Osteopathic fellowship

Started by JimmyB123
This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

JimmyB123

Full Member
7+ Year Member
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I was reading up on the EM residency program at the Henry Ford Health System(in MI). Very good program by the way. But it said that DOs need to do an osteopathic internship before applying for the PGY-1 year. Is this common? Do Osteopathic grads need to do an intern year before applying for allo residencies? Or is it state dependent ?
 
I was reading up on the EM residency program at the Henry Ford Health System(in MI). Very good program by the way. But it said that DOs need to do an osteopathic internship before applying for the PGY-1 year. Is this common? Do Osteopathic grads need to do an intern year before applying for allo residencies? Or is it state dependent ?

Hey I was going to ask something like this yesterday!

@DermViser , do you know a lot about this? Wasn't it that for DO's to even consider an MD derm program you had to do an additional rotating year or something?
 
In order to practice in some states (like MI), DO's must complete an osteopathic internship or apply for a waiver. You do not need to complete this intern year prior to applying for residency. All EM programs (MD and DO) are categorical, meaning that when you match, you are matching for the entire duration of training at that institution.

All AOA EM programs are PGY 1-4.
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I was reading up on the EM residency program at the Henry Ford Health System(in MI). Very good program by the way. But it said that DOs need to do an osteopathic internship before applying for the PGY-1 year. Is this common? Do Osteopathic grads need to do an intern year before applying for allo residencies? Or is it state dependent ?

Four states (FL, MI, PA, & OK) require that DOs complete a TRI or "AOA equivalent" internship prior to becoming licensed. This is a requirement set forth by the DO medical boards of thoses states. There is a way (AOA Res. 42) to get an ACGME PGY-1, pre-lim, or TY to be considered equivalent in order to get licensure in those states. It requires some extra stuff you have to do during 1st year of residency, like give a presentation about OMT, attend an AOA conference, etc.

That said, I have been noticing that some ACGME programs near me (I'm in PA) require that DOs complete the TRI prior to starting residency, regardless of whether or not they have a categorical pre-lim year. They either don't know about Res. 42, or they just don't want to have to deal with the hassle associated with it. As a result of this, those programs only interview DOs who are in a TRI. This complicates things a bit, because from what I've heard, applying from a TRI might actually hurt your chances with AOA programs, but it might actually have the opposite effect with ACGME programs.

Now, its expected that after the merger (after 2020), Res. 42 won't be necessary anymore because all programs will be ACGME accredited and there will be no AOA internships, but the states involved will have to modify laws in order for that to be official, which they'll have to do, or else they wouldn't be able to license DOs.

Hey I was going to ask something like this yesterday!

@DermViser , do you know a lot about this? Wasn't it that for DO's to even consider an MD derm program you had to do an additional rotating year or something?

The Dermatology issue is different. First off, Dermatology is an advanced residency. They start as a PGY-2 year following one year (PGY-1) of an internship that's either a TY or a pre-lim medicine year. For the ACGME programs, you apply to match in Derm programs 2 years prior to starting (i.e. you apply as a MS4 for a position you will start after you complete an internship, which you also apply for in the same match). So basically, the people applying Derm this cycle, won't start their Derm residencies until July 2016. Derm is not alone in this, and a few programs require an internship or pre-lim year, while some may actually be "categorical" meaning that the specific program includes a PGY-1 year.

Second, for AOA residencies, it works a little differently. They still require a 1 yr PGY-1 internship (TRI - traditional rotating internship), but the difference is that they do NOT accept applications in advance, and you can only apply to them as an intern the year before you are supposed to start PGY-2. This is why many match lists don't list a Derm match. Those matches are made by people who matched into a TRI when they graduated, because they had the intention of applying Derm during their TRI year.

In order to practice in some states (like MI), DO's must complete an osteopathic internship or apply for a waiver. You do not need to complete this intern year prior to applying for residency. All EM programs (MD and DO) are categorical, meaning that when you match, you are matching for the entire duration of training at that institution.

All AOA EM programs are PGY 1-4.

This is true.

The thing that I have actually noticed, however, is that some ACGME programs in those states simply don't interview any DOs that aren't currently in or that haven't already completed a TRI. I'm guessing they're scared that the DOs will have an issue getting licensed, they don't know about Res 42, or they just don't want to have to deal with it. These programs make it very clear that DOs should only apply if they have done/are doing a TRI. The funny thing is, if you apply out of state, if you're from those 4 states, and complete an ACGME program and do Res. 42, you'll probably save yourself a year and still be able to practice/be licensed.

Also, its weird, because regardless, the DO medical board in my state provides the temporary licensure to DOs for residency, even if they're doing an ACGME program without Res 42. They won't be able to get permanent licensure after training, but its perfectly fine for people to train in the state and be licensed (after PGY1/Level 3 obviously) even without a TRI or Res. 42.
 
Last edited:
Four states (FL, MI, PA, & OK) require that DOs complete a TRI or "AOA equivalent" internship prior to becoming licensed. This is a requirement set forth by the DO medical boards of thoses states. There is a way (AOA Res. 42) to get an ACGME PGY-1, pre-lim, or TY to be considered equivalent in order to get licensure in those states. It requires some extra stuff you have to do during 1st year of residency, like give a presentation about OMT, attend an AOA conference, etc.

That said, I have been noticing that some ACGME programs near me (I'm in PA) require that DOs complete the TRI prior to starting residency, regardless of whether or not they have a categorical pre-lim year. They either don't know about Res. 42, or they just don't want to have to deal with the hassle associated with it. As a result of this, those programs only interview DOs who are in a TRI. This complicates things a bit, because from what I've heard, applying from a TRI might actually hurt your chances with AOA programs, but it might actually have the opposite effect with ACGME programs.

Now, its expected that after the merger (after 2020), Res. 42 won't be necessary anymore because all programs will be ACGME accredited and there will be no AOA internships, but the states involved will have to modify laws in order for that to be official, which they'll have to do, or else they wouldn't be able to license DOs.



The Dermatology issue is different. First off, Dermatology is an advanced residency. They start as a PGY-2 year following one year (PGY-1) of an internship that's either a TY or a pre-lim medicine year. For the ACGME programs, you apply to match in Derm programs 2 years prior to starting (i.e. you apply as a MS4 for a position you will start after you complete an internship, which you also apply for in the same match). So basically, the people applying Derm this cycle, won't start their Derm residencies until July 2016. Derm is not alone in this, and a few programs require an internship or pre-lim year, while some may actually be "categorical" meaning that the specific program includes a PGY-1 year.

Second, for AOA residencies, it works a little differently. They still require a 1 yr PGY-1 internship (TRI - traditional rotating internship), but the difference is that they do NOT accept applications in advance, and you can only apply to them as an intern the year before you are supposed to start PGY-2. This is why many match lists don't list a Derm match. Those matches are made by people who matched into a TRI when they graduated, because they had the intention of applying Derm during their TRI year.



This is true.

The thing that I have actually noticed, however, is that some ACGME programs in those states simply don't interview any DOs that aren't currently in or that haven't already completed a TRI. I'm guessing they're scared that the DOs will have an issue getting licensed, they don't know about Res 42, or they just don't want to have to deal with it. These programs make it very clear that DOs should only apply if they have done/are doing a TRI. The funny thing is, if you apply out of state, if you're from those 4 states, and complete an ACGME program and do Res. 42, you'll probably save yourself a year and still be able to practice/be licensed.

Also, its weird, because regardless, the DO medical board in my state provides the temporary licensure to DOs for residency, even if they're doing an ACGME program without Res 42. They won't be able to get permanent licensure after training, but its perfectly fine for people to train in the state and be licensed (after PGY1/Level 3 obviously) even without a TRI or Res. 42.
Wow thank you so much for this post!!
 
Four states (FL, MI, PA, & OK) require that DOs complete a TRI or "AOA equivalent" internship prior to becoming licensed. This is a requirement set forth by the DO medical boards of thoses states. There is a way (AOA Res. 42) to get an ACGME PGY-1, pre-lim, or TY to be considered equivalent in order to get licensure in those states. It requires some extra stuff you have to do during 1st year of residency, like give a presentation about OMT, attend an AOA conference, etc.

That said, I have been noticing that some ACGME programs near me (I'm in PA) require that DOs complete the TRI prior to starting residency, regardless of whether or not they have a categorical pre-lim year. They either don't know about Res. 42, or they just don't want to have to deal with the hassle associated with it. As a result of this, those programs only interview DOs who are in a TRI. This complicates things a bit, because from what I've heard, applying from a TRI might actually hurt your chances with AOA programs, but it might actually have the opposite effect with ACGME programs.

Now, its expected that after the merger (after 2020), Res. 42 won't be necessary anymore because all programs will be ACGME accredited and there will be no AOA internships, but the states involved will have to modify laws in order for that to be official, which they'll have to do, or else they wouldn't be able to license DOs.



The Dermatology issue is different. First off, Dermatology is an advanced residency. They start as a PGY-2 year following one year (PGY-1) of an internship that's either a TY or a pre-lim medicine year. For the ACGME programs, you apply to match in Derm programs 2 years prior to starting (i.e. you apply as a MS4 for a position you will start after you complete an internship, which you also apply for in the same match). So basically, the people applying Derm this cycle, won't start their Derm residencies until July 2016. Derm is not alone in this, and a few programs require an internship or pre-lim year, while some may actually be "categorical" meaning that the specific program includes a PGY-1 year.

Second, for AOA residencies, it works a little differently. They still require a 1 yr PGY-1 internship (TRI - traditional rotating internship), but the difference is that they do NOT accept applications in advance, and you can only apply to them as an intern the year before you are supposed to start PGY-2. This is why many match lists don't list a Derm match. Those matches are made by people who matched into a TRI when they graduated, because they had the intention of applying Derm during their TRI year.



This is true.

The thing that I have actually noticed, however, is that some ACGME programs in those states simply don't interview any DOs that aren't currently in or that haven't already completed a TRI. I'm guessing they're scared that the DOs will have an issue getting licensed, they don't know about Res 42, or they just don't want to have to deal with it. These programs make it very clear that DOs should only apply if they have done/are doing a TRI. The funny thing is, if you apply out of state, if you're from those 4 states, and complete an ACGME program and do Res. 42, you'll probably save yourself a year and still be able to practice/be licensed.

Also, its weird, because regardless, the DO medical board in my state provides the temporary licensure to DOs for residency, even if they're doing an ACGME program without Res 42. They won't be able to get permanent licensure after training, but its perfectly fine for people to train in the state and be licensed (after PGY1/Level 3 obviously) even without a TRI or Res. 42.

Which other specialties require this?
 
  • Option 1: The OGME-1 year is an integral part of the residency, and is considered the first year of residency training. Students will match directly into the specialty residency program.
  • Option 2: The OGME-1 year consists of a prerequisite preliminary year of training, providing a designated curriculum for the specialty, but no residency credit is given for the OGME-1 year. Option 2 specialty programs will make arrangements for the OGME-1 preliminary year for their students. In the Match, students will match to one program that incorporates both the specialty residency program and the prerequisite OGME-1 year. Thus, for purposes of the Match, there will be no practical difference between Option 1 and Option 2 specialties. Option 2 specialties are Diagnostic Radiology, Neuromusculoskeletal Medicine and OMT, Ophthalmology, Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, Pathology and Radiation Oncology.
  • Option 3: The specialty requires completion of a separate OGME-1 traditional rotating internship prior to beginning a residency program. Students interested in these specialties will first need to obtain a traditional rotating internship for OGME-1 training, prior to applying for specialty residency training. Option 3 specialties are Dermatology and Preventive Medicine-Public Health. OGME-2 Dermatology positions that start training in 2015 are offered in the Match; students interested in obtaining an OGME-2 Dermatology position through the Match must currently be in or have already completed OGME-1 training. Preventive Medicine-Public Health positions are not offered through the Match; students interested in this specialty should seek this OGME-2 training independent of the Match.
https://natmatch.com/aoairp/aboutoverview.html
 
Which other specialties require this?

Siggy's quote from the AOA match covers the programs on that side.

As far as ACGME, it's program specific, but I believe all advanced ACGME programs work the same as Derm, in that you apply to the program ahead of time, as a 4th year for a PGY-2 position and it really depends on the specific program. Common ones include PM&R, Neurology, RadOnc, etc. Like I said, some may have an attached internship or associated TY, but most will expect you to find one yourself.
 
Siggy's quote from the AOA match covers the programs on that side.

As far as ACGME, it's program specific, but I believe all advanced ACGME programs work the same as Derm, in that you apply to the program ahead of time, as a 4th year for a PGY-2 position and it really depends on the specific program. Common ones include PM&R, Neurology, RadOnc, etc. Like I said, some may have an attached internship or associated TY, but most will expect you to find one yourself.

Is it the norm that programs will have an attached internship or TY?

So are all surgery residencies considered advanced ACGME programs then?

Sorry if the questions are lame, I've never actually known this before so I'm learning a lot!
 
Is it the norm that programs will have an attached internship or TY?

So are all surgery residencies considered advanced ACGME programs then?

Sorry if the questions are lame, I've never actually known this before so I'm learning a lot!

You really have to look at the specific programs. Usually there's an attached internship, but they might only have a fraction of the spots, so you'll have to apply for an internship or pre-lim year. I've also heard in cases where someone matches an advanced program, but no TY/pre-lim, the program they matched in can help them find an affiliated internship or at least has connections worth some internships.

Again, it really depends on the program. Most surgery programs are actually not considered advanced, because they don't require a pre-lim surgery, and are actually categorical. I believe some plastics programs are PGY2, but it's only a handful.

The main ACGME programs that are advanced are:

Anesthesia - a bit less than half of them (most are categorical)
Dermatology - almost all of them
Child Neuro - ~25% of them
Neuro - around half of them
PM&R - around 2/3 of them
Rad Onc - almost all of them
Rads - around 5/6 of them

Then there are some more obscure ones like:

Neuro Developmental Disabilities
Nuclear Medicine
Preventive Medicine
Rads-Nuclear
 
Last edited:
You really have to look at the specific programs. Usually there's an attached internship, but they might only have a fraction of the spots, so you'll have to apply for an internship or pre-lim year. I've also heard in cases where someone matches an advanced program, but no TY/pre-lim, the program they matched in can help them find an affiliated internship or at least has connections worth some internships.

Again, it really depends on the program. Most surgery programs are actually not considered advanced, because they don't require a pre-lim surgery, and are actually categorical. I believe some plastics programs are PGY2, but it's only a handful.

Oh okay. That makes more sense. I did a bit more digging myself and got some more explanation here. Thanks again!
 
Oh okay. That makes more sense. I did a bit more digging myself and got some more explanation here. Thanks again!

I edited the post above before I saw your reply.

The easiest way to see what programs do is to look at the NRMP match data from 2014. Pages 4-5 list the matches and separates them by PGY-1, PGY-2 (advanced positions) and the much less common "R" positions that are basically for people in an internship, kind of similar to the way AOA Derm works.
 
I edited the post above before I saw your reply.

The easiest way to see what programs do is to look at the NRMP match data from 2014. Pages 4-5 list the matches and separates them by PGY-1, PGY-2 (advanced positions) and the much less common "R" positions that are basically for people in an internship, kind of similar to the way AOA Derm works.

I just reread. Thank you again for the explanation. Are you in your 4th year right now? You are a wealth of information regarding these things!
 
I just reread. Thank you again for the explanation. Are you in your 4th year right now? You are a wealth of information regarding these things!

Haha no, 2nd year. I've just spent way too much time looking into this stuff and talking to a bunch of different people about it. It also helps that I'm related to a bunch of docs, two of which either have in the past or currently are involved in ACGME residencies and fellowships as APDs.
 
Haha no, 2nd year. I've just spent way too much time looking into this stuff and talking to a bunch of different people about it. It also helps that I'm related to a bunch of docs, two of which either have in the past or currently participate in ACGME residencies and fellowships as APDs.

Must be a great thing to have those connections early! Now you're prepared!
 
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
Must be a great thing to have those connections early! Now you're prepared!

Connections are useful, but unfortunately for me, both are in some of the few fields I'm actually pretty certain I wouldn't want to do/wouldn't fit into. I'm keeping an open mind, especially since I expect to have a much better idea of what I want come 3rd year, but I'm pretty certain I will not be applying to any programs in those fields.

It does help in terms of getting an inside look at what some programs look for.