Med School Internal Ranking Transparency

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

compstomper

Full Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2007
Messages
217
Reaction score
192
How transparent are your schools with regards to how class ranks works? (Quartile vs quintile vs specific class position). I ask because a classmate asked about how internal class ranking works at our school and was stonewalled, which raised some red flags for me.
 
Every school is different so it's hard to make any blanket statements. Ours was very open with me regarding how ranks are maintained and how certain things like AOA are chosen. Of course the real questions that matter:

1) where do YOU rank?
2) how does this impact things like AOA?
3) how/will this be reported on your MSPE?

Answers to the first question for us are not really given, though you can infer your general position. We have some awards given to the top student at certain points so you would know you were 1st at that point in time, though obviously that's a dynamic thing. Things like AOA would tell you that you were at least to 25% and likely much higher.

Most AOA chapters are pretty open about how members are elected. While each school varies slightly, membership is drawn from the top quartile per national rules. Beyond this is somewhat more school-specific.

MSPE reporting varies dramatically. Our school does not report outright rank nor do they use a "code word" like some schools. They do report our grades and they show rough histograms of the grade distribution, but not an overall one.

If you talk to any faculty who review residency apps from around the country, they can attest to how different these things are and how difficult it can be to figure out. I think this is why boards are so heavily relied-upon
 
How transparent are your schools with regards to how class ranks works? (Quartile vs quintile vs specific class position). I ask because a classmate asked about how internal class ranking works at our school and was stonewalled, which raised some red flags for me.
Depends. Some schools are quite transparent on their websites, some are not. If you're concerned, you should talk to your Dean of Student Affairs and ask to see a sample MSPE. Some use actual ordinal rank, quartile/quintile or whatever segment of the class you fall in, or code word "Compstomper will make an outstanding/excellent/very good/good" house officer" which then has a rubric at the end of the MSPE which tells where you are.
 
We weren't allowed to 'know'. But, then again, it is irrelevant for residency (for the vast vast majority of people), so I'm not sure why anyone would care.
Why?
 

I have no idea. I didn't know we were internally ranked and we were retooling our curriculum (or trying to at least) and some administrator mentioned the rankings and I asked where it was stored/how people could find out their ranking (assuming that it was just posted on our web portal or something). They shrugged and said, "Oh, we don't give that out." I shrugged and kept working. Never really followed up on the 'why'. I can't imagine any good reasons though. The whole thing is stupid.
 
I have no idea. I didn't know we were internally ranked and we were retooling our curriculum (or trying to at least) and some administrator mentioned the rankings and I asked where it was stored/how people could find out their ranking (assuming that it was just posted on our web portal or something). They shrugged and said, "Oh, we don't give that out." I shrugged and kept working. Never really followed up on the 'why'. I can't imagine any good reasons though. The whole thing is stupid.
Oh we weren't ranked by ordinals either. It was by "code word", I believe.
 
ask for a past MSPE from your school. boom issue solved.

screw you derm I wrote this before I saw your post
 
ask for a past MSPE from your school. boom issue solved.

screw you derm I wrote this before I saw your post
I've never understood why people don't ask. The worst they can say is no. And you'll be hearing that a lot thru med school from admins anyways.
 
I've never understood why people don't ask. The worst they can say is no. And you'll be hearing that a lot thru med school from admins anyways.

They'll send me a sample one with a random code-word, I'll reply in an email " Can you send the key used for the code words?" Administrator immediately acquires look of horror on their face. Yes, you've been figured out sucker.
 
They'll send me a sample one with a random code-word, I'll reply in an email " Can you send the key used for the code words?" Administrator immediately acquires look of horror on their face. Yes, you've been figured out sucker.
They'll hope you'll be satisfied on seeing the word "Very Good" thinking everyone gets that.
 
Had to hop through so much administrative hoops, but I eventually found out that my school ranks by quartiles on the MSPE. Thanks to everyone for all of your input.
 
I have no idea. I didn't know we were internally ranked and we were retooling our curriculum (or trying to at least) and some administrator mentioned the rankings and I asked where it was stored/how people could find out their ranking (assuming that it was just posted on our web portal or something). They shrugged and said, "Oh, we don't give that out." I shrugged and kept working. Never really followed up on the 'why'. I can't imagine any good reasons though. The whole thing is stupid.

Ditto.

We weren't allowed to know either.

It vaguely annoyed me but no one every really pushed the admin on this.

Apparently they routinely gave out a super-secret scholarship to the top-ranked M1.
 
Ditto.

We weren't allowed to know either.

It vaguely annoyed me but no one every really pushed the admin on this.

Apparently they routinely gave out a super-secret scholarship to the top-ranked M1.

entering 4th year or what?
 
How transparent are your schools with regards to how class ranks works? (Quartile vs quintile vs specific class position). I ask because a classmate asked about how internal class ranking works at our school and was stonewalled, which raised some red flags for me.

My school is very transparent in terms what the ranking system is and how the rankings are determined. So for example they tell us that we are ranked in quartiles based on overall grade in each course, they tell us how many credits each course is worth, and they tell us that our quartile ranking for each course goes on our transcript and our overall class ranking (e.g. 75/150) goes on our MSPE. However, they will not tell us what our individual rank is or what quartile we were in for each class.

Some scholarships are based on class rank in that you must be above a certain threshold to be considered. If you are lucky enough to receive a merit scholarship after M1, you are notified via email of your scholarship amount, what the scholarship is called, and what the conditions are to be eligible.. So if I get an email saying "Congrats, you have been awarded the SDN Super Gunner Award in the amount of $10,000 per semester. Eligibility for this award is dependent on MS2 standing, top 10% of your class after completion of MS1, and greater than 100 hours spent on SDN biweekly" then I know I am an MS2 currently in the top 10% of my class who spends >100 hours on SDN biweekly. Otherwise, there's no way for me to know what percentile I'm in.
 
Ditto.

We weren't allowed to know either.

It vaguely annoyed me but no one every really pushed the admin on this.

Apparently they routinely gave out a super-secret scholarship to the top-ranked M1.
M1?!? or M4?
 
Ditto.

We weren't allowed to know either.

It vaguely annoyed me but no one every really pushed the admin on this.

Apparently they routinely gave out a super-secret scholarship to the top-ranked M1.
So they just said sorry we're not sending you the last page of your MSPE?
 
So they just said sorry we're not sending you the last page of your MSPE?

When we met with our dean we were told what adjective they would be using along with a loose approximation of what that meant. We were never shown our entire MSPE. (although I was allowed to review a copy at one of my interviews lol)
.
M1?!? or M4?

After M1. My friend showed me the email - very similar to what seminoma outlined above. Congratulations on your wonderful achievement blah blah blah, then the amount of the scholarship and the conditions for it continuing.
 
When we met with our dean we were told what adjective they would be using along with a loose approximation of what that meant. We were never shown our entire MSPE. (although I was allowed to review a copy at one of my interviews lol)
I've never understood why they would do that. Students need to know where they fall in the class so they can decide which specialties are open for them. The MSPE is essentially your transcript from medical school. Maybe they're afraid of students contesting their code word - How dare you, I'm not "Excellent", I'm "Outstanding"! Then you have some schools who will filter evaluation comments, and others who won't touch it at all (or not without an extended process of appeal).
 
When we met with our dean we were told what adjective they would be using along with a loose approximation of what that meant. We were never shown our entire MSPE. (although I was allowed to review a copy at one of my interviews lol)
.


After M1. My friend showed me the email - very similar to what seminoma outlined above. Congratulations on your wonderful achievement blah blah blah, then the amount of the scholarship and the conditions for it continuing.

how much we talkin here, like 500 bucks or 50k?
 
I've never understood why they would do that. Students need to know where they fall in the class so they can decide which specialties are open for them. The MSPE is essentially your transcript from medical school. Maybe they're afraid of students contesting their code word - How dare you, I'm not "Excellent", I'm "Outstanding"! Then you have some schools who will filter evaluation comments, and others who won't touch it at all (or not without an extended process of appeal).

My school claims that grades aren't important (lol) and that knowing specifics would increase competition and takeaway from teamwork (lol again).
1. If grades weren't important you wouldn't be grading me.
2. If you tell me my class rank the only thing I'm going to do is keep doing what I'm doing or perhaps reach out to my classmates for help if my class rank is a lot lower than I thought. If my school told me today that I'm far and away #1 in my class I wouldn't suddenly start being more (or less) competitive or less (or more) helpful to my classmates.

how much we talkin here, like 500 bucks or 50k?

$8k for the year at my school. Top 10% is eligible, but I don't know how many of those people are actually awarded the scholarship.
 
I've never understood why they would do that. Students need to know where they fall in the class so they can decide which specialties are open for them. The MSPE is essentially your transcript from medical school. Maybe they're afraid of students contesting their code word - How dare you, I'm not "Excellent", I'm "Outstanding"! Then you have some schools who will filter evaluation comments, and others who won't touch it at all (or not without an extended process of appeal).

We were fortunate to have advisers in general surgery (and the other fields, from what my classmates said) who gave very realistic and appropriate advice. My general surgery mentor correctly predicted about 90% of my interview yield.

But at the same time I was a pretty good candidate applying for a only moderately competitive field, so I never had the need to have any "come to jesus" type talks with our dean. I have heard rumors of others in my class who did.
 
how much we talkin here, like 500 bucks or 50k?
The ones that I know that give full scholarships to medical school do it before M1 even starts, like Canby Robinson scholars at Vanderbilt.
 
We were fortunate to have advisers in general surgery (and the other fields, from what my classmates said) who gave very realistic and appropriate advice. My general surgery mentor correctly predicted about 90% of my interview yield.

But at the same time I was a pretty good candidate applying for a only moderately competitive field, so I never had the need to have any "come to jesus" type talks with our dean. I have heard rumors of others in my class who did.
Oh, so your general surgery mentor then knew where you stood in your class (even though you didn't).
 
Oh, so your general surgery mentor then knew where you stood in your class (even though you didn't).

I guess I don't know the answer to that. He knew my grades and my board score to be sure...I always just sort of assumed he had been around the block long enough to know where that meant I stood in the general scheme of things.

I don't know if the school gave him access to more information, but I suppose it's possible.
 
My school claims that grades aren't important (lol) and that knowing specifics would increase competition and takeaway from teamwork (lol again).
1. If grades weren't important you wouldn't be grading me.
2. If you tell me my class rank the only thing I'm going to do is keep doing what I'm doing or perhaps reach out to my classmates for help if my class rank is a lot lower than I thought. If my school told me today that I'm far and away #1 in my class I wouldn't suddenly start being more (or less) competitive or less (or more) helpful to my classmates.
I swear half of SDN's Raison d'être is bc people's medical schools bald-faced lie to them. "Oh, we're not ranking you!" Yes, correct, they aren't sending your exact ordinal rank in the class to programs, but they do tell what segment of the class you fall in whether that's specific quartile, by code word adjectives (with the rubric at the end that explains that code word), etc. I understand with some people it might make them more nervous, more competitive, but is it better to just to make it up?

I can't imagine lying to medical students and telling them one thing at MS-1 and then when an MS-4 comes for guidance on specialty selection telling them, Oh we've been ranking you this whole time, my bad". Of course, medical school administrators aren't exactly known for having a conscience when it comes to lying to medical students to meet their ends.

There was one student here whose medical school told him he didn't need to study long for boards, using board review books was unnecessary, and that their score wasn't that important. That's ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
I swear half of SDN's raison d'etre is bc people's medical schools bald-faced lie to them. "Oh, we're not ranking you!" Yes, correct, they aren't sending your exact ordinal rank in the class to programs, but they do tell what segment of the class you fall in whether that's specific quartile, by code word adjectives (with the rubric at the end that explains that code word), etc. I understand with some people it might make them more nervous, more competitive, but is it better to just to make it up?

I can't imagine lying to medical students and telling them one thing at MS-1 and then when an MS-4 comes for guidance on specialty selection telling them, Oh we've been ranking you this whole time, my bad". Of course, medical school administrators aren't exactly known for having a conscience when it comes to lying to medical students to meet their ends.

There was one student here whose medical school told him he didn't need to study long for boards, using board review books was unnecessary, and that their score wasn't that important. That's ridiculous.
Hence why I donated to SDN. I wouldn't have gotten into a single med school if I had just taken the advice of PhDs or premed advisors at undergrad.

I'm glad I chose not to go to the school I "liked" the most, and instead chose to go to the school that gave me the largest scholarship, or else I'd have a big case of buyer's remorse what with the constant obfuscation by the school administration and all.

This is why SDN is my go to place if I need any real advice from people in the know, and not be fed a bunch of BS by school administrators.
 
Hence why I donated to SDN. I wouldn't have gotten into a single med school if I had just taken the advice of PhDs or premed advisors at undergrad.

I'm glad I chose not to go to the school I "liked" the most, and instead chose to go to the school that gave me the largest scholarship, or else I'd have a big case of buyer's remorse what with the constant obfuscation by the school administration and all.

This is why SDN is my go to place if I need any real advice from people in the know, and not be fed a bunch of BS by school administrators.

that type of crap is the only reason I stay on this site. I disagree with a ton of people on it, but the information on it is too valuable to pass up. I've learned more about the entire process and how it works from this site than I have from my school for sure.
 
Hence why I donated to SDN. I wouldn't have gotten into a single med school if I had just taken the advice of PhDs or premed advisors at undergrad.

I'm glad I chose not to go to the school I "liked" the most, and instead chose to go to the school that gave me the largest scholarship, or else I'd have a big case of buyer's remorse what with the constant obfuscation by the school administration and all.

This is why SDN is my go to place if I need any real advice from people in the know, and not be fed a bunch of BS by school administrators.
As much as medical school administrators and admissions officers say not to ever trust advice on SDN (which yes, there is a sprinkling of that), a lot of advice that is given is actually quite good and valuable, esp. if you're struggling with something (and we all struggle with something in med school at some point). I think it also helps in finding out the current going ons of the school - change in curriculum, change in grading scheme, student body culture (this is a big one), etc. That admissions people and the brownnoser med student who do med school tours won't let you be privy to. Same story for residency program interviews. A lot of it is reading in between the lines.

Part of the problem with med school admissions, medical school, residency, etc. is the huge knowledge asymmetry. For example, they get to know your MCAT scores, but you're not allowed to know their Step 1 averages. You're given the line "Oh, we're above the national average." - when it comes to pass rate and mean score. Well if all schools say this, then someone is lying. (Caveat: University of Virginia - is very transparent on their website about their board scores even posting their score reports for people to see). I think SDN helps a lot with premeds, med students, and even residents going for fellowship getting to look behind the curtain.

To be fair, in your scenario, your decision isn't necessarily the right answer for everyone, and I think it depends a lot on what you're going for, where you see yourself as an attending, what schools you are deciding between, etc. No school is 100% perfect nor should they be 100% deferential to the med student. There are med schools that are fantastic to their students, average, and mediocre to their students when it comes to helping them get to where they want to go. We all use the same books for classes, boards, etc. - that's not ALL of what medical education is and residency faculty know this.
 
I wish I went to Baylor. Instead I go to a school that says don't worry about what's in FA, worry about what I tell you is clinically important and testable.
 
Urban legend says that the top student at Harvard gets a 1 million unrestricted scholarship and their choice of any residency in the country.

Not srs
 
I wish I went to Baylor. Instead I go to a school that says don't worry about what's in FA, worry about what I tell you is clinically important and testable.
It's one thing to say not to 100% rely on First Aid. It's another thing to say not to use it at all. This is a standardized exam. Going thru your PhD professor's powerpoints is not a good use of your time to review for Step 1. Step 1 doesn't test what's "clinically important" all the time. It tests things in clinical vignette window dressing, but the underlying principle is a basic science concept.
 
Hence why I donated to SDN. I wouldn't have gotten into a single med school if I had just taken the advice of PhDs or premed advisors at undergrad.

I'm glad I chose not to go to the school I "liked" the most, and instead chose to go to the school that gave me the largest scholarship, or else I'd have a big case of buyer's remorse what with the constant obfuscation by the school administration and all.

This is why SDN is my go to place if I need any real advice from people in the know, and not be fed a bunch of BS by school administrators.

Glad someone listened to people like me. You have no idea how frustrating it is to listen to clueless premeds wax poetic about the importance of rankings and match lists
 
Glad someone listened to people like me. You have no idea how frustrating it is to listen to clueless premeds wax poetic about the importance of rankings and match lists
I'm going to have to report you for this comment. Mainly bc I don't like it.
 
LOL. It was in reference to Psai giving good personal advice to another user in another thread and the user took it badly (and then cursed him out).

I know. And that poster had started the sniping by posting "reported" as a one line response to a pretty innocent comment.

So now I'm hoping "reported" becomes a thing
 
Glad someone listened to people like me. You have no idea how frustrating it is to listen to clueless premeds wax poetic about the importance of rankings and match lists

they're all so stupid they deserve what they get. I'd love to know what percent of those know it all pre-meds even make it into medical school.
 
they're all so stupid they deserve what they get. I'd love to know what percent of those know it all pre-meds even make it into medical school.
It's stupid to correlate a USWNR ranking with a match list. That being said, if you are at a top tier med school, your chances of matching into a good institution even in an non-competitive specialty is quite good. I think WashU (for example), which doesn't have the name-dropping potential that Harvard, Penn, or Yale does, is a good example of this. There are many people here on SDN who are at the top of every metric, and are just shocked that they aren't getting interviews at UCSF, BWH, MGH, JHU, etc.

I think sometimes the realistic expectation of med students is a work in progress.
 
lol pre-med thread about illegal immigrants getting spots in schools : http://forums.studentdoctor.net/thr...n-medical-school-spots.1098152/#post-15678739

Someone they turned someone saying illegal immigrants shouldn't be allowed into medical school into "being against immigration." Uh no stupid f*ck, I'm cool with immigrants, they're just as American as me, provided they do so through the legal channels. However if an illegal gets a spot in medical school, that's pretty screwed up. I'm pretty sure if you're hard working enough to get into medical school, you can get into the country legally.


Look at this gem obtained from that thread.
https://www.aamc.org/download/321520/data/2013factstable25-5.pdf

So someone with a 5-14 MCAT and a 3.4-3.59 GPA got into an american medical school last year... Look at those stats. 25 % of those minorities who got 18-20 with a 3.8+ are in. lol 53 % from 21-23 with 3.8+ and 83% with 24-26 got in. It's lovely to know that with the MCAT score I got without studying after 1 year of college I'd have a 90+ % chance of getting accepted if I were one of those minorities and applying through trad route.
 
Last edited:
lol pre-med thread about illegal immigrants getting spots in schools : http://forums.studentdoctor.net/thr...n-medical-school-spots.1098152/#post-15678739

Someone they turned someone saying illegal immigrants shouldn't be allowed into medical school into "being against immigration." Uh no stupid f*ck, I'm cool with immigrants, they're just as American as me, provided they do so through the legal channels. However if an illegal gets a spot in medical school, that's pretty screwed up. I'm pretty sure if you're hard working enough to get into medical school, you can get into the country legally.


Look at this gem obtained from that thread.
https://www.aamc.org/download/321520/data/2013factstable25-5.pdf

So someone with a 5-14 MCAT and a 3.4-3.59 GPA got into an american medical school last year... Look at those stats. 25 % of those minorities who got 18-20 with a 3.8+ are in. lol 53 % from 21-23 with 3.8+ and 83% with 24-26 got in. It's lovely to know that with the MCAT score I got without studying after 1 year of college I'd have a 90+ % chance of getting accepted if I were one of those minorities and applying through trad route.
This is very well known in medical education as the statistics/charts released by the AAMC support this. Yes, at the same MCAT/GPA metric, if you are Black or Hispanic, your chances of getting into medical school are higher than say an Asian/White. That's just the facts and the AAMC has released that data which you posted.

The AAMC is quite clear and upfront about this and in the Fisher vs. UT Austin case, wrote an amicus curiae brief advising the court not to stop affirmative action in their goal to achieve diversity (in this case, by skin color).

The school you are referring to that takes illegal immigrants into med school is Loyola: http://www.thecollegefix.com/post/19194/
 
This is very well known in medical education as the statistics/charts released by the AAMC support this. Yes, at the same MCAT/GPA metric, if you are Black or Hispanic, your chances of getting into medical school are higher than say an Asian/White. That's just the facts and the AAMC has released that data which you posted.

The AAMC is quite clear and upfront about this and in the Fisher vs. UT Austin case, wrote an amicus curiae brief advising the court not to stop affirmative action in their goal to achieve diversity (in this case, by skin color).

The school you are referring to that takes illegal immigrants into med school is Loyola: http://www.thecollegefix.com/post/19194/

They're openly committing a felony. I wish them nothing good.

Also jesus christ is pre-allo stupid. My god if darknight and I were preaching about marriage, they'd probably doxx us to "teach us a lesson about how the world works." or something bs like that.
 
They're openly committing a felony. I wish them nothing good.

Also jesus christ is pre-allo stupid. My god if darknight and I were preaching about marriage, they'd probably doxx us to "teach us a lesson about how the world works." or something bs like that.
I don't know about felony. If you read the article, apparently it's under DACA under Obama's executive order. I like the line: Mark Kuczewski, chair of Loyola’s department of medical education, told Crain’s Chicago Business that he is surprised no one else is following Loyola’s lead. “I am a little surprised that we’re not hearing more interest within the state,” he said.

My favorite comment: "Well, in the defense of these illegal immigrants: they are just going to the medical schools that American students just aren't willing to go to anymore."
 
I don't know about felony. If you read the article, apparently it's under DACA under Obama's executive order. I like the line: Mark Kuczewski, chair of Loyola’s department of medical education, told Crain’s Chicago Business that he is surprised no one else is following Loyola’s lead. “I am a little surprised that we’re not hearing more interest within the state,” he said.

My favorite comment: "Well, in the defense of these illegal immigrants: they are just going to the medical schools that American students just aren't willing to go to anymore."

anyone that assists an illegal is committing a felony.


A person (including a group of persons, business, organization, or local government) commits a federal felony when she or he:

* assists an alien s/he should reasonably know is illegally in the U.S. or who lacks employment authorization, by transporting, sheltering, or assisting him or her to obtain employment, or

* encourages that alien to remain in the U.S. by referring him or her to an employer or by acting as employer or agent for an employer in any way, or

* knowingly assists illegal aliens due to personal convictions.

lol DACA is about not deporting them I love how some crackpot academic turned that into getting them into medical school. and LOLOLOL at there being medical schools that medical students from USA won't go to. there's people in the Carribean that would probably fight those people to the death for their seat.
 
anyone that assists an illegal is committing a felony.


A person (including a group of persons, business, organization, or local government) commits a federal felony when she or he:

* assists an alien s/he should reasonably know is illegally in the U.S. or who lacks employment authorization, by transporting, sheltering, or assisting him or her to obtain employment, or

* encourages that alien to remain in the U.S. by referring him or her to an employer or by acting as employer or agent for an employer in any way, or

* knowingly assists illegal aliens due to personal convictions.

lol DACA is about not deporting them I love how some crackpot academic turned that into getting them into medical school. and LOLOLOL at there being medical schools that medical students from USA won't go to. there's people in the Carribean that would probably fight those people to the death for their seat.
Yes, but DACA only applies to only a certain subset of immigrants who are here illegally - those were brought here illegally before the age of 16. Essentially they are in limbo are allowed to stay.

"DACA was created in 2012 when President Obama signed an executive order that stated, in effect, that illegal immigrant children who were brought to the United States before their 16th birthday, are currently no older than 31, and have completed a certain level of education or military service, can obtain work permits and Social Security numbers."
 
Top