I dropped UHC in the past, was blunt, you don't pay enough, and you reject too many codes that other companies pay for. Pay me X or more to get in line. They balked. I submitted my termination. But then they got shady saying you didn't send it to Optum, you sent to UHC, and other things. I had my email trails and or fax trails saved, and said no you are all full of scat. On my way they contacted me to say they would pay the equivalent to medicare rates in that area. Not interested. They were also the biggest source of headaches for my assistant, and they would also months later disproportionately request refunds for 'non services' or other Scat things. It was a volume drop as they were about ~18% of the local market, but such a relief to not deal with them. They of course kept me on their directory etc for months. ~10% [I have the exact number on my private practice thread] converted to be cash only and continue on.
Cigna in the past I basically said pay me more I drop. They nudged up to medicare rates, from below medicare.
I recently moved from an area that was an anomaly for higher payments to psych - but even at that - they were still way lower than the local Big Box shops. Image a colorful religious symbol company paying more than double medicare, but almost triple to the local Big Box shops. My new local area, I was flawed in my pre-move reconnaissance of rates - that same colorful religious symbol company, is barely paying better than medicare. It's a substantial punch to the gut for what this means for my practice. I now have to play the volume game. I tried to escalate a petition of 'WTF, pay me more.' They didn't care. Positively, this new area I'm in has a decent flow of patients coming in compared to previous area that was saturated.
For people who are starting out with practices: I was more receptive to insurance scat, when the rates were higher in past location, but now the new location is lower, the zeal to continue with their BS is less. If you go to an area like most of the country is, you'll need to be
@randomdoc1 and read over as many of those posts as possible for guidance. Otherwise, if you have the desire/drive/skills for therapy, just open up a lean tiny office, cash only, therapy focused practice and enjoy the small panel.
I intend to stick with my original plan. Build up the panel, and once closer to full, I let the biggest headache or lowest paying insurance know, they need to increase their rates or drop. I have no intention to play the game others above have, with "justifying" or trying to "show" why higher rates are justified. Odds are the balk, I walk. Patients that move on, open up more slots for the other higher paying insurance and I accrue a few more cash pay patients. Repeat once closer to full.