- Joined
- Apr 18, 2009
- Messages
- 64
- Reaction score
- 1
what are the fundamental differences in each unit? I'm talking patient population, acuity, mortality, and procedures. starting respiratory therapy school soon and I'm curious
SICU are patients who just came out of surgery and are usually admitted because they're still mechanically ventilated, require pressors or vasodilators, lost a lot of blood in the OR or organ transplanted patients. note that these aren't the only reason for admission. These patients can be young or old and medical co-morbidities vary though many tend to be healthier at baseline. As a general rule surgeons usually don't operate on and anesthesiologist don't provide anesthestic care on medically unstable patients unless the benefits of the procedure outweigh the risk.
Of course, I am a big believer in the quality of MICU care, and I know there are some super-sick pts there as well.....I just don't know if I can say, at least in my experience in the 20 or so different ICUs I'm familiar with, that the SICU patients are less sick.
Arguing which unit is sicker is a loser-argument. Everyone who does CCM wants to think they take care of the sickest patient. It's completely understandable. We all have sick patients.
BICU burns are awful, MICU ARDS pulmonary hemorrhages are awful, CSICU bivads with pulmonary HTN are awful. I think my alcoholic cirrhosis with acetaminophen OD who was anhepatic for 3 days waiting for a liver is probably as sick as they come. BTW, the guy got his liver and 2 weeks later is on the floor.
That said, you can have a sick medicine patient in the SICU and vice versa if beds are at a premium.
The procedures are for the most part the same, art line placement, central line placement, line changes, intubate and vent. The difference in hte SICU is since surgeons are present they'll do bedside tracheostomies, PEGs, and on really rare occasion ex-laps.
There's the VAC dressing change sometimes done at the bedside. 30 minute procedure rarely worth a transport to the OR. The only true reason to do a real bedside ex-lap is for abdominal compartment syndrome. Although, I don't know if the current surgical thinking has shifted away from this (it's been a while). Oh, and some post-cardiac surgery patients have clots or bleeding that requires reopening the chest.
It's wild, but it happens, I promise. I've seen it twice myself.
I watched OMFS do a bedside jaw-wiring of mandibular fx. Now THAT was medieval. You could hear the guy screaming down the hall.
PS I just realized how off-topic that comment was. Sorry. For a second, I thought this was a thread about crazy bedside stuff that would usually be done in the OR.
I've worked in MICU, SICU, Neuro ICU, and CT ICU settings. Of far more importance to me then the question of MICU vs SICU is whether or not the non-ICU attendings are collaborative. This goes beyond closed/open, too.
I have no problem working in 'open' SICUs with two caveats: 1) The surgeon's defer to the ICU team on issues that are 'non-surgical' -- like antibiotic regimens, culture strategies, prophylaxis and the like -- and 2) Communication flows freely between BOTH ICU team and primary team.
There is nothing worse than an old school primary team attending who just doesn't faulking listen to the intensivist advice.
Interesting. I had just visited an open NICU where a PCCM doc and neurosurgeon are on each patient. My initial response was thinking that it must be fascinating for the PCCM. I guess it might be a pain as well.