Milkshake - Game Thread

[genny]

---

Members don't see this ad.

I need like 6 naps.

 

[Coopah]

AM hasn't closed the thread so maybe that wasn't majority?

You mean this? Because she reacted to what I said? Lol ok nice stretch

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 3 Lynch Tally
Kota (2) - BC, Coop
Suni (3) - genny, Barks, Doggo
genny (1) - Kota
BC (1) - Sporty
Coop (1) - Suni

8/11
lynch close in ~1 hour
Missing: Wonder, alissa, Paws

 

[JustPaws]

She thought what?

Well that's majority right after someone warned about it (I think) so let's see if that worked otherwise I'm definitely going after you

AM hasn't closed the thread so maybe that wasn't majority?

You don't want to end discussion early. Why would you intentionally hit Maj without discussing it?

If you/doggo did tip it to being majority, it wouldn't have mattered if you unlynched. But either way it shouldn't have been majority yet since it's 11 players = 6 majority

You both thought I tipped maj when I unlynched. That's weird

 

[genny]

I just don't see the fighting right now that makes me think we're barking up a wolf tree and suni seems like a convenient distraction

This sounds like fighting against a Suni lynch 🤔

 

[Coopah]

@Coopah it's just tone stuff. Her posts sound off. I also think at least one of the wolves is skating under the radar. Not necessarily in post quantity but in votes. I think one (or both?) of the wolves have basically not been spoken about at all.

I just don't see the fighting right now that makes me think we're barking up a wolf tree and suni seems like a convenient distraction

Wait what? Both wolves haven't talked about her? Did I kiss one? At the rate I'm going I might have

 

[Coopah]

You both thought I tipped maj when I unlynched. That's weird

Lol she said she didn't read the thread. She was reacting to me saying you tripped maj. Not sure how a wolf would misread the same thing as me and not just be like yo ******* it's not maj

 

[genny]

Did I kiss one?

 

[genny]

I would like to talk about how Paws keeps tossing shade at everyone and anyone to see what we're going to chase after.

 

[Coopah]

Lol she said she didn't read the thread. She was reacting to me saying you tripped maj. Not sure how a wolf would misread the same thing as me and not just be like yo ******* it's not maj

Clarification, not sure why you'd have to be a wolf to have the same **** up as me. Unless you're trying to implicate that she both didn't read and listened to me on thread, which is what I was saying anyways and not sure how that means we're wolves together.

 

[deleted804295]

Guys I'm sorry for my poor performance. Life has gotten the best of me and I've more than likely entered into a depression because of everything going on in my life.

I tried my best to log on and attempt to contribute but it looks like I'm not doing enough. I considered getting a sub but didn't think it was fair to the mods so I tried playing earnestly even when I've felt like crap trying to keep up with life and this game.

 

[Coopah]

This no editing thing is killing me

 

[SportPonies]

Most important BC posts that read wolfy to me (ie, if you ignore most of this post, at least read this portion)

Lol I know, I literally can't even defend any of that because it just looks so bad. Totally agree with you. I guess the only thing I can say is why would I be saying those things right around lynch close? Like I already said "hey I don't like the Doggo lynch given her post 10 minutes before close and given the way that people are reacting- rather, not reacting- to it", SAR is already going down, what possible purpose does it serve me as a wolf to say 3 minutes before close "gee I don't know if I like the SAR lynch either"? Clearly I didn't want anyone to switch from SAR to Doggo or something since I really didn't like the Doggo wagon, so what would the point of me being like "wow this feels like a v/v lynch" have been if I knew that in 3 minutes, SAR was going to flip wolf? Like I just can't see how it would benefit me as a wolf to be commenting like that unless it was for the specific reason of being able to make this post right now lol.

(also on a side note I'm prone to long rambly paragraphs in general so that's just me lol)

This entire post sounds like waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay over-justification for a villager that doesn't have that much heat on them.

You are really not helping quell my Kota/Paws theory lol

This post and the above one- "lol" use in certain circumstances always makes me feel like an attempt at deflection.


_______________________________________
The others:

Also

unlynch SAR
lynch Sunbodi

Though I would like to hear more from SAR too please and thank you

This totally reads "Imma unlynch my fellow wolf but still poke at them a tiny bit to distance myself"

Does maj start today? 7 to hammer?

Asking questions to look like contributions, but not actually all that helpful?

Yep, totally agree. I think that’d be pretty obvious if they both jumped on a lynch at once to push it over since we’re nowhere near LyLo yet lol but definitely a good thing to keep in mind!

Tone here just sounds... forced happy-nice. Sorry in advance to BC if she actually was just being happy-nice and is village lol. But this post just made me squint real hard when it happened and again on ISO

 

[JustPaws]

Lol she said she didn't read the thread. She was reacting to me saying you tripped maj. Not sure how a wolf would misread the same thing as me and not just be like yo ******* it's not maj

I think it just seemed like it happened really fast but when I look at time stamps there is like a 5 minute gap that felt like 30 seconds

 

[WonderingStudent]

You mean this? Because she reacted to what I said? Lol ok nice stretch

I didn't go count the number of votes on the lynch. You seemed like you thought it was majority but based on that I had messaged AM a question not too long ago about the game which she responded to, I assumed she would be on sdn and she would have closed the thread if maj actually occurred.

 

[Coopah]

I think it just seemed like it happened really fast but when I look at time stamps there is like a 5 minute gap that felt like 30 seconds

This is me noting your backtracking now that you've lost the argument.

 

[SportPonies]

Wait what? Both wolves haven't talked about her? Did I kiss one? At the rate I'm going I might have

I... can't tell if I just wasn't clear? Or if you're misunderstanding me. Or both
I was saying I think one or both of the wolves are in the group of people that haven't been discussed at length. I think one or both is/are flying under the radar compared to the people that keep getting brought up.

 

[JustPaws]

Maybe just lynch me to get out of this tunnel

 

[genny]

Tone here just sounds... forced happy-nice. Sorry in advance to BC if she actually was just being happy-nice and is village lol. But this post just made me squint real hard when it happened and again on ISO

Funny, I've felt like her tone has been pretty village, and that's what's kept me from lynching her thus far. The flip off SAR + "oh darn I got fooled again" reaction afterwards definitely skeeved me out.

 

[SportPonies]

Better question: why do you NOT want to lynch BC? Because that's the impression I've gotten from this.

 

[SportPonies]

Better question: why do you NOT want to lynch BC? Because that's the impression I've gotten from this.

@Coopah

 

[JustPaws]

I do the right thing and unlynch, cuz people are actively reading and you jump down my throat lol. I call you sketch for it and I'm sketchy lol

 

[SportPonies]

Funny, I've felt like her tone has been pretty village, and that's what's kept me from lynching her thus far. The flip off SAR + "oh darn I got fooled again" reaction afterwards definitely skeeved me out.

hmmmmmmmmm
I guess we'll have to agree to disagree on her tone then haha
She just sounds saccharine sometimes, in a furry way.

 

[Coopah]

I... can't tell if I just wasn't clear? Or if you're misunderstanding me. Or both
I was saying I think one or both of the wolves are in the group of people that haven't been discussed at length. I think one or both is/are flying under the radar compared to the people that keep getting brought up.

Oh! You're saying they haven't been discussed in general. I thought you meant the wolves haven't talked about BC, like SAR hadn't listed BC in her lists or whatever, thanks for clarifying

 

[genny]

She just sounds saccharine sometimes, in a furry way.

This reminds me of the 2 cats I had to shave today.

 

[SportPonies]

Just putting this out there:
I still have tinfoils that Coop and/or Paws are wolves.

 

[Coopah]

Maybe just lynch me to get out of this tunnel

That's my consideration considering how strongly the resistance was against your lynch

 

[JustPaws]

Just putting this out there:
I still have tinfoils that Coop and/or Paws are wolves.

I thought you let go of the coop one? After you "did some things?"

 

[Coopah]

Better question: why do you NOT want to lynch BC? Because that's the impression I've gotten from this.

For the reason in that post you disliked of mine

 

[Coopah]

I do the right thing and unlynch, cuz people are actively reading and you jump down my throat lol. I call you sketch for it and I'm sketchy lol

Yes

 

[Coopah]

Just putting this out there:
I still have tinfoils that Coop and/or Paws are wolves.

I mean yeah I'm on the paws train. Have been since D1

 

[alissa14]

here’s my reads list y’all. I’ll be on for lynch close if anyone has questions

Coopah - I feel like coopah has been giving very solid reads and has been playing very pro-village. Nothing weird here


BC - as I said yesterday.. wolf!BC would’ve NEVER gone for a 3 way tie so she scored some major village points for that. I’m honestly shocked she’s this high on my list. This move basically cleared BC for me which unknown territory and kinda scary.

Wonder - she had some catching up to do but I think she’s come off as strong village while she’s been here. I have her as village

Barks - wish I had more thoughts here but I’ve been mostly agreeing with what she’s saying and nothing so far has pinged me as weird.

Doggo - I’ve been agreeing with a lot of her reads so I have her as high village neutral

Sunbodi - I’ve been over it a million times in my head and I don’t think wolf!sunbodi would just announce vanillager. I know she hasn’t wolfed before but I don’t think she would as a new wolf make a move without consulting her pack first. I disagree with a lot of what she’s saying but I think we usually disagree lol. I begrudgingly have Sunni in my village neutral pile.

Genny - while I’ve been reading genny as village, I’ve been wrong about her before. I’m keeping her dead neutral. I’m worried we are all giving genny a pass since this is her practice game and has gone without a lot of scrutiny. We can’t let genny fly under the radar just because we want to keep her alive to practice
.
Kota - moved vote away from paws towards 3M. However tied the vote between SAR and doggo D1... VCA is confusing. Neutral wolf leaning for you

Paws - mpm was not high on my radar AT ALL. The night kill choice was super weird plus paws voted to try to lynch her yesterday.. not super significant but I felt worth noting

Sporty - lynched paws 10 minutes before lynch close yesterday. Seemed odd as both her and paws were leading for most of the day. Didn’t give any reasoning from what I can see and seemed easy to slip a vote in. I also disagree with her vote for BC.

 

[genny]

wolf!BC would’ve NEVER gone for a 3 way tie so she scored some major village points for that. I’m honestly shocked she’s this high on my list. This move basically cleared BC for me which unknown territory and kinda scary.

Does your opinion change since we know what happens in a tie? The rules say it's RNG'd to one person. So not a terribly risky move for a wolf to pull if it's villagers in the tie.

 

[alissa14]

By the way if it wasnt clear I’m gonna lynch sporty. The way that the vote just casually moved towards 3M and away from paws and sporty that close to lynch close really rubbed me the wrong way. I think that sporty and paws while both high on my sketch radar are w/v

 

[SportPonies]

I thought you let go of the coop one? After you "did some things?"

It was a real thought yesterday. Now it's a tinfoil based on that voting pattern. Still something I haven't let go of completely.

 

[Kota1000]

By the way if it wasnt clear I’m gonna lynch sporty. The way that the vote just casually moved towards 3M and away from paws and sporty that close to lynch close really rubbed me the wrong way. I think that sporty and paws while both high on my sketch radar are w/v

If sporty flips wolf, do you have a pack mate theory on anyone?

 

[SportPonies]

By the way if it wasnt clear I’m gonna lynch sporty. The way that the vote just casually moved towards 3M and away from paws and sporty that close to lynch close really rubbed me the wrong way. I think that sporty and paws while both high on my sketch radar are w/v

sooooooo..... why aren't you voting for the people that moved the vote off of us and onto 3m? Who's the wolf that moved the vote onto 3m?

 

[BigCats]

Honestly the way the Sunbodi lynch has been sloooooowly building all day does not make me think it’s likely to catch a wolf

 

[alissa14]

Does your opinion change since we know what happens in a tie? The rules say it's RNG'd to one person. So not a terribly risky move for a wolf to pull if it's villagers in the tie.

I’m gonna say no because I still have paws and sporty pretty high on my sketch list today so I don’t think BC would take the chance to RNG if one of her pack mates was at risk

 

[Kota1000]

sooooooo..... why aren't you voting for the people that moved the vote off of us and onto 3m? Who's the wolf that moved the vote onto 3m?

Who is the “off of us” referring to?

 

[Coopah]

By the way if it wasnt clear I’m gonna lynch sporty. The way that the vote just casually moved towards 3M and away from paws and sporty that close to lynch close really rubbed me the wrong way. I think that sporty and paws while both high on my sketch radar are w/v

As a mod courtesy please place lunch votes in separate lines

 

[deleted804295]

Honestly the way the Sunbodi lynch has been sloooooowly building all day does not make me think it’s likely to catch a wolf

What does this mean?

 

[alissa14]

If sporty flips wolf, do you have a pack mate theory on anyone?

i would honestly think the other wolf may be you if sport flips wolf. If sporty flips village I’ll be looking more closely at paws

 

[Kota1000]

i would honestly think the other wolf may be you if sport flips wolf. If sporty flips village I’ll be looking more closely at paws

Why me?

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 3 Lynch Tally
Kota (2) - BC, Coop
Suni (3) - genny, Barks, Doggo
genny (1) - Kota
BC (1) - Sporty
Coop (1) - Suni
Sporty (1) - alissa

9/11
lynch close in ~45 minutes
Missing: Wonder, Paws

 

[alissa14]

sooooooo..... why aren't you voting for the people that moved the vote off of us and onto 3m? Who's the wolf that moved the vote onto 3m?

I’m kicking myself for not keeping track of lynches. I usually do so in a very detailed spreadsheet but I have not had the time since I’ve been at my internship.

 

[deleted804295]

When I flip village who is wolf? 😀

 

[alissa14]

Why me?

Well after paws I have you as third highest. You’re also not reading as village-y as much this game as I feel you have in the past..

 

[BigCats]

What does this mean?

I feel like if you were a wolf, your partner would be trying a lil harder to figure out how to save you since it’s not like your bandwagon just exploded in the last hour unexpectedly. It just doesn’t feel like the kind of bandwagon that ends up well given how it’s formed.

 

[JustPaws]

I’m kicking myself for not keeping track of lynches. I usually do so in a very detailed spreadsheet but I have not had the time since I’ve been at my internship.

I updated lynch trackers today if that helps