I am on OMFS resident in a four year program. I think that an MD is a beautiful option. There are absolutely no negatives with getting an MD as a part of OMFS training. One can only gain from it immensely. There are number of ways that MD can serve:
1. More education is always good.
2. It looks better next to your name...especially to people who are "OMFS confused"
3. One has more options when choosing national and international fellowships
4. American board of Cosmetic surgery only recognizes oral surgeons who have MD
5. In many states, such as CT, and MA, a single degree OMFS is not allowed to perform any cosmetic procedures on the face...they are not allowed to use BOTOX for cosmetic purposes, due to the fact that they are governed by the state's dental associations...THIS IS PAINFUL AND DEGRADING
6. Our MD colleagues in the community, are much more comfortable to refer patients to a dual degree surgeon, just because they foolishly think that MD makes one a better surgeon. This is true. and it sucks
7. ORAL AND MAXILLOFACIAL SURGERY as we know it in US is a MEDICAL SPECIALTY in many major countries, including UK...so it is easier to be eligible if one was to move, or operate outside the US.
8. MD can be potentially much more helpful in academics...its not necessary as seen so far...but who knows in the future
9. One has almost almost no chance of performing a cleft lip and palate surgery as a single degree OMFS guy in US...not to mention get a craniofacial fellowship. Of course you will tell that you know single degree guys who do it. And I will tell you that some i.e. Turvey...have been doing it forever, and have a nice setup and a reputation, and other guys live far from major centers...i.e. Hawaii and are doing those procedures there. Whether it is an important factor is up to the individual.
10. If one were to choose to extend his/her career beyond OMFS...i.e. plastics, microvascular...an MD is a must.
So...an MD is quite simply a very nice icing on the cake. Now for the defensive types...you notice that I didn't mention anything about who is a better surgeon.
That factor of course has nothing to do with degrees, and has everything to do with an individual, their wanting to be great, and continuous striving for perfection...just like anywhere else in life. I know single degree guys who graduated from "SMALL" programs in Brooklyn and Bronx and who became amazing surgeons and have tremendously advanced our field. I also know dual and singe degree guys who came out of amazing programs...that really gave one all the opportunity and experience to become great, and who can't operate.
At the end of the day, we have to keep some things in mind. DONT CREATE A DOUBLE STANDARD. Our field, OMFS, is a constantly evolving and growing field. We came very far from our exodontist origins in the 1950's. And of course as a result of our superior training and desire to do more procedures, we are encroaching on other fields.
One can argue that PERIO is also an evolving field that has in its own right advanced tremendously...and has been continuously encroaching on OMFS...in terms of procedures and an many cases anesthesia.
You will tell me: "You should see the complications periodontists have...they are not "Surgeons"...they are "gum gardeners", "Hygientists with balls" , they "should not be placing implants, or "getting into the sinuses, or taking out wisdom teeth". In reality its all bull****. I know periodontist who are amazing at what they do...have amazing hands and make great clinical decisions. They handle both hard and soft tissues well, and have a great understanding of restorative aspects. However, the truth is, that they ARE encroaching on OMFS turf...and of course it is unpleasant for us...especially because these are the $$$ procedures. Hey...this is the truth.
Now PLASTICS and some ENTS feel that we are the "PERIODONITSTS" who "SHOULD NOT" be "CUTTING SKIN ON THE FACE", we are not trained well enough, and we should work on the "LOWER JAW" and take out teeth. "HEY WE HAVE A CONSULT FOR YOU...WE HAVE A PATIENT ADMITTED FOR SEIZURE WORKUP AND WE NOTICED SHE HAS BAD TEETH, WE WANTED TO CALL THE DENTIST TO TAKE A LOOK AT HER."
Go google around, read the forums. Read what the MD's think of us. It is amazing how so many of them think that we are "PERIODONTISTS".
In reality it is very annoying.
In reality it is probably much better for someone just to go the traditional route to become a plastic and craniofacial surgeon and be recongized for it. Doing it through OMFS it possible but very painful and one has to constantly be on defensive and "explain" that "I am a facial surgeon who takes the posterior table out and allows the brain to fill in the frontal sinuses"...people in the community will always call us "dentists"...and its ok...if thats who you want. My point, is that a lot of OMF guys are really embarassed that they are dentists...when rounding in the morning or in the hospital they tell patients "I am a facial doctor". Its a defense mechanism. They want to be indistinguishable from facial plastic surgeons...and be treated the same, and it doesn't sit well with MD's. It never will. Just like it will never sit well with us that PERIOS go into the sinuses, take out wizzies, and do IV sedations.
The moral is this:
1. If you choose to be a super surgeon (facial cosmetics, cleft, microvascular), want to be equally treated by the plastics and ENT's...then be it...strive for it and fight for it...but remember...that you ARE taking a different and uncoinventional route...and they who have "done it the right way", will despise you for it.
2. If you really want to be Facial plastic surgeon, then you probably have enough desire and drive to do it...then become it the right way. Go to ENT...or PRS residency. That was you wont have to defend yourself.
3. Undersatnd this...if your loved one needed a 3rd molars out whould you sent him/her to? To a trauma center OMFS who does crazy trauma and who roughly takes out teeth in a community clinic, or to the PRIVATE PRACTICE OMFS, who ONLY takes out wizzies and does it quickly, gently and autramatically.
Now if you relative needed a nosejob, who would you sent him/her to? To an oral surgeon who in addition to 3rd molard, implants, sunus lifts, mandible fractures, several times a months does rhinoplasties in some well selected cases, or to a guy who only does nose jobs all day and nights such as Dr. Paul Nassif ?
You know the answer.
There is no solution. We, OMFSs should continue doing what we are doing despite all the people who are against us and the confusion of who we really are. We have been doing it well for a long while. But if we want to be treated with respect by our MD colleagues, we have to treat our own dental specialists (perios) with respect.
There is enough candy for everyone.