Milkshake - Game Thread

[deleted804295]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Hi sporty nice to see you!!!!!!!!!!

Do you think this vote circle will help find a wolf??!!!!!!

I'm not a wolf this time so I have no reason to flood the thread. Plus AM is modding. I expect this one will be more manageable!

Hey man I'm no @genny or @Melchizedek, I only wolf twice a year 😉

What about you? Finally making your wolfing debut?

I'm sorry you dont like them!!!!!!!

That's what I thought too!!!!!!

I could vote 3m for echos on exclamation points that they dont really know playing with me that well!!!!!!!
Yeah, it feels right for now!!!!!!!!
Lynch 3m

Dubz and Paws are way too enthusiastic. Paws would not put a target this easily on their back so I'm leaning paws in village pile for now.

 

[deleted804295]

I don’t have a main suspect yet, I want to see posts from others who haven’t participated yet.

I think you're acting weird with this.

Not feeling too good about Kota's early noob questions.

Lynch Kota

I'm 3 pages in so my vote might change after I get caught up fully

 

[WonderingStudent]

Have your reads changed since this morning? I saw your previous post regarding sunny, but what about any one else?

leaning 3m and mpm village based on posts feels and how they have had similar thoughts to myself.

Based on posts today, coop has become more suspicious but I think it's more telling who players voted for based around a known wolf (ie voting for SAR yesterday). Wolves can string any post together they want to seem village for reads and questioning players but I'm putting more stock in voting as slightly more telling atm as when there are already a few votes on their wolfy comrade it doesn't seem great to vote there since you are trying to use your village power (your lynch vote) to get rid of villagers.

 

[deleted804295]

Y'all... My mom just came home and it's mothers day and I have to talk to my boyfriend tonight!!!


Will try talking before lynch close.

 

[mmmdreamerz]

Oh shoot.

Oh shoot what?

You forgot about this game? Your a wolf? You left the oven on at home?

I’m not much into lynching people for inactivity but it would be nice if you’d start contributing and not just get mod killed

 

[Kota1000]

I think you're acting weird with this.

Not feeling too good about Kota's early noob questions.

Lynch Kota

I'm 3 pages in so my vote might change after I get caught up fully

That was very early D1. As a noob, I find it hard to get reads early on, so I did not want to Lynch for no reason. It is reasonable to wait for people to post more before deciding on a Lynch... not sure how that is suspicious.

 

[mmmdreamerz]

Ok this has been covered extensively, maybe you're catching up in a weird way but wtf dude?

Sometimes I catch up in reverse and have thoughts that I realize are answered later lol

 

[mmmdreamerz]

I think you're acting weird with this.

Not feeling too good about Kota's early noob questions.

Lynch Kota

I'm 3 pages in so my vote might change after I get caught up fully

Kota doesn’t seem any less village than the previous games I’ve played with them as of now IMO

 

[Coopah]

Sometimes I catch up in reverse and have thoughts that I realize are answered later lol

That's why I hedged but I'm still confused

 

[mmmdreamerz]

That's why I hedged but I'm still confused

Totally fair. Just throwing it out there because sometimes I definitely do that.

 

[genny]

Based on posts today, coop has become more suspicious

What about coop's posts seem suspicious to you?

 

[WonderingStudent]

I gotta get to work. Based on POE I have in neutral right now (others are more village based on posts/voting)
sunbodi
paws
bc
bark
sporty
genny

lynch sporty

Hate to put a vote on someone that hasn't given much of reads yet but she feels lower down on my village feels than others so I'm putting my vote there and I gotta leave so this is what we are getting.

 

[WonderingStudent]

What about coop's posts seem suspicious to you?

Letting you know if I have time at work before lynch close I'll try to answer but I can't right now look for the posts

 

[deleted804295]

Okay, upon reread. Some thing I’ve noticed:

First, sunny is very quiet, which is unusual for them I think.

Second, BC is also quiet, but since they flipped village last time, it’s not super concerning as they were quiet last game too.

Third, genny seems to be posting sort of snarky posts




And usually they are pretty aggressive in WW based on previous games, but they seem a little more judgmental for a D1 discussion.

Still staying with my WZ lynch for the moment.

Genny is always snark

 

[genny]

Oh shoot what?

You forgot about this game? Your a wolf? You left the oven on at home?

I’m not much into lynching people for inactivity but it would be nice if you’d start contributing and not just get mod killed

omg what if it's you and SunnyB, and she's about to get mod killed, leaving you totally alone for your first wolf outing. And you killed Dubz last night because you were afraid she'd go after you on D2 when she made that comment about leaving you alone D1. 🤔

 

[deleted804295]

Not really yet... the post sunbodi had was SUPER weird. Why claim vanillager D1? The exchange between dubz and 3M pinged me as well but I’m not sure it gave me wolf feels. Just caught my eye

Since I've been asked by both BC and Alissa and cooper.

I claimed vanillager D1 since it's a small game. Honestly didn't put too much thought into it.

 

[Kota1000]

What about coop's posts seem suspicious to you?

leaning 3m and mpm village based on posts feels and how they have had similar thoughts to myself.

Based on posts today, coop has become more suspicious but I think it's more telling who players voted for based around a known wolf (ie voting for SAR yesterday). Wolves can string any post together they want to seem village for reads and questioning players but I'm putting more stock in voting as slightly more telling atm as when there are already a few votes on their wolfy comrade it doesn't seem great to vote there since you are trying to use your village power (your lynch vote) to get rid of villagers.

This what what she said when I asked why she was suspicious of Coop. Idk if you saw this or not

 

[genny]

This what what she said when I asked why she was suspicious of Coop. Idk if you saw this or not

Yes, that's the post I quoted when I asked her for clarification.

 

[Kota1000]

omg what if it's you and SunnyB, and she's about to get mod killed, leaving you totally alone for your first wolf outing. And you killed Dubz last night because you were afraid she'd go after you on D2 when she made that comment about leaving you alone D1. 🤔

This is a bold declaration. Do you think 3m is a wolf?

 

[deleted804295]

lynch Kota

didnt like their comments around Paws's exclamation marks. Felt very wishy washy over a short period of time between throwing shade and then thinking more villager. Then putting both Coop and 3m into their village pile. Idk, gave me feels

So I may have read that SAR died? if so, SARs predeath thoughts are matching my intuition right now. Kota is just acting off.

 

[Barkley13]

Ok I'm rereading everything and just got through day 1

I didn't like BC's first post and I see how someone thinks she's echoey already since genny made a comment about people being quiet and then bc made a very similiar comment about people needing to talk. Seeing her post again about how she didn't like the SAR lynch still sketches me out and felt like a wolf defending another wolf.

3m seemed like a mixture of defensive and throwing a lot of shade around to see what sticks on D1 and seemed pretty bothered by paws's vote on her

Alissa was really really focused on sunbodi's one post about being a vanillager and posted about it multiple times and not much else but also broke the tie toward SAR so don't see her as wolf either

Kota had an odd reaction to paws joking around and changing her quote. I also feel like a lot of her posts have been off but have a hard time seeing her as wolf based on where her vote ended up yesterday

Doggo's another one that has felt off but her voting for SAR over sunbodi makes me lean her more village in spite of the fact that her reads seem to echo other peoples

So basically the people I thought were sketchy based on posts/tone ended up voting for SAR so I'm having trouble seeing them as anything but village. So alissa, kota, and doggo are village rn

BC and 3m are sketchy

 

[genny]

This is a bold declaration. Do you think 3m is a wolf?

Did you read the post you quoted?

 

[Barkley13]

Since I've been asked by both BC and Alissa and cooper.

I claimed vanillager D1 since it's a small game. Honestly didn't put too much thought into it.

What does the size of the game have to do with anything

 

[Kota1000]

Did you read the post you quoted?

Yes I did. And it sounds like you think 3m is a wolf. It’s just sort of a surprise since I don’t think you mentioned them being a wolf today other then here.

 

[deleted804295]

On page 5 now.

 

[Kota1000]

So I may have read that SAR died? if so, SARs predeath thoughts are matching my intuition right now. Kota is just acting off.

SAR died a wolf

 

[deleted804295]

Day 1 Lynch Tally
SAR (1) - dubz
dubz (2) - Sporty, Kota
Suni (3) - genny, BC, alissa
Doggo (1) - Barks
Stagg () -
3m () -
Paws (1) - Coop
Sporty (1) - 3m
BC () -
Kota (1) - SAR

10/15
Missing: Paws, Stagg, Doggo, mpm, Suni
lynch close in ~1 hour

Wait I almost died yesterday??? am I dead? lol

 

[genny]

Yes I did. And it sounds like you think 3m is a wolf. It’s just sort of a surprise since I don’t think you mentioned them being a wolf today other then here.

Nope. I posted a POE earlier that you commented on. 3m was in it.

 

[genny]

Wait I almost died yesterday??? am I dead? lol

Not yet! But that can be arranged!

 

[deleted804295]

omg what if it's you and SunnyB, and she's about to get mod killed, leaving you totally alone for your first wolf outing. And you killed Dubz last night because you were afraid she'd go after you on D2 when she made that comment about leaving you alone D1. 🤔

Wow this is very WIFOM

 

[Kota1000]

Ok I'm rereading everything and just got through day 1

Kota had an odd reaction to paws joking around and changing her quote. I also feel like a lot of her posts have been off but have a hard time seeing her as wolf based on where her vote ended up yesterday

Well I didnt know what “ifify” meant, I thought it was spell checked from “iffy”, and I wanted to know why she thought me asking for reads on people for stuff that hadn’t been said before was iffy. I did sort of accuse her though, so I apologize

 

[mmmdreamerz]

omg what if it's you and SunnyB, and she's about to get mod killed, leaving you totally alone for your first wolf outing. And you killed Dubz last night because you were afraid she'd go after you on D2 when she made that comment about leaving you alone D1. 🤔

While this is a nice story, I would kill my wolf partner myself if they played like she’s playing to almost get mod killed on my very first wolf outting lolol

 

[genny]

Wow this is very WIFOM

No, it's not. You can call it tinfoil-y, but not WIFOM.

 

[SportPonies]

Y'all... My mom just came home and it's mothers day and I have to talk to my boyfriend tonight!!!

Will try talking before lynch close.

Who even prioritizes significant others over WW? Nonsense.
Moms though. Moms are gold.

 

[mmmdreamerz]

This is a bold declaration. Do you think 3m is a wolf?

I took this as a joke lol

 

[genny]

While this is a nice story, I would kill my wolf partner myself if they played like she’s playing to almost get mod killed on my very first wolf outting lolol

This is WIFOM though!

 

[SportPonies]

I revoke what I said about Coop now that I did my thing I had to do

 

[genny]

Who even prioritizes significant others over WW? Nonsense.
Moms though. Moms are gold.

Did you kill your mom last night?

 

[deleted804295]

Feeling village on paws, Coop, Genny. Susp on Kota and you for the most part. Everyone else files into a neutral category

Any particular reason it's felt like you're lying low today and trying to blend into the background?

Will look at this later since SAR is dead.

 

[SportPonies]

That was very early D1. As a noob, I find it hard to get reads early on, so I did not want to Lynch for no reason. It is reasonable to wait for people to post more before deciding on a Lynch... not sure how that is suspicious.

This post switches on my wolfy radar. I need to dig, but I don't remember Kota previously doing much "As a noob" in even her first game, and I think I've seen her do it twice this game.

 

[mmmdreamerz]

This is WIFOM though!

Nahhh because I’m not actually being serious

 

[Kota1000]

This post switches on my wolfy radar. I need to dig, but I don't remember Kota previously doing much "As a noob" in even her first game, and I think I've seen her do it twice this game.

I did it the 1st game, not so much the WWarriors cause it was established early on that I was a noob

 

[SportPonies]

Did you kill your mom last night?

Uh huh. She's my favorite N1 kill because then she'll pay more attention to me.

 

[deleted804295]

Well that’s a twist...

So looking back at D1, since SAR flipped wolf, two things that really bothered me were BC and sort of coopah’s lynch patterns.

BC lynched SAR early on for “you know I gotta do it” as a reason. And switched to Sunbodi because of their inactivity and early vanillager claim. BC later said that she didn’t like the SAR wagon, and said because SAR feels a comfortable level of sketch to them she felt better about a Sunbodi lynch.

Also, I don’t like how Coopah jumped on the SAR vote just because they like ties, but it’s not too suspicious.

I’ll be analyzing other stuff besides the SAR lynching too, I just wanted to get this out here early on, cause I think it stood out a lot.

Also, I typed this up earlier this morning when I got up so I don’t have quotes, but if you want me to show examples/find the quotes I am referencing let me know.

Yeah after kota doing a good VCA and defending me here I'm leaning towards kota in village for now. Will not unlynch until I have a better lynch candidate.

I'm on PAGE 6 NOW. For what its worth

 

[SportPonies]

I think I feel better about mpm now, after an ISO.

 

[deleted804295]

Are you referring to SAR's reads on certain people and how that reflects on those individuals? I don't put much stock into it. It's difficult to say if she would put players who she knows are villagers so that those players feel better about her because she called them village/other players can look back once those individuals flip to see that SAR's good at "reading people." Or if she slipped her wolfmate(s) in to push perception of them to village as positive early.

Unlynch Kota
Lynch wondering

you're being very helpful after sars lynch which I associate with wolf behavior

 

[deleted804295]

Okay I'm on page 8 but I'm just going to skip to current page.


DID WONDERING sub in for stagg???

 

[genny]

Okay I'm on page 8 but I'm just going to skip to current page.


DID WONDERING sub in for stagg???

Yes

 

[deleted804295]

Oh shoot what?

You forgot about this game? Your a wolf? You left the oven on at home?

I’m not much into lynching people for inactivity but it would be nice if you’d start contributing and not just get mod killed

I'm really sorry! I said oh shoot because I've been so busy this weekend and trying to take a healthier approach to WW by logging on every few hours rather than being on the whole day

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 2 Lynch Tally
Sporty (3) - Paws, 3m, Wonder
genny () -
Paws (3) - mpm, Coop, Kota
BC () -
Doggo () -
Barks (1) - genny
Kota () -
Wonder (1) - Suni

8/13
Missing: Sporty, Doggo, alissa, BC, Barks
lynch close in ~2 hours