Match 2025

[DrProtonX]

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad

Eras 2025 preliminary data shows 277 people have applied for radiation oncology, an increase from 255 last year.
Breakdown:
MD: 153 —> 160
DO: 26 —> 28
IMG: 76 —> 89
While IMGs take the bigger portion of the increase, MD/DO applicants number have increased as well. Looks like Rad Onc competitiveness continues the upward trend likely due to imroving job market.

Source: ERAS® Statistics

 

[Chartreuse Wombat]

The metric to follow is US Seniors applying

 

[yesmaster]

Pathology, rad onc, emergency medicine

Something about taking pride is being the tallest midget

 

[medgator]

Pathology, rad onc, emergency medicine

Something about taking pride is being the tallest midget

Unclear medicine as well (assuming pure nucs hasn't imploded as a standalone specialty)

 

[DrProtonX]

Pathology, rad onc, emergency medicine

Something about taking pride is being the tallest midget

I wasn’t taking pride in anything. Just presenting data and giving a possible explanation for it.

P.S. why is everyone here so against mentioning anything even remotely positive about the field? Just because there are many issues, doesn’t mean we should appreciate good thing no matter how small they are.

 

[communitydoc13]

Just because there are many issues, doesn’t mean we should appreciate good thing no matter how small they are.

I do believe that the job market is improved relative to a few years ago.

I also believe that some fraction of graduating senior residents at this point are marginal (have a peculiar career trajectory or demonstrated difficulty performing in a prior opportunity).

A little boost in competitiveness is not a bad thing. However, it should not be the product of concerted outreach campaigns. It should reflect the quality of the opportunities that the field provides (understanding that this is difficult to measure).

 

[metallica81788]

The job market is probably better this year only to snap up the remaining "decent" residents
Followed by a 4-5 year unspoken hiring freeze

 

[yesmaster]

Good things for the field would be new indications or at least not losing indications like esophageal adenoCa, and practice changing or at least hypothesis generating findings from Astro.

I didn’t go but partiqol was a big waste of resources to tell big proton centers what they still don’t want to hear. Any community rad onc has been telling patients protons don’t do **** for years. I can tell you now any proton phase 3 trial vs best vmat plan, ENI, risk category, hypofrac whatever angle will be negative.

Anyways I digress. A few more marginal med students isn’t indicator of job market getting better

 

[medgator]

Good things for the field would be new indications or at least not losing indications like esophageal adenoCa, and practice changing or at least hypothesis generating findings from Astro.

I didn’t go but partiqol was a big waste of resources to tell big proton centers what they still don’t want to hear. Any community rad onc has been telling patients protons don’t do **** for years. I can tell you now any proton phase 3 trial vs best vmat plan, ENI, risk category, hypofrac whatever angle will be negative.

Anyways I digress. A few more marginal med students isn’t indicator of job market getting better

Emperor still needs to know he has no clothes. And now we have RCTs to prove it to payors and CMS at large

 

[RickyScott]

When will the Breast trial present results?

 

[Doctorer]

When will the Breast trial present results?

2030s iirc.

 

[IonsAreOurFuture]

When will the Breast trial present results?

Radcomp breast cancer regional nodal RT trial has closed to accrual with 1200+ women enrolled and will probably report short term toxicity data in 2 to 3 years.

Longer term cardiac toxicity and 5 year PFS and OS I suspect a couple years after that

 

[fiji128]

Looking at the Reddit spreadsheet, which itself references Discord, there were a total of 5 positions that went unfilled with Brooklyn Methodist, Thomas Jefferson and Stony Brook participating in the SOAP. All Soap position were filled before today.

 

[Doctorer]

You have to hand it to them: Jefferson is a very consistent training program.

 

[TheWallnerus]

Rad Onc competitiveness continues the upward trend likely due to imroving job market.

*citations needed

“The job market is improving.”

“But the job quality is weak.”

 

[Ray D. Ayshun]

Is today Match Day?

 

[medgator]

Is today Match Day?

Guessing st pattys was as it was historically

 

[Neuronix]

The only thing that was stopping the academic program where I work from expanding was unfilled spots.

Now that they're filling them all, they're expanding again.

 

[GapCalc]

The only thing stopping the academic program where I work from expanding was unfilled spots.

Now that they're filling them all, they're expanding again.

boooooooooo

 

[yesmaster]

Rad onc is elite again

 

[drowsy12]

 

[Bbopper]

The job market is probably better this year only to snap up the remaining "decent" residents
Followed by a 4-5 year unspoken hiring freeze

Comments like these are what makes this forum such a malignant echo chamber.

 

[madchemist89]

Comments like these are what makes this forum such a malignant echo chamber.

We are cancer docs. Did you expect a benign echo chamber? 😄

 

[RickyScott]

Who soaped this year?

 

[Ray D. Ayshun]

Comments like these are what makes this forum such a malignant echo chamber.

To be an echo chamber, wouldn't every comment be exemplary?

 

[NotMattSpraker]

This made me laugh out loud, hes a great follow on Twitter and apparently a great mentor for his rotating students.

At this point, I really have to wonder if our "dip" was from the 2018 ABR debacle. Certainly I would be discouraged about applying to this field with the way the ABR leadership treated trainees at the time. ABR has had a great turnaround, but potentially speaks to the importance of good leadership for attracting trainees.

The job market uncertainty has been the same and this class particularly will be graduating right at the end of ASTROs model period. Whatever you think about that model, this class is in a data free zone.

 

[DrProtonX]

Does anyone know the unfilled programs? Did they participate in soap?

 

[Bbopper]

This made me laugh out loud, hes a great follow on Twitter and apparently a great mentor for his rotating students.

At this point, I really have to wonder if our "dip" was from the 2018 ABR debacle. Certainly I would be discouraged about applying to this field with the way the ABR leadership treated trainees at the time. ABR has had a great turnaround, but potentially speaks to the importance of good leadership for attracting trainees.

The job market uncertainty has been the same and this class particularly will be graduating right at the end of ASTROs model period. Whatever you think about that model, this class is in a data free zone.

I've spoken to a lot of medical students who are hesitant about the field specifically because of SDN, because SDN is one of the only way medical students can look online at sentiment, and many go into it because their real life conversations tell them discordant things than they hear here.

 

[NotMattSpraker]

I've spoken to a lot of medical students who are hesitant about the field specifically because of SDN, because SDN is one of the only way medical students can look online at sentiment, and many go into it because their real life conversations tell them discordant things than they hear here.

Im glad they are reading SDN. The goal should be to help medical students find the field that is right for them, not "recruit" them to become radiation oncologists.

SDN remains the only place for public balanced discussion about this field, and in my opinion that is more true than ever. Every medical student is smart enough to realize it is an anonymous internet forum and apply the relevant caveats to what they read.

I think if people are only talking with their local academic attending who has had 1 job where they trained and reading Twitter or ASTRO newsletters, they are getting a very biased view of the field.

One edit to add: I did a podcast with Laura Flores last year about the perception of the field. It seems like SDN is no longer THE popular place for people to get information about different fields. Im sure it is still checked, but now days it may be more Reddit or Discord (also both anonymous). I know its popular to blame SDN for all of Rad Onc's problems, but that just doesn't really make sense or jive with what I hear out there. Its also lazy.

If interested, the podcast is here: "Fallen Out of Favor": The Rad Onc Match with Laura - The Accelerators Podcast

 

[Neuronix]

I've spoken to a lot of medical students who are hesitant about the field specifically because of SDN, because SDN is one of the only way medical students can look online at sentiment, and many go into it because their real life conversations tell them discordant things than they hear here.

I'm happy to tell anyone in real life whatever I say on here.

However, my department tries to keep me away from students because they know I'm honest about my feelings and experiences.

That's not to say that I'm overly pessimistic. Some students I've worked with have gone into rad onc, others have decided to go into other specialties.

But, there is a tremendous pressure here and at many academic institutions on their faculty to only say positive things to students in efforts to fill their residency positions.

 

[Gfunk6]

I've spoken to a lot of medical students who are hesitant about the field specifically because of SDN, because SDN is one of the only way medical students can look online at sentiment, and many go into it because their real life conversations tell them discordant things than they hear here.

Welcome new residents to the best field in medicine!

 

[medgator]

 

[A_DeMichele]

RadOnc is back (again)

 

[medgator]

RadOnc is back (again)

70% US MD fill rate? Sure but it's not a "ROAD" specialty anymore

 

[NotMattSpraker]

Its a really good thing for trainees that the number of SOAPs has gone way down.

We are a very unique field. Better to join intentionally than under duress.

 

[medgator]

Its a really good thing for trainees that the number of SOAPs has gone way down.

We are a very unique field. Better to join intentionally than under duress.

Agreed. Should be true of any field but feels like oncology esp

 

[NotMattSpraker]

Agreed. Should be true of any field but feels like oncology esp

I think a lot of people don't realize that we now know programs really abused the SOAP during our dip. It was presented in that ASTRO workforce session that the vast majority of people who SOAP'd in did not originally apply to Rad Onc. I suspect this embarrassing fact is a big driver of why ASTRO deleted that workforce session and buried any discussion.

Now we have low SOAPs but a much higher percentage of FMG matches than in the past. The stories of DO and FMG discrimination in hiring in this field are rampant, so hopefully that starts to change as well.

FMGs face a lot of barriers getting US residency positions and there is a lot of discussion online about strategy to get a spot. I worry about Rad Onc as a strategy because it is so challenging to pivot if a career in Rad Onc doesnt work out. Not true for IM or FM. I certainly understand the upside of RO over FM, but the field seems to agree that these upsides are NOT guaranteed into the future.

I wonder if any PDs are discussing these demographic changes in our field and the implications for their graduates.

 

[RickyScott]

some fmgs would happily match even if it meant that they became permanent fellows and why match is not a gauge of supply and demand. Btw, anyone notice that university of Miami took 5 residents?

 

[Bequerel]

I matched in the peak of competitiveness with most of my co-residents being MD/PhD, Ivy League type grads and I look at the current residents at my old program and just laugh and a part of me loves the fact that the same d-bag, stuffy snooty faculty that slummed it and had to hold their nose when they matched a state school grad with only a single publication now has to kiss the ass of Caribbean and DO grads with average scores to get them to match! This field is no where near as competitive as it was 10-15 years ago..not even same ballpark.

 

[NotMattSpraker]

some fmgs would happily match even if it meant that they became permanent fellows and why match is not a gauge of supply and demand. Btw, anyone notice that university of Miami took 5 residents?

Yea to be clear Im not questioning their motivations at all and anyone who has a genuine interest in this field should be welcome to join it. Im really just speaking about PD considerations for job placement after training and the culture of our field.

Every single place Ive worked, academic and community, a person in a decision making position to hire has made comments to me about pedigree or place of training. Some obviously worse than others.

 

[RickyScott]

In principle, I don’t have a problem with

Yea to be clear Im not questioning their motivations at all and anyone who has a genuine interest in this field should be welcome to join it. Im really just speaking about PD considerations for job placement after training and the culture of our field.

Every single place Ive worked, academic and community, a person in a decision making position to hire has made comments to me about pedigree or place of training. Some obviously worse than others.

I am not sure how important motivations are. If I had soaped into anesthesia, or half a dozen other fields, I have no doubt I would be invested, and engaged and as or more competent than colleagues.

The essence of a “proffesion” dating back to middle age guilds is to wield a monopoly over a field and provide its practitioners with good income and work in return for certain standards/quality. Astro and scarop are basically breaking this social contract for cheap labor. Almost by definition, radonc has the worst culture in medicine because it expanded more than any other specialty.

 

[medgator]

I matched in the peak of competitiveness with most of my co-residents being MD/PhD, Ivy League type grads and I look at the current residents at my old program and just laugh and a part of me loves the fact that the same d-bag, stuffy snooty faculty that slummed it and had to hold their nose when they matched a state school grad with only a single publication now has to kiss the ass of Caribbean and DO grads with average scores to get them to match! This field is no where near as competitive as it was 10-15 years ago..not even same ballpark.

Yea to be clear Im not questioning their motivations at all and anyone who has a genuine interest in this field should be welcome to join it. Im really just speaking about PD considerations for job placement after training and the culture of our field.

Every single place Ive worked, academic and community, a person in a decision making position to hire has made comments to me about pedigree or place of training. Some obviously worse than others.

worst, most self-serving academic leadership in all of medicine. Continues to be proven year in, year out

Wouldn't go into rad onc just on that alone

 

[NotMattSpraker]

In principle, I don’t have a problem with

I am not sure how important motivations are. If I had soaped into anesthesia, or half a dozen other fields, I have no doubt I would be invested, and engaged and as or more competent than colleagues.

The essence of a “proffesion” dating back to middle age guilds is to wield a monopoly over a field and provide its practitioners with good income and work in return for certain standards/quality. Astro and scarop are basically breaking this social contract for cheap labor. Almost by definition, radonc has the worst culture in medicine because it expanded more than any other specialty.

This is a good point. The trainees are not necessarily "abused" despite the motivations of programs participating in SOAP. Id guess its common that those that SOAP in with no prior interest ultimately become competent and engaged radiation oncologists.

 

[Haybrant]

i wouldnt say the job market has improved at all and has actually gotten quite a bit worse. its like the housing market. are there houses on the market, yes lots of them. but when you get into the nitty gritty you all know that there are major fatal flaws with alot of those houses despite them being 50% more expensive than 7 years ago.

 

[medgator]

i wouldnt say the job market has improved at all and has actually gotten quite a bit worse. its like the housing market. are there houses on the market, yes lots of them. but when you get into the nitty gritty you all know that there are major fatal flaws with alot of those houses despite them being 50% more expensive than 7 years ago.

Way harder to lateral out of a bad job, way less independent/PP opportunity out there as a PSA model becomes less appealing and the deck is stacked against physician ownership/entrepreneurship

So it's basically dealing with large hospital/academic employers and veritable monopolies/duopolies when it comes time to job hunt in the context of too many grads coming out

 

[Chartreuse Wombat]

So it's basically dealing with large hospital/academic employers and veritable monopolies/duopolies when it comes time to job hunt in the context of too many grads coming out

Yes indeed. Employers have all of the leverage in most cases (not all, but most). This trend will only worsen as consolidation continues the race to the bottom.

 

[TheWallnerus]

Yes indeed. Employers have all of the leverage in most cases (not all, but most). This trend will only worsen as consolidation continues the race to the bottom.

If there’s one thing I wanted as medical student it was to spend a decade plus* of training and accumulate huge loan debt so I could choose a specialty where someone had “all the leverage” over me.




*counting my proton fellowship

 

[drowsy12]

If there’s one thing I wanted as medical student it was to spend a decade plus* of training and accumulate huge loan debt so I could choose a specialty where someone had “all the leverage” over me.




*counting my proton fellowship

If leverage is a goal of a medical student right now, they should look elsewhere.

Medicine is not what it was when you went to medical school, to say the least.

 

[medgator]

.


Given that most spots fill in SOAP, and there being so many R spots, I am beginning to wonder if spots that were "decreased" in the initial match, are just being used as reserved spots.
Anyone with a residency program know?

191 spots in the match, up from prior year


Huh?

 

[Chartreuse Wombat]

In my book the best simple metrics for "competitiveness" are # of Senior US MD/DOs applying and % of spots filled by Senior US MD/DOs.

Using these 2025 was improved from the last five years but nowhere near the 200 + applicants and 95%+ from a decade ago