Please helpchoosing between two medical schools

Started by tjenner
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

tjenner

New Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
I know this thread has been done to death, and now I'm in a place where I'm adding to the SDN traditional pattern.

I have to make a decision between 2 DO schools, uh, by tomorrow and I hope some of you can provide insight from your experience.

Biggest question: does location trump all other pros in a med school? I just got pulled off the waitlist for my local school and location (love the area, family is here) and maybe the match list are the main advantages of the school. But it has all-day classes (start at 8am!), not a lot of pre-clinical experience opportunities, the lecture system is the old style, and the lecture hall seats are uncomfortable. It's also a newer, but not brand-new school. I've heard students going on their rotations don't do as well as students from other nearby schools, and lots of students have to move for rotations.

School #2, half-way across the country, is a great school. I think I'll have more opportunities for clinical experience, but no family there and the weather sucks. I think I'll get a better education at that school (not that i couldn't at my local school, but i might have to work harder for it) and will be better prepared for rotations. I won't have to get to class at 8 am (i'm such a night owl). The OMM program at school #2 might not be as good, but I really like all the people I've met. I wouldn't have to move for most of my rotations (except electives if i want), but i am scared to get stuck so far from home for residency! School #2 is also cheaper.

I feel like i'm comparing an apple and an orange and i am nervous to make the wrong choice. i worry that if i move half-way across the country i won't have any way to change my mind if it really doesn't work for me (i'm VERY sensitive to cold weather).

But I also would feel really stupid choosing a school just because I like the location more. That seems short-sighted on my part. So I wonder if people who have done this are happy with their choice. Or if people who opted for the faraway school are happy with their choice.

Thanks in advance for responding to my rambling and somewhat incoherent post. I know I'll need to make tougher decisions than this one in the lives of my patients, but i'm really struggling right now to make this choice. And yes, I'm grateful to have a choice!
 
tjenner said:
I know this thread has been done to death, and now I'm in a place where I'm adding to the SDN traditional pattern.

I have to make a decision between 2 DO schools, uh, by tomorrow and I hope some of you can provide insight from your experience.

Biggest question: does location trump all other pros in a med school?

My opinion is that when you find the school, you know. I turned down the school closer to my home because I did not feel as comfortable there. From your post, I get the feeling that you are more comfortable at the school closer to your home. The more comfortable you are, the better you will do. I think that you can get more out of a program you like. Even though the lecures are "old school" you will still learn medicine. And even though the school doesn't offer mandatory experiences, you can always find someone to shadow or work with. I think you are going to get out of a program what you put into it.

A lot of people choose medical school based primarily on location. I think this is fine, if you feel comfortable going there. I personally placed it second to my desire to feel accepted and happy. The biggest question for you should be WHERE am I going to be happy?

It sounds to me like you've already made the decision, but you want someone to tell you that it is okay to do so. :luck: good luck.
 
Thank you, Dancing Doctor. I don't know if I want to be told to go to my home school (the faraway school has SO much going for it!), but I am feeling paralyzed by this decision.

Up until today I was fairly sure I would choose the faraway school even if I got pulled off the waitlist for my home school. I've had a lot of time to get used to the idea of going to the faraway school, too.

I really prayed that I would only get into the one right school for me. Obviously that didn't happen, and I am lucky enough to have a choice. I am trying to make this decision quickly so I can free up a spot at whichever school I don't choose.

Whatever I choose, I won't look back. I know I'll be okay wherever I go. But I really want it to be the best possible choice (ack!!). Congratulations on choosing the right school for you. I have read wonderful things about PCOM on this site.
 
I would look into the program, the type of curriculum, the surrounding amenities, the cost of living, whether or not you want to travel a lot during your third and fourth years, etc. For example, I chose TUNCOM because of the location, amenities, family, not having to travel out of town for my third and fourth year rotations, the weather, the curriculum, etc.

Unfortunately most DO schools have their third and fourth year students on the road for the most part. This is much harder on a person who has a spouse and or children.
 
http://www.princetonreview.com/medical/research/articles/decide/osteoAdmissions.asp

"While the curriculum at all osteopathic schools is based on the same general philosophy, each school has its own specialties, character, and strengths. When evaluating programs, consider how the pre-clinical coursework is taught, where clinical rotations are conducted, how clerkship time is spent, and where the school is located. You should also evaluate the general composition and character of the student body to see where you might best fit in. In addition, if you are interested in an allopathic residency, you may want to investigate how recent graduates fared in the Match, as well as the percentage of students who passed the boards (both COMLEX and USMLE)."
 
tjenner said:
Thank you, Dancing Doctor. I don't know if I want to be told to go to my home school (the faraway school has SO much going for it!), but I am feeling paralyzed by this decision.

Up until today I was fairly sure I would choose the faraway school even if I got pulled off the waitlist for my home school. I've had a lot of time to get used to the idea of going to the faraway school, too.

I really prayed that I would only get into the one right school for me. Obviously that didn't happen, and I am lucky enough to have a choice. I am trying to make this decision quickly so I can free up a spot at whichever school I don't choose.

Whatever I choose, I won't look back. I know I'll be okay wherever I go. But I really want it to be the best possible choice (ack!!). Congratulations on choosing the right school for you. I have read wonderful things about PCOM on this site.

I too hoped that I would only get into one school. I think this is difficult for a lot of people because there are no cut and dry answers; one school does not fit all. We all want to pick the best possible (i think that goes back to perfectionistic tendancies) but there's not a straight answer as to which school is better. Even if a program or curriculum is better, you will get less out of it if you are unhappy. Talk to your family, let them know you are having trouble deciding. My family really helped me out with that.

Thankfully I do not have a husband or children to think about, at least not yet. I want t omove around a bit my third and fourth uears, see where I would like to live/work. But as medicine1 said, it's harder when you have those things to think about.

I am sure you will make the best decision for you. And remember, no matter what you choose (unless you choose neither option) you're going to be a doctor!! 🙂
 
Hey What 2 Schools Are They? We Can Help More If We Know The 2 Schools We Are Talking About

This Website Is Anonymous, So Don't Worry About Anything
 
shttthttle said:
Although this isn't my post, does anyone have thoughts between DMU and CCOM? Thanks


I just finished my first year at CCOM. And while I know nothing of DMU, I wouldnt recommend CCOM unless you like getting rammed in the ass by at least 2 exams and one quiz per week.....every week.
 
I have met a couple doctors who graduated from DMU: one is an orthopedic surgeon, the other is an ENT doc. Both of them went into very competive residency programs, and they are terrific doctors. A bonus at DMU is also the cost of living, and that you get a free PDA, Laptop computer, and a computer/school bag.


Apropos, I heard from a first year student at DMU, that DMU places more of an emphasis on HVLA in their OMT class vs. other DO schools.
 
Buckeye(OH) said:
I just finished my first year at CCOM. And while I know nothing of DMU, I wouldnt recommend CCOM unless you like getting rammed in the ass by at least 2 exams and one quiz per week.....every week.
😱 😱
 
to tjenner-
SInce you will have enough stress with class and medical school and doing school work etc, I would recommend that everything outside the classroom to be as stable as possible. I wouldn't want to be worrying about family far away, or stressing about a location that makes you uncomfortable. As another person said, in the end, you will be a doctor regardless of where you go. With that said, if you think you would do OK in the school farther away, and thrive in the new location, then go! Sounds like a better school, cheaper, better future, etc. But... your mental state has to be your first priority and do not go somewhere that would make you upset. You won't need added stress.

Hope this helps. 🙂
 
Pick the one with less OMM. Just my opinion. 😉


oh ok. More seriously, I really value family. So all else being equal I would stay close to home. Sounds like you want to be near family as well.
 
You know, reputation and location are a big deal where choosing a school is concerned, but there was one thing that sealed the deal for me: atmosphere. Do you want to know why you hear good things about PCOM on this site? The education is above average, but the student body goes above and beyond to be warm and friendly.

I am not bragging about the school I chose. Everyone speaks of the 'feeling' of being in the right place. Well, when you walk into a new school, being the low man on the totem pole, feeling nervous and out of your league, and then an upperclassman approaches, introduces him/herself and welcomes you like a sibling... Nothing compares. And it does not matter to me how great of a reputation a school has for the stats of its graduates--if classmates are rivals, ready to stick knives in each others' backs, then it is simply not my choice. Go to the school where the students are genuinely happy to be there and do not attend just because of the prestige. Talk to them about study groups, comradery, professor relations, etc. It is a long four years if you are too stressed by your surroundings to enjoy what you are doing.