Every adcom, pre-med advisor, and bit of pre-med urban myth has it that if your scores are widely off from each other, you are not a "well rounded" candidate. Of course, all kind of people get in all over the place with weirdnesses on their GPA and their MCAT. Hell, I got a C in my first semester of Orgo, and I got in, but an Ad Com told me that my 12 verbal was more impressive than a 12 in either of the others. I don't think they see those alot. I think it depends on what the rest of your app is like. If you have strong clinical or research or volunteer experience and can really speak to those, it'll draw people away from other inconsistencies in your app. If you're really only going on MCAT's and GPA, then I'd say retake it. It seems like you're super-golden on the sciences, so I'd say throw all of your concentration into studying for the verbal. And even if you come down to an 11 or a 10 in Physical and Biological and bring the verbal up to a 9 or a 10, I think you're in better shape. Either way, it'll suck to take that test again, I'm glad I don't. My heart is with you, brother!