Anyway, he said that he's worked with a lot of Psychiatry interns in the ER and that I was different from most of them in that I was actually interested and doing well with the medicine versus the others who were not interested in doing anything else except psych. Another attending told me something like "Are you sure you want to do Psych, you're too good of a doctor to be doing Psych."
I got the same, in fact I was offered to switch programs. I was also told by 3 gastroenterologists that if I made the switch, they would make a personal guarantee that they would get me into a GI fellowship. I had worked with those 3 during a medschool elective, got along very well with them, and I did my residency in the same hospital those 4 worked in. We did keep a good relationship even though I stayed in psychiatry, and they offered me to be a consultant for them if I stayed in the Southern NJ area (which I did not) because they needed a psychiatrist for their patients on Pegasys. They often times told me their frustration with dealing with patients who became depressed & suicidal, and not having a psychiatrist they felt they could work with.
I think its a combination of factors. First, several who go into psychiatry, while doing medicine see it as the temporary thing they just have to survive. These same people may have gone into psychiatry specifically because they found it easier than IM. Other psychiatry residents when thrust into IM do so at the latter part of the year where they are very much behind their IM colleagues in IM knowledge. Psychiatry residents that start with IM residents usually are closer if not equal to their IM colleagues by the time they leave the rotation.
You'll have the rest of your life to do psychiatry. You only have a few months of IM, and that IM knowledge will help you out tremendously as a psychiatrist. You need to approach your IM rotation as if it is a golden oppurtunity you will never have again.
You should try to get as much out of your IM rotation as possible. It will help you to study for USMLE Step III, C&L psychiatry, and it will leave a very good impression on the hospital should you choose to stay there. Trust me, I've seen plenty of non-psychiatric doctors think their psychiatric colleagues are terrible to excellent.
If you stay in that same area, and develop your rep which seems to be off to a good start, several of your future attending colleagues will be more likely to refer to you, call you up for advice, and open several other doors for you. I had about 3 possible jobs lined up by the time I left residency in that area (which I had to turn down, and I wasn't happy about doing that-some of them would've been very lucrative, some of them would've been working with people I highly respected & got along with well), and one of my colleagues who was known to be lazy had to search far & wide to find a job. I was somewhat regretting leaving the area for fellowship, knowing that if I moved, I'd have to spend another few years redeveloping that rep.