Personal Statement Critique!

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

ckwsnik

Balto_woof
7+ Year Member
Joined
Feb 18, 2014
Messages
10
Reaction score
0
If anyone would review/critique my personal statement it would be greatly appreciated! please feel free to use any positive/negative feedback and share your thoughts. I really hate writing and it is something that is always hard for me, so any feedback is appreciated.
 
Last edited:
Honestly, this needs a complete overhaul. First off, it's way too long (probably much longer than the cutoff). While there are several grammatical and structural issues, the major problem is content. Your statement largely focuses on irrelevant personal information, and it is very disjointed. I don't mean to sound harsh, but I think you need to entirely redo this. If you're interested, I'd be happy to expand on my suggestions over PM.
 
I agree with mufasha. it is way too long you wont be able to upload it to aadsas.
you tend to talk to your readers a little too directly. I know youre trying to make it sound personal but it is too much
I also think you should focus more on what you learned and how you've grown as a person (ie: how to be a better person, working with people, life experiences) instead of having a long list of stuff you've done. it is impressive, but it doesnt hold my attention and it certainly wont hold an adcom's attention.
maybe brainstorm on what qualities do you want them to see that you have from your story... rather than you telling them. remember: show, dont tell
how can you portray yourself as patient, gentle, and compassionate without saying you are

you have a cool story to tell... you just have to tell it with more impact
PM me if you have any questions
 
thank you Mufasha and Lemondrop for taking the time to read it and i appreciate your feedback. I agree with most of what was said. I wrote this about 6 months ago, then pushed it aside until now. At the time when i was writing it I was not sure of where I was going with it, I just wanted to get it done. Once I came back to it though I realized it was lacking in the areas you mentioned, however, I did not want to start all over so i wanted to see what the student Dr. network thought and what the suggestions were. So far they have been great, it looks like i will have to indeed start over but i appreciate the feedback and suggestions.
 
I agree with Musfasha. If you type this you need to tie everything or make things connect to dentistry rather than giving irrelevant information. Don't mention second person perspective. Use either First or Third. Some things sound too casual also. You can be casual/personal in some parts.
 
also something to keep in mind....
think of a purpose of your statement. it could be... i want them to know i want to help people with my career... or whatever. then tell your story and use what you have done as support. your experiences should enhance your statement but not be the star of the show
 
I agree with the posters above. The way you phrase some sentences such as "As you can tell, family is very important to me" is too casual. That sentence would sound stronger without the "As you can tell" part. This is a good start to a personal statement, but it needs more work.

Also at the end of your fourth paragraph, your ending is very weak. "Being a dentist provides a similar job security as a medical doctor, but it allows for much more free time to spend with those who are close to you. Being a dentist is also fun! I experienced that during my summer internship, and now years later I can see that with my mother and her practice."

1) Why are you mentioning a comparison of a medical doctor in there? It's irrelevant to your story thus far. 2) You can also expand on the "Dentistry is fun" aspect (don't use fun, find better adjectives that describe your point).


These are just a few things.
 
Last edited:
Thank you everyone so far this has been very helpful
 
You really should delete your ps from the thread.
If anyone would review/critique my personal statement it would be greatly appreciated! please feel free to use any positive/negative feedback and share your thoughts. I really hate writing and it is something that is always hard for me, so any feedback is appreciated.


“You want to be what”? or “You want to do what”? Are the most common responses I get when I tell people I want to be a dentist. For some reason, people always seem to be shocked once they find out. As a kid although, I never thought I would be interested in pursuing Dentistry (Any reason dentistry is capitalized?) . In fact, I think my first profession of choice as a youngster was to be a firefighter. A firefighter turned into a policeman, a policeman turned into a professional hockey player, and finally when I arrived at college I decided I was going to study medicine. (This is probably a tale that everyone and their mother experiences.) Even though I grew up as the son of a dentist, the thought of actually becoming one never even crossed my mind. (Any reason to point out how foolish you were?) It was not until I spent a summer doing a compelling internship that I realized how exciting the dental profession is. I choose the internship because my brother had previously completed it and told me of all the wonderful experiences he had. (It's a good thing you had a brother!) I remember my first day and the first patient I observed. A sinus lift was being performed and at the end of the procedure I realized my own jaw was hurting. This was not because of any particular reason, other than the fact that during the procedure I was so amazed at what was going on my jaw was literally dropped for the entire time. Luckily my surgical mask was hiding my facial expression and neither the doctor nor the patient knew of my wonderment. Until that one internship, I simply had no idea of how amazing the profession of dentistry truly is. (Love at first bite.)

After my freshman year of college, I started my oddesy into dentistry. I got reregistered as a dental assistant, and in three short weeks I was already assisting the Doctors of Associates in Periodontics. (Why is doctors capitalized?) At Associates in Periodontics (You are repeating yourself, not to mention starting and ending a sentence with the same wording.) I did everything from taking out the trash, to assisting during implant, restorative and regenerative procedures. Some days I was even in charge of what is known as the “third column”. This is where the post operation patients would come and before the Doctor could arrive it was my job to perform some basic evaluations, as well as afterwards remove any lose sutures or perio-putty. I spent roughly 40-50hrs per week that summer in dental offices around the state of Vermont, and yet the only time I was ever bored was during my hour-long drive to and from the offices and home.

The main doctor I worked under, Dr. Levi, (There are 150K dentists in the US. Do you believe his name is important?) brought me to Tufts for a few days to see what the life of a dental student was like. I attended some classes, seminars, and even was able to assist the dental students themselves in the clinic. Other than my experience assisting at Associates in Periodontics (Is this a plug for the clinic?) that summer, I also had the wonderful opportunity of being able to spend time with Doctors In every other field of Dentisty. I had multiday rotations in Orthodontics, Dental health clinics, Oral and Maxillofacial surgery, General, Pediatric, Prosthodontics, Tempomandibular joint, and Endodontics. (Unless Webster made some recent chanes, none of those are capitalized.) Needless to say, this summer after my freshman year of college really motivated me to pursue dentistry. Due to the excitement, lifestyle, caring of others, accomplishment, and joy that internship provided with me, I knew dentistry was what I wanted to do.

I commonly get the question, however, “are you choosing this profession for yourself or because its in your family?” To be honest, it is both. My mother would never directly pressure me to become a dentist like herself, she never even mentioned it to me once, but growing up around that lifestyle has definitely influenced me indirectly. My mother is a single mother who raised 13 kids. Yes that’s right, 13. I’m (Avoid contractions) the second youngest myself, five are biological, and the rest are adopted from Vietnam, Korea, and the Ukraine. There is a lot of cultural diversity in my household, but I never perceived my siblings as being anything other than my own brothers and sister. I think one of the reasons as to why I’m so close with all of them is because my mother is a dentist. Being a dentist provides a similar job security as a medical doctor, but it allows for much more free time to spend with those who are close to you. Being a dentist is also fun! (This sort of an expression is for fitting of a first grader.) I experienced that during my summer internship, and now years later I can see that with my mother and her practice.

As you can tell, family is very important to me. At the age of six, I lost everything in a house fire except for my family and the shorts (What color were they?) I went to bed in. After the house fire, with thirteen kids homeless and two parents struggling to figure out what to do, my Father became sick, could no longer work and was diagnosed with terminal cancer. At the age of ten my father passed away. The next few years were very hard for my family, my mother, and me, but we all helped out to make ends meet. Things turned for the better when my mother met another man, Mark was his name. Mark grew to be a father like figure for me. He would take me to all of my sports practices and was always there for my family no matter what we needed. Very sadly, eight years later, just three months after marrying my mother, he too passed away from cancer. Adding to these unfortunate events, a little over a year later during my junior year of college one of my brothers also passed away. At this point in my life I was no longer mentally there for school. The thought of quitting crossed my mind, however, my friends and family pushed and helped me to continue and finish the school year. The point is, there are events in everyone’s life that shape who they are today, and for me, these dramatic events have allowed me to acquire a greater appreciation for the surrounding world. It has allowed me to have an unparalleled motivation to become greater than I once was, and has given me a new outlook on life. I am more thankful for what I have and the opportunities I am given. I now do my best not to take everything for granted and try to really appreciate the little things in life. These events have not only taught me to take risks, or to challenge myself and to better those around me, but to also be patient, gentle and passionate. I truly look forward to incorporating these qualities into my dental career and enjoying the lifelong relationships I get to build with my dental family (patients). (Not much in this paragraph that is salvageable.)

My goal for these last few years has been to graduate and attend dental school. As you can see from my transcript I have worked very hard to do so, but I also work very hard on all the other aspects of my life, such as my athletics and hobbies. Along with the dedication I have put into school and extracurricular activities, I am an avid adventurist. It seems every opportunity I get I am traveling to a new place to engage in a wild adventure. Whether it is traveling in a raft down the Grand Canyon, climbing for days at a time to reach the mountain peaks of Washington, going to Africa to swim with and research the great whites, or even going to dental school. The answer is always the same...“Yes, I want to do that”.
 
Im just curious doc toothache, but whats your reasoning on why i should delete the PS from the thread? I wanted to make it available to the public so that they could easily read it and comment.
 
Reason why you want to delete your personal statement because someone can just mimic your idea, and have a faster turn around time. Technically, they could submit their application using your story and background. In fact, if they can steal any ideas.

I am not the best when it comes to a personal statement, but there are few things that you should know.

1.) Whenever you are describing your experiences, be sure to talk about what you gained from the experience, and more importantly how you grow as a person.
2.) If you can, be able to relate your experiences to dentistry. It does not matter if you did not work at a dental office, but be able to articulate your experiences and relating it to dentistry will be great. For example, I volunteer at the hospital. I began talking about how I learned how to interact with patients, and ultimately made me grow as a person with dedication, empathy, etc.
3.) Whenever you are doing a conclusion, you want to make it strong. End it with a powerful sentence of why you ultimately want to be a dentist or what will you do in the future.
4.) Remember, don't fuss over because your personal statement is generic. I am sure that almost everyone's personal statement is generic, however it depends how you present it.
5.) It is also pretty late in applying, I would suggest that you finish the personal statement ASAP if you are applying this cycle. If you do not get in, then work on your weaknesses so it can eventually be your strengths.

Goodluck!
 
Last edited:
BabyShades thanks for the tips and advice! I know it is late, but i plan on deferring until the following year if i were to get in. I understand most schools would just recommend reapplying the following year, but i figured why not at least try.
 
BabyShades thanks for the tips and advice! I know it is late, but i plan on deferring until the following year if i were to get in. I understand most schools would just recommend reapplying the following year, but i figured why not at least try.

Really? You're throwing away thousands of dollars.
 
I understand its not easy. And to me i'm not throwing away "thousands" of dollars, but rather investing about a thousand dollars in the opportunity of having the security of acceptance in a school and also having a year off. Sometimes people are so concerned with money that they forget what its like to live. Im just not one of those people. It might sound crazy manifesto, but to me money is not important.
 
I understand its not easy. And to me i'm not throwing away "thousands" of dollars, but rather investing about a thousand dollars in the opportunity of having the security of acceptance in a school and also having a year off. Sometimes people are so concerned with money that they forget what its like to live. Im just not one of those people. It might sound crazy manifesto, but to me money is not important.

I agree. I'm the first to say money is not important. But there's a difference between investing or even gambling VS. throwing away money. I understand you have high stats, but your personal statement is honestly one of the worst I've seen. And with DAT scores on the up trend and many more people with high stats, I really do believe the rules have changed. People with good stats can no longer just apply whenever they want especially with a bad personal statement. There's people that are already rejected from schools with stats like yours.

Add to that that many schools do not have deferral options unless you can prove a big emergency has happened, there is a chance you will need to apply next year anyways. So there's two reasons that support the fact you're going to just throw away money: 1) good chance you'll be rejected or at least not offered admission because you applied so late and 2) many schools do not have deferral options.

And if "living" is as important as you say it is, then you're probably already set on taking a year off because it'll be your last free summer vacation in your life. Which means regardless of school policy, you'll probably still take a year off and be forced to apply again.

Sorry for being so confrontational, but just make sure you're thinking this through and not be so fanatical with "principles" when making a decision.
 
BabyShades thanks for the tips and advice! I know it is late, but i plan on deferring until the following year if i were to get in. I understand most schools would just recommend reapplying the following year, but i figured why not at least try.

From my consensus, none the schools that I applied to allow deferring matriculation. This isn't med school.

But like @manifesto said, it could be pretty hard to convince a school to let you take a year off. Im fairly certain "I want to live my life" isnt an explanation.


I understand its not easy. And to me i'm not throwing away "thousands" of dollars, but rather investing about a thousand dollars in the opportunity of having the security of acceptance in a school and also having a year off. Sometimes people are so concerned with money that they forget what its like to live. Im just not one of those people. It might sound crazy manifesto, but to me money is not important.

How many schools are you planning on applying to? Personally, Ive applied to about 10 schools and have spent about $2-3k on application fees and travel costs. This isnt including the deposit each school demands after acceptance, ranging anywhere from $500-$1500 nonrefundable.

I think you are a little deluded on the application process. I suggest you do a little more research to clear some of the discrepancies up.
 
Im just curious doc toothache, but whats your reasoning on why i should delete the PS from the thread? I wanted to make it available to the public so that they could easily read it and comment.
Embarrassment, perhaps. But if you are happy, everyone is happy. DS will be happy to receive your "investment".
 
Honestly, my first draft of my PS is very similar to yours. I basically just stated everything I kind of wanted the school to know about me. For my 2nd draft, I picked a direction for the PS and concentrated mainly on one thing. I wasn't happy until I wrote my 3rd draft, which to be honest, included like 10% of the first draft. It's good to get all of your ideas out, but don't have them all in the final PS. If you want to let adcom know about more of your story, there's always the chance of doing that at interviews!

Also, like most have said, I think you should apply next cycle (if I can recall, you're a junior? I could be mistaken.) If so, you'll have a lot of time to think about and edit your PS.
 
we all have to start somewhere, my first draft was a hodge podge of random stuff that I could think of.
Brainstorm, develop, cut, edit, cut, edit, etc, etc.

Keep working on it. Maybe find someone who majored English, or hire someone who'd look at your paper. There are professional people out there if you need.
 
Top