This is interesting. I had this same thing happen to me a few months ago, and I still can't explain it. I also use a mid SIJ for my initial approach (get an arthrogram with it maybe 1/3 of the time).
Any thoughts on best approach for SIJ? I have a younger patient population, so I figure many of them are more extra articular pain. I target mid SIJ. If I get an arthrogram, I inject half of injectate, pull back to interosseous ligament and posterior sacroiliac ligament, and inject the other half. If I don't get an arthrogram, I simply inject the ligament with half of the injectate, withdraw the needle, and hit the intra-articular joint using the traditional approach at the inferior pole.
Maybe this approach is needlessly over-complex, but I worry the conventional approach doesn't target the pain generator adequately extra-articular SIJ pain.