LI Cop banked $246,374

Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

So what? Doctors SHOULD be making more than college coaches. In the same vain, I guess we should also say that if we are going to compare salaries between professions we should also compare MEDIAN salaries. Well guess what? Median police salaries in some areas are EQUAL to those of primary care salaries. Swallow that and then get back to me.

No sport coach deserves anything beyond average salary - less than that of a PhD. However, do you watch any sports? Do you like basketball? If you do, you're the one who's indirectly paying the coach. I don't like to sit and watch any of those sports, so I am not contributing. Regardless of what you say about coaches and their salaries, actions always speak louder than words. This is true for any branch of entertainment. The society is generally ignorant, indolent, insolent, and hedonistic. This includes people from every profession in the world. So until this changes, don't expect the scientists to be paid more than the entertainers. People are more interested in Wood's in-and-outs than the supreme court nominees.

Primary care physicians are generally underpaid. Some other specialists are also underpaid, given the overhead. But you are not making any valid points by taking the highest paid cop and comparing him to the lowest paid doctor. Showing the medians would be better, but only a little. Nevertheless, I would be very interested to see how median police salaries even come close to primary care physician medians (http://www.payscale.com/research/US/Job=Police_or_Sheriff's_Patrol_Officer/Salary). I am sure that you can equate them if you go to some very specific regions across the country and pick the highest paid regional police salary compared to the lowest paid regional doctor salary and then use medians - similar to what you used already.

I am not saying that doctors shouldn't be paid more, but I am saying that putting down another profession is never going to help elevate another one, especially when there are so many specializations in each profession. Some cops might be doing nothing but setting up illegal speed traps and munching on donuts all day long. Others are spending their nights in gang-infested areas of LA where every day could be their last. Not too many people want to do this, ergo, there are higher salaries to lure them in. So what? Are we also going to compare doctor salaries to Alaska crab fishermen/captains?
 
I totally agree with you, medsucks....I don't understand why docs/residents can't muster up the intestinal fortitude to unionize and protect their salaries.

For those of us who agree with you, and I know there are a lot, what can we realistically do in order to protect ourselves?
Don't worry, you'll get your chance starting now. I have noticed that a lot of doctors are conservative Republicans. Thanks to Repubs, the supreme court just reversed a century old restriction on companies/organizations to contribute only a limited amount to a politician. As of now, there are no more limits. You'd think that those same conservative doctors would be happy, right? Well, just wait until the real bloodbath. AMA is nothing compared to the powerful health insurance organization which soon will overflow DC with so many crooks that doctors will be left on the curb crying about the days gone by and the complete disappearance of their independence. The irony is that these same uber-conservative doctors might never get it to their heads that Repubs are the ones responsible for their decreased wages. Many docs were extremely concerned about the healthcare reform. Well, in my opinion, the Repub led supreme court's decision will do more to screw doctors than any health care reform proposed to this day. I wasn't against the reform that much, but the court's decision has made me very apprehensive about the doctor's future.

As a side note, did anyone see Scalia's interview on PBS? That guy has so much arrogance and sense of righteousness that makes you want to put his ass back in Sicily and allow the Cosa Nostra to lambaste his face in until he looks like Dali's Soft Self-Portrait with Fried Bacon.

scalia.JPG
 
Thanks to Repubs, the supreme court just reversed a century old restriction on companies/organizations to contribute only a limited amount to a politician.

There has been no change in contribution limits to politicians. What has changed, is that corporations and unions now have more rights to run their own political ads, as long as they don't coordinate with a candidate.
 
There has been no change in contribution limits to politicians. What has changed, is that corporations and unions now have more rights to run their own political ads, as long as they don't coordinate with a candidate.
Usually the main reason politicians need money is to pay for expensive ads. Are you aware of any other, major sink for contributions? The court's decision can be disastrous because the insurance companies can run their "own" ads for the candidates they want. I am not even sure the limitations and enforceability of coordination with the politician, but I think there will be some form of tacit mutualism developed between certain politicians and certain wealthy corporations who will run the ads to make sure their candidate gets elected. You get enough cronies to DC, eventually there will be no limitations whatsoever since everyone will be bought - starting from the congress and the president down to the supreme court. This was a very dangerous ruling by the court and the consequences can be dire. I think it would be much better if they could make those contributions to the politicians who then could not use any of those monies for ads or personal use. Now that doesn't leave much else, does it?

If congress does not enact a myriad of shrewd new regulations to deal with the court's ruling, the average person might just get screwed back to the colony era. We'll be back to taxation without representation where the lowest and the middle classes pay the largest taxes percentage-wise and have no say in the elections and where the wealthy pay as little taxes as possible and control DC. We all know how susceptible Americans are to ads. Even if the ad is about some obvious BS, there is always some demographic that will buy into it. This is why a good ad is more influential than a good candidate. And if anyone has any doubts about that, just remember how a war hero with a Purple Heart was turned into a deserter and a coward through slander and libel. I am talking about John Kerry, of course.
 
http://www.newsday.com/long-island/...246-374-going-after-drunken-drivers-1.1451129

I begin to realize more and more each and everyday that I plinkoed myself into the wrong profession. This was a mere cop (not a lieutenant, commander or police chief) just working overtime after only a decade on the job.

Another clear cut example of another profession plowing right past the stagnant pay of a physician like a Formula 1 driver overtaking a 90 year old grandma in her 1978 Yugo.

Mere cop? People sure were singing the praises of NYPD on 9/11. How quickly some forget.
 
Lots of folks at the hospitals and in the private EMS agencies in Vegas have been perusing this site a lot lately. It's a list of what all the municipal employees make in Clark County.

You'll notice that the top earner, a fire battalion chief, banked $643,511 which did include some severance pay. The top earning firefighter without any severance got $333,430. So not only are the widely held feelings among the general public that doctors make "too much" money in need of some rethinking but many of the perceptions about professions that make to little do as well.
 
So not only are the widely held feelings among the general public that doctors make "too much" money in need of some rethinking but many of the perceptions about professions that make to little do as well.

From what I can gather, the general public perceives every career except maybe for two to be compensated too highly. Exception #1 is the career of the person answering the question. Exception #2 is that of their spouse.
 
From what I can gather, the general public perceives every career except maybe for two to be compensated too highly. Exception #1 is the career of the person answering the question. Exception #2 is that of their spouse.

I don't know. I frequently hear in the media and in conversation how public sector employees such as teachers get the shaft. I just don't know that I buy it. They have the most powerful unions in the country and they get a lot of benefits. I think that to a large degree these perceptions are put out there and perpetuated to forward a political agenda.
 
Lots of folks at the hospitals and in the private EMS agencies in Vegas have been perusing this site a lot lately. It's a list of what all the municipal employees make in Clark County.

You'll notice that the top earner, a fire battalion chief, banked $643,511 which did include some severance pay. The top earning firefighter without any severance got $333,430. So not only are the widely held feelings among the general public that doctors make "too much" money in need of some rethinking but many of the perceptions about professions that make to little do as well.

Are you sure those are annual salaries? Because I also saw salaries of $500 and other very large variations in pay in just one field: http://transparentnevada.com/salaries/search/?title=FIRE%20ENGR%20LAUGHLIN. Also, medical examiners: http://transparentnevada.com/salari...dical&year=0&jurisdiction=&sort_by=T#results; and http://transparentnevada.com/salaries/search/?title=MEDICAL EXAMINER.
 
Are you sure those are annual salaries? Because I also saw salaries of $500 and other very large variations in pay in just one field: http://transparentnevada.com/salaries/search/?title=FIRE%20ENGR%20LAUGHLIN. Also, medical examiners: http://transparentnevada.com/salari...dical&year=0&jurisdiction=&sort_by=T#results; and http://transparentnevada.com/salaries/search/?title=MEDICAL EXAMINER.

Yes, that annual compensation including overtime and 401K. Note that the ones with the little warning signs include things like severance pay outs of accrued benefits like sick time and vacation time, etc.
 
Yes, that annual compensation including overtime and 401K. Note that the ones with the little warning signs include things like severance pay outs of accrued benefits like sick time and vacation time, etc.

A friend of mine lives in Vegas. Last time I was there we got together with some of his buddies. One of these guys - 22, no college degree, and physically unfit - works at a fire department, makes about $70K, and he told me that all he does is show up at work and play video games all day long and discuss their guy-relationship-drama with the rest of the firemen like him. I was so surprised that couldn't help but ask him as to whether he thinks he's in shape to be a fireman. He obviously got very defensive...

Anyway, since then I have been thinking about Nevada once in a while. Do you know if your state is weird or something? Or is this a national trend? I just was unable to find any firemen position here in SoCal that could match what Nevada pays. Or maybe I didn't care to spend enough time to find out. Common sense would tell you that if you're going to pay someone more than twice than graduate salary, at least the person has to be qualified to do the job. Paying $70K to a fat slob that you wouldn't want to show up when your house is burning seems like a waste of money. But then again, you can't complain now, can you? NV doesn't take any income tax to begin with.
 

I'd be interested in hearing a justification for this as well.

Compensation is a function of inherent difficulty of the work, barrier of entry into the work, "value to society," and unpleasantness of the work.

Perhaps the *average* college coach shouldn't earn as much as the *average* doctor. But actually... that's true, they don't. How much does the average Division 3 women's tennis coach earn versus the average general internist?

I went to an enormous state university in the South, one with very famous and successful Div 1 sports teams. The value of those sports teams was absolutely tremendous-- well over $100 million annually. In fact, those sports teams gave my state university enough money to fund my academic scholarship, enough to keep the French Department alive and give me my degree, to buy a harpsichord and hire an orchestra conductor so I could be the university harpsichordist, etc. All the fun, non-income-generating frills.

So, in terms of a) the difficulty of the work, how do you think coaching an extremely successful, visible Div 1 men's basketball team stacks up against a private practice radiology gig, reading MRIs for LBP and routine chest x-rays for work physicals?

In terms of b) barrier of entry, how much more difficult is it to be offered the head coaching job for a top football program versus getting a residency spot in internal medicine?

In terms of "value to society," the top coach generates hundreds of millions of dollars for my state and my alma mater. Which funds the liberal arts departments that grant hundreds of college degrees, the salaries of all those profs and TAs, not to mention hundreds of jobs for people in the community doing everything from cleaning the stadium to writing sports commentary for the newspaper. What single doctor could claim he provides that much monetary value to society? Not to mention the intangible values of entertainment and pride.

We feel that we "deserve" to make the most $$$$ because we're relatively smart and relatively hardworking and relatively well-thought of by the community. And-- here's the secret-- WE DO. The *average* doc (anesthesia, right?) is still the highest-paid *average* gig in the country.

But the market is by and large a rational entity, and people are paid according to what they generate. I harbor no illusions that my future surgical practice could ever generate as much value as, say, Mike Krzyzewski does for Duke or for the state of NC. http://news.google.com/news?hl=en&s...=news_group&ct=title&resnum=1&ved=0CBcQsQQwAA
 
A friend of mine lives in Vegas. Last time I was there we got together with some of his buddies. One of these guys - 22, no college degree, and physically unfit - works at a fire department, makes about $70K, and he told me that all he does is show up at work and play video games all day long and discuss their guy-relationship-drama with the rest of the firemen like him. I was so surprised that couldn't help but ask him as to whether he thinks he's in shape to be a fireman. He obviously got very defensive...

Anyway, since then I have been thinking about Nevada once in a while. Do you know if your state is weird or something? Or is this a national trend? I just was unable to find any firemen position here in SoCal that could match what Nevada pays. Or maybe I didn't care to spend enough time to find out. Common sense would tell you that if you're going to pay someone more than twice than graduate salary, at least the person has to be qualified to do the job. Paying $70K to a fat slob that you wouldn't want to show up when your house is burning seems like a waste of money. But then again, you can't complain now, can you? NV doesn't take any income tax to begin with.

That's an interesting question.

Before I answer it let me say that my comments must be tempered by the fact that I work in the system here in several capacities and so I have to be diplomatic about it.

That said I don't know any firefighters in Vegas who are incompetent or unqualified. I think they do a great job. I know they work hard for their pay and do a lot of overtime which is cheaper to the system than hiring additional FTEs. I was surprised when I read the web site at issue and saw the figures. These do seem like high numbers.

Nevada has no income tax but we do have significant property and sales taxes as well as lots of fees, special distric taxes, car registration taxes, etc. Even with those we are falling short now. Nevada has always been used to the taxes from gaming and tourism taking the pain away from the tax bite. Now that Nevada's cities have grown up into real cities, not just life support systems for casino districts, we have also come down with real city type problems like homelessness, the mentally ill, worse crime, etc. These have been ignored for decades but can't be pushed aside any longer and dealing with them takes money. Because of the economy there is no money. During the previous happy days the public worker's unions became very powerful and got great contracts for their people. Now that the salad days are over there is scrutiny of those contracts that did not exist before.

Other places that have very influential public employee unions are having similar problems such as California and New York.