- Joined
- Sep 21, 2005
- Messages
- 596
- Reaction score
- 13
thanks all!
Last edited:
playing internist-light with a small side of rehab
YES! That sums up EXACTLY how I've felt since starting...
Thankfully we have home call which is awesome but I've also had very (VERY) little attending supervision since I started and I feel like I'm left to the dogs about what to read/what I should be learning... even how to go about learning. It's a deja vu of 1st year medical school anatomy almost where you know you have a lot to learn but don't really know how to go about learning it all...
I'm lost as to whether it's my residency program that's the wrong choice or the specialty that's the wrong choice? Or maybe I just feel like a lost 1st yr med student again and need to stick it out and wait for it to get better.
hmm...some interesting and important points to consider and ask about as we M4s are about to embark on interviews. (sorry to hijack your thread)
Agree with all of the above.I would use your patient list to guide your reading. SCI? read the SCI chapter in something basic like Braddom or Delisa to get started. All those textbooks have referenced the major articles which you can pull for more in-depth reading. Each rehab patient may have 12 active rehab problems that each could be a book chapter. (SCI, spasticity, neurogenic bladder, pressure sores, etc)
It's tough being PGY-2 on the wards because you are superfly at medicine but stupid at rehab at this point. Nurses will mock you for not knowing what a magic bullet is. PT staff will mock you for not knowing what an AFO is. OT will mock you for not knowing about tenodesis. SLP will not mock you, they are generally well adjusted people.
Hang in there, learning the lingo is half the battle.
The PTs will just hate you.![]()
I would use your patient list to guide your reading. SCI? read the SCI chapter in something basic like Braddom or Delisa to get started. All those textbooks have referenced the major articles which you can pull for more in-depth reading. Each rehab patient may have 12 active rehab problems that each could be a book chapter. (SCI, spasticity, neurogenic bladder, pressure sores, etc)
It's tough being PGY-2 on the wards because you are superfly at medicine but stupid at rehab at this point. Nurses will mock you for not knowing what a magic bullet is. PT staff will mock you for not knowing what an AFO is. OT will mock you for not knowing about tenodesis. SLP will not mock you, they are generally well adjusted people.
Hang in there, learning the lingo is half the battle.
Why do PTs hate rehab docs?
Why do PTs hate rehab docs?
Just read the thread on mid levels and PM&R.
What they said, and I really was kidding, hence the "Why do PT's hate PM&R?
Well my reflections were mainly from residency and the culture of being a resident in a large academic institution. I think everyone hates residents because we drop in with a white coat and suddenly everyone has to call us doctor and pretend to follow our orders even though we haven't spent 10 years getting hazed and abused and clawing our way up the pecking order like the RN's, PT's. OT's etc. So they get bitter and try to pull you down.
Medicine is a breeze compared to hospital politics.
Putting the old man hat on here. I don't think that life needs to be easy or that you have to like everything you do. Life as a physician is very hard, and not always "directed". It is important to learn "self-directed learning". These skills will help you in your future.I've been polling some of my PGY-2 friends in other specialties. They're all saying the same thing: "I finally get to do what I really like... It's awesome... I'm so psyched I entered this specialty... My choice was right on... etc."
What is wrong with PM&R that this PGY-2 slump is expected and accepted? That we should have to wait a year or two for things to "get better." I think we can and should do better in our residency programs. There's always something to learn, but that doesn't mean it's an optimal learning situation. This is residency. I have higher expectations. A year of my life and training is no small chunk of time. I'm surprised this goes on year after year and we as a specialty accept it.
...Only a certain type of person chooses to be an academic physiatrist on a General inpatient rehab unit. Suffice to say, they are not necessarily our strongest swimmers.
I've been polling some of my PGY-2 friends in other specialties. They're all saying the same thing: "I finally get to do what I really like... It's awesome... I'm so psyched I entered this specialty... My choice was right on... etc."
What is wrong with PM&R that this PGY-2 slump is expected and accepted? That we should have to wait a year or two for things to "get better." I think we can and should do better in our residency programs. There's always something to learn, but that doesn't mean it's an optimal learning situation. This is residency. I have higher expectations. A year of my life and training is no small chunk of time. I'm surprised this goes on year after year and we as a specialty accept it.
PM&R needs to be split into two specialities:
1. Rehab medicine which would be a fellowship after IM or Neuro (code brown!)
2. MSK Medicine which would be all outpatient
problem solved
...the rehab teams usually consist of a PGY2 and an attending only. You don't always have a senior resident (like in medicine) that helps show you the ropes. Furthermore, the medical students are not always the most helpful because they too are learning about the field and still trying to acclimate to the flow. This translates into a majority of the work to be carried by the resident.
They is a TON to learn from your stroke, spinal cord, and TBI patients.
If you simplify/minimize the year down to "I just need to get to the other side," you will miss out on this great opportunity.
Never again will you be able to spend as much time with your patients practicing your examination skills.
I had a variety of experiences depending on the service I was on. You should talk with your chiefs and/or residency director on how to make it a more educational experience for you.Bingo. And my attending is barely ever around. I wish I had time to teach the med students something so they would be more helpful and have a better experience
Been there and through it (recently.) I even contemplated switching to IM about 2 months in. However, I had a heart to heart with an attending who told me to wait until the 3rd and 4th month of PGY2. In his experience, it takes about that long for PGY2s to feel more like a physiatrist. Trust me, it's kind of like "Karate Kid" training where all of it a sudden it clicks. I just tried to take it one day at a time and try to find a learning experience every day. That's a shame that seniors are kind of perpetuating the mood.This is the general attitude of most PGY-2's I encounter and the mantra of my upper level residents. Read the annual PGY-2 Slump thread and this is what everyone keeps saying, except for you Fozz.
The lack of good hand-offs is a crucial point and indicative of our medical education system. Across the board, new graduates leave their med schools knowing nothing about what our field is about. It's no wonder that they don't know how to prepare a patient for transfer. Unfortunately, at my institution, there was not a lot of education for the transferring teams on our end from the leadership end as well.The census and turnover and lack of good hand-offs from other services dictate that I sit in front of the computer the vast majority of my day. Emphasis is on quantity not quality. I hear this echoed from others. I think residencies need some guidelines about how to make PGY-2 a better educational experience. Census caps, admission caps, protected didactics, amount of time the attending should be on service, etc. Yes I am more of an outpatient MSK guy but I still want a good inpatient experience.
I would suggest we get subq heparin for DVT ppx except that the risk of bleeding would be too great from slamming our heads against our keyboards in frustration.
because the pay sucks, and the politics are ridiculous. Oh, and if you don't already have grant money, real research is difficult.I wonder why excellent physiatrists joining academics are only the minority...
The handoff from ICU or the acute hospital side is the PMR consult service job and not the admitting services job. This way your DVT, GI proph, skin check, b/b program, and degree of med stability/ tolerability is done and known and your admit hp is giftwrapped for rehab.
Absolutely, but this only holds true when it's your consult team inside your home institution that also houses the rehab unit. However, this is infinitely more difficult when accepting patients at a stand-alone rehab facility. The quality and utility of the PM&R consult in the transfer records (if there even was one) is at best marginal. Typically, once PM&R rec's acute rehab (and that patient is not going to the consult teams facility).....their input is done unless they were specifically asked to comment on something like meds for spasticity or cognition. The final say re "stable for d/c to rehab" is left to the primary team (can only hope they were put on a medicine/hospitalist service)The handoff from ICU or the acute hospital side is the PMR consult service job and not the admitting services job. This way your DVT, GI proph, skin check, b/b program, and degree of med stability/ tolerability is done and known and your admit hp is giftwrapped for rehab.
teaching programs have been unable to adapt to the rapid decline in rehab stays, reimbursement, and admittable diagnoses. Quads used to stay on rehab for a year, paras for 6 months at least, etc. If you took on a tenuous patient you had weeks to stabilize them and usually they would not decompensate after that. So you did some medicine and watched them rehab for weeks to months. Now you're lucky if you get a month for a new para. Rehab is used to offload overflowing medicine units. You admit constantly because turnover is so fast and your census increases because you need 3 patients to reimburse what 1 used to. You barely stabilize them and then they get a few days of rehab and go home. You don't see much rehab anymore. Everyday is an admit and discharge sprint. Ages ago you admitted 1-2 patients a week because your unit was full of long stay patients. This is turning inpatient rehab into a 2.5-3 year IM internship. Even PGY2 IM's have interns to scut out.
But look at it this way, you're a doctor so you're duty is to practice medicine even if it's not all rehab. So take pride that you're still THE doctor.
Currently, I am a PGY-2 at a pretty good rehab program. However this year has been one of the most frustrating years since I started medical school. I came across this page and I am glad that others have been where I have. The PGY2 year is extremely frustrating due to all the inpatient rehab. I have contemplated switching out and going into Internal Medicine. I came into PMR as a route to do Spine and Sports but its hard to not just slam my head in frustration. My felt more fulfillment during my internship than I do right now, the excitement and logic.
MY question for the people that did answer this a couple years ago; how do you guys feel now? Was it the right decision to tough it out like I keep on hearing? Did you guys end up switching?
I am happy that I stayed. And I was miserable enough that I did consider doing something else. It wasn't just that it was all inpatient though - it was the *lack* of the key items people mentioned above: good teaching, good handoffs, good consult service to liaison, etc. For a variety of reasons, I actually ended up transferring programs (nearly impossible to do BTW). But I've had an awesome PGY3 (including some inpatient) at my new program which has a strong MSK experience. Actually the year has flown by.
Some programs don't front load all the inpatient, but instead give a variety of experiences during the PGY2 year. That's the way my new program does it and I see the PGY2's actually seem pretty happy. I know there are other programs like this. The rule is every program has to have 12 months inpatient rehab and 12 months outpatient rehab. The other 12 months are at the discretion of the individual program. I think programs with 18+ months of inpatient are doing a disservice. The best situation is to have several months of electives - then you can do what you want. But that's another topic.
I feel EXACTLY the same way. I am currently in my PGY2 year at a decent PMR program. I just feel the loss of excitement and drive to go to work in the morning, it is truly depressing. Despite the long and crazy hours internship had - I enjoyed the work and the daily learning. In Rehab, I feel my attendings don't teach, I am monitoring bowels and bladder on a daily basis and the most I've learned in the past 3 months is how I can get my narcotic-addicted patients to take a real good bowel movement. It is just boring and dull and I feel - is this PMR? Is this my life? Because I'd rather do call q4 day than have my weekends and go to work on a daily basis and feel unfulfilled.
I am now at the point where I am considering to transfer out and go into Internal Medicine and need to hear some guidance from PMR vets - as well as residents going through this as well. Has anyone switched to Internal Medicine? Anyone recommend this - I am now three months into my residency and pretty miserable, does it get better? Any advice is appreciated. Thanks!
Okay, what do you want to do long term. I can say that while my PGY2 yr was indeed scut city (and it was 20yrs ago), it was one year of my life. I do not regret my career choice one bit. But my friends in IM who work in outpatient clinics do regret it. Most are looking for non-medical things to do with the rest of their lives, or looking at doing another residency or fellowship (Rads for example). There is no respect for general IM, since people go to specialists for everything, and you are called a provider, not a doctor (because the insurers think that ARNPs and PAs are your equivalent)
The ones that are happy are the hospitalists, but that is because their days are predictable and it is basically shift work.
Whereas I still love my job. I AM the specialist, and my patients and the other docs respect me and my opinion. My friends who do primarily INPT are also happy with their careers (although the happiest seem to work either for the VA or Kaiser).