Low GPA non-trad to M4 matching anesthesia - AMAA

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Quizlet04

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
May 30, 2011
Messages
408
Reaction score
271
I am a white female who started this process at 33, graduating at 39. I went to an ivy league college where I graduated with a 3.3cGPA, 3.0 sGPA. I then did a PhD. My GPA there was ~3.65. I was a lecturer and writer in between grad school and med school.

I did a 2 year DIY post bacc. One summer I took my bio, chem, and physics pre-reqs at a state school. I did OChem, as well as two humanities courses and cell bio, during the following school year. 3.67 cGPA, 3.43 sGPA(got a 3.94 in my sGPA post-bacc). MCAT was a 30 (9/10/11).

ECs: Clinical volunteering was 78 hours in an ED and 120 hours at the VA. Non-clinical 50 hours on a committee, 300 hours planning a massive international event, 100 hours working with my synagogue. Hobbies were writing, animal keeping, and art. Published one paper and a bunch of abstracts.

Applied: 24 MD programs for 2014 year. Two interviews, wait listed at both. Reapplied for 2015 year both MD and DO. Four days after I resubmitted my application, I was accepted off the waitlist to a USMD school.

M1: I struggled significantly and was worried I might have to repeat a year, though I ultimately passed all my classes. Luckily my school is *true* pass fail, with no hidden rankings for M1/M2 year. My fears helped me get things together.

M2: Changed studying habits and also addressed some lingering medical problems that went undiagnosed and untreated for decades. I went from barely passing to comfortably passing. Still, it was so late in my year that I had lost a lot of time and information studying. End result: Step 1: 214 (ouch).

M3: Did well in general and improved test scores. Honors in surgery, emed, and psychiatry, high pass in all others. Scored a letter of rec from my surgery preceptor.

At the end of M3 year, I realized how important it was to nail Step 2. I took off almost four weeks to recuperate and study. I doubled down on the question bank and multimodal learning. End result: Step 2 was 249 🙂

Although I had thought I would go into neurology, I found I liked the intensity of anesthesia and the possibility of critical care. My Step 1 score was a little under average for the average applicant, which is why I applied broadly.

M4: Did three away rotations, one at a very prestigious hospital where I received a letter. Third letter was from my home anesthesia adviser.

Applied to ~50 categorical + advanced anesthesia positions and ~40 preliminary year positions. End result: 20 anesthesia interviews; I attended 17 due to travel and a death in the family. Three preliminary year interviews; I later discovered about half of those were missing documents.

Last Monday: Learned I had matched into an advanced program in my target city but not a preliminary program. I entered SOAP, received 6 interviews, and ended up in a phenomenal preliminary surgical position in a top 10 surgery program.

Last Friday: Matched my #7 program. It is technically more prestigious than 3, 4, 5, and 6 but I liked some aspects of the other programs more. Still, it has good name recognition and excellent fellowship placement. I am VERY happy to go there in two years!

(I was not initially offered an interview by this program. I wrote to the program director and stated I was interested in the program. A few days later, I received an invite. I only did this for two schools and obviously the results were awesome. Don't do this for every school or else you'll look like you're trying to game the system.)
 
Last edited:
Take away lessons:

If you do not fix the problems that led you to a low GPA in the first place, you will continue to struggle throughout medical school. These can be medical issues, studying issues, personal drama, or whatever.

It is never too late to stop screwing up. Turning it around in my M3 year is why I got those 20 interviews.

Being interesting helps. At least half of my interviews focused on my very odd hobbies and careers; very few mentioned my Step scores.

Prestige helps. The PhD and the Ivy League background, even though both were remote, likely gave me a boost. My med school is less prestigious, though I will say it has treated me very well.

If I've missed anything, ask away.
 
Applied to ~50 categorical + advanced anesthesia positions and ~40 preliminary year positions. End result: 20 anesthesia interviews; I attended 17 due to travel and a death in the family. Three preliminary year interviews; I later discovered about half of those were missing documents.

Congratulations on matching! That's an awesome achievement :clap::clap:


Could you explain what you meant in the bolded statement?
 
Congratulations on matching! That's an awesome achievement :clap::clap:


Could you explain what you meant in the bolded statement?

Half of my preliminary surgical applications were missing their personal statements, letters of rec, and USMLE scores. That's likely one of the reasons I didn't get many interviews. I applied to them later in the cycle and they were incomplete!
 
What do you think prepared you for MS1 or (given your fear of having to repeat) do you wish you'd done differently? And what did you tweak for MS2 (maybe that's already answered in first ??)
 
Congrats on all your success! Are you at all concerned with losing continuity of care in anesthesia, or was that never a concern? I like the idea of anesthesiology, but I also love the continuity that comes with primary care.

I am thrilled to be losing the continuity of care! Well, in a manner of speaking. 😉 I found in my M3 year I preferred something a lot more hands-on and intense. Too many days spent barely interacting with patients and only writing notes made me realize I wanted to do something. I preferred immediate payoff, get in and get out types of situations. The long haul treatment of someone with a chronic disease isn't for me.

What do you think prepared you for MS1 or (given your fear of having to repeat) do you wish you'd done differently? And what did you tweak for MS2 (maybe that's already answered in first ??)

Find a studying groove and stick with it. I did a lot more practice questions and a lot less reading for M2 year, odd as it sounds. Highlighting in a textbook is the worst way for me to learn. I need to interact with the material. I learned that too late.
 
Find a studying groove and stick with it. I did a lot more practice questions and a lot less reading for M2 year, odd as it sounds. Highlighting in a textbook is the worst way for me to learn. I need to interact with the material. I learned that too late.
I draw everything ... not a highlighter; also not admitted 🙁 Thank you for the AMA
 
How early is too early to go to the learning center? I, like you, went Ivy and had a bad GPA (3.3 cGPA mainly from my freshman year - medication-induced depression that was controlled easily by stopping the medication the next year). I have done quite well in my post-bac, but it's at an easy school and I'm nervous that doing that it will not translate to med school. I'll be at a pass/fail school, but I want to hit the ground running and be sure to stay on top of everything. Could I go in the first week or two just to talk with someone there about different learning styles and what to try out in the first few weeks as I jump in? Will they think I'm completely neurotic? Thanks for starting this - and CONGRATS!
 
How early is too early to go to the learning center? I, like you, went Ivy and had a bad GPA (3.3 cGPA mainly from my freshman year - medication-induced depression that was controlled easily by stopping the medication the next year). I have done quite well in my post-bac, but it's at an easy school and I'm nervous that doing that it will not translate to med school. I'll be at a pass/fail school, but I want to hit the ground running and be sure to stay on top of everything. Could I go in the first week or two just to talk with someone there about different learning styles and what to try out in the first few weeks as I jump in? Will they think I'm completely neurotic? Thanks for starting this - and CONGRATS!

I don’t want to nose in on the op, but it is never a bad idea to talk to the learning center about your learning styles. Definitely do that if you haven’t already determined how you learn best. Prevention is always better than repair.
 
How early is too early to go to the learning center? I, like you, went Ivy and had a bad GPA (3.3 cGPA mainly from my freshman year - medication-induced depression that was controlled easily by stopping the medication the next year)

Go as soon as you can. Attend review sections and hook up with the free tutoring if it's there.
 
How early is too early to go to the learning center? I, like you, went Ivy and had a bad GPA (3.3 cGPA mainly from my freshman year - medication-induced depression that was controlled easily by stopping the medication the next year). I have done quite well in my post-bac, but it's at an easy school and I'm nervous that doing that it will not translate to med school. I'll be at a pass/fail school, but I want to hit the ground running and be sure to stay on top of everything. Could I go in the first week or two just to talk with someone there about different learning styles and what to try out in the first few weeks as I jump in? Will they think I'm completely neurotic? Thanks for starting this - and CONGRATS!
Go the first day if you want to. Of course they will think you are completely neurotic but so are all of your classmates. It will help you to feel more comfortable and to relax and enjoy yourself.If you struggle with depression then find a therapist you can connect with as well to help keep yourself grounded. It takes a few weeks to months to find your learning style.
 
Top