You will get into dental school from either of these 2 schools. However there are various things you have to consider.
1: Size. Rutgers is large (small city) where as Lafayette is a small liberal arts college. No matter what people say... you will get more personal attention going to Lafayette. However when you go to a major University you have more oppurtunity to do research than going to a liberal arts school.
** I went to a small liberal arts in the Lehigh Valley as well. I had no problem finding a dozen of professors that would write me a recommendation. In addition, I never felt like a number. I also liked the fact that the administration knew who I was and my prehealth advisor went above and beyond for me and every student she worked with.
2. Pre-health acceptance %: what amount of people get accepted into medical/dental programs each year. It will show the strength of the program. ** be advised some schools will discourage students not to apply if their averages are not high enough.- keeps their acceptance % higher (but they only do this if they are sure that person will not get in; and in my schools case will work with you to increase chance)
**I know now that my school had a 100% acceptance rate into Med/Dent/Opt school for a reason.... The majority of students scored into the top percentages on the DAT and MCAT along with a rigorous science program. Have so many people score well on these standardized tests, in my opinion, show that these students are capable and well prepared for professional school
3. Name. It sounds like you are from the PA/NJ/NY area like I am. Be advised, if you plan on applying to schools outside the area most likely they will not know Lafayette. I had to explain my school at every school other than UMDNJ and Temple.... this did create a small problem for me. Rutgers is a nationally known university so that would be an upside to going there.
I would not trade my small liberal arts education for one at a Major university. I know Lafayette is expensive where as Rutgers in state is not so yes that could be a factor. However the personal attention I received and my solid educational background made my small liberal arts school a better fit for me.
PM me if you have any questions.