The NRRS has done just that to students before. One of my friends had a degree from NYU (an MA in psych) and they would not take her into the clinical psych program unless she did an MA their. So she agreed and paid the crazy amount of tuition, and then when she applied for the PhD program, they rejected her. She had a lot of clinical and research experience at the time as well. She asked them why and they said she was "rough around the edges and perhaps not suited for clinical work"....Who the heck are they to say that to a student?
I agree that the whole get an MA here before applying is a scam. Furthermore, they only give out one full scholarship a year, and most students have to take out at least a 18500 loan each year.
The NRRS thinks they are like Columbia or NYU, and they do not even have a library. I feel that many people go here if it is their only option, and if they "have to be" in NYC. Also, their PhD in clinical is more like a PsyD because their clinical students do not have a whole lot of publications, and most want to have only private practice.
I earned my MA in general psych at Hunter College (soooo much cheaper) and am now applying to doctoral programs.
So, everyone please be warned about NSSR!
I am currently in the program at New School...and a few words about it. It's a great program, and the faculty is quite impressive as well...Howard and Miriam Steele are known throughout the world for the research as is Dr. Marcel Kinsbourne.
In terms of the girl not getting in, they make it very clear that admission is not guaranteed and many schools also have to consider whether or not they feel someone is ready to be a clinician. If they don't feel someone will make a good clinician then its pretty likely that the interviewer of externship positions will feel the same way.
This is why school's hold interviews, and while some may reject you in a mass email, NSSR offers you constructive criticism with the option to reapply the following year. However, this is why people apply to more than just 1 school, even though they will accept 16/40 applicants you shouldn't put all your eggs in one basket.
And you can't really compare them to Columbia or NYU as NYU does not have a clinical phd and Columbia has not had a stable run with their clinical program.
We actually have 5 libraries, Fogelman being the one dedicated to Social Sciences.
There's no catch to completing the M.A. and transitioning into the Ph.D. except that in order to apply you must have a 3.5 GPA and show that you have established solid relationships with faculty and are interested in doing research....nothing in life comes for free.
In terms of requiring you get your M.A. there...the first 2 years of any PhD program is theoretically the M.A. degree. If you have your M.A. in psychology from one school and apply to others very few schools will take more than 6 credits of previously earned classes at the M.A. level toward their PhD program (hence they are also making you earn your M.A. through them first).
At NSSR when you transition from M.A. to PhD you already have the first 2 years of course work done and are starting hospital rounds and applying for externships within the first semester.
A lot of the research that goes on at NSSR is very large, longitudinal, and international...so many studies are still in the works which explains why students aren't punching out publications. Beyond that I am really not sure where you got your information regarding most students desire to be clinicians and not being involved in research. Unless you happen to know every student enrolled in the program I think that is a pretty bold assumption on your part.
However, they do you connect you with many opportunities outside of the university and at this point I already have done 2 publications with large hospitals in the area via New School connections.
Everyone will have an opinion about a program, but its one of those things where if you fit there, you fit, and in the long run thats what matters