Oral pseudoephedrineIschemic60–120 mg PONot recommended for established ischemic priapismWeak evidence; may be used for stuttering prevention by urology

Wisdom isn’t knowing everything. It’s knowing what to use.
Please stop posting AI summaries. We can all access AI. If you continue to post AI-generated posts, I will start issuing warnings/infractions.
 
I think there is also a difference in PA training (in person, clinicals usually done alongside medical students) and NPs (large portion are online, clinicals are self-arranged with no quality oversight). Any study should separate the two.

I cancel a lot of CT orders that the screening APPs order (i.e., CT lumbar spine for atraumatic back pain).
I haven't cancelled any, I don't micromanage them. They work pretty independently unless they have a question.
 
I haven't cancelled any, I don't micromanage them. They work pretty independently unless they have a question.
I think you missed a key portion of my statement. Screening APPs.

If I find that an APP is ordering unnecessary tests and I'm signed up with the patient with them, then yes, I will educate them. It's not micromanaging. We are stewards of our own department and responsible for our own flow. Unnecessary CTs cost money, delays in care of others, and expose to unnecessary radiation.

Your comment worries me with its lackadaisical attitude.
 
Please stop posting AI summaries. We can all access AI. If you continue to post AI-generated posts, I will start issuing warnings/infractions.
The table was AI generated to provide how easy it is to access this information. The rest was generated by me. Tying dead internet to my response is a bit of a stretch.

I have been on this site for years and am finally engaging on a good topic and you start power tripping on a table I posted to summarize the access to info. I can see why this site is dying. I won't be posting here. Please ban my account southerndoc.