frozone112
New Member
- Joined
- Dec 23, 2020
- Messages
- 10
- Reaction score
- 1
Hi!
I know the three accrediting bodies mentioned above are all recognized, but my question pertains to counseling, specifically. I am (planning) on going to graduate school this fall to get a MA in CMHC from a CACREP accredited program, and potentially getting a doctorate in either counseling psych or counselor education and supervision (so either teach or work at more of an organizational level) as my ultimate career goals. This post is basically because I've had anxiety throughout my MAs application process for continuously hearing pretty forceful information on "the best choice."
Multiple independent sources have told me to go the SW route, get a LCSW degee, etc. I've heard claims the degree can get better reimbursement thru insurance, it's "more appealing" to potential employers, and there's even a post on here about someone saying they're the best of the three in terms of network support from the org. I picked CACREP because my heart really is in counseling, and I know I could do it with SW too, but I rather invest in a program that is 100% dedicated to what I care about, as opposed to picking a similar but separate degree and trying to find one that most closely would match my goals.
It then gets a little more complicated because if I do get a doctorate, there's the choice between CACREP and APA having entirely separate accreditations, and from my understanding APA has had the history of being "the accreditor" for doc programs.
So, my request is this: to those of you who have personal experience/knowledge (or have heard directly from someone who has) in the reputability of each of these three orgs, could you share your thoughts? Whether it be how you've noticed applicants with a specific accreditation be treated, or any correlations in job placement/financial issues, anything you think that someone should know who's planning on committing to one of 'em, I'd like to know 😀
And if your advice is "depends on the program, if you pick a _________-accredited program that has high placement rates you'll be fine," I'd be happy with that! The CMHC programs I've applied to are Vanderbilt, Northwestern, Wake Forest, and Adler, and based on my research they'd all be a solid starting point for entering the field of counseling.
Also as a last clarification, I know there's a distinction between, say, CACREP and the NBCC, but in my mind they're part of the "same path" (as compared to SW or APA) because one is the accrediting body for degrees, and the other is the national org that all it's members can join. So really I'm interested on any of your opinions on the three paths, whether it be the accrediting body for a degree type or the joinable org that represents them.
I've found similar threads on here, but not one that was specifically about differences between the three, and I'd also like to hear more varied and direct input. Thanks in advance 🙂!
*final final note, I'm sure someone will ask, so my bachelors is in bio and I have a ton of clinical experience but no academic work in psych, so I can get into a MA program now but not a PhD. I really don't want to work for another year to buy time to takes classes to get the academic background to apply straight to PhDs, and if I did choose a PhD in counseling education that would require a MA so no matter what I'm doing a MA first!
I know the three accrediting bodies mentioned above are all recognized, but my question pertains to counseling, specifically. I am (planning) on going to graduate school this fall to get a MA in CMHC from a CACREP accredited program, and potentially getting a doctorate in either counseling psych or counselor education and supervision (so either teach or work at more of an organizational level) as my ultimate career goals. This post is basically because I've had anxiety throughout my MAs application process for continuously hearing pretty forceful information on "the best choice."
Multiple independent sources have told me to go the SW route, get a LCSW degee, etc. I've heard claims the degree can get better reimbursement thru insurance, it's "more appealing" to potential employers, and there's even a post on here about someone saying they're the best of the three in terms of network support from the org. I picked CACREP because my heart really is in counseling, and I know I could do it with SW too, but I rather invest in a program that is 100% dedicated to what I care about, as opposed to picking a similar but separate degree and trying to find one that most closely would match my goals.
It then gets a little more complicated because if I do get a doctorate, there's the choice between CACREP and APA having entirely separate accreditations, and from my understanding APA has had the history of being "the accreditor" for doc programs.
So, my request is this: to those of you who have personal experience/knowledge (or have heard directly from someone who has) in the reputability of each of these three orgs, could you share your thoughts? Whether it be how you've noticed applicants with a specific accreditation be treated, or any correlations in job placement/financial issues, anything you think that someone should know who's planning on committing to one of 'em, I'd like to know 😀
And if your advice is "depends on the program, if you pick a _________-accredited program that has high placement rates you'll be fine," I'd be happy with that! The CMHC programs I've applied to are Vanderbilt, Northwestern, Wake Forest, and Adler, and based on my research they'd all be a solid starting point for entering the field of counseling.
Also as a last clarification, I know there's a distinction between, say, CACREP and the NBCC, but in my mind they're part of the "same path" (as compared to SW or APA) because one is the accrediting body for degrees, and the other is the national org that all it's members can join. So really I'm interested on any of your opinions on the three paths, whether it be the accrediting body for a degree type or the joinable org that represents them.
I've found similar threads on here, but not one that was specifically about differences between the three, and I'd also like to hear more varied and direct input. Thanks in advance 🙂!
*final final note, I'm sure someone will ask, so my bachelors is in bio and I have a ton of clinical experience but no academic work in psych, so I can get into a MA program now but not a PhD. I really don't want to work for another year to buy time to takes classes to get the academic background to apply straight to PhDs, and if I did choose a PhD in counseling education that would require a MA so no matter what I'm doing a MA first!