- Joined
- Jan 10, 2008
- Messages
- 3,581
- Reaction score
- 11
From PBS Frontline and ESPN:
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/concussion-watch/
http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/concussion-watch/
I'm not really sure what the motive of your post is, but I'll bite.
Interesting. I was a defensive end. Maybe that explains my poor memory and pugnacious attidude.
Does anyone have opinions or comments about the relatively new "Sports Neurology" fellowships? I'm curious which places and names are leading the way in this area?
There is an individual that I have heard of proposing no contact football until the age of 18 years?
If you are interested in Sports Neurology, contact Frank Conidi in Florida.
There is an individual that I have heard of proposing no contact football until the age of 18 years?
Typhoon is exactly correct. Great topic btw.
I'd go further than this and recommend no football to anyone. All we know about repetitive head blows is that some seem to tolerate them better than others, but we don't know who or how much. There is probably no safe dose of head blows on a prospective basis.
Football should be banned and in a rational world it would be. Such as the world is, we can still try our best to prevent injury for course entertainment. No-one should stand silent while children put themselves at risk of an incurable but preventable disease, CTE.
I fear that "sports neurology" and "concussion clinics" only serve to give credibility to those who would deny and coverup the facts of the matter. In part you can see that happening now. By focusing on concussions only, we're not focused on the forces drving CTE.
Doctors have been co-opted in the manner before by tobacco, and the parallels between smoking circa 1950 and now are striking, offering their support or at least their assent towards allowing smoking. That's one reason to be a zealot and to draw red lines. A neurologist at the sidelines offers exactly ZERO protection against CTE, only (perhaps) moderate to severe concussions. But he offers credibility to the sport and to the interest$ that keep football going.
I fear that sympathetic doctors will have an opinion that differs from mine adn states that some head blows are permissible (and that's fine, rationale people can disagree), but they will be incentivized towards being entirely cavalier.
I am no athlete, nor will I pretend to be, but lets not be hasty here. I suppose I would ask, why pick on football? How about the NHL? Apparently, being a MLB umpire is a dangerous job? Boxing? Professional Wrestling? UFC? Come to think of it, I think I have seen a few good knocks to the head from womens' vollyball (they can be damn brutal!)
Anyways, back on topic. The problem with banning professional sports, and I hate to present it this way, would be the financial aspects of it all. I am sure that right now, there is some high school student that can make a solid argument that their only hope of a college education is a sports scholarship.
Sports are a past time and a big part of our culture in the US, good luck banning them!
Does anybody remember the Saints last year having a "hit" bounty out on star members of other teams?
How about proper screening? I am sorry, but I think we all know that somewhere, a team physician is likely inappropriately clearing a player due to public or internal pressures. Would you want to be known as the doctor would that is blamed for the team missing playoffs because you would not clear the star QB for play? The public and "armchair QBs" are brutal on the players enough.
I'm not into watching sports. But off the top of my head: soccer, basketball, baseball, biking are very safe. Even hockey and MMA are pretty safe. Football is the problem. And things could tip. I think in a generation or two football will be like NASCAR: viewed by a few and generally thought of as a stupid thing by everyone else. Football might become a white red-neck and black inner city thing exclusively. People who's parents don't care or don't know about brains.
I fear this as well. How'd you like to be the doctor who allows a kid to enter the arena and die of second impact syndrome?