Milkshake - Game Thread

Started by Animal Midwife
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Browse articles Compare schools My application plan Read Interview Feedback
Practice for interviews Ask an Advisor
Barkley13 said:
Is the post you quoted why you’re saying she’s wishy washy? Because if so, how does saying she’ll be back later = wishy washy?
Click to expand...
Because genny asked for her thoughts and all she got was “hmmm” and the post I quoted

you may read it differently but that’s how I took it
 
mmmdreamerz said:
Because genny asked for her thoughts and all she got was “hmmm” and the post I quoted

you may read it differently but that’s how I took it
Click to expand...

Sporty posted “hmmm” right at the start before genny posted, I don’t think genny got a response from sporty
 
Also this is just a general note of courtesy now that I’m thinking about it but if someone has a lot of votes racked up well before lynch close and isn’t around to defend maybe give them time to come back and defend before hammering
 
JustPaws said:
I dont think we want to let it get close to hammer cuz two wolves are still alive
Click to expand...
Yep, totally agree. I think that’d be pretty obvious if they both jumped on a lynch at once to push it over since we’re nowhere near LyLo yet lol but definitely a good thing to keep in mind!
 
mmmdreamerz said:
I’m still leaning sporty as wolf...

The post about not being able to read people on D1 and the wishy
washy-ness today come off wolfy

So for now

Lynch sporty
Click to expand...
So have your feelings on Paws changed since you’re now voting with her after voting for her yesterday?
 
Kota1000 said:
Thanks for this! Really helpful for info, and I didn’t want to be the only one to post long reads. here’s my reads on people:

I think Paws has been fairly confrontational this game, but it seems in line with last game as well when they flipped village, so I’m leaning more village on them, although I’d like to see more wolf hunting effort. Also, I don’t like that they switched MO without mentioning it in the actual thread and not the sign ups, but that’s just my opinion because once I sign up I usually don’t go back and read the sign ups except to see the final roster.

Sporty, Doggo and Barks I need to hear more from, so they are in my neutral pile.

Although, Barks did ask “why is SAR sketchy?.” When they SAR lynch was happening, although maybe they hadn’t caught up.

And doggo did give some opinions, but they were very vague and not super helpful, so sketch points for that.

Moose, I am leaning more village on as they seem to be trying to wolf hunt through their questions, answers to questions directed at them have details, and they provide good reasoning for their lynches so far. One thing that bothers me is that they asked Sporty what they though of barks even though barks posted very minimally, and then MPM said that they asked the question on a random player.

Alissa is in my neutral- leaning wolf pile, and I’d like to hear more from them. I feel like the content they provided has been very shallow with quick explanations that don’t really contribute much to wolf hunting, or they have been echoing others. They also don’t seem as active as usually, but it’s only D1. However, nothing they have done has stood out as super sketchy to me.

So 3m has done a lot of lynching based on people’s actions that don’t seem to significant in my opinion, and didn’t change their lynch for something more concrete - lynching Paws for her posting style this game, and lynching Sporty for a comment on not being able to read people based on feels D1. They also just sort of disappeared before lynch fest. I didn’t like the 3m X Dubz exchange early on regarding Paw’s posting style, but it seems in character for 3m. Right now I am placing her in my slight village lean pile.

Genny wasn’t super active later on, but they did post a lot to start. I feel like they haven’t contributed much in terms of wolf hunting. They also jumped on Sunny really quick, and lynched her without providing a reason. Then later made a comment about the being a wolf. They also made the comment that “I don’t think I deserve special treatment in this game,” which I found a little odd. Lastly, they have been throwing a lot of jokes and sarcasm around. So for now they are going in my suspect pile after the reread of D1.
Click to expand...
Question on alissa, why would she be the deciding vote on a wolf lynch if shes a wolf? I don't see that fitting.

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile
 
genny said:
I'm wondering if it was to make Paws look more village, or because of whom Dubz was suspecting.
Click to expand...
Sar had a similar post, trying to throw suspicion on dubz move. Idk why they killed her if they were gonna shade her like that though... lemme go find it

(Edit- I thought it was sar but it was actually paws, my b)

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile
 
mypetmoose said:
Sar had a similar post, trying to throw suspicion on dubz move. Idk why they killed her if they were gonna shade her like that though... lemme go find it

(Edit- I thought it was sar but it was actually paws, my b)

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile
Click to expand...
Sorry AM I didn't realize about the edits, I won't do it again

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile
 
mypetmoose said:
Question on alissa, why would she be the deciding vote on a wolf lynch if shes a wolf? I don't see that fitting.

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile
Click to expand...

As I posted earlier, the Alissa read was not based on her lynches it was based on her posts. However, to answer your question, I think Alissa could have lynched SAR just to make her seem less wolfy. Although, she did break a tie against doggo and SAR to vote for SAR, so that gains her village points, but I still am leaning more wolf then village. I am awaiting for her reads once she returns.

Regarding paws -

Kota1000 said:
I think Paws has been fairly confrontational this game, but it seems in line with last game as well when they flipped village, so I’m leaning more village on them, although I’d like to see more wolf hunting effort. Also, I don’t like that they switched MO without mentioning it in the actual thread and not the sign ups, but that’s just my opinion because once I sign up I usually don’t go back and read the sign ups except to see the final roster.
Click to expand...

I still feel the same, and nothing Paws has done so far since I posted that has made me change my mind. It is a little strange she switched her posting style after just 1 day, but based on the heat she got yesterday it’s understandable and I think it’s NAI
 
Kota1000 said:
As I posted earlier, the Alissa read was not based on her lynches it was based on her posts. However, to answer your question, I think Alissa could have lynched SAR just to make her seem less wolfy. Although, she did break a tie against doggo and SAR to vote for SAR, so that gains her village points, but I still am leaning more wolf then village. I am awaiting for her reads once she returns.

Regarding paws -



I still feel the same, and nothing Paws has done so far since I posted that has made me change my mind. It is a little strange she switched her posting style after just 1 day, but based on the heat she got yesterday it’s understandable and I think it’s NAI
Click to expand...
Hang on.
Here how about this... if alissa is a wolf, what does that mean for doggo?

If alissa and doggo and sar are all wolves, then sunbodi is not. And if sunbodi is not a wolf and doggo is, they why would Sar self prez to doggo instead of sunil. Sooooo again, alissa is NOT a wolf. It doesn't make sense.

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile
 
mypetmoose said:
Hang on.
Here how about this... if alissa is a wolf, what does that mean for doggo?

If alissa and doggo and sar are all wolves, then sunbodi is not. And if sunbodi is not a wolf and doggo is, they why would Sar self prez to doggo instead of sunil. Sooooo again, alissa is NOT a wolf. It doesn't make sense.

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile
Click to expand...

Well it’s just what I think, you don’t have to agree with me. My wolfy suspects are Genny and Alissa at the moment.

I still want to here more from Alissa today, as well as sporty and barks.

I think Doggo is village, although I’d like to see more posts from them. I don’t know about suni since they haven’t posted like at all, and I don’t want to just say that they are wolfy because they’ve been absent. And since no one else is sticking out to me, I’m staying with my Alissa feels. If Alissa posts her reads and they seem valid, I will reconsider
 
Also to add to this, I am considering Barks and Sporty as neutral, and I want to hear from them before I switch either to wolfy or village.
 
Thought dump time!

I feel pretty strongly that it is paws.

Lynch paws

SAR had paws in their village pile. SAR backed paws up about the silly !!!!!!!!!!!! thing when it looked like people were coming after her for that. "Why would paws give her a post restriction?" Uh huh, okay.

Also, SAR posts about a post minimum and absentee players more than once. I am thinking that the other one is an absentee wolf.

I also have a side theory that BC is a wolf... but my focus today is paws

Woofy--> ps if it ends up being sar paws sunni, I want to give doggo all the kudos in the world bc she said it first 🙂
Paws
Sunni
BC
 
Kota1000 said:
Well it’s just what I think, you don’t have to agree with me. My wolfy suspects are Genny and Alissa at the moment.

I still want to here more from Alissa today, as well as sporty and barks.

I think Doggo is village, although I’d like to see more posts from them. I don’t know about suni since they haven’t posted like at all, and I don’t want to just say that they are wolfy because they’ve been absent. And since no one else is sticking out to me, I’m staying with my Alissa feels. If Alissa posts her reads and they seem valid, I will reconsider
Click to expand...
Mah dude, can you give me any reason why my way of thinking is flawed? What part do you disagree with, because all I see are facts...
 
mypetmoose said:
Mah dude, can you give me any reason why my way of thinking is flawed? What part do you disagree with, because all I see are facts...
Click to expand...

I don’t disagree, but anything is possible. I am putting Alissa more neutral because you’ve made valid points. I just don’t have any other strong suspects at the moment.
 
Since I moved Alissa neutral, I decided to do some rereading.
So looking back at posts, I am going to switch my lynch off Genny for now. Though she is still a suspect,

unlynch genny
Lynch Bc

BC has initially lynched SAR but then unlynched her and lynched suni. They then said they didn’t feel comfortable about the SAR lynch and felt that SAR had a good level of suspicion to make BC feel good about them.
Today, BC started out on a short rant regarding failure to lynch SAR, which is fine, but it seems a little too loud with the caps and punctuation. She did give rather good reads regarding other people and their interaction with SAR yesterday, but it also had a lot of punctuation and just sort of blabbed it all out in one long paragraph.

I know a lot of people have suspicions about Paws, but I don’t really agree at the moment.
 
Coopah said:
I'm thinking we had two wolves for lynch D1

Lynch doggo
Click to expand...
k so back to this whole thing, why would sar choose to "self prez" to doggo if they are a wolf and sunni is not... only way this makes sense is if sunni is also a wolf... otherwise we would just be killing off a semi-cleared villager
 
mypetmoose said:
k so back to this whole thing, why would sar choose to "self prez" to doggo if they are a wolf and sunni is not... only way this makes sense is if sunni is also a wolf... otherwise we would just be killing off a semi-cleared villager
Click to expand...
I am actually wondering about Sunni being a wolf as there's a huge tone shift from her standard village play. But more than that there were a few fast a furious votes on doggo and SAR may not have felt the pressure to place one on doggo, especially considering what's happening now. Not saying I'm right, but I definitely want to explore it a bit.
 
Coopah said:
I am actually wondering about Sunni being a wolf as there's a huge tone shift from her standard village play. But more than that there were a few fast a furious votes on doggo and SAR may not have felt the pressure to place one on doggo, especially considering what's happening now. Not saying I'm right, but I definitely want to explore it a bit.
Click to expand...
So you think the top three last night, D1 was the whole pack? We are just that good?
 
JustPaws said:
You realize you are voting for me and just quoted me about why doggo is likely village?
Click to expand...
Where did I quote you? If I had the same thoughts, its coincidence, bc I puzzled a lot of things out last night before I even looked at the thread.

So you agree about doggo, thoughts on bc and sunni?

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile
 
Coopah said:
I am actually wondering about Sunni being a wolf as there's a huge tone shift from her standard village play. But more than that there were a few fast a furious votes on doggo and SAR may not have felt the pressure to place one on doggo, especially considering what's happening now. Not saying I'm right, but I definitely want to explore it a bit.
Click to expand...
JustPaws said:
Yes I said it hours ago to kota. Why would sar vote for doggo when am she could have voted sunni
Click to expand...
Here you clearly missed this one
 
Barkley13 said:
Can you explain this theory more
Click to expand...
It's based partially on tone and partially on conversations/interactions with paws and sar... idk, it isn't fully fleshed out since I've been kind of focusing on paws more. Its preliminary, but based on how today goes, I'll be looking more into it later today, or tomorrow for sure...

What are your current thoughts on bc and genny?

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile
 
JustPaws said:
Except you also said you dont think we got all three on top of lynch D1. Cuz you either think that's the whole pack, or you see why doggo is likely village
Click to expand...
Then that's my fault for not being clear. Doggo just got a flurry of votes. If SAR votes Sunni then later flips wolf it might look like she was actively protecting doggo, then doggo gets lynched.
 
Coopah said:
Then that's my fault for not being clear. Doggo just got a flurry of votes. If SAR votes Sunni then later flips wolf it might look like she was actively protecting doggo, then doggo gets lynched.
Click to expand...

Does it appear that way to you?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.