lexswift

Membership Revoked
Removed
Jul 2, 2016
233
134
Is it still a good idea to get a committee letter from a premed advisor who is less than enthusiastic about your chances at medical school? I do not have a MCAT score yet but GPA wise I am below the median.

It is possible her opinion may change after the MCAT but if it does not should I still get a letter? Wouldn't a premed advisor's opinion affect the committee letter? I am confused how this works. I do think my individual professor letters would be good.
 

ThoracicGuy

5+ Year Member
Jun 11, 2013
9,600
23,468
Status
Attending Physician
Is it still a good idea to get a committee letter from a premed advisor who is less than enthusiastic about your chances at medical school? I do not have a MCAT score yet but GPA wise I am below the median.

It is possible her opinion may change after the MCAT but if it does not should I still get a letter? Wouldn't a premed advisor's opinion affect the committee letter? I am confused how this works. I do think my individual professor letters would be good.
Perhaps, but if your GPA is significantly lower than median, you should look at doing some grade repair before you apply. Are you ready for the MCAT yet? You need to plan to just take it once.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Goro
OP
L

lexswift

Membership Revoked
Removed
Jul 2, 2016
233
134
Perhaps, but if your GPA is significantly lower than median, you should look at doing some grade repair before you apply. Are you ready for the MCAT yet? You need to plan to just take it once.
I have a 3.64 and 3.43 science GPA with a good upward trend. I already graduated and am taking time off to study for my MCAT that I am planning on taking in a few months. I definitely dont want to take the MCAT more than once!
She was not very enthusiastic when she saw my transcript.
 

ThoracicGuy

5+ Year Member
Jun 11, 2013
9,600
23,468
Status
Attending Physician
I have a 3.64 and 3.43 science GPA with a good upward trend. I already graduated and am taking time off to study for my MCAT that I am planning on taking in a few months. I definitely dont want to take the MCAT more than once!
She was not very enthusiastic when she saw my transcript.
It is a bit on the lower side, but a strong MCAT will help. Also, state of residence can help along with targeting the right schools (MD and DO).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Goro
OP
L

lexswift

Membership Revoked
Removed
Jul 2, 2016
233
134
It is a bit on the lower side, but a strong MCAT will help. Also, state of residence can help along with targeting the right schools (MD and DO).
She made it sound like no matter what MCAT I get my GPAs would hurt me. Do you think it would be a bad idea to get a committee letter from her? I'm not sure why schools call it a committee letter when it is usually just one person compiling and writing the letter from my understanding.
 

FindersFee5

2+ Year Member
Jun 22, 2016
335
663
Status
Medical Student
The reason she was discouraging you from applying was because she wanted to maintain your school's acceptance percentage. However, once you ARE already applying (assume you haven't totally pissed her off so she's out to get you), she is incentivized to do her best to get you in. I think you'll be fine.
 

The Knife & Gun Club

MS - 4
2+ Year Member
Nov 6, 2015
2,329
4,495
Hollywood Upstairs Medical College
Status
Medical Student
You should get the committee letter, it's really important to have one if your school offers it. MANY secondary essays will ask you to explain the lack of one if you don't.

However maybe wait to ask until after the MCAT. If you can put up a decent score it may make them much more supportive of your app.

My premed advisor was very unsupportive because I also had a low GPA, but once I did well on the MCAT they were much more willing to help.

Depending on your undergrad, state, MCAT, ethnicity, and ECs you could be very, very far from sunk. Best of luck!
 

ThoracicGuy

5+ Year Member
Jun 11, 2013
9,600
23,468
Status
Attending Physician
You should get the committee letter, it's really important to have one if your school offers it. MANY secondary essays will ask you to explain the lack of one if you don't.

However maybe wait to ask until after the MCAT. If you can put up a decent score it may make them much more supportive of your app.

My premed advisor was very unsupportive because I also had a low GPA, but once I did well on the MCAT they were much more willing to help.

Depending on your undergrad, state, MCAT, ethnicity, and ECs you could be very, very far from sunk. Best of luck!
Though many times if you have already graduated, you can explain no committee letter as you are not currently in classes at the university.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Goro and Crayola227

gonnif

Only 389 Days Until Next Presidential Election
Lifetime Donor
10+ Year Member
Jul 26, 2009
20,497
31,233
The Big Bad Apple
Status
Non-Student
Though many times if you have already graduated, you can explain no committee letter as you are not currently in classes at the university.

I tend to agree the chest cutter here (@ThoracicGuy ). if you have good year by year upward (list them if you want) and have already graduated, a lack luster committee letter is worse than no committee letter, especially if you are below a median already. this assumes you can get 3-4 strong academic letters.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ThoracicGuy
Dec 9, 2015
488
1,218
Status
Pre-Medical
The reason she was discouraging you from applying was because she wanted to maintain your school's acceptance percentage. However, once you ARE already applying (assume you haven't totally pissed her off so she's out to get you), she is incentivized to do her best to get you in. I think you'll be fine.
Or maybe it is because OP's GPA isn't that competitive and it is better to be realistic with someone than give them false hope...