Milkshake - Game Thread

[genny]

---

Members don't see this ad.

I think the two people up for lynch today have to be Doggo and Barks based on the D1 vote. If Doggo is village, Barks has got to be a wolf. If Doggo is a wolf, then Barks could be either.

If I had been paying more attention the last two days, I probably would have wanted either Barks or Wondering up for lynch earlier, so that we could look at how those votes went. But alas, I was preoccupied. We've had villagers up for lynch on the subsequent days, so it makes it easier for wolves to hide.

 

[genny]

Ok we need to narrow this down to two. Please

Are you going to share your target list?

 

[Doggo Labs]

Just got back on, need to catch up on today. Will be back after I read

 

[genny]

Keeping it classy, over here. Drinking wine and eating cheetos. 😎

And then I have to go clean cat pee out of some fabric. My days off are just wild, I tell you.

 

[Coopah]

Are you going to share your target list?

I didn't want to until the other JOAT revealed because I don't want to out them before they're ready

 

[Coopah]

I think the two people up for lynch today have to be Doggo and Barks based on the D1 vote. If Doggo is village, Barks has got to be a wolf. If Doggo is a wolf, then Barks could be either.

If I had been paying more attention the last two days, I probably would have wanted either Barks or Wondering up for lynch earlier, so that we could look at how those votes went. But alas, I was preoccupied. We've had villagers up for lynch on the subsequent days, so it makes it easier for wolves to hide.

Ok Unlynch Kota

 

[Barkley13]

I say doggo and kota

 

[Kota1000]

Thoughts:
Will be ISOing Kota, Doggo, and Barks today.
While I felt good about doggo jnitially as village neutral, their flip flop of votes yesterday made me uneasy. Kota I feel is just all wrong. I’m confused why she’s still on the genny train when genny is an outed JOAT but okay. Barks I had suspicions for yesterday but their interactions with me seemed okay so I didn’t end up lynching there. We’re down to the nitty gritty at this point and we can’t screw up this lynch.. I’m probably leaning more towards Kota and Barks over Doggo though If I’m gonna be honest.

I did not see where genny said she was a JOAT... just that she thinks the JOAT should reveal themselves, and coop did as 1

 

[Kota1000]

Oh we can talk about reads if you want



Lastly, it's not my fault people decided to vote there when I wasn't pushing it in any way and wasn't around
You're really helping my kota/doggo wolf pack theory though with how much you've defended her though

I will say your consistency with doggo is being slight village, and I feel like you upped your reads regarding them. Slight village creds. I still feel better about doggo then you at the moment

 

[Kota1000]

Also [mention]Barkley13 [/mention] your quotes you picked for my reads were just a few of what I said, that’s being very selective. You missed all the big ones and the ones where I talked about more then just paws, bc or 3m so that’s not really helping your case

 

[Barkley13]

Also [mention]Barkley13 [/mention] your quotes you picked for my reads were just a few of what I said, that’s being very selective. You missed all the big ones and the ones where I talked about more then just paws, bc or 3m so that’s not really helping your case

You mean genny who you keep lynching and unlynching and who we don’t know the affiliation one? And idk how they’re not “big ones” when you literally voted to lynch them but ok

 

[Doggo Labs]

I like how two people who have been reading me village have now said I am one of their wolf candidates today.

 

[genny]

I didn't want to until the other JOAT revealed because I don't want to out them before they're ready

I mean, you already said you think I'm the other JOAT. So idk why you're waiting.

We should probably discuss actions for tonight too before lynch closes. The way I see it, we have two options: either we try to catch a wolf and assume one of us is going to die, or we protect each other and hope we lynch a wolf tomorrow.

 

[genny]

I like how two people who have been reading me village have now said I am one of their wolf candidates today.

Are you going to claim JOAT now? Because I was thinking of voting Barks.

 

[Doggo Labs]

@Doggo Labs your input at the moment + current reads would be much appreciated.

I still have Kota up at the top of my reads, along with genny.
Coop I am still reading as village.
Alissa is leaning more on the village side of things.
Barks is neutral wolf lean
And you I have as neutral village lean

 

[Coopah]

I mean, you already said you think I'm the other JOAT. So idk why you're waiting.

We should probably discuss actions for tonight too before lynch closes. The way I see it, we have two options: either we try to catch a wolf and assume one of us is going to die, or we protect each other and hope we lynch a wolf tomorrow.

I mean no I didn't, it could be interpreted that way but that's not what I intended. Regardless my Target list

N1 track dubz - she died
N2 motion paws - nothing
N3 doctor wonder - nothing
N4 track genny - followed her to wondering

 

[genny]

I still have Kota up at the top of my reads, along with genny.

This bothers me. You have someone who has claimed JOAT, who is saying I'm the other JOAT, and you still have me at the top of your wolf reads? Unless you're planning to counterclaim Coop, I just don't see how that's possible.

 

[genny]

N1: Paws did nothing.
N2: no motion detected near Barks.
N3: protected Coop.
N4: no motion detected near Wondering.

 

[genny]

Thank goodness I didn't protect a wolf.

 

[Coopah]

Thank goodness I didn't protect a wolf.

I was worried about the same thing 😀

 

[Doggo Labs]

Are you going to claim JOAT now? Because I was thinking of voting Barks.

I'm not going to claim it because I am not the JOAT, I said what I said D1 because I didn't want to die D1.
Are you going to claim it then?

 

[Doggo Labs]

I'm not going to claim it because I am not the JOAT, I said what I said D1 because I didn't want to die D1.
Are you going to claim it then?

JK just saw that last post of yours, I need to do some rereading and rethinking

 

[genny]

I'm not going to claim it because I am not the JOAT, I said what I said D1 because I didn't want to die D1.
Are you going to claim it then?

Yes. So Coop and I are off the table. Who's in Kota's pack now?

 

[Barkley13]

Yes. So Coop and I are off the table. Who's in Kota's pack now?

Prediction: she’s going to say me

 

[WonderingStudent]

I like how two people who have been reading me village have now said I am one of their wolf candidates today.

At this point I'm rethinking everything. Only reason I was thinking you were village was because of D1 lynch position, how SAR was voting to lynch you and what I thought was a soft claim. Wolf pack combinations currently make little sense to me so I'm just going to go based on posts. You haven't made much of them and they have felt weird. I didn't push you earlier because as has already been said I and others thought you were soft claiming JOAT.

 

[Coopah]

@genny why did you think wondering should've been up for lynch?

 

[genny]

@genny why did you think wondering should've been up for lynch?

Because we have no data for her on D1.

 

[genny]

I feel like a Doggo lynch would get us the most info - if she's wolf then all bets are off for the people on SAR's lynch. But if she's village, then the people on SAR's lynch are less likely to be clear. But we just don't have enough lynched left for an info lynch. I think we should try for the wolfiest person today, and I don't necessarily believe that's Doggo.

 

[Doggo Labs]

Yes. So Coop and I are off the table. Who's in Kota's pack now?

Based off what I said before it would be Barks, but I'm going to iso some things and get back to ya on that.

 

[genny]

If Barks and Doggo are wolves, then their best move is for Barks to bus Doggo.

 

[Coopah]

I feel like a Doggo lynch would get us the most info - if she's wolf then all bets are off for the people on SAR's lynch. But if she's village, then the people on SAR's lynch are less likely to be clear. But we just don't have enough lynched left for an info lynch. I think we should try for the wolfiest person today, and I don't necessarily believe that's Doggo.

#****it

lynch doggo

 

[Coopah]

If Barks and Doggo are wolves, then their best move is for Barks to bus Doggo.

I mean barks is already after doggo

 

[kaydubs]

Day 5 Lynch Tally
Barks (1) - Kota
Kota ()
Doggo (2) - Wondering, Coops

3/7
lynch close in ~3 hours

 

[genny]

So here's how I see village winning: Coop and I protect each other tonight. We have 2 cleared villagers tomorrow, and we've absolutely got to lynch a wolf for lylo. Then we have to talk about who to check the next night, so we're looking at different people. We'll have one living JOAT + one cleared person + one wolf that should be easily identifiable. The biggest fault with this plant is that we've got to pick a wolf on lylo. We have a 66% chance, but it's got to happen.

Alternatively, Coop and I pick different people to check, the wolves kill someone (probably one of us JOATs, and then we still face the same problem on lylo: 2 cleared villagers, one uncleared villager, and two wolves. But no chance to figure it out with 100% certainty overnight.

 

[Doggo Labs]

Thoughts at the moment:

Wondering would fit into my noob wolf pack idea with the crazy lynches, and I could maybe see her in a pack with Kota.
I'm not sure I can see a pack with Kota and Barks.
If Kota is not wolf then Barks goes up my list more
genny and coop are clear cause of claims and no one has countered their claim
Alissa would also go up my list more if Kota is not wolf.
Kotas flip gives me the best course of action to go on next, so i'm going

Lynch Kota

 

[Coopah]

So here's how I see village winning: Coop and I protect each other tonight. We have 2 cleared villagers tomorrow, and we've absolutely got to lynch a wolf for lylo. Then we have to talk about who to check the next night, so we're looking at different people. We'll have one living JOAT + one cleared person + one wolf that should be easily identifiable. The biggest fault with this plant is that we've got to pick a wolf on lylo. We have a 66% chance, but it's got to happen.

Alternatively, Coop and I pick different people to check, the wolves kill someone (probably one of us JOATs, and then we still face the same problem on lylo: 2 cleared villagers, one uncleared villager, and two wolves. But no chance to figure it out with 100% certainty overnight.

We have to remember there is no switching votes in lylo, so we need to determine the voting order and stick to it. Have the people we determine to vote early actually vote during a specified time and if they don't that them admitting they're a wolf.

Can everyone agree to that?

 

[Coopah]

We can also no lynch today to buy a day

 

[Doggo Labs]

I need to go make supper, I havent eaten since 9AM this morning and its now after 6PM, I'll be back cause I am very hungry

 

[WonderingStudent]

We can also no lynch today to buy a day

It depends on what you guys want to do. I don't know if we will be in a better position tomorrow. This would be the worst case scenario: If we mislynch today or do no lynch today, Day 6 (tomorrow) will still be lylo (unless doctor ability is used to correctly choose the NK of course).

Worst case scenario:
Day 5
7 players alive today
No lynch + NK

Day 6 - Lylo
6 players alive (2 wolves + 4 villagers)

mislynch + NK

Parity reached by Day 7

 

[Kota1000]

You mean genny who you keep lynching and unlynching and who we don’t know the affiliation one? And idk how they’re not “big ones” when you literally voted to lynch them but ok

Well I meant the long ISO’s I did and the long reads I posted at the start of D2 and D3. I didn’t mean “big” as in important haha

 

[genny]

We can also no lynch today to buy a day

If we did this, and protect each other tonight, we'd be looking at a 4V 2W mylo instead of a 3V 2W lylo.

 

[Coopah]

If we did this, and protect each other tonight, we'd be looking at a 4V 2W mylo instead of a 3V 2W lylo.

yeah it'd have to be two no lynches to make a difference. Not worth it

 

[Kota1000]

If we did this, and protect each other tonight, we'd be looking at a 4V 2W mylo instead of a 3V 2W lylo.

I’m sorry I pushed your lynch! I guess I suck at reading people, maybe I just need to slow down and actually think about stuff before jumping to conclusions

 

[alissa14]

Popping in to say I’m EXHAUSTED. I still have 3 more raccoons to feed and I’m so tired. I don’t even know what’s going on so I guess I’ll just vote who had the most wolf points in my book. Hopefully I’ll be on before lynch close to change if needed but no guarantees. I’m sorry guys but with the pandemic volunteers are few and far between so it’s basically me and two other people doing EVERYTHING. I will do my best when I’m home to not pass out and analyze and come up with a better list of reads before I have to be back at my internship tomorrow. For now:

lynch barks

 

[WonderingStudent]

Day 5 Lynch Tally
Barks (2) - Kota, alissa
Kota (1) - doggo
Doggo (2) - Wondering, Coops

3/7
lynch close in ~1 hour

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 5 Lynch Tally
Barks (2) - Kota, alissa
Kota (1) - Doggo
Doggo (2) - Wonder, Coop

5/7
lynch close in ~1 hour
Missing: Barks, genny

 

[WonderingStudent]

Day 5 Lynch Tally
Barks (2) - Kota, alissa
Kota (1) - doggo
Doggo (2) - Wondering, Coops

3/7
lynch close in ~1 hour

Nope that number of people whose voted is wrong.
Day 5 Lynch Tally
Barks (2) - Kota, alissa
Kota (1) - doggo
Doggo (2) - Wondering, Coops

5/7
lynch close in ~1 hour

 

[genny]

o hai
i forgot to vote.

Does anyone think that I'm totally off-base in my thinking?

 

[Barkley13]

Is it safe for me to vote now without anything bad happening? I think it is

 

[WonderingStudent]

@genny before you put your vote down maybe confirm with coopah what you guys are doing if you want to coordinate. I don't want wolves to cause maj before you get to talk. Causing maj would look bad for the player that creates it but I can see players claiming self-prez for their reasoning for causing majority.