question regarding scheduling 4th year pathology rotations

This forum made possible through the generous support of SDN members, donors, and sponsors. Thank you.

freakedout06

Junior Member
10+ Year Member
15+ Year Member
Joined
Jun 21, 2006
Messages
65
Reaction score
0
I'm nearing the end of my 3rd year at an osteopathic medical school, and was wondering if I could get some people's opinions/advice on setting up 4th year rotations. I haven't had a pathology rotation yet....the one elective I did have 3rd year was early and at that time I wasn't thinking about pursing pathology, and so decided to do something else. Now being interested in pathology, and almost starting my 4th year, I'm really trying to figure out how the past way to approach scheduling my rotations.

Our school allows us to do a maxium of 3 rotations in any given specialty. Right now I have scheduled 2 pathology rotations. The first one is around July to Aug (2nd rotation for 4th year) and is at a hospital that does not have a residency program. My reasoning was, I didn't want to look like a complete idiot at future rotations, since I haven't had a pathology rotation yet. I figure this one would be a warm up. Is this a waste of a rotation? My second path rotation falls around August to September, and is at a major university with a residency program. Should I be doing all of my path rotations as audition rotations, and should I do 3 consecutive pathology rotations, or is this overkill??

As far as competitiveness, I would say I'm an average applicant. My COMLEX score is definitely better than my USMLE score, which was average.

I know the topic of audition rotations has been discussed in other threads, but they seem to be related to either uncompetitve fields or super competitive fields. I'm not sure where pathology falls. Btw, if there are any DOs out there, I'd love to hear what you have to say!

Thanks in advance for any advice!
 
I'm nearing the end of my 3rd year at an osteopathic medical school, and was wondering if I could get some people's opinions/advice on setting up 4th year rotations. I haven't had a pathology rotation yet....the one elective I did have 3rd year was early and at that time I wasn't thinking about pursing pathology, and so decided to do something else. Now being interested in pathology, and almost starting my 4th year, I'm really trying to figure out how the past way to approach scheduling my rotations.

Our school allows us to do a maxium of 3 rotations in any given specialty. Right now I have scheduled 2 pathology rotations. The first one is around July to Aug (2nd rotation for 4th year) and is at a hospital that does not have a residency program. My reasoning was, I didn't want to look like a complete idiot at future rotations, since I haven't had a pathology rotation yet. I figure this one would be a warm up. Is this a waste of a rotation? My second path rotation falls around August to September, and is at a major university with a residency program. Should I be doing all of my path rotations as audition rotations, and should I do 3 consecutive pathology rotations, or is this overkill??

As far as competitiveness, I would say I'm an average applicant. My COMLEX score is definitely better than my USMLE score, which was average.

I know the topic of audition rotations has been discussed in other threads, but they seem to be related to either uncompetitve fields or super competitive fields. I'm not sure where pathology falls. Btw, if there are any DOs out there, I'd love to hear what you have to say!

Thanks in advance for any advice!

I recommend that both rotations are at programs that you are interested in. It's much better to get your face in there for people to see. Most places will cut you some slack because most medical students don't do ANY pathology rotations. Besides, PDs are interested in your potential to do well not how much pathology you know as a medical student.

my 2.

Geo
 
I recommend that both rotations are at programs that you are interested in. It's much better to get your face in there for people to see. Most places will cut you some slack because most medical students don't do ANY pathology rotations. Besides, PDs are interested in your potential to do well not how much pathology you know as a medical student.

my 2.

Geo

Congrats on Post # 666
 
Don't worry about looking like an idiot - you still will even after a "practice" rotation. Everyone does! I've done three path rotations this year and expect to look like a complete idiot for at least the first few months of residency. I will do my best to correct this, but I've accepted the fact that it will happen

The important thing is to show interest and to read, IMHO (and also advice from residents, ect)

My 2 cents is to try to rotate where you want to go without being TOO repetitive. IE doing an AP and a CP rotation and then doing a surgical away rotation. Definitely do a rotation in path at your home school before doing any aways.
 
I completely agree with previous posters that a "practice" pathology rotation at a hospital without a residency is a waste of your time. As mentioned above, most med students are pretty clueless about pathology (I know I was) and it will be your eager display of interest in the field, work ethic, ability to get along with colleagues, etc. that make you shine during a rotation.

I would do one path rotation at a local program with a residency (if you want to apply/interview there) and another audition rotation at whatever program you are most interested in. I would suggest trying to spend some time on AP and some time on CP at both places if possible, so you can meet more of the faculty and get a better sense of how both areas are run in each program. I'm not sure what your medical school has available, but for your third month you might want to think about looking at a particular subspecialty in more detail (i.e. forensics at the medical examiner's, blood bank/transfusion, molecular, etc.).
 
Wow, I was just thinking about starting a thread like this! I am in a similar situation. I am a 2nd year medical student (about to take boards) and start rotations in July. I have wanted to do pathology since high school and it's the only reason I am in medical school. I am stressing myself out (probably too much) about setting up rotations. I am also an osteopathic student and the anxiety is probably a result of the importance of rotating at a program to even get looked at when it comes to osteopathic residencies.
I have an elective month in August (my 2nd EVER rotation) and another one in January of my third year. My school does not have any restrictions on the number of rotations we can do in one specialty. Out of all 8 of my electives, 2 have to be primary care but that's it. So, I guess I could technically do 6 path rotations. I know that is probably overkill but I am in the same boat as the original poster. I have been looking to set up rotations at some path programs but most of them specify that you need to be a 4th year and some don't even accept osteopathic students for rotations. So I was wondering what to do with these 2 months? I was thinking about setting up a rotation with a local pathologist to avoid "looking stupid" at my subsequent rotations but from reading this post, I'm guessing it's inevitable to be clueless on path rotations.
FreakedOut: Did you have any problems getting the one path rotation at the residency program set up?

I have started to narrow some places down (ie emailed all the programs in the country to get a feel for who accepts COMLEX over USMLE and who actually has DO residents in their program) and surprisingly there are about 60+ programs that fall into this category. The problem is just knowing when and how to schedule rotations and get seen. I am probably worrying ENTIRELY too much but I am just very concerned of not getting into a decent path program in a couple years. It's just the lack of knowing what to do and how to strategically plan everything that is frustrating!
 
Wow, I was just thinking about starting a thread like this! I am in a similar situation. I am a 2nd year medical student (about to take boards) and start rotations in July. I have wanted to do pathology since high school and it's the only reason I am in medical school. I am stressing myself out (probably too much) about setting up rotations. I am also an osteopathic student and the anxiety is probably a result of the importance of rotating at a program to even get looked at when it comes to osteopathic residencies.
I have an elective month in August (my 2nd EVER rotation) and another one in January of my third year. My school does not have any restrictions on the number of rotations we can do in one specialty. Out of all 8 of my electives, 2 have to be primary care but that's it. So, I guess I could technically do 6 path rotations. I know that is probably overkill but I am in the same boat as the original poster. I have been looking to set up rotations at some path programs but most of them specify that you need to be a 4th year and some don't even accept osteopathic students for rotations. So I was wondering what to do with these 2 months? I was thinking about setting up a rotation with a local pathologist to avoid "looking stupid" at my subsequent rotations but from reading this post, I'm guessing it's inevitable to be clueless on path rotations.
FreakedOut: Did you have any problems getting the one path rotation at the residency program set up?

I have started to narrow some places down (ie emailed all the programs in the country to get a feel for who accepts COMLEX over USMLE and who actually has DO residents in their program) and surprisingly there are about 60+ programs that fall into this category. The problem is just knowing when and how to schedule rotations and get seen. I am probably worrying ENTIRELY too much but I am just very concerned of not getting into a decent path program in a couple years. It's just the lack of knowing what to do and how to strategically plan everything that is frustrating!

Well so far my application to that one program is still being processed. They told me up to 10 weeks actually (another frustration)....hopefully it won't take that long. Many of the schools I've come across don't even know availability until June because they have to schedule their own students first. So I feel like I have to go with whatever program knows availability now because if I wait to find out from others, I might risk not getting anything at all.

But I know how you feel about the lack of knowing what to do and how to plan. I think for your 2 months if you can't get to rotate at any programs, maybe a rotation with a local pathologist is the way to go, as you mentioned. Try and talk to some of your path professors and see what they have to say.

Thanks to the previous posters for your advice!
 
Wow, I was just thinking about starting a thread like this! I am in a similar situation. I am a 2nd year medical student (about to take boards) and start rotations in July. I have wanted to do pathology since high school and it's the only reason I am in medical school. I am stressing myself out (probably too much) about setting up rotations. I am also an osteopathic student and the anxiety is probably a result of the importance of rotating at a program to even get looked at when it comes to osteopathic residencies.
I have an elective month in August (my 2nd EVER rotation) and another one in January of my third year. My school does not have any restrictions on the number of rotations we can do in one specialty. Out of all 8 of my electives, 2 have to be primary care but that's it. So, I guess I could technically do 6 path rotations. I know that is probably overkill but I am in the same boat as the original poster. I have been looking to set up rotations at some path programs but most of them specify that you need to be a 4th year and some don't even accept osteopathic students for rotations. So I was wondering what to do with these 2 months? I was thinking about setting up a rotation with a local pathologist to avoid "looking stupid" at my subsequent rotations but from reading this post, I'm guessing it's inevitable to be clueless on path rotations.
FreakedOut: Did you have any problems getting the one path rotation at the residency program set up?

I have started to narrow some places down (ie emailed all the programs in the country to get a feel for who accepts COMLEX over USMLE and who actually has DO residents in their program) and surprisingly there are about 60+ programs that fall into this category. The problem is just knowing when and how to schedule rotations and get seen. I am probably worrying ENTIRELY too much but I am just very concerned of not getting into a decent path program in a couple years. It's just the lack of knowing what to do and how to strategically plan everything that is frustrating!

just wondering if u knew of any def DO unfriendly programs? i also go to to a DO school and will be matching into pathology hopefully this coming year w/ u. could've graduated last year but finished a little late so decided to do an mph and apply this year on time. i already completed 4 path rotations (2 were 2 wks) and 1 was at a program w/o a residency. i needed a 2 wk rotation since one of my CP rotations was only 2 wks and i didn't feel it was a waste of time even though it couldn't be an audition rotation. i got more time actually to sit individually w/ the attendings b/c they didn't need to teach residents.

honestly, even as a DO student, i don't think u need more than 3 max rotations in pathology even if u have more electives. i was told by most of the residents at programs i rotated at, they did only 1 or 2 path electives, but they also were MDs. since my school also only allows 3 electives in the same specialty, i did the other electives in closely related fields of interest for me (id, hem, and public health research/id pathology).

having been where u guys r now, i know the stress of the uncertainty of having to apply to MD residencies as a DO and not knowing if we need to "do more" to get looked at the same as an MD candidate. i didn't have any problems setting up my path rotations but i also did them late (2nd semester) since i knew that i was going to match in 2012 and i'm guessing fall electives are filled much more quickly and are harder to come by. so just apply as early as u can so that u can avoid missing out b/c they don't have spots available. some programs i applied to had application fees and some wanted transcripts (and could turn u down if they didn't like ur grades).

sometimes its difficult to know what to do on path electives esp if the program/ppl don't go out of their way to have a structured plan for u. so take initiative...brush up on ur histo so that u can at least id what tissue u r looking at during surgpath signouts. robbins is also good to read and knowing ur step 1 boards type "most commons" helps (i got asked what is the most common tumor in ...? etc). offer to do a presentation (i know at one program, some residents were amazed i volunteered to do one b/c no med student ever had and it helped them out that week b/c they were short a presenter and trying to recruit someone). 2 programs i rotated w/ required a presentation so if u put together one awesome one (i was lucky, i had actual bone marrow bx slides from my hem rotation and supplemented w/ some web pix, too), u can recycle the presentation or tweak it for each site if u want to cut down on the work of putting together a different one for each site. one of my sites required that we found a case early at their site (tell your resident to be on the look out and to point out to u if there is an interesting case u can use for a presentation at the end of rotation) - and u had to get the clinical info, etc from the EMR (resident said she could help since i didn't have complete access) and include that, too.

most places won't let u gross due to liability issues but if they do, by all means, do (after making sure u know what u're doing b/c that's precious tissue if u f it up)! ask if they have slide boxes of interesting teaching cases or current cases that u can preview on ur own - if they're teaching cases, maybe ask a nice resident if they'll go over them w/ u after u've previewed/tried on ur own. if they're current cases, then ask to preview a couple that the resident is done looking at and then sit in on the signout w/ that resident and her/his attending.

find out the schedules for the residents (eg - who is on autopsy, etc) and then introduce urself to that resident and let them know u're interesting in going w/ them to ...eg - autopsy - when there is one and if its ok w/ them. i am more interested in cp so i spent a lot of time on mol path, micro, blood bank/tm/apheresis, chem, hemepath. if u have a good idea of what u'd like to try, its easier for them to figure out who to send u to (or which resident to assign u w/ that day) if they don't already have that planned out for u (most places i was at didn't have a plan for me and built the rotation around my interests).

this is getting long so if u have specific questions, PM me (i rotated at community based hospitals w/ and w/o a residency, top tier academic center, and government sites due to my interest in public health).
 
just wondering if u knew of any def DO unfriendly programs? i also go to to a DO school and will be matching into pathology hopefully this coming year w/ u. could've graduated last year but finished a little late so decided to do an mph and apply this year on time. i already completed 4 path rotations (2 were 2 wks) and 1 was at a program w/o a residency. i needed a 2 wk rotation since one of my CP rotations was only 2 wks and i didn't feel it was a waste of time even though it couldn't be an audition rotation. i got more time actually to sit individually w/ the attendings b/c they didn't need to teach residents.

honestly, even as a DO student, i don't think u need more than 3 max rotations in pathology even if u have more electives. i was told by most of the residents at programs i rotated at, they did only 1 or 2 path electives, but they also were MDs. since my school also only allows 3 electives in the same specialty, i did the other electives in closely related fields of interest for me (id, hem, and public health research/id pathology).

having been where u guys r now, i know the stress of the uncertainty of having to apply to MD residencies as a DO and not knowing if we need to "do more" to get looked at the same as an MD candidate. i didn't have any problems setting up my path rotations but i also did them late (2nd semester) since i knew that i was going to match in 2012 and i'm guessing fall electives are filled much more quickly and are harder to come by. so just apply as early as u can so that u can avoid missing out b/c they don't have spots available. some programs i applied to had application fees and some wanted transcripts (and could turn u down if they didn't like ur grades).
snipped the rest...

I just graduated from a DO school this year and am halfway into my first month in pathology residency. In medical school I did a total of five pathology rotations, each 2 weeks long, and one forensics rotation, and I was actually told at some of my interviews that that might have been pathology overkill. I didn't think so, but from my experience in residency so far and from what I've heard from my colleagues at other residencies, we really are started at ground zero with respect to knowing practical pathology. Two of my rotations were with residency programs, one of which I ended up not even applying to because of my experience there. I matched at a location I had never been to before my interview there. So the crap about audition rotations being important in that sense---false for me. You can't really DO anything on a path rotation anyway besides sit at sign out or watch people gross. So it's all about your learning, not you trying to look awesome.

From the perspective of a DO entering the MD world, don't buy into the across-the board anti-DO bias BS. Also, DO NOT ENTER THE ERAS SEASON with the DO chip on your shoulder. If you're smart, have good scores and letters and don't screw up your interviews, you'll be fine. There are a couple programs that I believe just don't accept DO's, and send me a PM for my interview breakdown and how I felt about things during my interview cycle last year--I'm more than happy to share my experience and give any advice to you guys, since I really had no guidance at my school since I wasn't going into primary care. Good luck!
 
Guidance regarding a future in pathology I feel is notoriously substandard at most medical schools, which goes hand in hand with the substandard to nonexistant teaching of pathology as it is practiced by an AP/CP pathologist -- there's often a lot of pathophysiology, but not much of what a practicing pathologist does day-to-day. Most pathology residency programs seem to understand this, and as such most MD/DO students are on essentially the same poor initial footing going into either electives or residency.

In general I suggest on the order of a couple of months worth of practical pathology rotations -- one of your goals is to see what a pathologist actually does day-to-day, and determine if it's really something you're interested in. You're not really going to have enough scope time to learn a significant amount of histology during an elective, though you -might- get a chance to get your hands dirty a little with grossing &/or autopsies -- point being, doing a couple of local months isn't going to really buff you up "academically" for an elective at a hot program you want to end up in, though it might help you get familiarized with the basic workings of a path department. CP is a little different because parts of it (transfusion, for example) I think you can be more involved in and learn about. If you have limited elective time, go to the grooviest places you can. If you have a lot of elective time, sure it's worth rotating locally (helps you find someone local you can come back to for career advice too), but again I'd focus on places you think you might want to land. Personally. Then I'd do some electives in things I will probably never get to see or do again.
 
Top