Penn State vs MCW

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

PlayfulT-Rex

New Member
Joined
Feb 23, 2024
Messages
4
Reaction score
1
I appreciate any insights or opinions on what you would do in my shoes, I’m completely torn between these two great schools!

Things about me:
  • I’m from the D.C. area
  • I’ll be fully covering the cost of medical school on my own through loans and whatever aid I receive (have not received offers yet)
  • I’m currently interested in some of the more competitive specialties such as ortho, IR, anesthesiology, ENT, but am still keeping options open
  • The most important factor for me is being able to successfully match into one of these specialties (ideally east coast but not a requirement), but not far behind are cost of attendance and proximity to significant other (also lives in D.C. and cannot move due to his job) and family
Penn State:

Pros:
  • Cheaper (COA: ~93k if living on campus, ~100k if living off campus)
  • Much closer to support system, only a 2 hour drive
  • Strong match list in competitive specialties (many of which are on the east coast which is a pro)
  • School seems to have strong research opportunities across many specialties
  • P/F Preclinicals. Honors/Pass/Fail Clerkships. No internal ranking.
  • Super cheap to live on campus
  • While there is nothing in Hershey, they’re in the middle of many cities (DC, Baltimore, Philly, NY)
  • Students do seem happy and have minimal complaints (besides location, they were very open about disliking Hershey)
Cons:
  • Being in Hershey is a big con for me, I think I would prefer being in a city with an abundance of things to do (how much does this really matter while being busy in school?)
  • Rural feel. Seems like hershey park carries the area and there is nothing else to do
  • Little breaks within the curriculum (finish one block on a Friday and jump straight into the next on the following Monday)
  • In-house exams, which includes free response questions
  • Living situation seems meh. On-campus housing seems pretty depressing and price increases if you live off-campus
Medical College of Wisconsin:

Pros:
  • Located in a city - plenty of things to do
  • Significant research opportunities built into the curriculum (very interested in scholarly concentration program)
  • Ability to work with diverse population and be in an urban setting
  • Living situation - ability to either live in Suburbs of Milwaukee or in the city, with plenty of options and nicer places to live
  • Also strong match list in competitive specialties
  • P/F Preclinicals. Honors/Pass/Fail Clerkships. No internal ranking.
  • Spiral weeks between blocks, gives a week off lecture to recharge (still have some mandatory events but no exams)
Cons:
  • Milwaukee. While I do want to be in a city this is very far from my support system in D.C.
  • Very cold. I love cool weather but I have never experienced weather like Wisconsin
  • While the match list is strong, I wonder if my options to match back to the east coast will be limited in comparison with Penn State
  • Not directly tied to an undergraduate institution. Not sure if this is a true con but it is a standalone med school
  • In-house exams
  • More expensive (COA: 107k)
Any thoughts on insights would be greatly appreciated! Thank you in advance!
 
Last edited:
MCW is yet to give scholarships, but it seems like Penn State is the better fit for you.
 
Top