Pain Is A Great EM Subspecialty That You Should Think About

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Birdstrike

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Dec 19, 2010
Messages
10,310
Reaction score
13,725
Doing an Interventional Pain fellowship is something that's open to EM residents and physicians, just as much as it is to Anesthesiologist and Physiatrists. You should look into it. It's a whole different world, and a whole different life. Sleeping at night, and being awake during the day. Spine epidurals, joint injections, nerve blocks, nerve ablations, using fluoro/ultrasound, joint injections, placing spinal cord stimulators. Cool procedures. I have a 2 level kyphoplasty on a cancer patient coming up this week. It's awesome stuff. It's not what you think it is. It is not "seeing EM drug seekers 100% of the time." Keep your EM boards and do as much or little EM along with it, as you want.

Bye bye, shift work sleep disorder. Sleep, normalcy, 90% less stress and a normal life. Look into it.
 
Doing an Interventional Pain fellowship is something that's open to EM residents and physicians, just as much as it is to Anesthesiologist and Physiatrists. You should look into it. It's a whole different world, and a whole different life. Sleeping at night, and being awake during the day. Spine epidurals, joint injections, nerve blocks, nerve ablations, using fluoro/ultrasound, joint injections, placing spinal cord stimulators. Cool procedures. I have a 2 level kyphoplasty on a cancer patient coming up this week. It's awesome stuff. It's not what you think it is. It is not "seeing EM drug seekers 100% of the time." Keep your EM boards and do as much or little EM along with it, as you want.

Bye bye, shift work sleep disorder. Sleep, normalcy, 90% less stress and a normal life. Look into it.

Is there a list of programs that accept EM folks?
 
Is there a list of programs that accept EM folks?
You can apply to all of them, regardless of what their websites say. As of 2014, EM is as much officially part of Pain Medicine, as is anesthesiology. Pain became a multi-specialty subspecialty, several years before that, actually.

I can private message the programs that gave me interviews if you want. You can also check the Pain forum, which has a bunch of stuff on this. But the bottom line is, if your an EM physician applying to Pain fellowships, you should apply to all of them. Literally, all of them.

There is no better background from which to go into Pain Medicine, than Emergency Medicine. None.
 
whats the money look like doing pain and EM?
 
Doing an Interventional Pain fellowship is something that's open to EM residents and physicians, just as much as it is to Anesthesiologist and Physiatrists. You should look into it. It's a whole different world, and a whole different life. Sleeping at night, and being awake during the day. Spine epidurals, joint injections, nerve blocks, nerve ablations, using fluoro/ultrasound, joint injections, placing spinal cord stimulators. Cool procedures. I have a 2 level kyphoplasty on a cancer patient coming up this week. It's awesome stuff. It's not what you think it is. It is not "seeing EM drug seekers 100% of the time." Keep your EM boards and do as much or little EM along with it, as you want.

Bye bye, shift work sleep disorder. Sleep, normalcy, 90% less stress and a normal life. Look into it.

All my anesthesiology friends are doing this to avoid nights and horrible hospital hours. The patients sound like the worst of the worst, but you're not as constrained by EMTALA, I guess.

My buddy applying to pain right now says that most of the good programs look at anesthesia only. Seems like it's hard to get a decent spot out of EM, from what I hear, which is admittedly just word of mouth.
 
All my anesthesiology friends are doing this to avoid nights and horrible hospital hours.
Yes. They deal with it too, just like us.

The patients sound like the worst of the worst, but you're not as constrained by EMTALA, I guess.
Incorrect. The worst of the worst are the ones you see in the ED. I used to see them in the ED, but I don't anymore. That's EM's baby.

My buddy applying to pain right now says that most of the good programs look at anesthesia only.
This is not the way it's supposed to be, but undoubtedly the way it is at some programs. The only way to change it, is for EM people to keep applying, everywhere, until they break through. The best way is to overwhelm the system with sheer volume. Anesthesia can get away with applying to 10 programs. If you're EM, you need to apply to all 80 or 90, to find the programs open to EM. Looking at websites isn't enough. Many that said "Anesthesia and PMR only" gave me interviews. But once you find the programs that don't inappropriately discriminate against EM, not only are you not at a disadvantage, in some ways you're at a greater advantage. The programs that value multidisciplinary inclusion, are looking to add less common specialties. They consider it an asset. They realize your specialty will learn things from them, and they'll learn things from you, that none of us might expect. They value the cross pollination. It makes everyone more well rounded.

At these programs your stock goes up, and may actually be higher than those of Anesthesia. But don't go by websites and rule places out easily. The only way to decrease your chances of an interview to zero is to not apply. So, apply, apply, apply!

Seems like it's hard to get a decent spot out of EM, from what I hear, which is admittedly just word of mouth.
Correct. It's "hard to get a decent spot" coming from an EM background. But I got one. And I personally know of several others who have, too (less than 10, I'm sure there's many more). Perhaps unexpectedly, the programs EM people are getting into are not the bottom of the barrel, they have tended to be at the stronger programs, at big academic places. I think that is partly because the bigger, stronger, more academic programs are more on the forefront of the fact that Pain is multidisciplinary. Also, the bigger academic places are more used to having multiple trainees of multiple specialties, constantly floating in and out of off service rotations. Plus, some of the smaller, lesser know programs may not actually even know EM has been an official since 2014. Another factor is that many of the worst programs, scut out their fellows to do general anesthesia call, which is a horrible waste of time during a pain fellowship where you only have 12 months to learn and entire specialty. These places necessarily avoid people from non-anesthesia specialties because they're not going to be as useful as scut monkey's placed there to make anesthesia attendings OB call nights, cozier. You wouldn't want to go to these programs. Learning to do OB epidurals would be a horrible waste of time for someone who wants to practice office based Pain Medicine. You'd be much better off getting a good night's rest, so you can scrub a spinal cord stimulator, kyphoplasty or fluoro-guided epidural steroid injections the next day, rather than help an anesthesia attending get REMs.

Then, there's the politics of Pain. Some anesthesia people feel they "own" the subspecialty, that it's their "turf." There's no quick for this, other than to be persistent. If their track record with protecting their specialty from CRNAs is any predictor (it is) then it's only a matter of time before this firewall collapses spectacularly. They don't own it. Not at all.

The biggest barrier to EM physicians going into this fellowship, is the EM physician mindset. Many don't know, or think about it. Many have incorrect information and think it's something other than what it is, and therefore don't see it as highly desirable as their Anesthesia and PM&R counterparts do. Also, there's an inferiority complex that "I'm must not be as good as anesthesia" for this specialty. That's wrong. Emergency Physicians are equally, if not better trained for Interventional Pain than anesthesia, assuming the Pain fellowship is training you to become a Pain physician and not scutting you out to take call for anesthesia doing things irrelevant to the practice of Pain Medicine. If you can thrive in EM, you will absolutely ROCK a Pain fellowship, no problem. You have my personal guarantee.
 
Last edited:
To follow one of the above posters, what's the change in pay compared to ED? Obviously not the only factor, but definitely something important.
 
To follow one of the above posters, what's the change in pay compared to ED? Obviously not the only factor, but definitely something important.
I tried to private message you some info but it says your profile is locked. Search MGMA averages.
 
Current EM and Pain physician here. Best decision ever. I do both. Haven't worked a night shift in over a year. Happy with the money. I think $ wise way more opportunity for growth as opposed to EM where you kinda start high but other than working more shifts or getting into other consultant type of activities your at your peak.
 
where can you view fellowship options? why does the ASRA say all applicants must be enrolled or have completed an anesthesia residency? Are those not an option for EM trained docs?
 
Pain is way harder to get now than when the previous poster(s) did their fellowships. It's also a match now, which is always harder IMO for nontrads. But none of that should dissuade anyone.
 
where can you view fellowship options? why does the ASRA say all applicants must be enrolled or have completed an anesthesia residency? Are those not an option for EM trained docs?
I'm not sure. Is someone is trying some monkey business (trying to protect turf and shut out) or at a minimum dissuade, perfectly qualified people out of a specialty?

Hopefully not.

Regardless, Pain has never been a "one specialty" subspecialty. Not now, not 5 years ago, no 25 years ago. PM&R, EM, FM, Radiology, Psychiatry, Neurology and Anesthesiology all are official specialties. That's the official stance. The unofficial stance is that many specialties see patients in acute and chronic pain in high numbers and it's absurd for one specialty to think they own it "cuz turf." Blind epidurals without fluoro, acute peri-operative pain, not writing any kind of prescriptions and not managing patients over time, is 0.0000001% of Pain Medicine. Ultimately, Pain needs its own residency. It's too much to learn in 1 year. But until then, it's not and cannot be a "one specialty" subspecialty.

Do you have a link or a screenshot of this ASRA statement you're referring to, so I can see it?
 
Last edited:
@Jlaw

This is directly from NRMP Match website. Notice that under Pediatric Anesthesia Fellowship it says you must have completed a "residency in Anesthesiology" and under Pain it says you must have completed a "U.S. or Canadian residency"?

When I applied, it was the last year before the Pain match. So, I'm not up to date on the specifics of the match. I had to apply to each program individually which was incredibly labor intensive. (Some programs may still not be part of the match, but can and should be, applied to separately). Make some phone calls to ABEM, ABA and NRMP and post what they tell you. But what I do know is that Pain Medicine is an official subspecialty of EM and you have every right to do an accredited fellowship and get board certified. American Board of Medical Specialties (ABMS) is another phone call you could make, to confirm that.

It is true that some programs will immediately throw you application in the garbage once they see "Emergency Medicine." But that should not dissuade you, and there's no better way to find out which will have the opposite reaction, but to apply. Once you've got an interview, you've got a shot somewhere greater than 0%. But if you don't apply, your chance is 0% and guaranteed to never be higher. Fear of rejection should never be a reason to avoid making an attempt. That's self rejecting.
 

Attachments

  • Match.PNG
    Match.PNG
    212.3 KB · Views: 205
Last edited:
American Board of Emergency Medicine (ABEM) has the info on how Emergency Physicians can go about subspecialty training in Pain Medicine.

https://www.abem.org/public/become-certified/subspecialties/pain-medicine

Take note, that "Anesthesiology Critical Care Medicine" is also an official subspecialty of Emergency Medicine. So, no surprise that Emergency Medicine and anesthesiology have an intersection also in the world of Pain Medicine.

https://www.abem.org/public/become-certified/subspecialties/anesthesiology-critical-care-medicine

cc @Jlaw
 
Last edited:
Continued:
 

Attachments

  • FM.PNG
    FM.PNG
    18.7 KB · Views: 156
  • PsychNeuro.PNG
    PsychNeuro.PNG
    49.2 KB · Views: 151
  • Rads.PNG
    Rads.PNG
    26 KB · Views: 170
i'll look through all the stuff you posted, this is what I was referencing, a list of fellowships...maybe out of date or not accurate? Anesthesia and EM are beginning to intertwine, I read there is going to be an anesthesia/EM combined residency and anesthesia/CC is indeed open for EM trained docs.

Fellowship directory - American Society of Regional Anesthesia and Pain Medicine

Physicians applying for a fellowship program in regional anesthesiology/acute pain medicine must be currently enrolled in, or have completed, an accredited anesthesiology residency program. Each individual program may have additional requirements such as medical licensing. The information published here has been supplied by the individual institutions. Please check back frequently for updates.
 
also doesn't an anesthesia residency prepare you for this? why TF would they need to do another year to learn how to manage sciatica, et al.
 
wrong thread
 
Last edited:
i'll look through all the stuff you posted, this is what I was referencing, a list of fellowships...maybe out of date or not accurate? Anesthesia and EM are beginning to intertwine, I read there is going to be an anesthesia/EM combined residency and anesthesia/CC is indeed open for EM trained docs.

Fellowship directory - American Society of Regional Anesthesia and Pain Medicine

Physicians applying for a fellowship program in regional anesthesiology/acute pain medicine must be currently enrolled in, or have completed, an accredited anesthesiology residency program. Each individual program may have additional requirements such as medical licensing. The information published here has been supplied by the individual institutions. Please check back frequently for updates.
That is what is commonly referred to as a "Regional" fellowship. That is anesthesia only. Those are for anesthesiologists that want to stay in hospital-based OR anesthesia, not to practice outpatient Pain Medicine or what you hear called "interventional" Pain Medicine. When you hear about people talking about "going into Pain" they're not talking about a regional fellowship but a Pain Fellowship. Totally different.
 
Last edited:
also doesn't an anesthesia residency prepare you for this?
No, not at all. My co-fellows who were anesthesia graduates had just as much to learn as I did. I'm sure they would freely admit they needed the fellowship as much as I did.

why TF would they need to do another year to learn how to manage sciatica, et al.
Because anesthesia residents spend the majority of their time in the hospital, doing OR related anesthesia or non-image guided labor epidurals. That is very different than taking care of patients with chronic pain in an outpatient setting. 99% of Pain Medicine is not that.
 
May I ask the EM pain docs here what the typical set up is?

Work for a hospital/system and what do they pay/hr?
open your own clinic and how much do you make/hr?

The reason I ask is unless you are making over $200./hr or just love doing pain, it really isn't worth it currently esp when you can work in slow/sleepy ERs/FSERs for close to 200/hr doing very little work like posting on SDN
 
May I ask the EM pain docs here what the typical set up is?

Work for a hospital/system and what do they pay/hr?
open your own clinic and how much do you make/hr?

The reason I ask is unless you are making over $200./hr or just love doing pain, it really isn't worth it currently esp when you can work in slow/sleepy ERs/FSERs for close to 200/hr doing very little work like posting on SDN

I work for a private group. Its salaried. 9-5 M-F, no call, weekends or holidays. The intensity is so much less than an ER shift. I think long term you come out ahead given you can become a partner (which is not guaranteed by any means). Currently in my region I am def making more per year than the ER docs that work full time at the place I moonlight at. There is also incentive bonuses for your procedures, ASC share buy ins and more businessey side of things which I think overtime will greatly outpace the EM pay which for most of us is work and collect a pay check. Different strokes though nothing wrong with either. Overall I'd say depending on region the start paying could be similar but EM your kinda capped unless you pick up more shifts, pain there is a lot more room for advancement. Plus procedures are fun.
 
7:30-12:00, 1:00-4:30 Monday through Thursday.
7:30-11:30 Fridays.
No nights, now weekends, no call, no holiday's. Ever.

Mean Pain MGMA > Mean EM MGMA

Procedures days are great.
Clinic days can be boring.
Stress is 95% less than EM.

With the pendulum swinging very much against opiates, nationally, I personally think this is the best time to go into Pain in the last 30 years.
 
7:30-12:00, 1:00-4:30 Monday through Thursday.
7:30-11:30 Fridays.
No nights, now weekends, no call, no holiday's. Ever.

Mean Pain MGMA > Mean EM MGMA

Procedures days are great.
Clinic days can be boring.
Stress is 95% less than EM.

With the pendulum swinging very much against opiates, nationally, I personally think this is the best time to go into Pain in the last 30 years.

I have heard mixed reviews on the future of pain when searching these forums. Do you think it'll still be a good option in 5-10 years?

Med student here interested in pain. Although I know it isn't smart to make a residency choice based off of future fellowship aspirations, two of my top interests (EM and gas) both have pain as a fellowship option so I have been trying to research/gain some clinical exp in pain
 
Hey Birdstrike thanks so much for all this, can you PM me, I'm thinking about applying to Pain this year
 
Top