Official mafia game thread

Veterinary School Application Advising Ad
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Members do not see this ad.
Lissarae06 said:
According to my informant, wildcat is not the right choice. I'm going with nohika. She has been flying under the radar and hasn't really contributed much.
Click to expand...
In that case -- unlynch wildcatj, lynch wldlfstdnt for now. Unless someone has a more solid lead/hunch/whatever?

And yeah, based on our group PMs I also trust nohika at this point. She's contributed a lot more behind-the-scenes than she has on the thread.
 
Lissarae06 said:
I feel like I am the only one posting lol. It looks like wldlfstdnt is also silenced. Maybe she is the one whose face got cut? Is anyone else silenced?
Click to expand...
Didn't see this until after I posted. It does look like wldlfstdnt is silenced. Ugh. I don't like lynching people when they're silenced, but at the same time I think there's a good chance that she or wildcatj is a wolf. And if Lissa's source says it isn't wildcatj... Not sure what to think.
 
cuitlamiztli said:
Didn't see this until after I posted. It does look like wldlfstdnt is silenced. Ugh. I don't like lynching people when they're silenced, but at the same time I think there's a good chance that she or wildcatj is a wolf. And if Lissa's source says it isn't wildcatj... Not sure what to think.
Click to expand...

That's why I am trying to figure out if it is more than just those 2 silenced. If they are the only ones, I don't think it is wldlfstdnt unless she silenced herself to not look like a wolf. I'm actually thinking we might want to have devyn use her veto. She gets one, right?
 
Checking in quickly, I am going to be in and out all day today.

I do trust nohika, she has been helpful behind the scenes...

I will try to check in before the deadline, but there are no promises, I have a lot going on today.
 
I'm actually not sure if devyn gets a veto or not; she hasn't said anything either way. But I'm guessing so, since it looks like krist is using old school rules/roles and such.
 
Maybe we should look at the people who haven't posted (not including sheeps since he is more than likely silenced)? So far this is:

nohika
orca2011
wildcatj
jamr0ckin

That leaves 1 player who is definitely silenced. The three others could be busy, at work, or whatever... or they could be wolves laying low/pretending to be silenced for now. Pretty sure I've pulled that at some point in every game I've been a wolf. So, if wildcatj and nohika are truly clear then maybe we've got a 50/50 shot between orca and jamr0ckin. How much do you know about orca, Lissa? And does anyone know if jam was ever investigated after claiming to have a role/her near-lynching?

Now, this isn't saying that none of us who have posted can't be wolves. Just that maybe we have a better shot looking at the non-posters. But I could be totally off base so feel free to refute/disregard this stuff. Maybe I'm thinking too much.

Anyway, keeping my vote for now. I'm going to go see if any of the non-posters have visited other threads.
 
cuitlamiztli said:
Maybe we should look at the people who haven't posted (not including sheeps since he is more than likely silenced)? So far this is:

nohika
orca2011
wildcatj
jamr0ckin

That leaves 1 player who is definitely silenced. The three others could be busy, at work, or whatever... or they could be wolves laying low/pretending to be silenced for now. Pretty sure I've pulled that at some point in every game I've been a wolf. So, if wildcatj and nohika are truly clear then maybe we've got a 50/50 shot between orca and jamr0ckin. How much do you know about orca, Lissa? And does anyone know if jam was ever investigated after claiming to have a role/her near-lynching?

Now, this isn't saying that none of us who have posted can't be wolves. Just that maybe we have a better shot looking at the non-posters. But I could be totally off base so feel free to refute/disregard this stuff. Maybe I'm thinking too much.

Anyway, keeping my vote for now. I'm going to go see if any of the non-posters have visited other threads.
Click to expand...
We should have one player besides sheeps silenced because in the write up it talked about someone going to the hospital with a facial laceration. I haven't really heard from orca at all. The only communication our group has had was started by nyanko. NStarz replied but that was it.
 
To be complete I'm going through everyone:

nohika -- hasn't posted anywhere or PM'd since yesterday (last post on this thread)
orca2011, wildcat, and jam -- none have posted since yesterday (all last posts also on this thread) but have visited the forum earlier today.

Not sure how much that helps, though. Anyone else have any input?
 
I haven't gotten a response to the PM I sent Wildcat yesterday.
 
cuitlamiztli said:
To be complete I'm going through everyone:

nohika -- hasn't posted anywhere or PM'd since yesterday (last post on this thread)
orca2011, wildcat, and jam -- none have posted since yesterday (all last posts also on this thread) but have visited the forum earlier today.

Not sure how much that helps, though. Anyone else have any input?
Click to expand...

*************************
I get all paranoid about this crap ^^^ lol Stop watching me!!! (when I play games)
*************************
 
Sorry. At work. Still honestly don't have much to contribute. I don't have my notes in front of me, but I'm honestly not sure if it would make much of a difference.
 
Sorry the sun came out here... and it has been raining a lot recently so went and took the dogs for a walk... have to jump in the shower... but will be around on and off

I would assume Sheeps is silenced because he protected. Nohika has not posted or PMed today... so not sure if she is busy IRL or not.

Orca has not really been very active in thread at all...so I am not going to assume she is silenced just yet..and Jam & Wildcat have been on and off posters and I know both work I think, so who knows... I don't know what time zones everyone is in..

And I would rather save my veto for the end of the game when I know someone is good rather than waste it on people I have no clue about..
 
Abney said:
*************************
I get all paranoid about this crap ^^^ lol Stop watching me!!! (when I play games)
*************************
Click to expand...
Yeah... I was mostly looking to see if they've posted elsewhere but didn't want to leave the other info off. I kinda felt like a creeper. Which is why I'm set to invisible.
 
cuitlamiztli said:
Yeah... I was mostly looking to see if they've posted elsewhere but didn't want to leave the other info off. I kinda felt like a creeper. Which is why I'm set to invisible.
Click to expand...

**************************
No no. I totally know what you were doing, nothing wrong with it. But when I've played games I'm always thinking "Who's watching where I'm posting?!" 😱:laugh:
***************************
 
Current lynch votes:

wldlfstdn - 1 (cuit)

Waffles: 2

5 hours left!
 
*********************************
wldlfstdnt I've always wanted to know, what does your name stand for? I can't figure it out. :laugh:

Also, you guys are boring 😴 Everytime I'm online, no one is posting.
********************************
 
cuitlamiztli said:
Yeah... I was mostly looking to see if they've posted elsewhere but didn't want to leave the other info off. I kinda felt like a creeper. Which is why I'm set to invisible.
Click to expand...
************
:laugh: Well, you do have a good example of creeper-ness how-to living with you.

Go civilians! It's nice to see that the loss of your detective has not kept you from detecting. 😎
************
 
wolfspeaker said:
*********************************
wldlfstdnt I've always wanted to know, what does your name stand for? I can't figure it out. :laugh:

Also, you guys are boring 😴 Everytime I'm online, no one is posting.
********************************
Click to expand...

**************
wildlifestudent. just no vowels.
****************
 
wolfspeaker said:
*********************************
wldlfstdnt I've always wanted to know, what does your name stand for? I can't figure it out. :laugh:

Also, you guys are boring 😴 Everytime I'm online, no one is posting.
********************************
Click to expand...
************
I know this one. It's "wildlifestudent" without the vowels. 🙂
************
 
************
Seriously, Abney, that's jinx twice in a row! :laugh: I think I'll just stop posting for a bit.
************
 
****************************
Thanks guys! Been bothering me for a while now. :laugh:
*****************************
 
lynch devyn I know she said she wanted to save the veto but there really isn't any point to that. The veto really only helps wolves. I have used it to take the heat off LIS in the GoT game and the wolves used it to win in the LOTR game. To me, it's better than lynching a random villager. It gives us another day to try and get info.
 
Lissarae06 said:
lynch devyn I know she said she wanted to save the veto but there really isn't any point to that. The veto really only helps wolves. I have used it to take the heat off LIS in the GoT game and the wolves used it to win in the LOTR game. To me, it's better than lynching a random villager. It gives us another day to try and get info.
Click to expand...

I would rather keep the veto until later in the game... I have seen it help save a good villager in the past... and no offense Lissa, but this strikes me as a move you used in the game where we were both wolves to get rid of the veto and work it in your favor as a wolf.... so I am now kind of suspicious of you.....
 
At this point I am between Orca and wldlfstdnt....since wildcat is vouched for now I am going to choose between those 2 for now... cuit & nohika have been pretty open in PMs so far, so no red flags as of yet. I am going to get some food in me and think on it...
 
devyn said:
At this point I am between Orca and wldlfstdnt....since wildcat is vouched for now I am going to choose between those 2 for now... cuit & nohika have been pretty open in PMs so far, so no red flags as of yet. I am going to get some food in me and think on it...
Click to expand...


How is wildcat vouched for? Wolfspeaker vouched for me before wolves got her, so I was vouched for too.
 
wldlfstdnt said:
How is wildcat vouched for? Wolfspeaker vouched for me before wolves got her, so I was vouched for too.
Click to expand...

Lissa said her source just vouched for wildcat.... and you said you did not even know how WS knew who you were or what WS was talking about, so I would not consider that vouching for you...sorry
 
devyn said:
I would rather keep the veto until later in the game... I have seen it help save a good villager in the past... and no offense Lissa, but this strikes me as a move you used in the game where we were both wolves to get rid of the veto and work it in your favor as a wolf.... so I am now kind of suspicious of you.....
Click to expand...

That's what I am saying. Saving the veto late in the game only helps the wolves. That's why I would rather get rid of it now than save it for later. When I used it to help the wolves in a previous game it was because a wolf was taking a lot of heat. No one is taking that kind of heat right now. There have only been a couple votes with plenty of time left. If you know someone is good later in the game, you can speak up and defend them. I'm sticking with it.
 
devyn said:
Lissa said her source just vouched for wildcat.... and you said you did not even know how WS knew who you were or what WS was talking about, so I would not consider that vouching for you...sorry
Click to expand...


I said I didn't know how WS knew I was a civilian because I honestly didn't know. I was also suspicious because she hinted that I have a role, which I don't which in turn made me confused.
 
I have a brief moment....

Lissa, I agree with you 100% about getting rid of the veto.. You and I tried to do that in LoTR to get rid of LIS' veto and help the villagers...

The only thing that I do not agree with is the time frame... It is only Day 5.. We have a few suspicions on a few people, so why not run with those..

I honestly think it is better to do the "get rid of the veto lynch" towards the end of the game when numbers are tighter (like we tried in LoTR) and there is no information.. It just seem really early in the game to be doing this especially when we do have a few suspicions.

That is just my opinion on the "get rid of the veto vote" much better to wait and do that at the end when numbers can be tight and the villagers might need the ability to vote and not accidently lynch a villager (at a critical point in the game)...
 
Just checking in. not silenced, just busy day at the clinic. Currently waiting on radiographs for rabbit with broken leg.

I have a feeling one of the silenced players (besides Sheeps) is a wolf.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using SDN Mobile
 
wldlfstdnt said:
And basically we are saying sheeps is silenced and the other two have been vouched for?
Click to expand...

I believe sheeps was silenced because he successfully protected someone. I think one of the other two is in the hospital from the facial laceration. No idea about the 3rd person. I can vouch for wildcat. DVM said earlier in the game that lynching nohika was a bad bad bad choice.
 
So it seems I am going to get lynched. I am a civilian. 🙁 Oh well. It was nice playing again.
 
just got finished with a long skype phone convo with the parentals... now checking back in..

hmmm.... Jam - why do you think one of the silenced players is a wolf?

if that is the case with Sheeps having protected someone and wildcat vouched for - that would mean nohika would be the only possibility.... she did not tell me her role, but I assume she told DVM and DVM seems to think she is a necessary person to keep around...
 
devyn said:
if that is the case with Sheeps having protected someone and wildcat vouched for - that would mean nohika would be the only possibility.... she did not tell me her role, but I assume she told DVM and DVM seems to think she is a necessary person to keep around...
Click to expand...
Nohika hasn't shared her role with me, either, but did say that she shared it with DVM. And like I said before she hasn't been suspicious in PMs. Ugh. I'm getting the feeling that someone is getting played somewhere 🙁
 
And where is everyone? Are we seriously going to have only two votes this cycle?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Animal Midwife
Death Nommy - Game Thread
83 84 85 86 87
Replies
4K
Views
59K
Animal Midwife
Animal Midwife
WildZoo
  • Poll Poll
Mission ImpoWWssible Game Thread
46 47 48 49 50
Replies
2K
Views
43K
Clem J
Clem J
WildZoo
Supernatural: Angels & Demons WW Game Thread
121 122 123 124 125
Replies
6K
Views
67K
CeeGee14
CeeGee14
supershorty
GGoats ThWWee: Here It GGoats Again - GAME THREAD
93 94 95 96 97
Replies
5K
Views
59K
vampyrica
vampyrica
Animal Midwife
Season 12 Mafia Championship Nominations
2
Replies
77
Views
3K
holdthemayo
holdthemayo
Top