Official 2016 Step 1 Experiences and Scores Thread

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Transposony

Do or do not, There is no try
10+ Year Member
Joined
Nov 10, 2011
Messages
1,810
Reaction score
999
Last edited:
so with 44q, did you feel like the q stems were longer? more difficult?
there are ~2 of what's the next step of management questions. overall, ~80% questions are normal q stems. ~20% have long stems. Difficulty wise, it's somewhere between nbme and world, although some questions are ridiculously WTH (no doubt...). I have 1 question EXACTLY the same (word by word) as a NBME 18 question. So do it.
 
How would you guys rate the difficulty distribution of the real thing in terms of UWorld questions? So, questions that >80% get right, 60% get right, 30%, etc.
 
my exam is in one week. I am going over first aid, and it's freaking me out, I thought I had a good grasp, but how little did i know. dang.
anyone having a similar experience???
 
my exam is in one week. I am going over first aid, and it's freaking me out, I thought I had a good grasp, but how little did i know. dang.
anyone having a similar experience???

Pretty much everything looks new to me after a couple days of not reading that particular section. I'm pretty sure the book is sentient and expands overnight just to spite me or something.
 
How would you guys rate the difficulty distribution of the real thing in terms of UWorld questions? So, questions that >80% get right, 60% get right, 30%, etc.

My exam felt very similar to NBME 18, may be a little harder. The stems were only slightly longer on avg than the ones on NBME 18, but most were short than uworld , and never achieved the length of some of the longer stems on uworld.

In regards to difficulty, for my exam form i would say about 15% easy, 55% medium , 25% hard , 2-5% very hard.

In terms of distribution of topics, i thought it was very similar in proportion to the NBMEs.

Edit: Not sure what percentage right that would be on uworld, so took it out, plus this is all very subjective.

Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile app
 
Last edited:
My exam felt very similar to NBME 18, may be a little harder. The stems were only slightly longer on avg than the ones on NBME 18, but most were short than uworld , and never achieved the length of some of the longer stems on uworld.

In regards to difficulty, for my exam form i would say about 15% were gimmes ( 70% right on uworld), 55% medium (45-60), 25% hard (35-45) , 2-5% very hard.

In terms of distribution of topics, i thought it was very similar in proportion to the NBMEs.


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile app

Goddamn, if it's that many of those 35-45% ones then that's torture. I only see about 2 of them per UW block.
 
Goddamn, if it's that many of those 35-45% ones then that's torture. I only see about 2 of them per UW block.

Haha, my thoughts exactly. Traditionally, those who perform 70+% on UW end up with above average step 1 scores. That's because scoring 70% on UW is supposed to be much harder than scoring 70% on NBME (70% on NBME is ~190). For our sake, let's pray that the above poster was suffering from a postictal state after the exam when he/she made that comment.
 
Goddamn, if it's that many of those 35-45% ones then that's torture. I only see about 2 of them per UW block.


Honestly I didn't think it was that bad. Like i said, i thought it was slightly harder than the newest NBME. I don't mean to scare you with the above comment. Maybe my comparison to uworld was off, but I still feel that my exam was about 15-20% easy , 55% medium, 25-30% hard.




Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile app
 
Honestly I didn't think it was that bad. Like i said, i thought it was slightly harder than the newest NBME. I don't mean to scare you with the above comment. Maybe my comparison to uworld was off, but I still feel that my exam was about 15-20% easy , 55% medium, 25-30% hard.




Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile app
Can you give a couple of examples of easy/medium/hard questions?

These things are all relative... Most of the questions that I am missing on these Qbanks are what people would consider easy since over 50% of people usually got them right.
 
Last edited:
Can you give a couple of examples of easy/medium/hard questions?

These things are all relative... Most of the questions that are missing on these Qbanks are what people would consider easy since over 50% of people usually got them right.
Not only is it all relative but that distribution is going to vary form to form. I wouldn't worry about it.
 
Can you give a couple of examples of easy/medium/hard questions?

These things are all relative... Most of the questions that are missing on these Qbanks are what people would consider easy since over 50% of people usually got them right.

That's hard to do man because as you said it's all relative. What i find hard you may find easy and vice versa. And may be it depends on the form you get on your exam date. In addition, IMO the exam did not feel like uworld, it felt like a hard NBME. I tried to use nbme 18 as a comparison above, as I thought it was most representative but somewhat easier .






Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile app
 
Overall @W19 I would say the only thing that is safe to assume would be that the difficulty of questions on the real things is a step up from UW. I've only seen one poster here say the real thing was easier, and I had only one friend at my school who thought that it was "equivalent" to UW. Those people probably had an easier form and are going to have a less forgiving scale/curve, so it probably wasn't "easier" when you consider the end result.

It is a waste of time and energy to worry about that though because in the end the only thing you can do is study as hard as possible. There is no way to derive actionable information from the difficulty breakdown of Step 1.
 
hey i had a quick question for anyone who did the kaplan qbank and then took step. Some of kaplans behavioral science question are wtf and have never learned some of that material. Do those kinds of kaplan behavioral questions actually show up on step? thanks.
 
Hey guys, I'd appreciate some input on what to do for the next week. My exam is next Thursday (5/19). I've read through some threads and it seems like everyone says that UWorld is the most important resource to complete before your exam, so that might be the answer I get here. However, I've had a lot of life things happen that hindered my dedicated and my progress hasn't been what it should and I need to downsize my plan. I have 8 days to go and plan on taking NBME 17 and 18 within the stretch. I have completed pathoma, but have 40% of UWorld left and haven't touched First Aid. I've never been a fan of First Aid, I've tried to get into it but I hate it with a passion. I've noticed I miss questions on the NBMEs on similar topics (gross neuro sections, certain biochem pathways, diseases I forgot existed until I see the question), so I feel that I should review more instead of just hammering out questions, but I'd like your opinions!

For reference, here are my NBME scores:
NBME 12- 239 (4/23)
NBME 13- 232 (4/29)
NBME 15- 251 (5/6)
NBME 16- 251 (5/10) - this morning
 
Hey guys, I'd appreciate some input on what to do for the next week. My exam is next Thursday (5/19). I've read through some threads and it seems like everyone says that UWorld is the most important resource to complete before your exam, so that might be the answer I get here. However, I've had a lot of life things happen that hindered my dedicated and my progress hasn't been what it should and I need to downsize my plan. I have 8 days to go and plan on taking NBME 17 and 18 within the stretch. I have completed pathoma, but have 40% of UWorld left and haven't touched First Aid. I've never been a fan of First Aid, I've tried to get into it but I hate it with a passion. I've noticed I miss questions on the NBMEs on similar topics (gross neuro sections, certain biochem pathways, diseases I forgot existed until I see the question), so I feel that I should review more instead of just hammering out questions, but I'd like your opinions!

For reference, here are my NBME scores:
NBME 12- 239 (4/23)
NBME 13- 232 (4/29)
NBME 15- 251 (5/6)
NBME 16- 251 (5/10) - this morning

With a couple 251s in my pocket I'd probably go through weak spots and try to get the most out of UW at this point but that's just my opinion (which would probably change if you said you were getting 210s if you know what I mean)
 
Hey guys, I'd appreciate some input on what to do for the next week. My exam is next Thursday (5/19). I've read through some threads and it seems like everyone says that UWorld is the most important resource to complete before your exam, so that might be the answer I get here. However, I've had a lot of life things happen that hindered my dedicated and my progress hasn't been what it should and I need to downsize my plan. I have 8 days to go and plan on taking NBME 17 and 18 within the stretch. I have completed pathoma, but have 40% of UWorld left and haven't touched First Aid. I've never been a fan of First Aid, I've tried to get into it but I hate it with a passion. I've noticed I miss questions on the NBMEs on similar topics (gross neuro sections, certain biochem pathways, diseases I forgot existed until I see the question), so I feel that I should review more instead of just hammering out questions, but I'd like your opinions!

For reference, here are my NBME scores:
NBME 12- 239 (4/23)
NBME 13- 232 (4/29)
NBME 15- 251 (5/6)
NBME 16- 251 (5/10) - this morning

250s buddy! Best wishes
 
Hey guys, I'd appreciate some input on what to do for the next week. My exam is next Thursday (5/19). I've read through some threads and it seems like everyone says that UWorld is the most important resource to complete before your exam, so that might be the answer I get here. However, I've had a lot of life things happen that hindered my dedicated and my progress hasn't been what it should and I need to downsize my plan. I have 8 days to go and plan on taking NBME 17 and 18 within the stretch. I have completed pathoma, but have 40% of UWorld left and haven't touched First Aid. I've never been a fan of First Aid, I've tried to get into it but I hate it with a passion. I've noticed I miss questions on the NBMEs on similar topics (gross neuro sections, certain biochem pathways, diseases I forgot existed until I see the question), so I feel that I should review more instead of just hammering out questions, but I'd like your opinions!

For reference, here are my NBME scores:
NBME 12- 239 (4/23)
NBME 13- 232 (4/29)
NBME 15- 251 (5/6)
NBME 16- 251 (5/10) - this morning

With 8 days remaining, definitely finish more UWorld over NBME's.
1. UWorld provides explanations, NBME doesn't; the questions are going to help you learn more.
2. Almost everyone will get more questions wrong in a UWorld block than an NBME block. For max efficiency, read the explanations ONLY for the UWorld questions you missed or guessed.
3. You already know that you're in a strong range of scores, so don't psych yourself out by taking NBME 18 if your mojo is easily shaken.

Also, even if you hate normal FA, quiz yourself from the final Rapid Review section of FA on the 16th and/or 17th. Super high yield stuff that I actually recalled when I took my step.
 
@drhousemd77051 Hey man ! I don't know if I can be of any help since this damn test changes like everyday , and its ca 5 months since mine.. But , you can read all the experiences of people like you who achieved great scores , and just get their sources , you don't have to reinvent the wheel . In my case , the books I bought were enough to achieve a great score , with almost zero baseline knowledge.

Anyways , If I could give you a single piece of advice , its : Pick ONE ( 1 ) source for each subject and master it , in the end it doesnt even matter what book you pick , the only thing that matters is to have the chosen one ingrained into your head. Best of luck !

P.S : Obviously don't pick a 2000pg reference book for path or smthing , stick to step 1 oriented stuff
Thanks a lot for your reply. Sure you can help. yes the exam changes, but still it's not going to become totally different or something, and again the luck or God factor is there. I just want to take my best prep possible, And in that i need your help. then leave the rest to God.
Anyways i'll certainly remember your advice to stick into one source, i'll ask from time to time, what i should choose. I have somehow created a problem for myself already, that is i first started with pathoma, annotating half of it, then again i picked up Goljan RR, and there i annotated from sattar lecture into half of goljan. Now i don't know where to go, when i would do review, FA/goljan/pathoma. I know i'll have to solve it myself. But just tell me where i should keep all my path stuff. It would really help. This would help. Thanks.
 
With 8 days remaining, definitely finish more UWorld over NBME's.
1. UWorld provides explanations, NBME doesn't; the questions are going to help you learn more.
2. Almost everyone will get more questions wrong in a UWorld block than an NBME block. For max efficiency, read the explanations ONLY for the UWorld questions you missed or guessed.
3. You already know that you're in a strong range of scores, so don't psych yourself out by taking NBME 18 if your mojo is easily shaken.

Also, even if you hate normal FA, quiz yourself from the final Rapid Review section of FA on the 16th and/or 17th. Super high yield stuff that I actually recalled when I took my step.

That rapid review section is actually gold
 
Did any scores come out today?

Yep! 259. Suuuuper grateful. Surprised so few people are posting here today.

Fun story: I found out awhile ago, via Facebook, that a friend of mine and I were MCAT score twins. He studied down the hall from me during Step prep and we'd sometimes chat during our study breaks, so I mentioned this to him, like, "oh hey not to be weird, but I did a search for MCAT on Facebook because I wanted to see everyone's nervous 'I'm freakin' out man!!' MCAT prep statuses... Figured it'd help give me perspective and stave off the inevitable Step freakouts... Anyway, turns out, we're MCAT score twins! Isn't that neat?"

We got our Step scores back today, and he texted me to offer to exchange scores since, y'know, score twins/study buddies. Amazingly, it turns out we got the same score. Again.

Here's my long, rambling write-up on /r/medicalschool that mostly boils down to "UFAP + Sketchy + NBME, heavy on the U, light on the FA":

 
Yep! 259. Suuuuper grateful. Surprised so few people are posting here today.

Fun story: I found out awhile ago, via Facebook, that a friend of mine and I were MCAT score twins. He studied down the hall from me during Step prep and we'd sometimes chat during our study breaks, so I mentioned this to him, like, "oh hey not to be weird, but I did a search for MCAT on Facebook because I wanted to see everyone's nervous 'I'm freakin' out man!!' MCAT prep statuses... Figured it'd help give me perspective and stave off the inevitable Step freakouts... Anyway, turns out, we're MCAT score twins! Isn't that neat?"

We got our Step scores back today, and he texted me to offer to exchange scores since, y'know, score twins/study buddies. Amazingly, it turns out we got the same score. Again.

Here's my long, rambling write-up on /r/medicalschool that mostly boils down to "UFAP + Sketchy + NBME, heavy on the U, light on the FA":


Wow! Great score and incredible that both you and your friend got the same score again.

What day did you take it?


Sent from my iPhone using SDN mobile
 
What day did you take it?

April 19th. I poked through your past posts - You took yours on the 28th or 29th, right? Your score should come out next Wednesday, then. You'll get an email around 10:46am telling you that scores will be available from the website after 11am. Keep busy. I spent all morning playing threes while I waited for 11 to roll around: http://play.threesgame.com
 
I took the test on April 18th and checked my score just now.

5 weeks of dedicated study (3/14 - 4/17).
NBME 16 (2 weeks in): 230
NBME 17 (3 weeks in): 239
NBME 18 (4 weeks in): 245
NBME 15 (2 days before test): 239
Actual score: 250

Folks, the only reason I'm posting is to prove that you can indeed score higher than your NBME average or even your highest NBME score. It's not terribly common, but I'm living proof it can happen. Have hope!!! A few more comments:
1) Yes, I walked out of the test feeling like utter unadulterated crap, with 10-15+ confirmed incorrect answers and ~8-12 questions marked per block. I know from experience that I consistently miss the number of questions I mark (not necessarily all marked questions, but a combo of those and unmarked ones), so I'm fairly confident I missed ~10 per block. n=1, just my experience.
2) My UWorld first pass average was 77%. I think my UWorld performance was a better predictor than the NBMEs. I always felt that I knew and understood so much more than the NBMEs gave me credit for..
3) I would NOT recommend taking an NBME within 4 days of your test. It's a gamble you do NOT want to lose. I was devastated by the 239 and literally contemplated cancelling my test date.
 
Cross-post from /r/medicalschool:
Got my score today, 264.

Whatever you do, trust your statistics. I was scoring in the low 260s range in the last 4 NBMEs I took, and NBME 18 was exactly 264, where I landed in the final one.

Here is my progression:
CBSSA (school administered practice): 245
NBME 12 (done as baseline 2 weeks before dedicated, before I had to take a break for school exams): 249
NBME 13 (done right at start of dedicated): 249
NBME 15 (end of week 1): 262
NBME 16 (end of week 2): 262
NBME 17 (end of week 3): 260
UWSA 2 (end of week 4): 263
UWSA 1 (day after UWSA 2): 264
NBME 18 (middle of week 5, a few days before my test): 264
Real deal: 264

Method used: UFAPS.

I decided to disregard everyone's advice (and I urge you do to the same), and do my own thing. I didn't set up a schedule of what subjects to cover on which day. My only goal was to get through UWorld as quickly as possible.

I used Rx throughout the year on untimed mode starting in August, keeping up with school material. In January, right after coming back from winter break, I switched to tutor mode so that I could pound through the rest of Rx. Goljan in one of his talks (around the 14:00 mark) mentions how it is useful to do tutor to go through many questions, so I heeded his advice. I finished around half of Rx in about 2-3 weeks. Since coming back from winter break, I also started listening to Goljan recorded lectures in the gym (I barely went) and while driving. I think I went through them at least 1x, some lectures maybe 2-3 times.

After winter break, I barely dedicated time to studying for class, choosing just to cram a few days before the exam. Rather, I focused all my efforts to study for boards.

Right after finishing Rx, I embarked on UWorld. I did UWorld only timed and random. In my opinion, this is the way to do it. Because of this, timing myself and thinking on the fly became second nature early on, rather than things to add on later. I would shoot for 3 blocks per day, every day, 6 days a week, until I was done. It took me a long time to go through UWorld (see below) so I finished it with only 2 weeks to spare at the end of my dedicated.

I went through UWorld extremely thoroughly. For every single question I got wrong or guessed on, I would read up on it (UWorld explanations, Goljan, Big Robbins, Wikipedia, FA, Moore's anatomy, Lippincott's Biochem, etc), and then write a passage about it in a Google Doc as if I were writing a textbook. I would add images as appropriate. I would spend a lot of time making my own diagnostic flow charts. I paid for a one month subscription to Lucidchart to make these more easily and make them more neat. This was very helpful for organizing my thoughts and creating a fast way for me to arrive at a diagnosis within a certain disease. I had a chart for the lysosomal storage disorders, trisomies, psych diagnoses, you name it. By the end of UWorld, I had written my own version of First Aid, which ended up being around 500 pages. It was tailored to things that I didn't know the first time around. Making this monster of a study guide took ages and ate up the majority of my dedicated, but it was extremely worth it because it forced me to really understand every single question that I got wrong.

By the end, I had used Rx x 1.3 at 74%, UWorld x 1.3 at 87% (2nd time at 99%: having really gone over the questions carefully paid off). I chose not to do UWorld twice in favor of reading more Goljan, and watching Pathoma several extra times, and reviewing Sketchy parasites, as that was my weakest section in micro.

In the last 2 weeks, I read sections of Big Robbins about obgyn and neuro pathology, which I felt like I needed more practice in. I also went through about ~500 MC questions in Firecracker (the cases that they offer) - these were honestly not great compared to UWorld or Rx (very lackluster explanations and lots of blatant errors), but it was useful to do them rapid fire to tune my intuition. I also did a quick read of Goljan's review of pathology (and then spent some time regretting I didn't start this book earlier with my classes). I also did the 100 free Kaplan questions (trial of their Qbank).

Throughout the process, I barely used FA (really just as a reference). In the final few days, I closely read the micro section, and then did the Rapid Review section at the end.

For those who haven't taken, good luck. My advice: 1. Don't listen to what others say. Do what works for you. I had no schedule and barely used FA. 2. Trust the NBMEs. If you have been consistently scoring in your target range, trust your preparation and go kill this exam.
 
First Aid is enough, but I used Kaplan Lectures(videos)- as I too felt I was rather weak in that area. Also, Kaplan Qbank questions followed by UW questions should be enough. I think Brachial plexus is probably the most important, along with nerve injuries- Questions in the question are pretty classic, and usually test nerve injuries (where was it injured/how did it get injured/symptoms of injury). There are a few questions about Psoas Major insertion/origin/function- just that one muscle. Trendelenburg's is pretty high yield along with nerve supplied to gluteus medius and maximus.
Lastly, the notorious knee injury triad : ACL, MCL, Lateral meniscus- you should also know anterior drawer and posterior drawer tests as well- as those will usually be described in the question stem.

Random :
Supraspinatus test/Empty can test
Wrist bones : X-rays
I think a bank had a question on ankle joint (just one)

That's all I'm focusing on. My exam is on the May 31st. Hopefully this post helped you out.

PS: I also used a Professor's Youtube channel 'Clinical Anatomy Explained' to revise brachial plexus, some neuroanatomy, GI blood supply. The videos are usually 45-50 minutes long, but if you're a visual learner like me, you might like them.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: W19
Any post-change/ Post May 9th exam experiences? I'm taking my exam on May 31. I'm guessing NBME 18 would be the most accurate score predictor.
 
Just took it.
Blocks 40 questions. Last block 28 questions. All blocks were 60 min. I don't think question length increased. I had a bunch one liner questions and the usual paragraph question and a few long ones. Didn't have that many next step in management.
3-4 questions were very similar to NBME 18 and 17. Very similar - almost verbatim.
 
Just took it.
Blocks 40 questions. Last block 28 questions. All blocks were 60 min. I don't think question length increased. I had a bunch one liner questions and the usual paragraph question and a few long ones. Didn't have that many next step in management.
3-4 questions were very similar to NBME 18 and 17. Very similar - almost verbatim.


Wait... I'm so confused.
How many blocks were there?
When you say all blocks were 60 minutes, you mean even the 28-question block was 60 minutes?
What is this madness!

(Thanks for sharing <3)
 
Wait... I'm so confused.
How many blocks were there?
When you say all blocks were 60 minutes, you mean even the 28-question block was 60 minutes?
What is this madness!

(Thanks for sharing <3)

Yeah. 60 min for 28 questions.

6 blocks of 40 questions. Last block was 28 questions. Each were 60 min long including the 28 question block.
 
I meant to ask this after my exam but I forgot. Are the experimental questions mixed in or is it just an entire block that is experimental?
 
Yeah. 60 min for 28 questions.

6 blocks of 40 questions. Last block was 28 questions. Each were 60 min long including the 28 question block.

That's ... mind-blowing. Wow.

I meant to ask this after my exam but I forgot. Are the experimental questions mixed in or is it just an entire block that is experimental?

Mixed in, I believe.
 
Yeah. 60 min for 28 questions.

6 blocks of 40 questions. Last block was 28 questions. Each were 60 min long including the 28 question block.

That...that makes no sense. So now the exam is only 268 questions? Why would they do this?
 
That...that makes no sense. So now the exam is only 268 questions? Why would they do this?
If you read their website it says each block will not exceed 40 but number of questions can vary (aka be less than 40). My test had 40 throughout until last block which was 28. I'm not sure if all new exams will follow this question format or if each exam has a variable number of questions. I honestly don't even know how that are going to score the exam with these new changes. I just shared my test experience. But I don't know how other "new tests" are formatted question wise.
 
That...that makes no sense. So now the exam is only 268 questions? Why would they do this?
Same thing with Step 2 CK, there are 22 questions in the last block for some people. My guess is that they realize everyone is burnout by the last block so they make it less questions albeit also promote even less room for errors.
 
Hey guys, I was originally planning on taking Nbme 15, 16, 17, 18 and UWSA 1 and UWSA2 before my exam coming up in about 4 weeks. I already took nbme 15 and was gonna take UWSA1 this saturday. Should i swap out the two UWSA for nbme 12 and 13.
 
If you read their website it says each block will not exceed 40 but number of questions can vary (aka be less than 40). My test had 40 throughout until last block which was 28. I'm not sure if all new exams will follow this question format or if each exam has a variable number of questions. I honestly don't even know how that are going to score the exam with these new changes. I just shared my test experience. But I don't know how other "new tests" are formatted question wise.

Thanks for sharing and congrats on being done! Were the questions comparable to Uworld questions? Also did you notice any more integrated/conceptual questions, or were the one liners more of memory/recall type of questions? 28 questions in one block/60 minutes makes me a little nervous. Were they more challenging than the previous blocks?
 
Last edited:
Top