Medical school Interview Help

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

hellohelpwithfuture

Full Member
5+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 25, 2017
Messages
183
Reaction score
214
Hi guys,

I am worried about medical school interviews because I want to share why I got interested in medicine but I am worried that I will get too emotional during the interview. Does anyone have any tips on how to get out these feelings during an interview? Has anyone else had this problem?
 
Hi guys,

I am worried about medical school interviews because I want to share why I got interested in medicine but I am worried that I will get too emotional during the interview. Does anyone have any tips on how to get out these feelings during an interview? Has anyone else had this problem?
Practice, practice, practice!!!!
Meditation, mindfulness, counseling might help as well.
 
I totally empathize, I tend to cry when I get even a little bit emotional. Like Goro said, practice. If you practice and you still can't talk about something without getting overly emotional, it's probably best to avoid talking about that altogether. If you do feel like you're about to start crying, take a moment or wait until the interviewer starts talking and count backwards from 100 by 7s.

If it helps, I cried during an interview and still got accepted to that school.
 
Hi guys,

I am worried about medical school interviews because I want to share why I got interested in medicine but I am worried that I will get too emotional during the interview. Does anyone have any tips on how to get out these feelings during an interview? Has anyone else had this problem?

DO NOT CRY DURING THE THE INTERVIEW, OR ANY INTERVIEW EVER!!

Keeping that in mind, if you an make the interviewer cry, that would be fantastic. The interviewee crying makes you look weak and unstable, risking being seen as an emo, and it could make all present uncomfortable. Don't create an awkward situation.
 
Hi guys,

I am worried about medical school interviews because I want to share why I got interested in medicine but I am worried that I will get too emotional during the interview. Does anyone have any tips on how to get out these feelings during an interview? Has anyone else had this problem?
You definitely need to practice. Not to the extent that you become robotic in your response, but enough to hear, and then modulate, your own voice as you touch on emotional issues. Along with that, however, you might consider utilizing the following technique: dig your thumb fingernail into one of your other fingers (not enough to impale your self (lol), but enough to feel it. You might find this action will disengage your emotional responsiveness to where you will be better able to maintain a sense of calm.
 
You definitely need to practice. Not to the extent that you become robotic in your response, but enough to hear, and then modulate, your own voice as you touch on emotional issues. Along with that, however, you might consider utilizing the following technique: dig your thumb fingernail into one of your other fingers (not enough to impale your self (lol), but enough to feel it. You might find this action will disengage your emotional responsiveness to where you will be better able to maintain a sense of calm.

If that doesn't work, pull a fidget spinner out of your pocket and go sit in the corner and rock back and forth. 🤣
 
This is not true!!!

I had a nontrad advisee who wrote on her challenge essay about getting a divorce and foreclosing on house as her challenge essay. One of her interviewers, who turned out to be a psychiatrist, probed her on this and she broke down during the session. She now attends this Ivy

Sure, it isn't universally true. BUT, you better have a damn good reason to start crying. Risk vs benefit analysis, risk outweighs benefit most of the time. It is possible to discuss sensitive topics while displaying emotion and not crying. For example, you had a child that died of medical illness = good reason.
 
Wow powerful story, sometimes the human element and connection breaks through even the most formal processes!
This is not true!!!

I had a nontrad advisee who wrote on her challenge essay about getting a divorce and foreclosing on house as her challenge essay. One of her interviewers, who turned out to be a psychiatrist, probed her on this and she broke down during the session. She now attends this Ivy
 
I totally empathize, I tend to cry when I get even a little bit emotional. Like Goro said, practice. If you practice and you still can't talk about something without getting overly emotional, it's probably best to avoid talking about that altogether. If you do feel like you're about to start crying, take a moment or wait until the interviewer starts talking and count backwards from 100 by 7s.

If it helps, I cried during an interview and still got accepted to that school.
Wow you cried, must have been a powerful moment.
 
Wow you cried, must have been a powerful moment.

LOL nope. The second to last MMI station kind of hit close to home for me, and if I had cried during that station it probably would have been a powerful moment. Instead, I waited until I was done with that stating and about to go into the final station to start bawling. So I walked into the station crying for no apparent reason. The interviewer was very baffled but very nice about it. Funnily enough, I see that lady almost every day now. I wonder if she remembers that I was the weirdo who cried.
 
I think that's not too uncommon but practicing should help as other have suggested. You should practice with strangers that don't know you to recreate the same sore of realistic situation
 
He is how my interview went with admissions. I did not cry but I had the voice that sounded like I wanted to cry the whole time it was horrible I even paused took some breaths it didn't help but I think that more practice I will definitely get better. He just asked why do you want to go to medical school I blanked and immediately started talking about all the things that I was going to advoid so I don't cry lol. And I could tell he was set back but he dealt with the situation as if I was not about to cry. The main reason I want to go to medical school is very emotional to me there is no way I can go to an interview and not talk about it. It Is the only reason that made me want to go to med school. But I will keep practicing with other people and see how it goes
 
LOL nope. The second to last MMI station kind of hit close to home for me, and if I had cried during that station it probably would have been a powerful moment. Instead, I waited until I was done with that stating and about to go into the final station to start bawling. So I walked into the station crying for no apparent reason. The interviewer was very baffled but very nice about it. Funnily enough, I see that lady almost every day now. I wonder if she remembers that I was the weirdo who cried.

You should reach out to her, might be interesting to see what she recollects. BTW that must have been interesting for your interviewers - kind of changes the power dynamic in the room. I did an interview once, where there was a person sat quietly in the corner, slightly out of my eye-line who was silent (their job was as a distraction only). After the two main interviewers had finished their questions by instinct I swiveled around to the person in the corner presuming that they had questions to ask. The three interviewers burst out laughing as no one had done this, completely changed the tone of the interview and the person in the corner was no longer this scary other presence anymore.
 
W
I think that's not too uncommon but practicing should help as other have suggested. You should practice with strangers that don't know you to recreate the same sore of realistic situation
Where to find strangers though!!! Lol
 
He is how my interview went with admissions. I did not cry but I had the voice that sounded like I wanted to cry the whole time it was horrible I even paused took some breaths it didn't help but I think that more practice I will definitely get better. He just asked why do you want to go to medical school I blanked and immediately started talking about all the things that I was going to advoid so I don't cry lol. And I could tell he was set back but he dealt with the situation as if I was not about to cry. The main reason I want to go to medical school is very emotional to me there is no way I can go to an interview and not talk about it. It Is the only reason that made me want to go to med school. But I will keep practicing with other people and see how it goes
I guess it is that balance of telling your story, with the importance of those emotions, but allowing yourself still to have that control to deliver this in an effective way. Very tough, but I guess good practice as to what we will have to do as medical professionals in our future lives (fingers crossed).
 
I didn't really cry during one my interviews, but I was getting very emotional to the point where I was fighting it back and the interviewer grabbed me a box of tissues... will let you know how it goes hahaha
 
I didn't really cry during one my interviews, but I was getting very emotional to the point where I was fighting it back and the interviewer grabbed me a box of tissues... will let you know how it goes hahaha
The fact that there was tissues present suggest you were not the first!?!?!?
 
My opinion as a non-ADCOM.

Crying doesn't make you weak, but I don't think it makes you 'strong' either.

I'd rather someone keep their composure than become too emotional.

Some people would just about cry during their thesis defense, and they would cry right after (almost exclusively girls, but I knew guys that would mess up by just zoning out).

Being too emotional only seems to hinder performance.

That's just my 2 cents, but I would personally avoid being too emotional, as that might show your passion, but also shows that you're very emotional, which could cause hindrances of performance.

In my opinion.
 
Last edited:
There's no firm rule here.

The reason for the tears makes a big difference. Crying because you're nervous will not make you look good to an interviewer. Crying over something truly heart-wrenching humanizes you. We don't want 4.0 robots, we want high-functioning geniuses who care about people.

In addition, the context matters greatly. Ask me about my father's illness and death, and I'll answer without tears. Ask me the right questions about it, and I'll get misty-eyed every time.

Finally, "normal" encompasses a wide range of personalities and behaviors. Some people are more stoic, others are more emotional. Both types of people can become incredible doctors. What you don't want is to be out of the normal range.
 
Being able to talk about the tough topics in a level-headed yet compassionate way shows a maturity and fortitude that many don’t possess, and that, I believe, is required of a quality physician. In my successful interview, the majority of it was focused on my 7+ years of experiencing childhood sexual abuse and my PTSD diagnosis and how that, in a bizarre turn of fortune, led to a career rehabilitating and advocating for the most heinous sexually violent offenders in my state, and the compassion I had developed not only for my patients but also for myself along the way. I believe you have to reach an inner sense of calm about the hardships in your life and face them head on, and be able to discuss them with dignity and courage - if you can do so, it will shine through in your interview, regardless of the presence of tears. Emotions are NOT a sign of weakness; just make sure it is your inner strength that the committee takes away from their time with you!
 
There's no firm rule here.

The reason for the tears makes a big difference. Crying because you're nervous will not make you look good to an interviewer. Crying over something truly heart-wrenching humanizes you. We don't want 4.0 robots, we want high-functioning geniuses who care about people.

In addition, the context matters greatly. Ask me about my father's illness and death, and I'll answer without tears. Ask me the right questions about it, and I'll get misty-eyed every time.

Finally, "normal" encompasses a wide range of personalities and behaviors. Some people are more stoic, others are more emotional. Both types of people can become incredible doctors. What you don't want is to be out of the normal range.
Being able to talk about the tough topics in a level-headed yet compassionate way shows a maturity and fortitude that many don’t possess, and that, I believe, is required of a quality physician. In my successful interview, the majority of it was focused on my 7+ years of experiencing childhood sexual abuse and my PTSD diagnosis and how that, in a bizarre turn of fortune, led to a career rehabilitating and advocating for the most heinous sexually violent offenders in my state, and the compassion I had developed not only for my patients but also for myself along the way. I believe you have to reach an inner sense of calm about the hardships in your life and face them head on, and be able to discuss them with dignity and courage - if you can do so, it will shine through in your interview, regardless of the presence of tears. Emotions are NOT a sign of weakness; just make sure it is your inner strength that the committee takes away from their time with you!

Thank you for your replies. To just flat out say it, I developed a condition that led me to want to research and treat others with this condition. I have developed many negative emotions with this condition, but they have allowed me to develop a strong passion and motivation to go above and beyond to help others that are going through what I am went through. I really need to practice my interview skills. As it makes me very emotional because it brings up feelings of what has happened to me but also emotion because I know countless others struggling with the same condition and I want to make a difference for them.

I really feel that crying would make me appear overly emotional and would negatively impact my interview, but I feel it is not avoidable because I have been practicing and cry everytime. I am most terrified that I will cry the whole interview or be so overly emotional that I can't speak. I want to appear strong and show them the amazing path I want to go down, but I feel they will only see someone that looks like they cracks under pressure and is not fit to see pts.

My last meeting with admissions I did not cry, but had the voice of someone that wanted to cry which lead me to become extremely self-conscious and loss of eye contact and not being able to explain what I wanted to explain because I knew I would start to cry.
 
Thank you for your replies. To just flat out say it, I developed a condition that led me to want to research and treat others with this condition. I have developed many negative emotions with this condition, but they have allowed me to develop a strong passion and motivation to go above and beyond to help others that are going through what I am went through. I really need to practice my interview skills. As it makes me very emotional because it brings up feelings of what has happened to me but also emotion because I know countless others struggling with the same condition and I want to make a difference for them.

I really feel that crying would make me appear overly emotional and would negatively impact my interview, but I feel it is not avoidable because I have been practicing and cry everytime. I am most terrified that I will cry the whole interview or be so overly emotional that I can't speak. I want to appear strong and show them the amazing path I want to go down, but I feel they will only see someone that looks like they cracks under pressure and is not fit to see pts.

My last meeting with admissions I did not cry, but had the voice of someone that wanted to cry which lead me to become extremely self-conscious and loss of eye contact and not being able to explain what I wanted to explain because I knew I would start to cry.

Ok here's a crash course on how to do this. This is a very common issue and sometimes even professionals struggle with it. If you've been to enough live theater and vocal performances, you've seen people get emotionally overcome and struggle to get the job done. It happens, we're human. So how to deal with it? This is what I learned from my years making a living on the stage:

1) Rehearse. Not just any rehearse mind you, but rehearse getting yourself worked up emotionally. Reciting your story without crying to 10 people is just a big waste of time as far as this goes. You've got to recite your story and lose it emotionally in front of a few people. For actors and singers we have a regimented rehearsal process with our colleagues on a production where part of the goal is to find that edge of emotion where we can still function but give the most compelling performance we can. While not playing a scripted part, you as an interviewer need to find that same edge and the only way to find it is to practice going over it a few times.

2) Recognize your tells that you're getting to that edge and have a strategy to collect yourself. My personal one is to stop speaking and and count 2-3 breaths, then start again.

3) If you're still struggling, it's time for the big guns. You need to have a plan for something to think about that will immediately pull you from the emotional brink. What works for me and many other artists is to picture something extremely sensationally sexual, the more outlandish the better. For whatever reason, this part of the brain seems to shut down the sad emotional pathway pretty fast. Just keep upping the ante with your mental pictures. Sorry if this sounds terribly crass, but it's a tried and true technique that has saved many a performance for me personally and for many of my friends. Also useful as a guy during a sad movie if you don't want to lose it in front of your date.

In the end you may still go over the edge and cry and that's okay. Just take a breath, get a tissue, pause, and keep going.
 
Ok here's a crash course on how to do this. This is a very common issue and sometimes even professionals struggle with it. If you've been to enough live theater and vocal performances, you've seen people get emotionally overcome and struggle to get the job done. It happens, we're human. So how to deal with it? This is what I learned from my years making a living on the stage:

1) Rehearse. Not just any rehearse mind you, but rehearse getting yourself worked up emotionally. Reciting your story without crying to 10 people is just a big waste of time as far as this goes. You've got to recite your story and lose it emotionally in front of a few people. For actors and singers we have a regimented rehearsal process with our colleagues on a production where part of the goal is to find that edge of emotion where we can still function but give the most compelling performance we can. While not playing a scripted part, you as an interviewer need to find that same edge and the only way to find it is to practice going over it a few times.

2) Recognize your tells that you're getting to that edge and have a strategy to collect yourself. My personal one is to stop speaking and and count 2-3 breaths, then start again.

3) If you're still struggling, it's time for the big guns. You need to have a plan for something to think about that will immediately pull you from the emotional brink. What works for me and many other artists is to picture something extremely sensationally sexual, the more outlandish the better. For whatever reason, this part of the brain seems to shut down the sad emotional pathway pretty fast. Just keep upping the ante with your mental pictures. Sorry if this sounds terribly crass, but it's a tried and true technique that has saved many a performance for me personally and for many of my friends. Also useful as a guy during a sad movie if you don't want to lose it in front of your date.

In the end you may still go over the edge and cry and that's okay. Just take a breath, get a tissue, pause, and keep going.

Thanks for these techniques, have gone to vocal coaches who work with mainly actors to help with presentation and interview skills so much that can be learned and transferred from these fields.
 
What’s the best way to practice for interviews in general? Is paying for mock interviews worth it? Don’t believe my school offers them
 
What’s the best way to practice for interviews in general? Is paying for mock interviews worth it? Don’t believe my school offers them

Much depends on your own strengths and weaknessses. As a general rule:

1) Prepare some good answers for questions you know you will be asked (ie. "tell me about yourself" and "so why do you want to be a doctor" or "why medicine and not X?"). Practice these and have them down cold. As you get better, you can even fashion your answers to end with something that will bait the interviewer into a follow up question or even a line of questions that you are also well-prepared to answer.

2) Prepare for answering behavioral based interview questions. These were a newish thing in business in the 1990s and are basically the standard now in corporate structured interviews. Medical schools and residency programs have been gradually adopting this as well. For those who don't know, these are those questions that begin with, "Tell me about a time when...." We all hate these, but you need to have a system for answering them. There are dozens of these online -- just google how to answer these and find one you like. More than scripting your answers, you really just need to have a structure in your mind of how to approach these. This is what I use:
SOAR
SITUATION- 1-2 lines that sets up the story
OBSTACLE- 1 very concise statement about the dilemma or issue asked in the question
ACTION- 1 very concise line about what you did when faced with the above situation
RESULT - 1-2 lines about what happened, what you might do differently, etd.

3) MMI prep. If you're interviewing somewhere that uses these, be sure to look up how they work and find tips for how to prepare.

4) practice practice practice. You’ve got to get used to saying these things out loud to another person. I think paying is worth it if you don’t have a free option available. I don’t know what services exist, but my guess is most people would probably just need an hour or two spread between a couple days to polish and get some pointers.
 
Top