Overrated career?

Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

coloradocutter

Junior Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
I actually found the description of a clinical psychologist offensive - like all of us want to be primarily in private practice with a psychodynamic method? I think it's way too narrow for me to take seriously. Plus, for someone who needs therapy, I would never send them to a "personal coach." And, I worked at a clinic, and I know that a lot of clients call specifically looking for clinical psychologists.
 
Agreed. Just shows how much people don't get what we do 😀
 
I actually found the description of a clinical psychologist offensive - like all of us want to be primarily in private practice with a psychodynamic method? I think it's way too narrow for me to take seriously. Plus, for someone who needs therapy, I would never send them to a "personal coach." And, I worked at a clinic, and I know that a lot of clients call specifically looking for clinical psychologists.

the idea of doing counseling full time, year after year -- hello burnout!

"You'll work one-on-one with clients in a private, peaceful setting, helping them conquer their inner demons."


i want to do clinical work, and i still have the dream of being able to do the whole balanced thing, but i have trouble believing that many folks who have worked so hard for so many years to get into a good program still have that idealized idea of what being a full time clinician is. not that it others wouldn't find that prospect awesome, but i think we all see how very very real world hard it would be to deal with "inner demons" full time.
 
Also, people are turning toward short-term cognitive therapists or personal coaches, who focus less on analyzing your childhood and more on developing pragmatic, step-by-step plans for solving problems, moving forward, and reaching goals.

Do they not realize that clinical psychologists can do cognitive-behavioral therapy??
 
I agree that the ridiculous caricature of psychologists in the article is overrated.

My favorite part was when the article talked about physiological bases for disorders. Because no psychologists study THAT.
 
If anyone was trying to become a clinical psychologist with THAT stated goal, they would be dissapointed when they were done with grad school.
 
It also does a lovely job of ignoring the extant research on the efficacy of psychotherapy, especially examining therapy v. medication.
 
I also particularly enjoy that "Behavioral geneticist" was on the list of best careers.

Guess what many of the folks doing behavioral genetics work have a degree in? I'll give you a hint. It starts with Clinical and ends with Psychology.
 
And who's questioning their own value? Since when does the idea that psychological disorders have biological components preclude the efficacy of psychosocial treatments?

My least favorite part of the article was where they recommended being a life coach instead. Oh yeah, there's no need for any training or scientific backing to do psychotherapy-- anyone with two ears and a heart can do our job, right?

Ugh.
 
Yeah psychology is really way overrated. All those ahead of me on the waitlists should try med school or something. 😛
 
As someone who's been an Educator and a Small Business Owner, I found the descriptions of those jobs also to be overly pessimistic. Hey, look, I just happened to find the minutes from a US News Editorial Board Meeting here on my desk. I'll type in what it says:😀

"In order to boost sagging sales of our slanted news reporting, let's publish completly subjective lists of things. What should we start with? Hey, everyone has a job, right? Lets find some of the most common jobs and tell everyone why the suck. That will make everyone want to read the article to see what smack we had to deliver about their life's work. Yeah! And then, some student based medical training website on the interblog will link to us and a teacher/small business owner/grad school applicant will type this onto their page."

Hey, who knew? I guess good news doesn't sell magazines.:laugh:
 
If you notice all of the overrated careers, it's very anti-education. Don't be a psychologist, be a life coach. Don't be a doctor, be a physician's assistant. Don't be a scientist, be a medical librarian. Seriously?!

The author basically only thinks of careers in terms as time invested in education, and stress/income once you work. That's simplistic and naive. Some people enjoy their education, and I think it can also be stressful to constantly be a assistant or in a role where you're not an expert. I also think he used to be a school psychologist, and has some sort of personal vendetta against clinical psychologists and the efficacy of psychotherapy.

By the way, your posts sound a lot like Chicken Little. Just an observation. ;-)
 
I would just like to point out that if you click on the author's name in that article it takes you to this website http://www.martynemko.com/ which is the author's site for promoting his own career as ...you guessed it LIFE COACH...talk about irony. Also, he is apparently somewhat of a controversial character in blogland

http://anarchogeek.com/articles/2006/04/16/marty-nemko-is-a-racist

http://www.bizstone.com/2006/04/marty-nemko-racist-or-jackass.html

So I wouldn't put too much stock in the worth of that article...:laugh:
 
What do you guys think is the reason we sit back and let people misrepresent what we do (or what we will be doing in the future)?
 
Is there another organization that ranks programs?
National Research Council: http://www.socialpsychology.org/clinrank.htm

There last review was in 2005 for clinical programs. I'm not sure how valid these rankings are either. Usually, rankings usually include lots of bizarre things that have very little import with respect to educational quality and so forth.

NRC based their 2005 clinical psych rankings on faculty publications and citation, from a study done by LSU (see the following: Matson, J. L., Malone, C. J., Gonzalez, M. L., McClure, D. R., Laud, R. B., & Minshawi, N. F. (2005). Clinical psychology Ph.D. program rankings: Evaluating eminence on faculty publications and citations. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 26, 503-513. )

And surprise, surprise! LSU ranks #6 below UC-Berkeley. I think US News (equally unreliable) would disagree.

Another NRC ranking of clincal programs was done in 1997: http://www.socialpsychology.org/clinrank1997.htm

This one ranks by EPPP score. With any of these rankings, you should note the disclaimers. For example:
"Of course, EPPP scores are only one measure of clinical training, and the use of average EPPP scores as an index of graduate program quality does not take into account pre-existing differences in student training and test-taking ability. Nonetheless, EPPP scores provide one useful way to objectively assess clinical training. According to the report cited above, high EPPP scores are associated with larger faculty-to-student ratios, smaller-sized clinical programs, and traditional Ph.D. programs rather than Psy.D. or Ed.D. programs."

I haven't seen any other websites that rank psychology (specifically clinical psychology) graduate programs. But again, I wouldn't think rankings would be that telling b/c you're usually working with a specific mentor. Mentor quality and training opportunities can vary not only between programs, but within them as well.

When trying to decide on which programs to apply to, faculty match with research interests was probably my #1 criteria. If you're accepted to a program, I think the best way to assess its quality is to talk to former and current students. With any luck, you'll talk to enough students (hopefully honest ones) to decide whether or not a program is right for you.
 
If anyone is interested, I know there have been some good discussions on the past about this, so a quick search will turn up some good info.

In regard to EPPP scores, it is important to keep in mind that people are looking to pass and may not be looking to ace it. I know colleagues who have studied and purposely paid attention to certain areas more than others because of the breakdown of the various areas, so they don't care as much about something like I/O related topics, which means they probably will not score well in those areas. I think of it like, "B=Ph.D.".
 
National Research Council: http://www.socialpsychology.org/clinrank.htm

There last review was in 2005 for clinical programs. I'm not sure how valid these rankings are either. Usually, rankings usually include lots of bizarre things that have very little import with respect to educational quality and so forth.

NRC based their 2005 clinical psych rankings on faculty publications and citation, from a study done by LSU (see the following: Matson, J. L., Malone, C. J., Gonzalez, M. L., McClure, D. R., Laud, R. B., & Minshawi, N. F. (2005). Clinical psychology Ph.D. program rankings: Evaluating eminence on faculty publications and citations. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 26, 503-513. )

And surprise, surprise! LSU ranks #6 below UC-Berkeley. I think US News (equally unreliable) would disagree.

Another NRC ranking of clincal programs was done in 1997: http://www.socialpsychology.org/clinrank1997.htm

This one ranks by EPPP score. With any of these rankings, you should note the disclaimers. For example:
"Of course, EPPP scores are only one measure of clinical training, and the use of average EPPP scores as an index of graduate program quality does not take into account pre-existing differences in student training and test-taking ability. Nonetheless, EPPP scores provide one useful way to objectively assess clinical training. According to the report cited above, high EPPP scores are associated with larger faculty-to-student ratios, smaller-sized clinical programs, and traditional Ph.D. programs rather than Psy.D. or Ed.D. programs."

I haven't seen any other websites that rank psychology (specifically clinical psychology) graduate programs. But again, I wouldn't think rankings would be that telling b/c you're usually working with a specific mentor. Mentor quality and training opportunities can vary not only between programs, but within them as well.

When trying to decide on which programs to apply to, faculty match with research interests was probably my #1 criteria. If you're accepted to a program, I think the best way to assess its quality is to talk to former and current students. With any luck, you'll talk to enough students (hopefully honest ones) to decide whether or not a program is right for you.

This is great information, clinpsychjack, thank you! I created a new thread about this specifically so I don't totally hijack this thread.

One more question though, how were you able to contact current and former students?
 
This is great information, clinpsychjack, thank you! I created a new thread about this specifically so I don't totally hijack this thread.

One more question though, how were you able to contact current and former students?
Glad to help! I contacted current students mostly on interview day, and a lot of them were nice enough to give me their email addresses in case I had any additional questions after the interview.

For former students, I just asked my POIs if they could provide the email/contact info. for their former students. One POI only came to his school recently, so none of his students are "out there" yet, but he was able to give me the email addresses of all of his former students and I talked to several of them. My other POI, who's been a faculty member at her school for 15 years, chose three former students who are have taken various career paths (research, program evaluation, practice, etc.) and I spoke with each of them over the phone.

Overall, I highly recommend talking to students. They're the only ones who really know what it's like to be in the program and have your POI as a mentor. Also, if a lot of them end up in research-oriented or practice-oriented careers (vs. a mixture or balance of both), then you can guage what kinds of careers the program will best prepare you for should you accept the offer.
 
Yeah, it seems pretty clear to me that the author of that article has little to no clue what so ever as to what clinical psychologists actually do... too bad that his view is reinforcing misconceptions that many continue to believe in