NW vs. Baylor

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

quidnunc

Senior Member
10+ Year Member
5+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Oct 27, 2005
Messages
144
Reaction score
0
What are your thoughts between these two programs? Having trouble ranking them. Definitely Fellowship bound (not sure Pulm/CC or Cards).
I liked both cities.

Thanks.
 
Stick with Northwestern...its a growing program, excellent fellowship placement, great city, and the program director isn't changing. Baylor used to have a name...though I think thats all its riding on right now.
 
Northwestern probably isnt even the best medicine program in Chicago according to many faculty (UChicago is well regarded).

NW is known as a cush predominantly private program where you dont do as much as most other places. Ask residency or fellowship directors what they think the most cush IM residency is-- likely they will say NW, which does not bode well if you want to do fellowship.
 
sadly enough my PD says that coming from NW is a negative, due to its cush reputation. He told me to strike it off my list!
 
Thanks for the feedback guys. I created this thread to see how to rank my mid-tiers (given that I'm pretty set on my top three choices), and I have to agree based on what I've seen and heard, NW definitely seems more cush than most programs, I just don't know how bad (in terms of fellowship placement or general clinical training) this is.

I was looking at NW fellowship placement yesterday, but the trouble with their list is that they don't exactly mention the # of people they've placed in the last 5 years, only the different # of institutions that they've matched, so it's hard to gauge how many they've placed overall in cards or gi, for example.

Compared to Baylor's matchlist, it seemed pretty similar (5 years span of course, but Baylor does mention the total # they've placed and where). I think the clinical training at Baylor is better than NW and being affiliated with St. Lukes (where THI) is really a boon, in addition to being in the setting of the TMC. Of course the downside is the current debacle with the Methodist, the PD leaving, and (at least for me), only 2 weeks of paid vacation vs. 4 at most other programs during the first year.

Any others care to join?
 
Top