NY subway SAFETY

Started by Barbara
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Barbara

Member
7+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
20+ Year Member
Hi,

I will be taking classes in NY, Manhattan and will need to leave Manhattan at 11 pm. I will be staying somewhere in Brooklyn (75th and 2nd Av). I am concerned about my safety. Can any of you who live in the area give me your opinion?

Thank you.
 
It is a proven fact that if you are on the subway at night in NYC, you will die. I have never heard of anyone surviving a nighttime subway trip in the city.





Seriously, NYC is a heck of a lot safer than people make it out to be.
 
Originally posted by ForensicPath
Seriously, NYC is a heck of a lot safer than people make it out to be.

I agree. I was there not too long ago, and I stayed in Harlem. When I walked around alone or with someone, I was fine and never bothered, day or night. I didn't ride the subway alone at night, but I saw alot of females (alone) who did. I think you'll be fine. Just like with any new place, be cautious.
 
Originally posted by Barbara
Hi,

I will be taking classes in NY, Manhattan and will need to leave Manhattan at 11 pm. I will be staying somewhere in Brooklyn (75th and 2nd Av). I am concerned about my safety. Can any of you who live in the area give me your opinion?

Thank you.
75th and 2nd in brooklyn....thats bay ridge/bensonhurst-ish area if i'm not mistaken? its a pretty nice middle class area, pretty safe 👍

like other posters have said, nyc isnt nearly as dangerous as people make it out to be.
 
if you're EXTREMELY concerned about your safety, and money isn't an issue, you could always take a cab... although the subway really isn't as bad a people make it out to be, and usually such people have NEVER riden the subway, much less BEEN to NYC. i've lived in the suburban MD for my entire life, and i was riding the subway like a pro after 3 months in NYC. i haven't had any issues with it in the 5 years i've been living here.

how far will you be from the subway in manhattan and brooklyn?
 
I took the subway on an almost daily basis this summer, most of the time alone, never had any problems. Just try not to walk too slowly, or look around like you're lost. You have a better chance of getting trampled than getting mugged, raped, or murdered.
 
i always take the subway myself. it's not bad at all. just make sure to be in the middle cars. teh first and last tend to get pretty empty, and that's not what you really be in, it's kinda freaky. but you'll be fine. you're not really gonna get a hard time. plus, they have the NYPD ride the cars from time to time, so it's completely fine.

but don't be stupid either, don't think everyone is super nice, cause that's also not true. just don't try to strike up convos with anyone, or look them in the eye. it's sad, but true, you never know what the other person is packing.
 
The scariest part about NYC subway system is how the train stations look, especially those that are not in Manhattan. But they are generally very safe and convenient, especially in good neighborhoods like bay ridge. Like musiclink said, middle cars are rarely empty. If you're really nervous, the car that stops in the very middle of the platform always has an mta guy in it, forgot what they are called -- the people who announce the stops.
 
Hi,

thank you for everyone's honest feedback. Just in case, I will be taking 5 canisters of mace ! Bring it on!
 
Originally posted by Barbara
Hi,

thank you for everyone's honest feedback. Just in case, I will be taking 5 canisters of mace ! Bring it on!

No offense, and I don't live in NYC but visited numerous times....

but grow up. Every major city has it's bad areas and it's good areas. Best advice: Act like you've been there before and nothing will happen.

You make NYC sound like Baghdad in the middle of Operation Enduring Freedom.
 
Really, its not that bad. As long as you practice common sense, you should be fine.

As a poster stated above, if you are really worried, get on the car with the conductor.

I love the subway. I hate the Tube (I'm in London right now studying abroad). London mass transit it annoying 😳
 
I completly agree with everyone. The best advice to mind your own business and be relaxed. If you are tense everytime you take the subway, you'll never get over it. Simply put, any place can be dangerous at night, but you shouldn't look at it as if there are a professional group of gangsters who prey on foreign students.
Bad things happen. Don't be a hero. IF someone asks you for your money, just give it. Your health is more important than any material possession.
Good Luck. Memorize this # very well 9-1-1. Your set 😳) hehe
 
The subways are not like people make them out to be. **** does happen, but rare. If your gonna be riding the subway late at night, two things: 1. Stay by the token booth clerk until the train comes (there is a signal to notify you when a train is coming). 2. Stay in the first car where the train engineer is or in the middle car where the conductor is.
 
The Subway is really fastest. I've never had any problems. But if you're hesitant, you could also take the Manhattan/Bay Ridge Express Bus run by the NYC MTA.

It's numbers X27 & X37. I think they run from Manhattan to Brooklyn as late as midnight or 12:30.

The area you're talking about in Bay Ridge Brooklyn is extremely safe. I don't know what part of the city you're leaving from, but the MTA buses are another option if the you're hesitant about the subways.
 
oh lord... 5 cansiters of mace.

i'm a new yorker born and raised. i've come home on the subway at 4 am many times... nothing happens.
stuff only happens if you act and look like you waiting for it to happen. act normal b/c new yorkers are normal despite whatever suspicions you may harbor.
 
"i hope your classes aren't at columbia because people have been getting jacked there lately. "

Which campus? Because I live next to the uptown campus and never heard about problems on the subway here (Heard about one carjacking that happened a few years ago. Some guy through a brick through the lady's window, but the cops came). And I haven't read about any problems in the Columbia Spec (which would talk about the downtown campus).
 
I just wanted to add that I live in nYC and I think that you will be fine taking the subway at 11pm, but I would NOT make a habit of being on the subway, non-empty car or not, after 12 or 1am. I've seen to much to take a really relaxed attitude to travelling by subway late at night, but like I said, at 11pm you will be fine.