Milkshake - Game Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Day 1 Lynch Tally
SAR (3)
- mpm, Coop, Doggo
dubz (2) - Sporty, Kota
Suni (3) - genny, BC, alissa
Doggo (3) - Barks, Paws, dubz
Stagg () -
3m () -
Paws () -
Sporty (1) - 3m
BC () -
Kota (1) - SAR

13/15
Missing: Stagg, Suni
lynch close in ~15 minutes
 
You can say that as many times as you want but I stand by my analysis of what I think would be consistent with your gameplay 😛
Paws shouting that things she's doing are NAI is also fairly well within her village range, so she's only giving herself more points here :laugh:
 
Day 1 Lynch Tally
SAR (3)
- mpm, Coop, Doggo
dubz (2) - Sporty, Kota
Suni (3) - genny, BC, alissa
Doggo (3) - Barks, Paws, dubz
Stagg () -
3m () -
Paws () -
Sporty (1) - 3m
BC () -
Kota (1) - SAR

13/15
Missing: Stagg, Suni
lynch close in ~15 minutes
This is gonna be fun for VCA later :heckyeah: nice job of triple-tying it up, dubz!!
 
Day 1 Lynch Tally
SAR (3) - mpm, Coop, Doggo
dubz (2) - Sporty, Kota
Suni (3) - genny, BC, alissa
Doggo (4) - Barks, Paws, dubz, SAR
Stagg () -
3m () -
Paws () -
Sporty (1) - 3m
BC () -
Kota () -

13/15
Missing: Stagg, Suni
lynch close in ~10 minutes
 
I don’t think it’s a good idea to lynch me, but y’all do whatever you want to I guess
 
I don’t think it’s a good idea to lynch me, but y’all do whatever you want to I guess
I mean you could, like, switch to Sunbodi and see how RNG pans out since the thread's gone eerily quiet
 
Glad I'm not the only one :laugh:

Oh crap did I know about this before I signed up? Reading comprehension is important

More thoughts coming, I'm almost done my new old house homeowner tasks for the day. Then I can actually read the thread closely instead of skimming.

But I do feel good about you for voting me like I figured you would 😛

I will say the majority of SAR’s posts have been jokey. Also, they said more thoughts coming soon, but they only posted a read on me and asked a few very minimal questions that had a brief mention of BC and genny. A little sketch so,

unlynch Dubz
Lynch SAR
 
Day 1 Lynch Tally
SAR (4)
- mpm, Coop, Doggo, Kota
dubz (1) - Sporty
Suni (3) - genny, BC, alissa
Doggo (4) - Barks, Paws, dubz, SAR
Stagg () -
3m () -
Paws () -
Sporty (1) - 3m
BC () -
Kota () -

13/15
Missing: Stagg, Suni
lynch close in ~5 minutes
 
Honestly I’d be fine with either a SAR or doggo lynch and I’ll leave it up to RNG gods. Both have pinged me as of recent. I’ll give specific posts later. Unlynch sunni lynch sar
 
I will say the majority of SAR’s posts have been jokey. Also, they said more thoughts coming soon, but they only posted a read on me and asked a few very minimal questions that had a brief mention of BC and genny. A little sketch so,

unlynch Dubz
Lynch SAR

Lol you have much grander ideas of what "thoughts" means

That was it, yo.
 
Honestly Doggo is probably not wolf with such a quiet thread and no one really reacting to that unless her partners are afk/already on the other wagons
 
Day 1 Lynch Tally
SAR (5)
- mpm, Coop, Doggo, Kota, alissa
dubz (1) - Sporty
Suni (2) - genny, BC
Doggo (4) - Barks, Paws, dubz, SAR
Stagg () -
3m () -
Paws () -
Sporty (1) - 3m
BC () -
Kota () -

13/15
Missing: Stagg, Suni
lynch close in ~3 minutes
 
Because in what world does wolf!Paws give herself a posting restriction?
I'd like to add to this/also ask another question, since its not listed in the description, does it mean that wolves have no special powers? I think whatever this is feels self-inflicted and more like the accents in the irish game lol
 
Hmmm but do I like the SAR wagon either
 
Lol you have much grander ideas of what "thoughts" means

That was it, yo.

To me when someone says they are going to post thoughts and in multiple posts, it seems to indicate reads on people, but that’s just my opinion
 
I'd like to add to this/also ask another question, since its not listed in the description, does it mean that wolves have no special powers? I think whatever this is feels self-inflicted and more like the accents in the irish game lol

I don’t think they were inferring that Paws actually has a post restriction, just that they are posting as so
 
@WildZoo tell me more about why you switched to doggo
Didn't like the naked/semi-naked SAR votes, how doggo popped up suddenly right after being mentioned with a wagon hop, and her list didn't make me feel any better
 
Final Day 1 Lynch Tally
SAR (5)
- mpm, Coop, Doggo, Kota, alissa
dubz (1) - Sporty
Suni (2) - genny, BC
Doggo (4) - Barks, Paws, dubz, SAR
Stagg () -
3m () -
Paws () -
Sporty (1) - 3m
BC () -
Kota () -

13/15
Missing: Stagg, Suni
 
Dead is @SARdoghandler Coconut Milkshake, mafia goon

frullato.jpg

Roster
1. @mmmdreamerz
2. @Doggo Labs
3. @Coopah
4. @mypetmoose
5. @Sunbodi
6. @StayingPositive2017
7. @WildZoo
8. @BigCats
10. @alissa14
11. @Stagg737
12. @Kota1000
13. @Barkley13
14. @SportPonies
15. @genny
 
Last edited:
Well that’s a twist...

So looking back at D1, since SAR flipped wolf, two things that really bothered me were BC and sort of coopah’s lynch patterns.

BC lynched SAR early on for “you know I gotta do it” as a reason. And switched to Sunbodi because of their inactivity and early vanillager claim. BC later said that she didn’t like the SAR wagon, and said because SAR feels a comfortable level of sketch to them she felt better about a Sunbodi lynch.

Also, I don’t like how Coopah jumped on the SAR vote just because they like ties, but it’s not too suspicious.

I’ll be analyzing other stuff besides the SAR lynching too, I just wanted to get this out here early on, cause I think it stood out a lot.

Also, I typed this up earlier this morning when I got up so I don’t have quotes, but if you want me to show examples/find the quotes I am referencing let me know.
 
I cannot BELIEVE that I could’ve legitimately lynched SAR but didn’t because I thought she was okay YET AGAIN omg I’m so mad
 
Anyway in a scenario where wolves wouldn’t bus D1 because that’s stupid, mpm is cleared for starting that wagon with like an hour til close (as opposed to if she’d voted there early on and then the wagon built up steam later and she wouldn’t have been able to hop off), Coop could’ve made a tie two other ways so she’s fine, I don’t think Doggo is a wolf based on counterwagon status and the weird silence after her post (like wolves were debating whether to tip that wagon over or not), I look sketch af lmao I can’t even deny it because I’d absolutely be lynching me today with the way I was defending SAR (YET AGAIN!!!!!!! :rage:), Barks and Paws both give me pause with their interactions with SAR at like 15 minutes to close and I’ll probably start there today, Kota’s fine for tying up the wagons again, alissa posted the same time as the tally was posted so I think she’s fine regardless of whether she was trying to tie it up or break the tie towards SAR, honestly dubz’s switch to Doggo weirded me out and I’m surprised she was NKed since she wouldn’t have been a terrible mislynch idea after that (which probably means that I’m today’s designated mislynch lol), Sporty and 3m were on weird single votes so that’s interesting but also didn’t seem to be around at lynch close.
 
The way that happened makes me think that the other wolves were either already on the counterwagon or afk. I just feel like they would’ve tried a bit harder to push SAR out of the lead since there’s only 3 of them and it is D1, although given that Doggo was the only viable counterwagon in the 10 minutes before close, they probably would’ve outed themselves by switching to Doggo if they weren’t there already.
 
Sorry @PippyPony didn’t know you would want to play. I would have let you have the spot if I knew that! (Also I actually thought you signed up and was real confused when I didn’t see you on the roster)
 
Anyway in a scenario where wolves wouldn’t bus D1 because that’s stupid, mpm is cleared for starting that wagon with like an hour til close (as opposed to if she’d voted there early on and then the wagon built up steam later and she wouldn’t have been able to hop off), Coop could’ve made a tie two other ways so she’s fine, I don’t think Doggo is a wolf based on counterwagon status and the weird silence after her post (like wolves were debating whether to tip that wagon over or not), I look sketch af lmao I can’t even deny it because I’d absolutely be lynching me today with the way I was defending SAR (YET AGAIN!!!!!!! :rage:), Barks and Paws both give me pause with their interactions with SAR at like 15 minutes to close and I’ll probably start there today, Kota’s fine for tying up the wagons again, alissa posted the same time as the tally was posted so I think she’s fine regardless of whether she was trying to tie it up or break the tie towards SAR, honestly dubz’s switch to Doggo weirded me out and I’m surprised she was NKed since she wouldn’t have been a terrible mislynch idea after that (which probably means that I’m today’s designated mislynch lol), Sporty and 3m were on weird single votes so that’s interesting but also didn’t seem to be around at lynch close.

Thanks for this! Really helpful for info, and I didn’t want to be the only one to post long reads. here’s my reads on people:

I think Paws has been fairly confrontational this game, but it seems in line with last game as well when they flipped village, so I’m leaning more village on them, although I’d like to see more wolf hunting effort. Also, I don’t like that they switched MO without mentioning it in the actual thread and not the sign ups, but that’s just my opinion because once I sign up I usually don’t go back and read the sign ups except to see the final roster.

Sporty, Doggo and Barks I need to hear more from, so they are in my neutral pile.

Although, Barks did ask “why is SAR sketchy?.” When they SAR lynch was happening, although maybe they hadn’t caught up.

And doggo did give some opinions, but they were very vague and not super helpful, so sketch points for that.

Moose, I am leaning more village on as they seem to be trying to wolf hunt through their questions, answers to questions directed at them have details, and they provide good reasoning for their lynches so far. One thing that bothers me is that they asked Sporty what they though of barks even though barks posted very minimally, and then MPM said that they asked the question on a random player.

Alissa is in my neutral- leaning wolf pile, and I’d like to hear more from them. I feel like the content they provided has been very shallow with quick explanations that don’t really contribute much to wolf hunting, or they have been echoing others. They also don’t seem as active as usually, but it’s only D1. However, nothing they have done has stood out as super sketchy to me.

So 3m has done a lot of lynching based on people’s actions that don’t seem to significant in my opinion, and didn’t change their lynch for something more concrete - lynching Paws for her posting style this game, and lynching Sporty for a comment on not being able to read people based on feels D1. They also just sort of disappeared before lynch fest. I didn’t like the 3m X Dubz exchange early on regarding Paw’s posting style, but it seems in character for 3m. Right now I am placing her in my slight village lean pile.

Genny wasn’t super active later on, but they did post a lot to start. I feel like they haven’t contributed much in terms of wolf hunting. They also jumped on Sunny really quick, and lynched her without providing a reason. Then later made a comment about the being a wolf. They also made the comment that “I don’t think I deserve special treatment in this game,” which I found a little odd. Lastly, they have been throwing a lot of jokes and sarcasm around. So for now they are going in my suspect pile after the reread of D1.
 
I cannot BELIEVE that I could’ve legitimately lynched SAR but didn’t because I thought she was okay YET AGAIN omg I’m so mad
are you sure you got the appropriate level of outrage to pass as a villager in this post? Didn't overdo it with the caps lock?
 
What the heck is this read?
Alissa is the vote that got SAR lynched. You think she bussed SAR? Or that Doggo was also a wolf, and she just picked one of her two packmates to bus?

I did those reads not based off the SAR lynch. And Doggo I want to hear more from, as well as from Alissa. I know Alissa tipped the SAR lynch, which is why I’m not claiming wolf, I just said leaning wolf.
 
The way that happened makes me think that the other wolves were either already on the counterwagon or afk. I just feel like they would’ve tried a bit harder to push SAR out of the lead since there’s only 3 of them and it is D1, although given that Doggo was the only viable counterwagon in the 10 minutes before close, they probably would’ve outed themselves by switching to Doggo if they weren’t there already.
What's your opinion on Paws?
 
My initial thoughts that I noted last night when reading the thread:

- Doggo:
broke tie toward SAR (between SAR and sunni in the last 30 mins), probably village; I don't think SAR would shade his fellow wolf D1 but I don't know SAR's style too well
Feeling village on paws, Coop, Genny. Susp on Kota and you for the most part. Everyone else files into a neutral category

Any particular reason it's felt like you're lying low today and trying to blend into the background?
I was around for a hot couple of minutes there, then had stuff irl come up, and have been busy since

I see we see differently on paws, what makes you put her village?
Not trying to lie low, been pretty busy with field work on the farm
; SAR moved and voted doggo for self-prez

-Coop - feels fine for now, she voted for SAR; seems casual tonally which doesn't mean much

- alissa - broke tie between SAR and Doggo (unless Doggo is also a wolf - which I doubt - this makes me lean village)

- Kota - SAR voted to lynch her; could be to distance from teammates but I'm leaning toward probably not
 
are you sure you got the appropriate level of outrage to pass as a villager in this post? Didn't overdo it with the caps lock?
Oh of course I forgot to say “good job village!! Awesome lynch!!”, how silly of me
 
I did those reads not based off the SAR lynch. And Doggo I want to hear more from, as well as from Alissa. I know Alissa tipped the SAR lynch, which is why I’m not claiming wolf, I just said leaning wolf.
There's a difference between claiming wolf and leaning wolf? And you think a player who tipped a lynch toward a wolf belongs in one of those categories?
 
Top