Psychiatry & Sense of Humor

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

slappy

Neuropsychiatrist
7+ Year Member
Joined
Apr 1, 2014
Messages
587
Reaction score
366
Is it just me (and my program) or are people in psychiatry (residents and attendings) funnier than those in other specialties?

If you've noticed a skew, why does this bias exist? It can't just be the relatively high free time and low workload, can it? Do you think there's an element of self-selection in play here?

Members don't see this ad.
 
Is it just me (and my program) or are people in psychiatry (residents and attendings) funnier than those in other specialties?

If you've noticed a skew, why does this bias exist? It can't just be the relatively high free time and low workload, can it? Do you think there's an element of self-selection in play here?

Several possible things come to mind:

1) Ties back to the satisfaction thread [which trend trickles down to residents]... happier/more rested = more lighthearted/relaxed = more likely to find things funny and joke around.

2) Maybe people in psych have a different flavor for what's funny... A "weird" humor, if you will, that other people in psych appreciate and don't find as much in other specialties.

3) Similar to ED docs (notorious for always joking), psych sees (but more so hears) a lot of tragic things that can really bring the average joe down if ruminated on... it might be a defense mechanism of sorts.

4) Similar to Uro, there is no shortage of jokes about their specialty, therefore it behooves the practitioner to maintain a sense of humor to keep the chip off their shoulder.

Lastly, and perhaps least fair,

5) A certain "type" of person is more likely to actually pursue psych than say a surgical specialty. For example, the students in my school's psychiatry interest group are universally lighthearted, joking around, etc. I know of 3 people in my class that have intended to specialize in neurosurgery since day 1 -- I have only seen 1 out of those 3 people actually "laugh" at something during the past 2 years. And he looked like he was trying to keep it in. Yeah.
 
Last edited:
I haven’t noticed that psychiatrists are particularly funny. They do see a lot of s#$% you couldn’t make up if you tried. I think there is a difference between psychiatrists and neurosurgeons. Neurosurgeons look like they are about to slam their heads through a wall any second, and psychiatrists probably would slam their heads in the wall if they had neurosurgery jobs.
A neurosurgeon with a fondness for alcohol walks into a bar and sees a beautiful lady drinking alone. He sits next to her and offers her a drink. She smiles and says “no thank you, I’m beginning to feel that last one”. The neurosurgeon looks confused and says “My mistake, I thought that was the point of coming in here”.
 
Members don't see this ad :)
My psychiatry cartoons were banned on this forum. I rest my case. Even though they appear all over the internet on disability sites. Psychiatry can not take a joke.
 
saw a couple of the cartoons, I'm hoping they were more funny to British folks because they seemed pretty boring "psychiatry ruined my life" type things
 
Humour is very personal. What is funny to one is not funny to another..... I agree someone humourless got their panties in a knot and reported them for violating the TOS.

They were miles away from being anti-psychiatry.

I have reached my mental health work burnout, and I am fast reaching my artistic work burnout.
Maybe it is time for a completely new direction? A new religion - one that can't promise to save your soul, but will look after your hair.
So who wants to be a jojoba witness? And give out shampoo samples on the street? Here is our mag to distribute too - The Washtowel.
resizer.php


I guess some people just cant take a joke.

This below is hysterical.... how anyone can be offended is beyond me....

resizer.php

https://www.surveymonkey.com/s/WYR2WHV

How any of it could be found offensive is beyond me.....
 
I'm just confused how stuff like the bottom one would be funny? Is it reference to some sort of survey form in the UK?

Just go on and tell your favourite knock knock joke...... you want to, I can tell..... go on, let it out.....
 
My psychiatry cartoons were banned on this forum. I rest my case. Even though they appear all over the internet on disability sites. Psychiatry can not take a joke.

I am the one who reported your cartoons thread, I cannot speak to whether anyone else did (as I honestly do not know). I did not report it because I was offended by the cartoons themselves, a couple of them I found amusing, some I found rather puerile, I think there was only one I found even slightly offensive and that was more 'eh, I get it, but I also disagree' rather than steaming hot torrents of rage. I reported the thread because I felt the thread was posted with an intent to inflame and incite, not to amuse or to encourage debate or discussion, and that is what I found offensive - well that and the moment you inferred that because the person who had created the cartoons originally was a gay, ethnic minority male, who had been abused by the mental health system, ergo sum no one was therefore allowed to be offended (as I said to you in that thread, those of us who identify as part or all of any of those groups are not a hive mind and other people don't get to say what is and isn't offensive for us on an individual level). Bottom line for me, all of us who aren't in the medical profession (or a medical student) are guests in someone else's home, and as a guest in someone else's home we should conduct ourselves accordingly -- you wouldn't walk over to your neighbour's place, take a cr&p on their doorstep and expect them to pat you on the head now would you? Why should the internet be any different.
 
Last edited:
I am the one who reported your cartoons thread, I cannot speak to whether anyone else did (as I honestly do not know). I did not report it because I was offended by the cartoons themselves, a couple of them I found amusing, some I found rather puerile, I think there was only one I found even slightly offensive and that was more 'eh, I get it, but I also disagree' rather than steaming hot torrents of rage. I reported the thread because I felt the thread was posted with an intent to inflame and incite, not to amuse or to encourage debate or discussion, and that is what I found offensive - well that and the moment you inferred that because the person who had created the cartoons originally was a gay, ethnic minority male, who had been abused by the mental health system, ergo sum no one was therefore allowed to be offended (as I said to you in that thread, those of us who identify as part or all of any of those groups are not a hive mind and other people don't get to say what is and isn't offensive for us on an individual level). Bottom line for me, all of us who aren't in the medical profession (or a medical student) are guests in someone else's home, and as a guest in someone else's home we should conduct ourselves accordingly -- you wouldn't walk over to your neighbour's place, take a cr&p on their doorstep and expect them to pat you on the head now would you? Why should the internet be any different.

I implied no such thing. Thats daft. You have every right to be offended by what ever offends you from what ever source. And report away. Ring your mum while you are at it.....

I dont know why you have brought up crapping on door steps. Must be an Aussie thing.....
 
Members don't see this ad :)
I am the one who reported your cartoons thread,.

That makes sense.... I was surprised that it had been reported given that psychiatrists usually have a high tolerance for difference so I just assumed it was a very young green student.....

Your implication that you knew my intent in posting the cartoons is laughable..... but then you do play the amateur psychiatrist on here rather a lot. So that fits as well.
 
I haven’t noticed that psychiatrists are particularly funny. They do see a lot of s#$% you couldn’t make up if you tried. I think there is a difference between psychiatrists and neurosurgeons. Neurosurgeons look like they are about to slam their heads through a wall any second, and psychiatrists probably would slam their heads in the wall if they had neurosurgery jobs.
A neurosurgeon with a fondness for alcohol walks into a bar and sees a beautiful lady drinking alone. He sits next to her and offers her a drink. She smiles and says “no thank you, I’m beginning to feel that last one”. The neurosurgeon looks confused and says “My mistake, I thought that was the point of coming in here”.

This may be institution-specific. I have scrubbed in on more than one laminectomy that I spent giggling helplessly.
 
That makes sense.... I was surprised that it had been reported given that psychiatrists usually have a high tolerance for difference so I just assumed it was a very young green student.....

Your implication that you knew my intent in posting the cartoons is laughable..... but then you do play the amateur psychiatrist on here rather a lot. So that fits as well.

You are quite a vocal critic of Psychiatry on here, and you posted a number of Anti-Psychiatry cartoons on here with absolutely no point of reference or discussion. To me it felt more like you were shoving a point in people's faces, rather than inviting any form of meaningful discussion. Had you put something at the beginning of the thread that indicated the cartoons were a point of debate, or that in posting them you intended to invite discussion, I wouldn't have reported the thread at all.

As for playing 'amateur psychiatrist' I find it rather interesting that you appear to advocate for the individual rights of those with mental health issues, but when someone with mental health issues chooses to openly share their experiences with a forum of Psychiatrists, including trying to advocate for clearer understanding of certain issues from an individuals point of view, then all of a sudden they're playing 'amateur psychiatrist'? Really?

At this point I am disengaging from the conversation as it seems fairly clear to me that you are looking for an argument. Oh look, there I go again playing amateur shrink. 🙄
 
Is it just me (and my program) or are people in psychiatry (residents and attendings) funnier than those in other specialties?

If you've noticed a skew, why does this bias exist? It can't just be the relatively high free time and low workload, can it? Do you think there's an element of self-selection in play here?

Just to get the thread back on track (my apologies). I think it depends a lot on the individual personalities at play. I've known GPs who regularly made me laugh, and others who couldn't crack a smile if their lives depended on it, same goes for Dentists, Physios, Gastroenterologists, and yes Psychiatrists and Psychologists. The only group I've consistently noted a distinct lack of humour in is the more leaning towards the extreme end of the scale type 'New Age' counsellors. It's like they've crawled so far up their own backsides they've left their sense of humour behind.
 
Just to get the thread back on track (my apologies). I think it depends a lot on the individual personalities at play. I've known GPs who regularly made me laugh, and others who couldn't crack a smile if their lives depended on it, same goes for Dentists, Physios, Gastroenterologists, and yes Psychiatrists and Psychologists. The only group I've consistently noted a distinct lack of humour in is the more leaning towards the extreme end of the scale type 'New Age' counsellors. It's like they've crawled so far up their own backsides they've left their sense of humour behind.

There's a bit in Black Books where Dylan Moran's character says that an extremely granola person "farts because she's forgotten how to laugh." I know this type well.
 
If you're into unintentional, black humor, then yes, I'd say I've seen my share of crack-ups. 🙂
 
As a rule psychiatrists can't laugh at themselves or psychiatry in general. The fundamentals of psychiatry are so weak that any jokes about it are to close to the bone...

Psychiatry demands that it be taken seriously. To laugh at a psychiatrist is to invite anger.....

Hey Ibid, do us all a BIG favor and leave us alone. Take you downer spirit somewhere else. You ruin a perfectly nice thread, and insult us psychiatrists.

Here's some humor. I punch Ibid in the face. Good enough for a big laugh.
 
There's a bit in Black Books where Dylan Moran's character says that an extremely granola person "farts because she's forgotten how to laugh." I know this type well.

Haha, Oh god that's brilliant. Must steal (and correctly attribute) for my non crunchy granola Pagan & Wiccan discussion group. 😀
 
This forum is not for the rants of those in opposition to psychiatry. I'm all for debate that stirs stagnation and complacency, and definitely up for a good joke. But this site is for budding psychiatrists and the mentors that guide us. Posters that stray too far from this paradigm need to find another forum to satisfy their needs of expression.
 
This forum is not for the rants of those in opposition to psychiatry. I'm all for debate that stirs stagnation and complacency, and definitely up for a good joke. But this site is for budding psychiatrists and the mentors that guide us. Posters that stray too far from this paradigm need to find another forum to satisfy their needs of expression.

This! By the way have I ever told you how much I love your avatar 😀
 
This forum is not for the rants of those in opposition to psychiatry. I'm all for debate that stirs stagnation and complacency, and definitely up for a good joke. But this site is for budding psychiatrists and the mentors that guide us. Posters that stray too far from this paradigm need to find another forum to satisfy their needs of expression.
But it's so fun derailing.... almost as if it were looseness of associations!
 
Re: the original topic:

I don't think any one specialty has a better sense of humor than another. I just think if you find psychiatrists funnier that it's a pretty good sign you've found your tribe.

Being able to laugh and laugh well is an important part of life and much of life is spent at work. If you find that those in your field help you laugh and enjoy yourself? That's a lot more important than call or (shudder) prestige. You've chosen well.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
“for budding psychiatrists and the mentors that guide us.”?

Careful, you will make it sound too much like work. I use this blog to steal time from work, not expand it.

If I were going to describe one of the best unrecognized benefits of becoming a budding psychiatrist, it would be how some feel a fulfilling vengeance by going into psychiatry. Even those who are not bitter about their exaggerated exposure to parental expectations will concede that doing well enough in college to get into medical school and then enduring medical school feeds into parental pride so naturally, the fall from idealization can be quite startling when you announce your intention to go into psychiatry. I highly recommend that you withhold the announcement until you are in a losing argument with a parent. Blurting out this intention will be so disarming; they will not even remember what the fight was about. Getting a doctorate in medicine, then not becoming “a real doctor” is probably the most unforgivable forms of academic anorgasmia known to man. We should start a thread on the classic unsupportive statements relatives make when they hear the news:

“What a waste of all that education”
“But I told everyone you went to medical school to become a doctor”
“But you will be around all of those crazy people”
“What is wrong with neurology?”
“Why would you do that?”
“Stop joking around, really, what are you going to apply for?”

And my all-time favorite that makes so little sense to a fourth year medical student:

“You are going to miss medicine.”

Anyone else have any good ones?
:writer:
 
“for budding psychiatrists and the mentors that guide us.”?

Careful, you will make it sound too much like work. I use this blog to steal time from work, not expand it.

If I were going to describe one of the best unrecognized benefits of becoming a budding psychiatrist, it would be how some feel a fulfilling vengeance by going into psychiatry. Even those who are not bitter about their exaggerated exposure to parental expectations will concede that doing well enough in college to get into medical school and then enduring medical school feeds into parental pride so naturally, the fall from idealization can be quite startling when you announce your intention to go into psychiatry. I highly recommend that you withhold the announcement until you are in a losing argument with a parent. Blurting out this intention will be so disarming; they will not even remember what the fight was about. Getting a doctorate in medicine, then not becoming “a real doctor” is probably the most unforgivable forms of academic anorgasmia known to man. We should start a thread on the classic unsupportive statements relatives make when they hear the news:

“What a waste of all that education”
“But I told everyone you went to medical school to become a doctor”
“But you will be around all of those crazy people”
“What is wrong with neurology?”
“Why would you do that?”
“Stop joking around, really, what are you going to apply for?”

And my all-time favorite that makes so little sense to a fourth year medical student:

“You are going to miss medicine.”

Anyone else have any good ones?
:writer:
^ solid evidence of a sense of humor amongst psychiatrists... I think.
 
...Getting a doctorate in medicine, then not becoming “a real doctor” is probably the most unforgivable forms of academic anorgasmia known to man. ...
Anyone else have any good ones?
:writer:

I'll NEVER come up with a better one than "academic anorgasmia".
:highfive:

(Hmmm...why am I uncomfortable about using the dancing banana emoji for this...:thinking:)
 
[QUOTE

(Hmmm...why am I uncomfortable about using the dancing banana emoji for this...:thinking:)[/QUOTE]

Dancing banana nothing, what does this one say? :diebanana: :wow:
 
There should be a study on sense of humor and rapport. My patients tell me all the time about the boring, serious types that they have had to endure. "Hmmm...and how did that make you feel? (delivered with no inflection)" Some of my most humorous sessions have been with patients telling me the crazy things their therapists and psychiatrists have done or said. A personal favorite was the male teen who asked the psychiatrist with the low-cut blouse, "Do you think that you wear revealing clothes because of your 'daddy issues'"? He had some borderline pathology, obviously, but they also tend to be the best at hitting the weak spots.
 
I lump shrinks into 2 categories

(A) laid back, easy going normal people with a good (though sometimes strange) sense of humor who are fun to be around and take a very, "broad" approach to psychiatry

(B) Neurotic insane people who were too anxious to enter any other field of medicine and who are pushing to reduce psychiatry to the same boring, algorithm-based field as every other area of medicine in their endless quest for supreme accuracy and the, "right" diagnosis

Guess which one I am.
 
I lump shrinks into 2 categories

(A) laid back, easy going normal people with a good (though sometimes strange) sense of humor who are fun to be around and take a very, "broad" approach to psychiatry

(B) Neurotic insane people who were too anxious to enter any other field of medicine and who are pushing to reduce psychiatry to the same boring, algorithm-based field as every other area of medicine in their endless quest for supreme accuracy and the, "right" diagnosis

Guess which one I am.
Oh please...I just took my MOC exam and I can't handle another multiple choice question!
 
When taking a test written by ABPN, always go with evidence based.😀
 
There should be a study on sense of humor and rapport. My patients tell me all the time about the boring, serious types that they have had to endure. "Hmmm...and how did that make you feel? (delivered with no inflection)" Some of my most humorous sessions have been with patients telling me the crazy things their therapists and psychiatrists have done or said. A personal favorite was the male teen who asked the psychiatrist with the low-cut blouse, "Do you think that you wear revealing clothes because of your 'daddy issues'"? He had some borderline pathology, obviously, but they also tend to be the best at hitting the weak spots.
I think you mean the "cheap shots." I'm finding that more cringe-worthy than funny, but to each his own.
 
I think you mean the "cheap shots." I'm finding that more cringe-worthy than funny, but to each his own.
Definitely was pretty harsh. Patient was more like Dennis Leary than like a Bill Cosby. Biting humor as opposed to cute. He was also an adolescent so that eases the harshness a bit. Coming from an adult, it might not have been funny.
 
Top