Question about LORs

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

Grace82

Full Member
10+ Year Member
Joined
Jan 24, 2013
Messages
45
Reaction score
8
I will be applying this cycle to pathology residency and was wondering if pathology residencies want departmental letters. I have 3 letters, 2 of which are from pathologists but don't have a departmental letter or a letter from the chair or PD of the pathology department at my school. I know some other specialties want this but could't find any info on individual school websites (just that they usually wanted 3 letters). Any information on this would be very helpful!

Thanks!
 
I will be applying this cycle to pathology residency and was wondering if pathology residencies want departmental letters. I have 3 letters, 2 of which are from pathologists but don't have a departmental letter or a letter from the chair or PD of the pathology department at my school. I know some other specialties want this but could't find any info on individual school websites (just that they usually wanted 3 letters). Any information on this would be very helpful!

Thanks!

What do you mean by "departmental letter"?

In general, 2 of 3 LoRs from pathologists that know you and can speak to your interest in the field and general knowledge will serve you well. Letters from private practice pathologists that know you are better than letters from academic pathologists that don't know you.
 
Thanks for the information! I was just a little unsure as my advisor asked me if I needed one today and several of my friends applying to other specialties (mainly surgery and medicine) are required to get a departmental letter. It is usually from the chair of the department you're applying to. There is often a formal process of setting up a meeting with the chair, giving the department your CV etc. I had never heard of this with path but just wanted to check!
 
I don't think a "departmental letter" is all that common in pathology. Maybe my experience isn't indicative, I dunno -- I hadn't heard of a dean's letter either until I started the application process. I think having a couple of letters from pathologists who you have rotated with/actually worked with is what you need most, as it shows you have an idea of what you're getting into and aren't so terrible that no-one will give you a rec. A recognized name, professor, or department head helps, but I don't know that a so-called department letter would -- I suppose if it's good, and not one of those boringly honest ones like what I've seen of dean's letters. Otherwise LOR's just need to not be terrible. Everyone knows that almost no-one writes a completely honest or critical LOR, and the few who do tend to be blown off a bit as those classic hard-a55es who refuse to be completely pleased by any student. That's why it's called a letter of *recommendation*.

Having said all of that, I think it's a good idea to get any letter of recommendation you can, if you can choose -later- which ones to send to who. Some will let you read their letters, and that will help you make the decision of which ones to use. Some will never get around to writing the letter you were counting on. Most will give you a reasonable idea what kind of letter they write, even if they don't exactly spell it out for you, just by what they ask you about, etc. But heck, some will end up letting you write the letter before they review it and sign it.
 
Top