MGH Letter

Started by VPDcurt
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Status
Not open for further replies.

VPDcurt

2K Member
15+ Year Member
Did anyone receive any correspondence from either the PD or the Chairman after their interview?
 
I love threads like this. Oh woe is me...man's best hospital sent me a love letter but I don't know if they really liked me.... And my diamond shoes are too tight...

That was never the intent of this thread. I was just curious if it is their practice to send those letters to everyone or not. The program is irrelevant - you are just really defensive (and pathetic) for whatever reason. Shut your mouth if you don't have anything productive to add.
 
Shut your mouth if you don't have anything productive to add.

Here's my productive advice: Rank programs in the order you like them. Pay no mind to the games like phone calls and letters. It doesn't particularly matter if they send letters to everyone or not - correspondence from the program should have no effect on your rank list.

And if you're wondering about whether the letter should provide you peace of mind (i.e. surviving until match day without going crazy worrying that you will or won't get your top choice) - SDN is a notoriously terrible place for achieving that, due to the innate neuroticism of a large percentage of posters here (myself included upon occasion as in my last post).

I also would argue that a number of threads like this (maybe yours really wasn't intended that way), are a way for posters to get some subtle bragging in, and I find that very frustrating. If it wasn't intended that way, I apologize.
 
Thanks for the apology, but please spare me (and anyone else) all the preaching. I asked a simple yes or no question so stop reading into it. I don't need assistance with my ROL and I'm not looking for peace of mind.
 
Thanks for the apology, but please spare me (and anyone else) all the preaching. I asked a simple yes or no question so stop reading into it. I don't need assistance with my ROL and I'm not looking for peace of mind.

Not that I really want to be sucked into this conversation, but you kind of asked for it. You mentioned a controversial program, so you opened yourself up to criticism. Then, your answers weren't consistent, further opening yourself up to criticism.
VPDcurt said:
I was just curious if it is their practice to send those letters to everyone or not.
VPDcurt said:
The program is irrelevant...
Back to back sentences, yet leading one to believe two completely different intents of your initial post. The first sentence suggests you are looking into the practice of MGH. The second sentence says you are asking about the practice (of sending letters) in general. Which is it? Do you want to know about MGH or do you want to know if programs routinely send letters?
If it isn't going to change your rank list, what does it matter?

In the end, you have to understand that mentioning anything about the big Boston programs, JHU or any other reputable program and how they sent you something that could potentially suggest you are elite, even to them, will be met with some comments of jealousy, particularly if you are trying to pass your posts off as if you are someone who is "one of the rest of us." Most people don't get MGH interviews or know they won't so don't even apply. You already know you are in the top tier of applicants by getting the interview; you can't tell me that you can't see how asking about a post-interview letter you received could be interpreted as a little self-stroking, particularly when you phrase it in a "fact-finding mission only" sort of way. Should others grow up and let it pass? Probably, but no one likes to be made to feel small. Intentionally or not, your post kind of rubbed everyone's nose in it, and that isn't so cool. If you are smart enough to get an interview at MGH, you should be smart enough to realize the potential interpretations of a post like this.
 
Wow that post was way too long. Your "analysis," which was really lame, is simply incorrect. When I stated that the program was irrelevant, I meant that I don't care if it's MGH or some crappy program that no one has ever heard of. I was simply asking the initial question out of curiosity. Why is that so hard for everyone to believe? I'm not here to make myself out to be better than the next person - I can almost guarantee you that I suck more than most people. Everyone getting all worked up over someone asking a relatively benign question does not make me a cocky person; on the other hand, it clearly has exposed insecurities in everyone else that has taken an interest in this thread. Why do you care where I got an interview? I sure as hell don't care where you receive invitations. It's so incredibly lame, played out and hypocritical for so many people, including yourself, to come on here and post these long, drawn-out criticisms of others based solely on assumptions (that are usually incorrect, as in this case) and that turn out to be nothing more than condescending lectures with no substance whatsoever.
 
Not that I really want to be sucked into this conversation, but you kind of asked for it. You mentioned a controversial program, so you opened yourself up to criticism. Then, your answers weren't consistent, further opening yourself up to criticism.

You are pathetic. This is easily one of the most ridiculous posts I have seen during my time on SDN (or any other forum for that matter).

Why is MGH controversial? Because it's competitive? Maybe the world isn't as PC as you'd like it to be, but you still have a lot of growing up to do.
 
Most people don't get MGH interviews or know they won't so don't even apply. You already know you are in the top tier of applicants by getting the interview; you can't tell me that you can't see how asking about a post-interview letter you received could be interpreted as a little self-stroking, particularly when you phrase it in a "fact-finding mission only" sort of way. Should others grow up and let it pass? Probably, but no one likes to be made to feel small. Intentionally or not, your post kind of rubbed everyone's nose in it, and that isn't so cool. If you are smart enough to get an interview at MGH, you should be smart enough to realize the potential interpretations of a post like this.

This paragraph sums up the thought process that led to my first post.

In retrospect should have let it pass as socialist mentions...I made a poor posting decision out of reaction to my own stress from the impending rank list deadline.
 
Last edited:
When I stated that the program was irrelevant, I meant that I don't care if it's MGH or some crappy program that no one has ever heard of.
That is tough for me to believe, as you could have asked the question without mentioning the program's name if that was your only question. The fact of the matter is, if your question was generic, it was already answered this year here, as well as in numerous past threads, as this comes up every year. A search of previous posts could have answered the generic question and spared the debate this thread has generated.
Everyone getting all worked up over someone asking a relatively benign question does not make me a cocky person; on the other hand, it clearly has exposed insecurities in everyone else that has taken an interest in this thread. Why do you care where I got an interview? I sure as hell don't care where you receive invitations. It's so incredibly lame, played out and hypocritical for so many people, including yourself, to come on here and post these long, drawn-out criticisms of others based solely on assumptions (that are usually incorrect, as in this case) and that turn out to be nothing more than condescending lectures with no substance whatsoever.
First off, I am currently a resident, so I really don't care where you interviewed. Second, when I was interviewing, I interviewed at the "top tier" programs, too, so my comments are based on some understanding of what its like to be in your shoes and not from any insecurity on my part. What I'm trying to impart to you is that understanding all potential vantages of your audience is important, especially in academic medicine (which seems is your goal). Whether you like PC or not, the academic surgical world definitely believes in being PC and, should you choose to be successful, you might want to start buying into it professionally. Like it or not, the people on this forum will be your colleagues in the future, so you might as well treat them like it now.

As for growing up, well, you might want to learn to take advice from your senior residents who know a thing or two about what you're experiencing...🙄
 
I love threads like this. Oh woe is me...man's best hospital sent me a love letter but I don't know if they really liked me.... And my diamond shoes are too tight...

Hilarious.

That was never the intent of this thread. I was just curious if it is their practice to send those letters to everyone or not. The program is irrelevant - you are just really defensive (and pathetic) for whatever reason. Shut your mouth if you don't have anything productive to add.

Oh, it was a joke......

You are pathetic. This is easily one of the most ridiculous posts I have seen during my time on SDN (or any other forum for that matter).

Why is MGH controversial? Because it's competitive? Maybe the world isn't as PC as you'd like it to be, but you still have a lot of growing up to do.

What is it with people throwing "pathetic" around so much recently? I got it from some troll in another thread.....

Anyway, calling someone pathetic in the same thread where you claim to not be uppity and condescending doesn't work....."pathetic" is very reducing.


I'm not here to make myself out to be better than the next person - I can almost guarantee you that I suck more than most people.

Well, you sort of proved that here. No arguments.








I think a lot of us are super wound up and tense due to the time of the year.....actual doctors that post on this board just got done with a stressful ABSITE, and after multiple years of long long hours, we all have a little seasonal affective disorder.

As for the students, you all have a stressful match coming up soon, so you're stressed out, too.


I don't usually say this, since I love a good internet fight, but can't we all just get along?
 
I didn't think there was anything unreasonable about the original question. It's helpful to know whether a program sends out generic letters or only sends them to people they're truly interested in after the interview. By posting this question, one would be attempting to figure this out. If people are jealous or offended by the question, they need not respond, right?
 
I didn't think there was anything unreasonable about the original question. It's helpful to know whether a program sends out generic letters or only sends them to people they're truly interested in after the interview. By posting this question, one would be attempting to figure this out. If people are jealous or offended by the question, they need not respond, right?

This begs the question of what does it matter?


The rank list should be made based on how much you liked a particular program (based on whatever criteria you've decided on). Whether they send a dozen roses or not has nothing to do with how you make your list. I agree with the others that the tone of the original question and the subsequent immature outbursts were "pathetic" 😀
 
I completely agree that the rank list should be based on how much you like a particular program. However, this is irrelevant to the question posed in this post. The original poster asked neither a question pertaining to a rank list or whether the aforementioned "MGH letter" was going to influence his/her rank list.

Sometimes it's just nice to know whether a correspondence from a program is genuine or generic, especially if you liked the place and felt that the interview went well. Positive feedback and all. The rest of you guys seem to be projecting your own feelings and biases into a simple question.
 
Sometimes it's just nice to know whether a correspondence from a program is genuine or generic, especially if you liked the place and felt that the interview went well. Positive feedback and all.

I think Pir8DeacDoc's point is (and I get this mostly from the question asked), does it really matter if it is genuine or not if it isn't going to change your rank list?
 
I think Pir8DeacDoc's point is (and I get this mostly from the question asked), does it really matter if it is genuine or not if it isn't going to change your rank list?

My rank list was set prior to receiving this silly letter. It will not change my list. As I've stated numerous times, I was just curious. It may be difficult for a narcissistic person to understand, but I was not soliciting anyone's advice on the program or my situation in particular. My ROL has been certified for quite some time and nothing posted on this forum is going to change my order.
 
I didn't think there was anything unreasonable about the original question. It's helpful to know whether a program sends out generic letters or only sends them to people they're truly interested in after the interview. By posting this question, one would be attempting to figure this out. If people are jealous or offended by the question, they need not respond, right?

Alas, from reading the majority of the posts above, it is primarily the jealous and/or offended that respond! How ironic!

You guys assume way too much in calling the poster jealous, etc.....he made a joke. It was simple and kind of funny.....you didn't like it because you can't take a joke, and so you over-reacted big time.

You guys act like MGH is the holy grail. I promise you that some of the senior posters in here have the stats to interview there, and may have done so back in the day. People are reacting strongly to your posts because they are inflammatory and whiney, and we try to discourage that type of behavior....not because they are jealous of how super-awesome you are.


Geez....maybe your diamond shoes are too tight.
 
You guys assume way too much in calling the poster jealous, etc.....he made a joke. It was simple and kind of funny.....you didn't like it because you can't take a joke, and so you over-reacted big time.

You guys act like MGH is the holy grail. I promise you that some of the senior posters in here have the stats to interview there, and may have done so back in the day. People are reacting strongly to your posts because they are inflammatory and whiney, and we try to discourage that type of behavior....not because they are jealous of how super-awesome you are.


Geez....maybe your diamond shoes are too tight.

If someone thought that joke was funny, it doesn't say much about their sense of humor.

MGH is just another hospital and I was asking just a normal question without any inferences until people started flipping out.

As far as being qualified to interview there, I'm not one to assess that situation regarding the other residents but Wichita isn't exactly ideal. Furthermore, why is it so difficult for others to understand that I asked a simple yes or no question? These "senior residents" that you speak of don't understand that some of us don't care for their advice right now as our minds are already made up. It would be ridiculous and borderline insane to actually base my ROL on what they had to say anyway.
 
I completely agree that the rank list should be based on how much you like a particular program. However, this is irrelevant to the question posed in this post. The original poster asked neither a question pertaining to a rank list or whether the aforementioned "MGH letter" was going to influence his/her rank list.

Sometimes it's just nice to know whether a correspondence from a program is genuine or generic, especially if you liked the place and felt that the interview went well. Positive feedback and all. The rest of you guys seem to be projecting your own feelings and biases into a simple question.

I agree. I'm not applying in surgery, but it gets tedious to hear the same response anytime anybody asks anything about post-interview correspondence. Yes, we all know that it shouldn't influence our rank lists. It's still interesting to know if it's happening and if everybody who interviewed is getting the same correspondence. And if talking about it bugs you, don't participate or read the threads. Pretty simple.

I'm also puzzled about why this thread turned into a full on attack mode thread, but it's the surgery forum, so I shouldn't be surprised. The most benign threads turn into fights over here.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.