Personal Statement

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Sartre79

Full Member
20+ Year Member
Joined
Mar 29, 2003
Messages
633
Reaction score
8
Points
4,636
Location
Midwest
  1. Resident [Any Field]
Advertisement - Members don't see this ad
I know there are threads about this etc, but instead of searching I thought I would take the most direct route. Anyway, I am trying to get my AMCAS submitted, but my personal statement just isn't coming together. So if anyone would look at it and critique I would be appreciative. Thanks.

I cannot begin to fathom the anguish and pain that Peggy must have felt. I would have done anything to help ease her situation, but Peggy didn’t want sympathy from anyone. Still, I couldn’t help but ponder the injustice of a Kansas school teacher’s struggle against such insurmountable tragedy. I became acquainted with Peggy while working as a sleep technician, and quickly fostered a relationship with her. She always came in with a glow, and even brought baked goods on more than one occasion. Her primary reason for participating in clinical research was not to aid the science of sleep medicine. It was, however, a way to make ends meet due to her husband’s disabling bout with Hepatitis B. Despite her tragedy, Peggy truly inspired me by how gracefully she composed herself. My experiences with Peggy and others have left me with the indelible impression that serving others through medicine is how I want to dedicate my life.
My initial interest in medicine developed during my adolescence. I recall the trust that I had in my physicians, and how comforted I was upon receiving their guidance. Through their care, my physicians did not just fulfill a job qualification, but took the time to build a personal relationship. With every doctor visit, I became more intrigued by the notion that the integration of knowledge and compassion was inseparable when serving others through medicine. The activities and experiences I encountered throughout my collegiate education further instilled the principle that the actions we take can influence an individual’s life—for better or for worse. I believe that I can positively impact the lives of others through medicine.
While at the University of South Dakota, I became very intrigued with studying the various aspects of the human condition, and devoted my undergraduate studies toward humanistic disciplines–philosophy, psychology, and political science. Needless to say, my studies were very eclectic and beneficial because they exposed me to the diversity of human intellect. At the end of my baccalaureate studies, however, I still had a deep desire to study medicine. Subsequently, I began volunteering at Avera Sacred Heart Hospital to gain more exposure to medicine. While volunteering, I experienced a profound sense of personal fulfillment from giving my time and energy to others. Consequently, it was through these experiences and others like them, that I realized how much medicine could perpetuate such fulfillment.
Thus, while my wife was pursuing her Master of Arts in Audiology at the University of South Dakota, I concurrently used this opportunity to begin the necessary prerequisites for admission to medical school. During that time, I also obtained a Master of Business Administration because I felt an MBA would be valuable in future endeavors. Furthermore, it has become increasingly important to have a working knowledge of business in medicine. I believe that the strengths and assets I have acquired from each academic discipline will serve me well as a physician - there is no denying the human element that is intrinsic to medicine, as well as the administrative roles that physicians have come to accept. Studying these fields has given me greater compassion and understanding for the problems and needs that people face, and has developed me into a balanced individual.
Peggy was one of many individuals that have positively impacted my life. She helped me realize the empathy, compassion, and integrity that health care providers must possess. I am fully aware of the rigors and sacrifice required of becoming a physician, but am confident that the opportunities to aid those in need far outweigh the costs. Serving others is not a sacrifice, but a privilege.
 
Sartre79 said:
I know there are threads about this etc, but instead of searching I thought I would take the most direct route. Anyway, I am trying to get my AMCAS submitted, but my personal statement just isn't coming together. So if anyone would look at it and critique I would be appreciative. Thanks.

I cannot begin to fathom the anguish and pain that Peggy must have felt. I would have done anything to help ease her situation, but Peggy didn’t want sympathy from anyone. Still, I couldn’t help but ponder the injustice of a Kansas school teacher’s struggle against such insurmountable tragedy. I became acquainted with Peggy while working as a sleep technician, and quickly fostered a relationship with her. She always came in with a glow, and even brought baked goods on more than one occasion. Her primary reason for participating in clinical research was not to aid the science of sleep medicine. It was, however, a way to make ends meet due to her husband’s disabling bout with Hepatitis B. Despite her tragedy, Peggy truly inspired me by how gracefully she composed herself. My experiences with Peggy and others have left me with the indelible impression that serving others through medicine is how I want to dedicate my life.
My initial interest in medicine developed during my adolescence. I recall the trust that I had in my physicians, and how comforted I was upon receiving their guidance. Through their care, my physicians did not just fulfill a job qualification, but took the time to build a personal relationship. With every doctor visit, I became more intrigued by the notion that the integration of knowledge and compassion was inseparable when serving others through medicine. The activities and experiences I encountered throughout my collegiate education further instilled the principle that the actions we take can influence an individual’s life—for better or for worse. I believe that I can positively impact the lives of others through medicine.
While at the University of South Dakota, I became very intrigued with studying the various aspects of the human condition, and devoted my undergraduate studies toward humanistic disciplines–philosophy, psychology, and political science. Needless to say, my studies were very eclectic and beneficial because they exposed me to the diversity of human intellect. At the end of my baccalaureate studies, however, I still had a deep desire to study medicine. Subsequently, I began volunteering at Avera Sacred Heart Hospital to gain more exposure to medicine. While volunteering, I experienced a profound sense of personal fulfillment from giving my time and energy to others. Consequently, it was through these experiences and others like them, that I realized how much medicine could perpetuate such fulfillment.
Thus, while my wife was pursuing her Master of Arts in Audiology at the University of South Dakota, I concurrently used this opportunity to begin the necessary prerequisites for admission to medical school. During that time, I also obtained a Master of Business Administration because I felt an MBA would be valuable in future endeavors. Furthermore, it has become increasingly important to have a working knowledge of business in medicine. I believe that the strengths and assets I have acquired from each academic discipline will serve me well as a physician - there is no denying the human element that is intrinsic to medicine, as well as the administrative roles that physicians have come to accept. Studying these fields has given me greater compassion and understanding for the problems and needs that people face, and has developed me into a balanced individual.
Peggy was one of many individuals that have positively impacted my life. She helped me realize the empathy, compassion, and integrity that health care providers must possess. I am fully aware of the rigors and sacrifice required of becoming a physician, but am confident that the opportunities to aid those in need far outweigh the costs. Serving others is not a sacrifice, but a privilege.


My first impression is that your essay would flow better if you added a transition before you write "My initial interest in medicine..." In other words, it seems kind of like a mental jump between your talking about the people who have influenced you to pursue medicine and the paragraph about your adolescence.

:luck:
 
i think sierra gives really good advice.

your essay seems short to me. maybe i'm just a bad judge, but it seems like it's probably under the character limit (you can use up to 5,300).

considering that, i think you need to elaborate on your examples. you write about the valuable lesson peggy taught you. but, i think you need to support this more. perhaps, include a specific encounter you had with her.

this is just my opinion, but i think that the political sci, philosophy, etc part is kind of just wasted space. it doesn't really tell the adcom anything besides the fact that you majored in those disciplines - and they already know that.

i think you should really elaborate on your clinical and other volunteer experiences. talk not only about how they had an impact on you, but also explain the things you were able to do and learn. proving that you have what it takes to enter the field of medicine requires not only showing that you've learned things, but also showing that you can do things (i.e., comfort patients, make a difference in the community, etc, etc).

i hope i don't come across too harsh saying this, but i think, right now, it's kind of a hollow shell. i think you have the right idea, but you need to add more significance to it.

i know these are just kind of cursory comments. i haven't volunteered to edit essays in the past and i don't plan on doing so, but if you want, go ahead and PM me and i'll give it a more thorough edit. best of luck.
 
Sartre79 said:
I know there are threads about this etc, but instead of searching I thought I would take the most direct route. Anyway, I am trying to get my AMCAS submitted, but my personal statement just isn't coming together. So if anyone would look at it and critique I would be appreciative. Thanks.

I cannot begin to fathom the anguish and pain that Peggy must have felt. I would have done anything to help ease her situation, but Peggy didn’t want sympathy from anyone. Still, I couldn’t help but ponder the injustice of a Kansas school teacher’s struggle against such insurmountable tragedy. I became acquainted with Peggy while working as a sleep technician, and quickly fostered a relationship with her. She always came in with a glow, and even brought baked goods on more than one occasion. Her primary reason for participating in clinical research was not to aid the science of sleep medicine. It was, however, a way to make ends meet due to her husband’s disabling bout with Hepatitis B. Despite her tragedy (this is the second time you use "tragedy" - pick another word. Your description here is not convincing me that this was a tragedy), Peggy truly inspired me by how gracefully she composed herself. My experiences with Peggy and others have left me with the indelible impression that serving others through medicine is how I want to dedicate my life (Did you serve Peggy? How? If not, how exactly did this convince you that you wanted to serve others?).
My initial interest in medicine developed during my adolescence. I recall the trust that I had in my physicians, and how comforted I was upon receiving their guidance. Through their care, my physicians did not just fulfill a job qualification, but took the time to build a personal relationship. With every doctor visit, I became more intrigued (aware of?) by the notion that the integration of knowledge and compassion was inseparable when serving others through medicine. The activities and experiences I encountered throughout my collegiate (college) education further instilled the principle that the actions we take can influence an individual’s life—for better or for worse. (What activities? And HOW did they convince you that you can positively impact the lives of others? You really need to go into more detail about this. You should use this as the intro to a paragraph that goes into more detail about this topic, not as the last sentence in a paragraph.) I believe that I can positively impact the lives of others through medicine.
While at the University of South Dakota, I became very (delete very) intrigued with studying the various aspects of the human condition, and devoted my undergraduate studies toward humanistic disciplines–philosophy, psychology, and political science. Needless to say, my studies were very eclectic and beneficial because they exposed me to the diversity of human intellect. (How is this relevent to medicine?) At the end of my baccalaureate studies, however, I still had a deep desire to study medicine. Subsequently, I began volunteering at Avera Sacred Heart Hospital to gain more exposure to medicine. While volunteering, I experienced a profound sense of personal fulfillment from giving my time and energy to others (How? What were you doing there? Explain what you did and then give a specific example of a time when you felt particularly fulfilled). Consequently, it was through these experiences and others like them (What other experiences?), that I realized how much medicine could perpetuate such fulfillment.
Thus, while my wife was pursuing her Master of Arts in Audiology at the University of South Dakota, I concurrently used this opportunity to begin the necessary prerequisites for admission to medical school. During that time, I also obtained a Master of Business Administration because I felt an MBA would be valuable in future endeavors (Did you really obtain an MBA b/c you felt it would be valuable in medicine? That's not really a normal path to take, so I think that you should give some additional details about your motivation here). Furthermore, it has become increasingly important to have a working knowledge of business in medicine. I believe that the strengths and assets (not sure "strengths and assets makes total sense here) I have acquired from each academic discipline will serve me well as a physician - there is no denying the human element that is intrinsic to medicine (intrinsic to medicine? I'd rephrase this and try and explain in more detail exactly how you think your undergrad studies will help YOU as a doctor), as well as the administrative roles that physicians have come to accept. Studying these fields has given me greater compassion and understanding for the problems and needs that people face, and has developed me into a balanced individual (this sentence does a better job of explaining what you're trying to say. You might want to just delete the previous sentence. I also think you're bouncing around a little to much from undergrad studies to MBA back to undergrad - pick one, explain how it will be helpful to you as a physician, and move on to the next. Also, "developed me into a balanced individual" may or may not be grammatically correct, but it sounds funny.).
Peggy was one of many individuals that have positively impacted my life. She helped me realize the empathy, compassion, and integrity that health care providers must possess. I am fully aware of the rigors and sacrifice required of becoming a physician (are you? how?), but am confident that the opportunities to aid those in need far outweigh the costs. Serving others is not a sacrifice, but a privilege.


Like the previous poster, I've never really edited someone else's essay before, so you can take my comments however you want to. I really think you need to focus more on any clinical experience that you have and less on your education - the adcoms want to see that you have a good idea of what you're getting yourself into, and I'm not completely convinced of that from your essay. In fact, it seems kind of odd to me that you majored in everything besides science, got an MBA and then decided to go into medicine. I think you can use all this to your benefit, but you really need to show that there is something about medicine that really gets you.
 
It may seem odd to someone who COULD still be an undergraduate. There is a distinct difference between what the Ivory tower teaches and what the work world really wants. There weren't many jobs open pertaining to my degree, plus my wife was getting her Masters in Audiology. I was trapped in a dinky little college town with 2 years to kill....SD doesn't really have much of a thriving economy either. There is a certain extent to which altruism really exists before $$ comes into play. You WILL find this in medicine as well. I spoken to many MD's who wish they would have had a lot more business experience.
 
#1 - I'm not an undergrad
#2 - I didn't write my comments to offend or insult you, you asked for opinions and those are mine. I think that my PS benefitted a lot from others' honest advice.
#3 - I don't doubt that having an MBA will be beneficial to you in medicine, I just think you could explain it better in your PS. As I said, it's not a normal path to take so it wouldn't hurt to explain why you chose it (although I'm assuming that you don't want to put that you decided to get an MBA b/c you didn't have anything else to do.... but there had to be other reasons why you wanted this degree or felt that it would be helpful in the future - which you do go into a little - and I think maybe you could expand upon them).
 
Didn't mean to sound like I was pissed. It is just a complicated issue that I really dont know how to explain, and I have had several dr's tell me that I dont need to explain my reasons (for an MBA) in a personal statement...they will ask me in interviews....But I guess it is a concern of mine, that people may see my degrees and automatically judge me as not dedicated to medicine. Regardless, didn't mean to offend...just wanted to explain the situation. You know what the philosophy major says to the business major..."you want fries with that".
 
Top Bottom