This is pretty scary - I feel like I had a pretty easy form but can already think of ~13-15 I missed from stupid mistakes alone.
Heh it's not always the case. I think 99% of the time, you should trust your NBME scores. Now, there isn't anything you can do, but for people who're going to take the Step, it's obvious to avoid stupid mistakes, but make damned sure you do everything you can to avoid them if it seems easy/reasonable. This obviously doesn't apply to people who've scored 255+ consistently on their NBMEs, I'm talking in the 210-240 range.
Edit: Translation for people who have trouble following rather obvious lines of thought:
"Heh it's not always the case. I think 99% of the time, you should trust your NBME scores." - Trust your NBME scores, but there are times you need to be extra careful.
"Now, there isn't anything you can do, but for people who're going to take the Step, it's obvious to avoid stupid mistakes, but make damned sure you do everything you can to avoid them if it seems easy/reasonable." -
1. If you've passed the USMLE, this post doesn't apply to you. Move on.
2. Everyone will try to avoid stupid mistakes.
3. If you have an easier form, stupid mistakes will count for more, since more people will be getting more questions correct, and the exam will be scaled accordingly. Ergo, it behooves you to make doubly sure you aren't lax in any way.
"This obviously doesn't apply to people who've scored 255+ consistently on their NBMEs, I'm talking in the 210-240 range." -
1. Logically, people consistently scoring high on NBMEs have made a habit of reading carefully/minimizing silly mistakes, so this advice, once again, really doesn't apply to them.
2. People in the 210-240 range with a similar knowledge base to the 255s, need to be exceptionally careful, since we're assuming a similar knowledge base, their lower scores could be ascribed to misreading questions or timing issues. Either way, they're the most likely to suffer missed easy qs, aka stupid mistakes, so they need to be extra careful.
3. The third subset in that range are those at a lower 'high yield' knowledge base. They too, are likely to suffer greatly if they miss the gimme questions.
If you find this post offensive in any way, or my advice poor, please add me to your block list.