Milkshake - Game Thread

[Barkley13]

---

Members don't see this ad.

Lynch alissa

 

[Animal Midwife]

Day 6 Lynch Tally
alissa (1) - Barks

1/5
lynch close in ~10 hours

 

[Coopah]

Also this is a predictable argument that I saw coming. Pretty sure doggo was not going to be up for lynch yesterday and I had to spend a long time and a lot of effort showing that she was wolfy

Which would be an excellent bus...

I'm honestly not convinced between the two of you. It's a 50/50 shot but we lynch one one dies overnight (maybe I still have my protect) and we lynch the other. Game over

 

[Coopah]

No the last wolf is Alissa haha

Oops I misread

 

[Barkley13]

Which would be an excellent bus...

I'm honestly not convinced between the two of you. It's a 50/50 shot but we lynch one one dies overnight (maybe I still have my protect) and we lynch the other. Game over

Yeah that’s why I wouldn’t be horribly upset if I get lynched today because then there’s an easy lynch and win tomorrow

 

[Barkley13]

Although now that I think about it I do like Alissa’s “well I think it’s kota but it still could be barks with the ultimate bus!” so that she was free to push either lynch today lol

 

[Coopah]

Yeah that’s why I wouldn’t be horribly upset if I get lynched today because then there’s an easy lynch and win tomorrow

😕😕😕 what? you're upset because it'd be an easy lynch tomorrow?

 

[genny]

Funny you should ask, I was a bad JOAT and decided since there was once wolf left I would investigate Kota because it's been nagging me all game. I hoped the wolves would assume we were protecting each other.

She's clear.

Lol I had a feeling you were going to do this.

we should be in a good position if we have to go through tomorrow. We will have 2 cleared villagers, probably 3 if you protect me tonight.

 

[Barkley13]

😕😕😕 what? you're upset because it'd be an easy lynch tomorrow?

What? I said the opposite

 

[Kota1000]

So it’s Alissa 😕

What makes you clear?

 

[Kota1000]

Tomorrow would be lylo correct?

 

[Barkley13]

What makes you clear?

My role PM that tells me so 😛

but for you guys, you can decide for yourselves if you think I spent that much effort trying to get doggo lynched as a bus or as a villager who strongly believed she was super sketchy. And compare that to alissa’s play

 

[Barkley13]

Tomorrow would be lylo correct?

Yes

 

[Kota1000]

Wow... so then the last wolf must be Barkley. I’m vanilla town... a coffee milkshake in fact (@CoffeeQuestionMark 😉)

No the last wolf is Alissa haha

I'm gonna have to do some ISOing today. I might actually have the time to go on my computer and do it, yay!

 

[Barkley13]

In the interest of the game ending today

here’s alissas posts that mention doggo. They pretty much go back and forth between strong village and wants to hear more from her

Honestly I’d be fine with either a SAR or doggo lynch and I’ll leave it up to RNG gods. Both have pinged me as of recent. I’ll give specific posts later. Unlynch sunni lynch sar

Reads so far:
Feeling good about Kota, doggo, Coopah, surprisingly BC
Neutral: genny, barks, paws, everyone elese
Wolfish: 3M
Wolfy: sunbodi
Lynch sunbodi

I really wish doggo was here. I felt good about them earlier but the more absent she is the more sus I become. But I’m not ready to vote there simply because she’s inactive. It is mother’s day after all... maybe she’s celebrating with her family...

I think the point that was made was the timing of the self prez. If SAR is her wolf partner she could’ve self prezzed onto sunbodi instead of SAR. I think that’s the point people were making. I gotta check the votes again. I also agree with what BigCats said earlier that it seems unlikely that Doggo is wolf based on timing of her votes unless she was trying to bus the hell out of SAR which I don’t think was the case...

Hahaha cute lil noob. Basically you beat me to it. I wanted to tie it up yesterday but you beat me to it. I ended up breaking the tie towards SAR and good thing too because she flipped wolf! So I got really lucky. Especially since I’m leaning doggo more village than I was yesterday

Doggo - I’ve been agreeing with a lot of her reads so I have her as high village neutral

@ 9:45 there was a 3-way tie between SAR, sunbodi, and Doggo. I’m sure this has been mentioned before, but if doggo were SAR’s wolfy partner she could’ve easily made up some reason to switch her lynch to sunbodi and save both herself and SAR. There was enough time to make something up. But she didn’t. This basically clears doggo as village in my book.

@Doggo Labs 5-10 @ 9:14

“Okay thanks”

This was super weird. You then explained some sort of phone glitch? Can you please re-explain what happened here? I’m confused if this was an actual glitch or we all are dumb and missed a rojo.

Doggo Labs - while i agree with your reads lists, I wish some of them had more content behind the reasoning of specific placements. I hope to see more from you so that I can move you higher up because while you feel village, I’d like to see more reasoning/content from you. Village Neutral

@BigCats @WonderingStudent @Doggo Labs I would like to know your thoughts on Sporty or if my long analysis led me down a tunnel to nowhere lol.

Thoughts:
Will be ISOing Kota, Doggo, and Barks today.
While I felt good about doggo jnitially as village neutral, their flip flop of votes yesterday made me uneasy. Kota I feel is just all wrong. I’m confused why she’s still on the genny train when genny is an outed JOAT but okay. Barks I had suspicions for yesterday but their interactions with me seemed okay so I didn’t end up lynching there. We’re down to the nitty gritty at this point and we can’t screw up this lynch.. I’m probably leaning more towards Kota and Barks over Doggo though If I’m gonna be honest.

And take this as you will, but Alissa liked my post with all the quotes where doggo echoes someone else like right when I posted it and then lynched me after. So pretty much this post isn’t genuine:

As I had said last night, I was going to ISO doggo with the last 20 or so minutes before lynch close and between barks piecing all the times doggo echoed, her reads lacking a lot of content, and her “Okay thanks” comment which I’m now convinced was an accidental rojo.

 

[Barkley13]

Doggos posts on alissa

Sar is the top right now
Paws
Sunni
Dubz
Barks
Genny

Would like to hear some more from BC, Alissa, and some more people.
I may be slightly hydrated right now

Okay semi caught up. That last post of mine was saved from earlier. Idk how that happened SDN has been glitchy in my phone lately. Updated reads is

Wolf
Suni
Paws
Kota
Barks
Sport
Alissa
Wondering
Coop
genny

I know there are more people but that’s what I got at the moment

Alissa: Has made solid sounding posts and have agreeing/nodding with what shes been saying. She was pretty quiet at the beginning of the game, but has made up for that the last few days.

I still have Kota up at the top of my reads, along with genny.
Coop I am still reading as village.
Alissa is leaning more on the village side of things.
Barks is neutral wolf lean
And you I have as neutral village lean

Thoughts at the moment:

Wondering would fit into my noob wolf pack idea with the crazy lynches, and I could maybe see her in a pack with Kota.
I'm not sure I can see a pack with Kota and Barks.
If Kota is not wolf then Barks goes up my list more
genny and coop are clear cause of claims and no one has countered their claim
Alissa would also go up my list more if Kota is not wolf.
Kotas flip gives me the best course of action to go on next, so i'm going

Lynch Kota

 

[Barkley13]

Doggos posts on me

Sar is the top right now
Paws
Sunni
Dubz
Barks
Genny

Would like to hear some more from BC, Alissa, and some more people.
I may be slightly hydrated right now

Okay semi caught up. That last post of mine was saved from earlier. Idk how that happened SDN has been glitchy in my phone lately. Updated reads is

Wolf
Suni
Paws
Kota
Barks
Sport
Alissa
Wondering
Coop
genny

I know there are more people but that’s what I got at the moment

@Sunbodi what are your reads and thoughts on genny, barks, and kota?

Barks: I keep flip flopping on reading her village and reading her sketch.

@WonderingStudent
Villagey posts:







Sketchy posts:

I feel like when I read this the first time my sketch meter went up, but reading it now reads fine. I feel like this happens a bit when I'm reading barks, but as I'm rereading she is sounding more fine to me. I got a little burned by her a few games ago, but village ended up winning, and I don't want to make that mistake again, thats why I tend to read sketch on first read though but when rereading in context she sounds fine.

I still have Kota up at the top of my reads, along with genny.
Coop I am still reading as village.
Alissa is leaning more on the village side of things.
Barks is neutral wolf lean
And you I have as neutral village lean

Based off what I said before it would be Barks, but I'm going to iso some things and get back to ya on that.

Thoughts at the moment:

Wondering would fit into my noob wolf pack idea with the crazy lynches, and I could maybe see her in a pack with Kota.
I'm not sure I can see a pack with Kota and Barks.
If Kota is not wolf then Barks goes up my list more
genny and coop are clear cause of claims and no one has countered their claim
Alissa would also go up my list more if Kota is not wolf.
Kotas flip gives me the best course of action to go on next, so i'm going

Lynch Kota

 

[Coopah]

If anyone want to prove their innocence, go back and look when I was arguing for doggo to be lynched and who I was arguing with. I know it was paws and genny, and I think barks? That's going to determine my vote for today

 

[Barkley13]

my posts on doggo minus some ones from yesterday

Has doggo come back and talked after saying she wasn’t trying to talk cuz if not I’m good with my vote

Doggo's another one that has felt off but her voting for SAR over sunbodi makes me lean her more village in spite of the fact that her reads seem to echo other peoples

I really don't feel great about sunbodi, kota, wondering +/- sporty
Feel neutral about BC, paws, coop, genny
And villageish about alissa and doggo
I think that's everyone

Alissa was based on posts + voting pattern
Doggo was not based on posts because she’s been pretty echoey but is based on self prezzing to SAR over Sunni and how SAR voted her over Sunni too

So are you planning to vote for genny today then?

Doggo is based not only on her voting pattern but also SAR’s. And I don’t think there were two wolves up for lynch on D1.
And yes kota’s has become less important because her posts have been so sketchy

I mean she didn’t say today was the day and multiple people have already said this. This is what I meant by echoey

Also I haven’t been able to find it with the search function and can’t remember who said it but someone was questioning why doggo didn’t die N1. Which is still relevant

You have one sketchy post and it’s just me saying that genny is neutral? 😕
also I have no idea what game you’re referring to because I don’t even remember the last time I was a wolf

How does this make sense
If you’re voting for her then that means you must believe it

You know who’s creeping me out today? Doggo

So here’s where I’m at.

Why is doggo alive and why is no one else concerned about it???

I’m honestly feeling a doggo/kota pack right now

Oh we can talk about reads if you want



Lastly, it's not my fault people decided to vote there when I wasn't pushing it in any way and wasn't around
You're really helping my kota/doggo wolf pack theory though with how much you've defended her though

 

[Kota1000]

Okay so here's how Barks and Alissa voted each day
Barks
D1 - doggo
D2 3m
D3 suni
D4 Sporty
D5 Lynch doggo
Barks started the doggo Lynch D1 as a joke, but stayed on it, and then lynched Doggo D5, after which Doggo lynched Barks for "self-prez"

Alissa
D1 - BC -> Sun -> SAR
D2 suni -> 3m
D3 sporty ->paws
D4 Sporty
D5 barks -> doggo

Alissa had both a last minute switch to SAR D1 and to Doggo D5, which was not counted


Based solely on this, I am leaning more towards Alissa being a wolf mainly because they switched both last minute to SAR and Doggo, maybe for village points?

I do think it is odd that Doggo switched to Lynch Barks with the comment self-prez, which could either indicate that Doggo did not think Barks was a wolf, or they knew that Barks was a wolf and did not want to give it away, slight WIFOM when trying to consider this...

Will be Isoing Alissa and Barks

 

[Barkley13]

If anyone want to prove their innocence, go back and look when I was arguing for doggo to be lynched and who I was arguing with. I know it was paws and genny, and I think barks? That's going to determine my vote for today

I don’t think I argued about that?

 

[Coopah]

I don’t think I argued about that?

I can't remember which is why I'm asking, when I have time I'll go back and look but if someone wants to do so now I'd appreciate it

 

[Barkley13]

@Coopah

Spoiler: Quotes

I'm thinking we had two wolves for lynch D1

Lynch doggo

Why doggo?

k so back to this whole thing, why would sar choose to "self prez" to doggo if they are a wolf and sunni is not... only way this makes sense is if sunni is also a wolf... otherwise we would just be killing off a semi-cleared villager

It's right there with the lynch vote

I am actually wondering about Sunni being a wolf as there's a huge tone shift from her standard village play. But more than that there were a few fast a furious votes on doggo and SAR may not have felt the pressure to place one on doggo, especially considering what's happening now. Not saying I'm right, but I definitely want to explore it a bit.

No we want a reason why you think doggo is a wolf

So you think the top three last night, D1 was the whole pack? We are just that good?

And, that two of the three voted for each other

Hey you said it not me 😉 but no I doubt we're that good. Regardless, I'm simply giving my suspicions

Sunni didn't vote and the other two were self prez. Not out of the question

Yes I said it hours ago to kota. Why would sar vote for doggo when am she could have voted sunni

Well basically, I think doggo is a wolf based on play yesterday and today, potential lurking and the feel of the lynch yesterday.

Except you also said you dont think we got all three on top of lynch D1. Cuz you either think that's the whole pack, or you see why doggo is likely village

Then that's my fault for not being clear. Doggo just got a flurry of votes. If SAR votes Sunni then later flips wolf it might look like she was actively protecting doggo, then doggo gets lynched.

Does it appear that way to you?

Isn't that what I just said?

I guess that's fair but I've learned that if you can protect a wolf without arousing undue suspicion then you should. Feels like a stretch for D1 wolf thinking, like if Doggo and SAR were wolves then instead of self prezzing on each other they could have both hopped on sunni, and no one would know for days and then its wifom if one of them flip.

But I hear you and I agree its possible, I just don't find it likely.

Sent from my SM-G960U using SDN mobile

So who are the wolves in this scenario, sar and doggo but not sunni?

I really don't see why Doggo would be a wolf. 9:50 last night, Doggo is in the lead with four votes, Doggo is voting for SAR who has three votes, Sunbodi also has three votes. If she and SAR were exactly two wolves, why would Doggo not have switched to Sunbodi to self-prez? I even suggested that she do so in order to at least give herself a fighting chance but she stayed on SAR's vote. Unless y'all think she did so for the ultimate bus, I'm just not seeing it.

Like unless Doggo, SAR, and Sunbodi are exactly three wolves, I'm not buying it.

I do think Coop is village based on vote position and general tone but I just really don't agree with the Doggo vote.

Let me pull out my crystal ball...

I don't know. I'm thinking SAR and doggo, but I'm sure as hell not ruling out all three.

So if you go back and look at when Doggo placed her vote, the tally was SAR and Suni tied at 3 apiece, with Dubz and Doggo close behind with 2 each. The flurry of votes on Doggo happened after she voted, not before. Doggo's vote pushed SAR ahead in the tally. Do you think she'd try a bus like that on Day 1, when she could have voted Dubz or Suni?

Ok good point. I'll put away my shiny tinfoil for now.

Unlynch doggo

 

[Coopah]

@Coopah

Thanks, this doesn't help at all but I do remember that now! Sigh, you people need to just blindly trust my crackpot theories more.

 

[Coopah]

Eh #****it

Lynch alissa

 

[genny]

I'm inclined to lynch alissa today. But I'm not going to do it on my very brief lunch break.

 

[Coopah]

FYI genny, I was half convinced that the night kills were chosen to frame me and you were behind it

 

[Coopah]

Also wolves, when the game ends I would REALLY like to know the rationale behind the night kill choices...

 

[genny]

FYI genny, I was half convinced that the night kills were chosen to frame me and you were behind it

I thought you were doing them to taunt me for being so bad at wolf hunting lol

 

[Coopah]

Maj is at three today FYI for the other people

@Kota1000 who do you think? Barks or Alissa?

 

[Kota1000]

Maj is at three today FYI for the other people

@Kota1000 who do you think? Barks or Alissa?

I don’t really know... I’m leaning more towards Alissa, as I can’t see why Barks would fight for the doggo lynch so hard, unless it was for major wolf credits and maybe the desired to let Doggo go down versus barks...

What about you?

 

[Coopah]

I don’t really know... I’m leaning more towards Alissa, as I can’t see why Barks would fight for the doggo lynch so hard, unless it was for major wolf credits and maybe the desired to let Doggo go down versus barks...

What about you?

Well I'm kinda already voting Alissa...

 

[Kota1000]

Well I'm kinda already voting Alissa...

My phone hadn’t loaded to that yet, I see that now haha

 

[alissa14]

I’m so tired lol I don’t even care any more. It rained today and I forgot a rain coat so I was wet and freezing. Also my back is killing me and I’m not even done yet.
Lynch barks

 

[Coopah]

I’m so tired lol I don’t even care any more. It rained today and I forgot a rain coat so I was wet and freezing. Also my back is killing me and I’m not even done yet.
Lynch barks

That sucks

you wanna wolf brag?

 

[alissa14]

That sucks

you wanna wolf brag?

Look Imma be sporty!!!!

hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

How does one wolf brag?

 

[Coopah]

Look Imma be sporty!!!!

hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

How does one wolf brag?

Bascially laugh at all of us stupid villagers for fumbling around in the dark. The ultimate ones are video with props. The lesser ones are just gifs of wolves howling

 

[genny]

Look Imma be sporty!!!!

hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

How does one wolf brag?

This sounds like an admission of guilt

 

[Kota1000]

So anyone have any new arguments for why Alissa over barks or vise versa? I am still trying to decide, no I didn’t have time to iso either of them.

 

[Barkley13]

So anyone have any new arguments for why Alissa over barks or vise versa? I am still trying to decide, no I didn’t have time to iso either of them.

I mean Alissa just asked how to wolf brag 😛

 

[Kota1000]

I mean Alissa just asked how to wolf brag 😛

That is true...

 

[Coopah]

So genny, not that it matters because this is a mechanically locked win, but I'll protect you tonight and you investigate barks? Just for shiggles I guess

 

[genny]

So genny, not that it matters because this is a mechanically locked win, but I'll protect you tonight and you investigate barks? Just for shiggles I guess

Yeah, that sounds like a plan. If it’s not Alissa, it has to be Barks.

 

[genny]

lynch alissa

going to go make some dinner.

 

[Animal Midwife]

Final Day 6 Lynch Tally
alissa (3) - Barks, Coop, genny
Barks (1) - alissa

4/5
Missing: Kota

 

[Animal Midwife]

Dead is @alissa14 Coffee Milkshake, mafia goon

TOWN WINS​

Roster
3. Coop - JOAT
12. Kota - vanilla
13. Barks - vanilla
15. genny - JOAT

 

[Lawpy]

Congrats village!!!!

 

[Kota1000]

Yay! Good job!

 

[Lawpy]

Dead is @alissa14 Coffee Milkshake, mafia goon

TOWN WINS​

Roster
3. Coop - JOAT
12. Kota - vanilla
13. Barks - vanilla
15. genny - JOAT

RIP Lawpy, Ski and FTFlushy dartboards

 

[Kota1000]

I apologize for my crappy playing style this game, it was really bad.