Sorry, it was late, I made a mistake.
When titrating a weak acid with a strong base, you can estimate the equivalence point with:
pH(eq) = (pKa (initial acid) + pH (titrant base))/2
When titrating a weak base with a strong acid, you can estimate the equivalence point with:
pOH(eq) = (pKb (initial base) + pOH (titrant acid))/2
OR
pH(eq) = (pKa (conjugate acid) + pH (titrant acid))/2
Let's use the second one.
5 = ((pKa) + 1)/2
pKa ~ 9
Really, you don't have to do any math for this problem. You know that the pKb has to be above the equivalence point (when titrating a base). The equivalence point is the point at which you've added an equal number of moles of your strong acid to your initial number of moles of your weak base. That means that, at the equivalence point, ALL of the A- (base) you initially had in solution will be neutralized by the H+ (titrant acid). And you know that the pKa is the point at which HALF of your A- is neutralized (because A- = HA).
When dealing with titrations, you can think of the pKa (of your conjugate acid) as being your HALF-equivalence point, where the vol. of titrant you have added is HALF of what it would be at the equivalence point. When dealing with a titration curve where the y-axis is pH, we are only dealing with pKas. If you're titrating an acid, the half-equivalence point is the pKa of your initial acid. If you're titrating a base, the half-equivalence point is the pKa of your conjugate base.
If the y-axis is pOH, than the graph gets flipped upside down, and all values are really just (14 - what they were before). Now you're dealing with pKb. If you're titrating an acid, it's the pKb of the conjugate base. If you're titrating a base, it's the pKb of the base.
Hope that clears things up!