It would have required living in the south, supervising CRNA's, working more hours, more call, and taking less vacation, but yes, I had an offer that would have paid anywhere from 1.4-2.2 times my typical income here. In a good year here, I will match what I would make in a bad year there. In a good year there, I would make 1.6 times what I make in a good year here.
You could argue that the jobs aren't exactly comparable since the workload would have been significantly more at the other job. That being said, the workload there wasn't unbearable, there was plenty of vacation, and the work would have been different, not exactly onerous.
I just made the same kind of decision the Cliff Lee did. I would rather make less money (still plenty for my needs) and spend my working years in the type of location that I would retire to at the end of a career rather than make more money and live somewhere that I would constantly be escaping on vacation. It isn't the right decision for everyone, but it was for me.
I live in a >4000 sq ft house with views of the mountains, 20 minutes from the ski slopes, < 1hr from Glacier National Park, and < 1 hour from Seattle by plane. If, by some miracle, the Seahawks win in Chicago and Greenbay beats Atlanta, I can grab a flight to Seattle for the NFC championship game and be back home that evening. It isn't cheap, but I can afford it. There is world class fishing, hiking, hunting, skiing, river running etc.
As far as negatives go... The restaurant selection is limited a bit, but we cook at home a lot anyway. There are fewer of the small shops that you would get in a place like Seattle, but we do most of our shopping online anyway. We have a state income tax. There is no major sport nearby for tailgating. That is pretty much it. All of those would have applied at the other job except for the state income tax.
Speaking of snowboarding, we received 3" of new snow overnight and it is still falling. My son is off of school in 30 minutes and I had better go get ready to hit the slopes when he gets home. I am on vacation this week and guess where I want to spend it?
Yeah, money isn't everything.
- pod