New Medscape/WebMD article: What is PM&R?

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Taus

.
Staff member
Administrator
Volunteer Staff
15+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 1, 2005
Messages
4,899
Reaction score
1,883
http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/709726?src=mp&spon=25&uac=116351EX

What Is PM&R?

Sara Cohen, MD


Published: 10/05/2009
Medical Student Rating: 4.5 stars ( 3 Votes )

It was third year of medical school. I was at the midway point, when the excitement of being in the hospital had started to wear off and the fatigue was starting to set in. I had just finished internal medicine, a field I had once contemplated as a career but was no longer feeling as sure about.

While at a restaurant with some of my fellow students, I started venting to an older and wiser fourth-year med student named Pete. I whined that the medicine wards made me feel like I was just rushing patients in and out, to the point where I had to struggle just to remember the names on my small census. I didn't enjoy taking care of seriously ill patients, who were always teetering on the edge of death. I hated having to tell family members that their loved one had died. I preferred long-term stable patients whom I could watch improve over time, but there were few of those on the medicine ward. I also felt overworked and too exhausted to be as good a doctor as I wanted to be.

I wanted a residency where I could have regular hours and not just feel as if I were in a persistent groggy haze in which I could barely function.

"You know what would be perfect for you?" the very wise Pete asked after listening to all my gripes. "You could become a physiatrist."

"A what?"

"A physiatrist," Pete said. "That's a specialist in PM&R."

"What does PM&R stand for?" I asked.

"Plenty of Money and Relaxation," another fourth-year quipped.

Actually, it stands for physical medicine and rehabilitation, a lesser-known specialty that's been accredited since the 1940s. Most medical schools don't require a rotation in PM&R, so our residency programs are always getting refugees from other specialties who learned about PM&R a little too late.

It can be complicated to explain to a lay person what we do because the field is so diverse. And that's one of the things I love about it. Basically, PM&R involves the diagnosis and restoration of functional ability and quality of life in patients with disorders of the nervous and musculoskeletal systems.

Residency training in PM&R includes 1 year of internship, which can be a preliminary or transitional year, followed by 3 years of specialty training in PM&R. Some residencies combine the 4 years into 1 program. Generally, the first year focuses on the inpatient rehabilitation aspects of the field, whereas senior residents practice more outpatient physical medicine with a lighter call schedule.

The rehabilitation part (the "R" in PM&R) involves the long-term care of patients with disorders of the central nervous system, such as brain injury, spinal cord injury, and stroke. We also care for patients with amputations and orthopedic injuries. Our job as the physician on the inpatient rehab unit is to oversee the care of these patients and work with a team of therapists and other staff to maximize the patient's function. Although the interventions we use will not "cure" patients, we help them to make the most of what they've got.

Rehab patients remain on the unit for weeks or even months. As a result, during my residency I was able to build relationships with them and their families, as well as see the long-term outcomes of treatment. I have a shelf in my apartment filled with gifts from patients who were very grateful for the treatment they received on our unit.

The job opportunities in rehab are plentiful these days, with a whole new generation of injured veterans in need of our services and an aging population at high risk for stroke and other problems that may require inpatient rehab.

For the physiatrist who prefers outpatient work, there's the physical medicine end of PM&R. Residents are trained in general musculoskeletal and sports clinics, where we diagnose and treat nonsurgical back pain, knee pain, shoulder pain, or pain in any other joint. For med students who have an interest in pain medicine but don't enjoy anesthesia, PM&R residency provides extensive training in pain management, including titration of pain medications and performing fluoroscopic spine or joint injections. (We call PM&R a painless path to pain.) Residents also receive training in electrodiagnosis, where we learn to diagnose nerve and muscle disorders ranging from carpal tunnel syndrome to Lou Gehrig's disease and myopathy.

I know many med students are very concerned with lifestyle and salary. As that fourth-year student joked, PM&R stands for Plenty of Money and Relaxation. According to the Medical Group Management Association's Physician Compensation and Production Survey in 2007, the median salary for physiatrists after 1-2 years in practice is $213,701. For those who have done a 1-year fellowship, the salary is quite a bit more.

In terms of lifestyle, PM&R is exactly what I was looking for. The hours are very predictable, even for a resident. I never felt too tired to function, and I think I was a better doctor because of it. I took call from home, even during my first year of residency training. After internship, I can say how amazing it is to be able to sleep in my own bed every night. And more important, there were only about 2 nights in my daughter's life when her mother wasn't there to put her to bed.

All in all, I can't imagine a better fit for me than PM&R. I've made it one of my goals to help spread the word of this specialty so that no medical students miss out on what might be the perfect field for them

Members don't see this ad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Not a bad synopsis.
I am surprised that the quoted salary is >200,000. I see Academics is much, much less. I assume that the higher salaries are reflective of a not so "cushy" work week (avg more around 60 hours + call) or is taking in the outliers (>300, 000 for the interventional pain).
-Also I was wondering what the 1 year fellowships are that result in "significantly More" money, other than interventional spine/pain.

Not sports, not TBI, not SCI. Possibly Electrodiagnostics?
 
Members don't see this ad :)
Not a bad synopsis.
I am surprised that the quoted salary is >200,000. I see Academics is much, much less. I assume that the higher salaries are reflective of a not so "cushy" work week (avg more around 60 hours + call) or is taking in the outliers (>300, 000 for the interventional pain).
-Also I was wondering what the 1 year fellowships are that result in "significantly More" money, other than interventional spine/pain.

Not sports, not TBI, not SCI. Possibly Electrodiagnostics?

Not EMG.

But there may be somewhat of a selection bias working here. A lot of the PM&R neurophysiology/EMG fellows I know (myself included) were primarily interested and ended up going into academics. Now, this may not necessarily apply to neuromuscular medicine fellows, but I imagine the mentality is similar.
 
I should also mention…

Coming from PM&R, you don’t (and shouldn’t) need an EMG fellowship to practice “in the real world”. I don’t even think an EMG fellowship makes you that much more attractive to private practices (unless you join a neuro group, I suppose). I remember when I was interviewing for positions coming out of fellowship. I interviewed for both private and academic jobs, covering my bases and trying to gauge what was out there. The privates all asked me about my EMG fellowship, and more than one commented that I’d probably be bored in their practice.
 
PM&R neurophysiology/EMG fellows...this may not necessarily apply to neuromuscular medicine fellows...QUOTE]

Q: what is the difference between a neurophysiology/EMG vs neuromuscular medicine fellowship? I want to say most of these are offered through neurology dept's with the one exception that comes to mind for me is UCDavis' program which is called a "neuromuscular and electrodiagnostic" medicine fellowship.

An attending (physiatrist) that I greatly admire once told me that he wanted to do an EMG fellowship in NYC, but his wife did not want to live at the hospital where the program was based. I'm guessing that would have been at least 15-20 years ago.

are emg fellowships something that used to be more popular with physiatrists and less so now?
 
Q: what is the difference between a neurophysiology/EMG vs neuromuscular medicine fellowship? I want to say most of these are offered through neurology dept's with the one exception that comes to mind for me is UCDavis' program which is called a "neuromuscular and electrodiagnostic" medicine fellowship.

An attending (physiatrist) that I greatly admire once told me that he wanted to do an EMG fellowship in NYC, but his wife did not want to live at the hospital where the program was based. I'm guessing that would have been at least 15-20 years ago.

are emg fellowships something that used to be more popular with physiatrists and less so now?

Both types of fellowships are indeed primarily run through neuro departments, so when applying you would be competing against neurologists. Both have their share of accredited and non-accredited programs. There is undoubtedly curriculum overlap between the two types of fellowships, as well as a wide variety in quality and exposure amongst programs. You are correct in that UC Davis is currently the only PM&R based NM medicine fellowship.

Neurophys/EMG fellowships concentrate on NCS/EMG training. Depending on the fellowship, you can also gain experience in evoked potentials (motor, somatosensory, visual, BAERs), single fiber EMG, intraop monitoring, pediatric EMG, inpatient/ICU EMGs, etc. You may learn second hand about associated diagnostic testing and management of various neuromuscular disorders, you may even actively manage some patients, depending on the individual program. But the focus is on EDX testing. Some neurophys fellowships may be ACGME accredited, but as a PM&R graduate, you would not be eligible to sit for clinical neurophysiology boards. Only neurologists can do this.

A neuromuscular medicine fellowship further schools you in the overall diagnosis and management of patients with NM disorders. In addition to EMGs, you'll learn things like performing and interpreting muscle/nerve biopsies, esoteric lab and genetic testing, acute and critical care management of NM disorders like Guillain-Barre, myasthenic crisis, motor neuron disease, etc. You’ll reinforce the rehab management of NM diseases. You may also get trained in NM imaging/ultrasound. If the program’s accredited, completion would allow you to sit for the NM medicine subspecialty board ($1785). Which is not to be confused with the “EMG boards” through the ABEM/AANEM. You could sit for those too ($950).

The existence of accredited NM fellowships and recognized subspecialty boards is fairly new. I did my EMG fellowship back in the day before NM medicine was an official recognized subspecialty. (Being old sucks). That said, I suspect that the trend will be physiatry residents pursuing NM fellowships instead of EMG fellowships. Compared to pain/spine/sports/MSK, I guess EMG/NM fellowships were and still are less popular. But personally I never actually cared how popular certain fellowships or subspecialties were. I knew what I was interested in, so I went for it.
 
The average salary I've heard of for new grads for inpatient, outpatient, or inpatient/outpatient work is $140K.

Of course, it's not the hardest job in the world.

It's no wonder so many people want to do pain medicine.
 
I know I'm a bit late in this discussion, however I have a couple questions for everyone (Sorry if it's a dumb question).

Is it possible to do PM&R with a SM specialty and then follow that with a sport/spine fellowship that you guys were talking about earlier? Would it be useful going down that path or PM&R + sport/spine fellowship OR PM&R w/Spinal Cord Injury Medicine specialty?

I'm in the process of researching my career path but it's between:
EM - Sport
FM -SM+ sport/spine fellowship
PM&R

Thank you!
 
Just for clarification, what exactly do you want to get out of a spine fellowship? You can certainly do a sports medicine fellowship through family, PM&R, and EM. Some of these ACGME accredited fellowships do offer some opportunities for interventional spine care but I would not go so far as to say that it's the norm.

It seems as though you are interested in spine care and/or spinal cord injury medicine. There are some similarities but there are distinct differences in the fellowship training.

With spinal cord injury medicine, you are learning primarily both acute and chronic management of traumatic and non-traumatic (i.e. congenital, degenerative spine, neoplasms, autoimmune) spinal cord disorders. Procedurally, you will likely have opportunities in spasticity management (i.e. baclofen pump management, Botox injections) and fertility issues in patients with spinal cord injuries.

If you are looking for basic interventional spine experience (i.e. fluoroscopic injections), the non-accredited sports/spine fellowships and some accredited sports medicine fellowships should fit the bill. If you want high level interventional training, an ACGME accredited pain fellowship is typically the way to go. Pain fellowships are offered typically through anesthesiology, PM&R, interventional radiology, and psychiatry.
 
Shortest path to Sports = FP + sports fellowship = 4 years.

Best musculoskeletal training among your choices = PM&R (plus far less "call" than FP during residency)

Best way to torture yourself = ER
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
I'm in the process of researching my career path but it's between:
EM - Sport
FM -SM+ sport/spine fellowship
PM&R

Just so you know, there are no sports/spine fellowships in FM. Family wont offer the kind of base training you'll need to do any type of spinal interventions, you can only do those through PM&R.
 
Just so you know, there are no sports/spine fellowships in FM. Family wont offer the kind of base training you'll need to do any type of spinal interventions, you can only do those through PM&R.

I have a friend who is applying for sports medicine from family medicine who said that he will be learning how to do interventional spine procedures. After checking into it, there actually are some sports medicine fellowships that do provide interventional spine experience to family residents. Believe me, I was surprised as well.

After thinking about it, it doesn't take a specific residency to learn where to put a needle. However, I believe that PM&R gives you the best background to medically manage these patients compared to any other specialty.
 
Last edited:
After thinking about it, it doesn't take a specific residency to learn where to put a needle. However, I believe that PM&R gives you the best background to medically manage these patients compared to any other specialty.

I agree fozzy, I was thinking more that there's no way that they can learn well when to stick as opposed to only how to do it ie the PM&R vs anesthesia in pain argument.
 
I actually know of a pm&r grad, from a top program, that graduated to go and do a FM based sports fellowship.
 
Top