- Joined
- Dec 28, 2010
- Messages
- 5,050
- Reaction score
- 6,078
This is kind of a fun forum but I hope mods will allow it as it is relevant to issues in the medical school process. I've included a scenario below but if it's a tl;dr issue, just address the issues in the bolded headings and tell me how you'd design the medical school and WHY. In the scenario, I also discussed some of the pros/cons of different options in the medical schools.
DESIGN YOUR IDEAL MEDICAL SCHOOL!
Scenario:
The year is 2050 and you have been practicing as a [insert your specialty here], trained at [insert residency here], and graduated from [insert medical school here]. Citizens of your state [you choose] have written letters from your state asking you to develop a brand-new medical school. You have recently been elected as head of a super-committee whose purpose is to build a medical school.
0. Degree:
Will your medical school grant an MD degree or DO degree?
1. Name:
What will be the name of your medical school? Explain.
2. Funding:
Anonymous donors have jumped in want to pay a total $200 million dollars in order to build the new medical school. Either you can take that money and design a private medical school or you can settle down in a location where you live [your choice] and start a public medical school. If you choose the option of a public medical school, you will receive a starter amount of $500 million. However, if you start a public medical school, you will be obligated to fill your medical school class with 60% of in-state residents, be influenced by the state of affairs in congress/senate, and be under pressure to be influenced by pharmaceutical companies in your area. Explain.
3. Mission (Statement):
You can either open up a medical school that aims to provide medical support to the underrepresented in an inner city or a rural area of your choice. If you choose this, you will receive an additional government money totaling 50 million dollars. Another option is to try to enter the academic medicine competition but be aware that funding for this is limited and there are already lots of well-established competitive players in the market (see top research schools on USNews). If you choose to do this, your school will not receive as many competitive applicants as most interested in a career in academic medicine (or many who are gunning for a competitive residency/fellowship) realize that research opportunities at your school are limited for the first twenty years. Lastly, you can choose to run with a generic/community mission but you will still face the stigma of being a new school but you will at least be able to pick from slightly more competitive applicants than you would if you choose an academic school. Please explain your choice.
4. Recruitment:
a.)Interview: MMI/Traditional Interview/No-Interview/Combined Approach/Student Interviews/Other
Please explain your choice. Explain.
b.) MCAT/GPA: (Ignore the fact that this will have changed). Will you pre-screen secondaries? What will be the limits? Explain.
c.) Primary: What EC's will you instruct AdComs to place major emphasis on:
d.) Secondary: What will be the prompts on your secondary? How much will the secondary price be? (Minimum of $25 and maximum of $200). Keep in mind that you have an incentive to make it as high as possible. Given the volume of applicants, you stand to make lots of revenue per cycle by just increasing secondary pricing and unless you go significantly over $100, a good number of applicants won't be deterred by a high secondary fee). Explain.
e.) What will be your admissions communications policies? Explain.
i) When will you start inviting students for interviews (how many dates?) Explain.
ii) How often will you communicate with students regarding their admission status? Explain.
iii) How will you choose to reject applicants? How/will you reject Pre-interview/Post interview? Explain.
f.) Will you choose to hold a second look day?
5. Curriculum:
a.) Will you require a research project/scholarly project? Keep in mind that while this adds diversity and competitiveness to a student's CV, it will also detract from the amount of time the student will be studying. Explain
b.) What type of curriculum will you choose? Lectures (recorded or no?), PBL/TBL? Explain
c.) Will preceptorships be required during first/second year? (How often) Explain.
d.) How will you grade students? P/F, P/F (w/ internal ranking)
e.) Will you choose a systems based approach or an integrated approach?
For those who are confused, a systems based approach (at least in second year) goes through various organ systems individually while an integrated approach mixes them together.
f.) How much time will you allot to USLME preparation? (maximum is 6 weeks...anything over than and your school will be at risk for losing some sort of accreditation).
g. Alternative routes: pick 3
MD/PhD ($100 million to establish), MD/JD, MD/MBA, MD/MPH, MD/MS, MD/MA.
h. Will you allow students to have learning communities?
i. Will you allow students to partake in medical scholars programs where they meet 2-3 days a week with a physician in their field of interest, shadow, and do research in the area (a disadvantage is time lost studying).
j. What will be the order of medical education?
Exs. Western MI for example does 2 years basic science with weeks off for USLME prep and then does a third clinical year with weeks off for UsLME prep and then they take it after year 3.
6. Hospital Affiliations:
Your hospitals will already be up and running. What kinds would you associate your school with? If you want, you can spend 400 million to build a 300 bed university teaching hospital and it can have its own patient centered approach, custom population, mission, etc.
DESIGN YOUR IDEAL MEDICAL SCHOOL!
Scenario:
The year is 2050 and you have been practicing as a [insert your specialty here], trained at [insert residency here], and graduated from [insert medical school here]. Citizens of your state [you choose] have written letters from your state asking you to develop a brand-new medical school. You have recently been elected as head of a super-committee whose purpose is to build a medical school.
0. Degree:
Will your medical school grant an MD degree or DO degree?
1. Name:
What will be the name of your medical school? Explain.
2. Funding:
Anonymous donors have jumped in want to pay a total $200 million dollars in order to build the new medical school. Either you can take that money and design a private medical school or you can settle down in a location where you live [your choice] and start a public medical school. If you choose the option of a public medical school, you will receive a starter amount of $500 million. However, if you start a public medical school, you will be obligated to fill your medical school class with 60% of in-state residents, be influenced by the state of affairs in congress/senate, and be under pressure to be influenced by pharmaceutical companies in your area. Explain.
3. Mission (Statement):
You can either open up a medical school that aims to provide medical support to the underrepresented in an inner city or a rural area of your choice. If you choose this, you will receive an additional government money totaling 50 million dollars. Another option is to try to enter the academic medicine competition but be aware that funding for this is limited and there are already lots of well-established competitive players in the market (see top research schools on USNews). If you choose to do this, your school will not receive as many competitive applicants as most interested in a career in academic medicine (or many who are gunning for a competitive residency/fellowship) realize that research opportunities at your school are limited for the first twenty years. Lastly, you can choose to run with a generic/community mission but you will still face the stigma of being a new school but you will at least be able to pick from slightly more competitive applicants than you would if you choose an academic school. Please explain your choice.
4. Recruitment:
a.)Interview: MMI/Traditional Interview/No-Interview/Combined Approach/Student Interviews/Other
Please explain your choice. Explain.
b.) MCAT/GPA: (Ignore the fact that this will have changed). Will you pre-screen secondaries? What will be the limits? Explain.
c.) Primary: What EC's will you instruct AdComs to place major emphasis on:
d.) Secondary: What will be the prompts on your secondary? How much will the secondary price be? (Minimum of $25 and maximum of $200). Keep in mind that you have an incentive to make it as high as possible. Given the volume of applicants, you stand to make lots of revenue per cycle by just increasing secondary pricing and unless you go significantly over $100, a good number of applicants won't be deterred by a high secondary fee). Explain.
e.) What will be your admissions communications policies? Explain.
i) When will you start inviting students for interviews (how many dates?) Explain.
ii) How often will you communicate with students regarding their admission status? Explain.
iii) How will you choose to reject applicants? How/will you reject Pre-interview/Post interview? Explain.
f.) Will you choose to hold a second look day?
5. Curriculum:
a.) Will you require a research project/scholarly project? Keep in mind that while this adds diversity and competitiveness to a student's CV, it will also detract from the amount of time the student will be studying. Explain
b.) What type of curriculum will you choose? Lectures (recorded or no?), PBL/TBL? Explain
c.) Will preceptorships be required during first/second year? (How often) Explain.
d.) How will you grade students? P/F, P/F (w/ internal ranking)
e.) Will you choose a systems based approach or an integrated approach?
For those who are confused, a systems based approach (at least in second year) goes through various organ systems individually while an integrated approach mixes them together.
f.) How much time will you allot to USLME preparation? (maximum is 6 weeks...anything over than and your school will be at risk for losing some sort of accreditation).
g. Alternative routes: pick 3
MD/PhD ($100 million to establish), MD/JD, MD/MBA, MD/MPH, MD/MS, MD/MA.
h. Will you allow students to have learning communities?
i. Will you allow students to partake in medical scholars programs where they meet 2-3 days a week with a physician in their field of interest, shadow, and do research in the area (a disadvantage is time lost studying).
j. What will be the order of medical education?
Exs. Western MI for example does 2 years basic science with weeks off for USLME prep and then does a third clinical year with weeks off for UsLME prep and then they take it after year 3.
6. Hospital Affiliations:
Your hospitals will already be up and running. What kinds would you associate your school with? If you want, you can spend 400 million to build a 300 bed university teaching hospital and it can have its own patient centered approach, custom population, mission, etc.
Last edited: