Rampant Cheating

Started by Sesom
Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

Sesom

Full Member
10+ Year Member
I'm in a math class and there are a bunch of middle eastern guys cheating on the tests. It's pretty obvious and it happens every time the teacher turns his back. A lot of the time they'll even go up and ask the teacher questions to distract him. I am in the class with a friend and one of the cheaters (the one who actually knows the material) approached my friend after class and offered to let my friend in on the cheating. The reason this guy approached my friend is because my friend noticed he was cheating. He is pretty much afraid of my friend spilling the beans.

The guy admitted to how he is doing it via picture messaging and said that there were 11 other people involved who he is providing test answers. All of these guys are from the same country (I think) and this guy claims that if they do not make the grade they will be deported back and have to pay their government the cost of coming to America + tuition + living. So it's obviously a big deal for them.

How do you guys feel about telling on a group of 11 guys that runs the risk of getting them deported? Would you be worried that there could be revenge of some sort?
 
I'm in a math class and there are a bunch of middle eastern guys cheating on the tests. It's pretty obvious and it happens every time the teacher turns his back. A lot of the time they'll even go up and ask the teacher questions to distract him. I am in the class with a friend and one of the cheaters (the one who actually knows the material) approached my friend after class and offered to let my friend in on the cheating. The reason this guy approached my friend is because my friend noticed he was cheating. He is pretty much afraid of my friend spilling the beans.

The guy admitted to how he is doing it via picture messaging and said that there were 11 other people involved who he is providing test answers. All of these guys are from the same country (I think) and this guy claims that if they do not make the grade they will be deported back and have to pay their government the cost of coming to America + tuition + living. So it's obviously a big deal for them.

How do you guys feel about telling on a group of 11 guys that runs the risk of getting them deported? Would you be worried that there could be revenge of some sort?

Do you go to Wayne State... serious question...

Also, I don't think you should rat them out. If it's THAT obvious, the professor/TA/proctor should be noticing it.

I think that excuse of... getting deported bla bla bla is complete garbage. Someone comes to America to live the dream, and is here on the condition of getting good grades... they'd probably buckle down.
 
I don't think their personal gain justifies cheating. Many of us theoretically have something to gain by cheating and something we could no longer attain without it. That doesn't justify it.

Revenge is possible if they take this stuff really seriously, get into that "mob" mentality and see you as an easy target. However, if you decide that you will expose them, you need not be so overt about it that it's obvious that it's you. From what you've described, it sounds like a lot of people in the class could have noticed.

Personally, I would email the professor/TA anonymously and tell them to watch their students closer because some of them are cheating.
 
Do you go to Wayne State... serious question...

Also, I don't think you should rat them out. If it's THAT obvious, the professor/TA/proctor should be noticing it.

I think that excuse of... getting deported bla bla bla is complete garbage. Someone comes to America to live the dream, and is here on the condition of getting good grades... they'd probably buckle down.

I don't think they come looking for an American dream. Most of the middle eastern students at my university drive Aston Martins, GTR's, Maseratis, Vipers, Z06s, 911s, and Range Rovers (there is also the poor ones who drive camaros...). Seriously, for their age they are some of the wealthiest individuals I know.
 
Tell your professor/TA to keep a closer eye on them. And I really hope they're not planning to apply to medical school.
 
Back in Anatomy lab, I worked my ass off to get what I thought was the only A in the class. I saw a pudgy sorority girl cheating her ass off all through the final, and thought nothing of it. She can't do that well, she never came to class anyway.

Grades were posted, I got an 89.8 B, and that bitch got a 90. That day changed how I viewed cheaters. The TA went on to tell me if my 89.blahblah was the highest in the class she would have rounded it to an A.

I would drop an anonymous hint to the TA if I were in your shoes. Middle eastern kids cheat up and down in my o-chem class, and I'm counting down the days until they're caught. My professor is the drill-instructor type, and fireworks will fly.
 
Whether or not to discuss the violation of your school's honor code with your professor is one matter.

Whether or not the reasons for those students cheating merit their actions is another. This one's easier: the answer is they don't. Always.
 
I wouldn't rat them out. They're walking a fine line and if their cheating is as rampant as you say it is, there's a good chance they'll eventually get caught, whether in this or a future class. As CodeBlu said, don't buy into their "deportation" excuse. If you're really compelled to do something about the situation, I think the anonymous email to your TA or professor letting him know to keep a closer eye during exams in your best bet. Just my two cents.
 
Not sure about your school, but at BOTH my undergrad and current med school TECHNICALLY if you dont tell on them you have committed academic dishonest and can get in trouble IF you knew (which you obviously do).

So the way I see it....now its not about ratting them out, its to prevent your ass from being on the line when the cards fall.
 
Not sure about your school, but at BOTH my undergrad and current med school TECHNICALLY if you dont tell on them you have committed academic dishonest and can get in trouble IF you knew (which you obviously do).

So the way I see it....now its not about ratting them out, its to prevent your ass from being on the line when the cards fall.

👍

OP: what if that other kid that knows they are cheating goes to the Professor? He says, "Professor, there's a lot of cheating going on. If you don't believe me, I believe Sesom can corroborate my story - I believe he saw the cheaters as well" - at which point you either lie and say you didn't see anything or confess to violating honor code by knowing cheating is going on.
 
Serious--but sensitive--question for those of you from another country or who have extensive knowledge of other cultures: Is there a cultural-type reason why cheating/plagiarism seems to happen so disproportionately with foreign students? I'm not trying to stereotype or diss any nationalities, but are we here in America just way more tightwad about intellectual property and academic honesty issues than other societies? In other places is the cultural value of "being loyal" to your friends by "helping them out" more important than strict fairness and intolerance of rule-breakers?

Not saying that I empathize at all with these cheaters... mostly I'm just bewildered. Not the first time I've seen/heard of such blatant cheating, and not the first time the offenders came from some middle eastern or Asian country. They aren't even trying to rationalize to themselves why it's OK... they just don't care that it's unfair to others. Blows my mind.
 
I agree that you should inform the professor/TA but do so discretely/anonymously. If you don't do it anonymously and decline to specify which students are at fault, they might be able to force you to reveal the students' identities on pain of violation yourself, somewhat like others said about the academic integrity code stuff.

At the same time though, I agree you're probably bound by the integrity code to inform the professors of cheating regardless, so if you got asked about it and said "Well, I emailed anonymously..." that might not cut it.
 
Serious--but sensitive--question for those of you from another country or who have extensive knowledge of other cultures: Is there a cultural-type reason why cheating/plagiarism seems to happen so disproportionately with foreign students? I'm not trying to stereotype or diss any nationalities, but are we here in America just way more tightwad about intellectual property and academic honesty issues than other societies? In other places is the cultural value of "being loyal" to your friends by "helping them out" more important than strict fairness and intolerance of rule-breakers?

Not saying that I empathize at all with these cheaters... mostly I'm just bewildered. Not the first time I've seen/heard of such blatant cheating, and not the first time the offenders came from some middle eastern or Asian country. They aren't even trying to rationalize to themselves why it's OK... they just don't care that it's unfair to others. Blows my mind.

They learn from the best. What's an honest person to do when cheating is institutionalized?
 
Serious--but sensitive--question for those of you from another country or who have extensive knowledge of other cultures: Is there a cultural-type reason why cheating/plagiarism seems to happen so disproportionately with foreign students? I'm not trying to stereotype or diss any nationalities, but are we here in America just way more tightwad about intellectual property and academic honesty issues than other societies? In other places is the cultural value of "being loyal" to your friends by "helping them out" more important than strict fairness and intolerance of rule-breakers?

Not saying that I empathize at all with these cheaters... mostly I'm just bewildered. Not the first time I've seen/heard of such blatant cheating, and not the first time the offenders came from some middle eastern or Asian country. They aren't even trying to rationalize to themselves why it's OK... they just don't care that it's unfair to others. Blows my mind.

Maybe you just notice it more when someone "different" than yourself does it (I think it's called confirmation bias), but your experiences at your particular school don't exactly confirm a trend of "foreign cheaters". I know many, many hard working foreign students who don't cheat and I have seen quite a few American (White) individuals get caught cheating. Should I then assume that all White people, or better yet, all Americans, are cheaters? Cheating happens at any academic institution. There is no cultural factor that explains it. It may be the situation that foreign students face in this country which makes them feel extra pressure to succeed, but until someone shows me some kind of actual evidence that these students cheat more, I will have a hard time believing it.

To the OP, the middle east isn't a country, so before you start making certain cultural assumptions, at least name a country and give these people that respect.
 
Maybe you just notice it more when someone "different" than yourself does it (I think it's called confirmation bias), but your experiences at your particular school don't exactly confirm a trend of "foreign cheaters". I know many, many hard working foreign students who don't cheat and I have seen quite a few American (White) individuals get caught cheating. Should I then assume that all White people, or better yet, all Americans, are cheaters? Cheating happens at any academic institution. There is no cultural factor that explains it. It may be the situation that foreign students face in this country which makes them feel extra pressure to succeed, but until someone shows me some kind of actual evidence that these students cheat more, I will have a hard time believing it.

To the OP, the middle east isn't a country, so before you start making certain cultural assumptions, at least name a country and give these people that respect.

Blackwell while I agree with you on your first paragraph, in the OP's defense he did say middle eastern country, not that the middle east was a country unto itself. I don't think he was insulting anyone, just had a question based on his perception.
 
Serious--but sensitive--question for those of you from another country or who have extensive knowledge of other cultures: Is there a cultural-type reason why cheating/plagiarism seems to happen so disproportionately with foreign students? I'm not trying to stereotype or diss any nationalities, but are we here in America just way more tightwad about intellectual property and academic honesty issues than other societies? In other places is the cultural value of "being loyal" to your friends by "helping them out" more important than strict fairness and intolerance of rule-breakers?

Not saying that I empathize at all with these cheaters... mostly I'm just bewildered. Not the first time I've seen/heard of such blatant cheating, and not the first time the offenders came from some middle eastern or Asian country. They aren't even trying to rationalize to themselves why it's OK... they just don't care that it's unfair to others. Blows my mind.

I don't know about the middle east, but I've spent a lot of time in Asia and South Asia. The academic culture there is very rigorous, and in many countries a 70% or higher is an A grade, simply because it's way too hard to get an A. So yes, cheating is not as frowned upon in Asia as I know it, but in America one instance of cheating can ruin your career.
 
I don't know about the middle east, but I've spent a lot of time in Asia and South Asia. The academic culture there is very rigorous, and in many countries a 70% or higher is an A grade, simply because it's way too hard to get an A. So yes, cheating is not as frowned upon in Asia as I know it, but in America one instance of cheating can ruin your career.

😕
 
I don't think they come looking for an American dream. Most of the middle eastern students at my university drive Aston Martins, GTR's, Maseratis, Vipers, Z06s, 911s, and Range Rovers (there is also the poor ones who drive camaros...). Seriously, for their age they are some of the wealthiest individuals I know.

Yeah it's because plane tickets and full tuition aren't cheap so of course poor people will find it more difficult to study here. They're here to take advantage of an American education which probably opens some doors.

Anyway, I would do what narmerguy says, tell the professor and ta anonymously. The possibility of deportation is irrelevant. There should be zero tolerance for any kind of cheating.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If you can let the professior and/or TA know about the cheating TACTFULLY - and you can otherwise prove it (or the professor can prove it by going back and looking at the test - then I would definitely let them know. If you can't do either of those things, however, you run the risk of just coming across as a fool.
 
I don't know about the middle east, but I've spent a lot of time in Asia and South Asia. The academic culture there is very rigorous, and in many countries a 70% or higher is an A grade, simply because it's way too hard to get an A. So yes, cheating is not as frowned upon in Asia as I know it, but in America one instance of cheating can ruin your career.

I don't know about the places you might have been to, but where I lived for nine years, getting caught cheating at the school level meant corporal punishment, and you were not allowed to take any exam in any subject for that testing period. Of course there were teachers who let students off with initial warnings, but if they repeated their offense, they were punished.

When it came to secondary-level final exams (which involved invigilators sent by the state/national board of education) and university-level exams, if you were caught cheating, in addition to being kicked out, you would be barred from retaking those exams for 1-3 years.

And yes, it is very difficult perform well in school in Asia because of the system there, which is why some tend to repeatedly cheat regardless of the risks.
 
I know it sounds crazy, but I know some professors who have done work in China and basically everyone is so compelled to be successful that you do whatever it takes, so there are issues with academic integrity, and scientific papers coming from there may be suspect. In Greece cheating is common for a totally different reason. Then there are other countries where cheating is practically unheard of due to cultural views on success and integrity.
 
I know it sounds crazy, but I know some professors who have done work in China and basically everyone is so compelled to be successful that you do whatever it takes, so there are issues with academic integrity, and scientific papers coming from there may be suspect. In Greece cheating is common for a totally different reason. Then there are other countries where cheating is practically unheard of due to cultural views on success and integrity.

I think it's important to remember the limitations of individual experience in characterizing an entire nation (or group of nations). I have heard plenty of the suspect nature of scientific papers coming from China, but I think until there is some concrete evidence, it would be best to not spread what could be nothing more than slander.

The cultural reluctance (or lack thereof) to cheat is really irrelevant to this topic. Whether these individuals are Middle Eastern, Asian, or whatever, we should not vary our morals or how we handle people breaking these sorts of rules.
 
Rat them out, but do it anonymously. If you make a big scene, they'll probably get kicked out, but you will forevermore be known as "that guy."
 
Not sure about your school, but at BOTH my undergrad and current med school TECHNICALLY if you dont tell on them you have committed academic dishonest and can get in trouble IF you knew (which you obviously do).

So the way I see it....now its not about ratting them out, its to prevent your ass from being on the line when the cards fall.

I had a real honor code as well. If you didn't report it, it was your backside facing expulsion. Just because you may not have rigid honor code doesn't mean that you should take a less honorable path. Report them all. It's up to the faculty to follow up and/or investigate. If they choose to ignore what should be obvious proof on their exams, that says volumes about the integrity of your university.
 
Not sure about your school, but at BOTH my undergrad and current med school TECHNICALLY if you dont tell on them you have committed academic dishonest and can get in trouble IF you knew (which you obviously do).

So the way I see it....now its not about ratting them out, its to prevent your ass from being on the line when the cards fall.

I'm really not worried about this. I worry that a group of 11 guys have just been outed to a specific person. So now these guys know that person has knowledge of their cheating ring. Assuming the consequence is high for them if they are caught, would any of you feel a little threatened having to show up to class if they were caught? This isn't on the main campus, it is in a building 40 minutes away from the main campus.

👍

OP: what if that other kid that knows they are cheating goes to the Professor? He says, "Professor, there's a lot of cheating going on. If you don't believe me, I believe Sesom can corroborate my story - I believe he saw the cheaters as well" - at which point you either lie and say you didn't see anything or confess to violating honor code by knowing cheating is going on.

When I say friend I am actually talking about my girlfriend of 7 years. I would have no problem corroborating her story. I have seen cheating myself but she got an outright confession from the guy taking pictures of his test.

During the test she also informed the teacher that when he left the room 6 guys traded calculators.

When I had finished my test I got up to put on my jacket and the two guys sitting behind me were cheating out in the open. These guys noticed I was giving them a WTF look and when I went up to the professor they were stuffing papers into their backpack.

To the OP, the middle east isn't a country, so before you start making certain cultural assumptions, at least name a country and give these people that respect.

I never said the middle east was a country I was referring to the geographic area they are from. I do know the guy who confessed is from Kuwait . They may or may not all be from Kuwait, I don't know because I didn't think to ask.

It is more disrespectful for you to portray my post as insensitive than for me to reference their geographic location.
 
Last edited:
Why does it matter that they are Middle Eastern...

It doesn't matter in as much as the thread isn't about whether people from there cheat. However it is identifiable and in this class it is the uniting aspect between the people who are cheating. Is there someone in the class who isn't cheating that is from the middle east? maybe, I don't know.

The class is made up of hispanic and white people. On test day the dynamic changes to half the class being middle eastern. So for my purpose, it is the easiest way to identify the group of cheaters who happen to be racially homogeneous.
 
It doesn't matter in as much as the thread isn't about whether people from there cheat. However it is identifiable and in this class it is the uniting aspect between the people who are cheating. Is there someone in the class who isn't cheating that is from the middle east? maybe, I don't know.

The class is made up of hispanic and white people. On test day the dynamic changes to half the class being middle eastern. So for my purpose, it is the easiest way to identify the group of cheaters who happen to be racially homogeneous.

Why does it bother you? He said nothing bad about the race in general, just about the people who he referred to as "Middle-Eastern."
It is fairly pointless to defend yourself to the PC police. Once you make any comment they decide is "insensitive" or "racist" or "bigoted," anything you do to defend your comment is simply further proof of your intellectual inferiority and cultural insensitivity🙄.
 
Why does it bother you? He said nothing bad about the race in general, just about the people who he referred to as "Middle-Eastern."

It is fairly pointless to defend yourself to the PC police. Once you make any comment they decide is "insensitive" or "racist" or "bigoted," anything you do to defend your comment is simply further proof of your intellectual inferiority and cultural insensitivity🙄.

There is nothing gained in indicating their assumed ethnicity except to identify oneself as someone who is either culturally insensitive or at the very least not particularly socially adept.
 
There is nothing gained in indicating their assumed ethnicity except to identify oneself as someone who is either culturally insensitive or at the very least not particularly socially adept.

Well it's part of my story so deal with it.
 
It doesn't matter in as much as the thread isn't about whether people from there cheat. However it is identifiable and in this class it is the uniting aspect between the people who are cheating. Is there someone in the class who isn't cheating that is from the middle east? maybe, I don't know.

The class is made up of hispanic and white people. On test day the dynamic changes to half the class being middle eastern. So for my purpose, it is the easiest way to identify the group of cheaters who happen to be racially homogeneous.

Or you could read his post above explaining why he bothered to mention it.......

Well, it's generally a pretty weak reason. It would have been much easier to simply say that it was because it was critical to explaining the whole "deportation" angle, but that was obviously a phony excuse on their part anyway.

Either way, I think Sesom's usage is neither inflammatory nor significantly useful to the point that we should be paying any attention to it. Why not everyone ignore this aspect of the thread (I know) and just focus on the core problem? It's actually a good chance to generate some meaningful discussion on how to handle cheating and what one ought to do in these situations.
 
Which was fairly weak and useless to people who aren't in his class.🙂
Maybe so, but I am quite confident it fails to rise to the "why does every middle-eastern student in all of my classes always have to cheat? why are they all like that???" level, which is what would be necessary to justify the rabid PC response seen in some of the postings on this thread. 😉
 
Either way, I think Sesom's usage is neither inflammatory nor significantly useful to the point that we should be paying any attention to it. Why not everyone ignore this aspect of the thread (I know) and just focus on the core problem? It's actually a good chance to generate some meaningful discussion on how to handle cheating and what one ought to do in these situations.
I would have to agree with this, in its entirety. My point was that it was simply pointless to argue with those who jump on the PC police bandwagon any time any group is mentioned as being part of a group. Agree that it is best to let this part of the thread die.
 
I would have to agree with this, in its entirety. My point was that it was simply pointless to argue with those who jump on the PC police bandwagon any time any group is mentioned as being part of a group. Agree that it is best to let this part of the thread die.

Consensus seems to be report anonymously/non-obviously for everyone's benefit.👍
 
It is fairly pointless to defend yourself to the PC police. Once you make any comment they decide is "insensitive" or "racist" or "bigoted," anything you do to defend your comment is simply further proof of your intellectual inferiority and cultural insensitivity🙄.

andddddddd you've successfully derailed this conversation. Poor form
 
I'd report it anonymously. Send an email from another account and say you're a student in the class, but don't want to be identified and you have seen the group of students you mentioned cheating. Cheaters are crap. I don't care what the reason is. Report them.
 
I think it's important to remember the limitations of individual experience in characterizing an entire nation (or group of nations). I have heard plenty of the suspect nature of scientific papers coming from China, but I think until there is some concrete evidence, it would be best to not spread what could be nothing more than slander.

The cultural reluctance (or lack thereof) to cheat is really irrelevant to this topic. Whether these individuals are Middle Eastern, Asian, or whatever, we should not vary our morals or how we handle people breaking these sorts of rules.

Fair enough. The conversation was taking a bit of a detour, and I was just offering some of my experience on that, not slander anyone. But yeah, this:
Either way, I think Sesom's usage is neither inflammatory nor significantly useful to the point that we should be paying any attention to it. Why not everyone ignore this aspect of the thread (I know) and just focus on the core problem? It's actually a good chance to generate some meaningful discussion on how to handle cheating and what one ought to do in these situations.
is pretty much on point
 
There is nothing gained in indicating their assumed ethnicity except to identify oneself as someone who is either culturally insensitive or at the very least not particularly socially adept.
This sounds so nice and politically correct...but its not true.
 
In light of the way this thread is going, I'm guessing I'll get labeled as culturally insensitive but I can live with that. At my school the cheating out of control in the big science classes. There are students who talk in a foreign language (foreign to me at least) during the entire exam. It's completely unfair, and if anyone ever started talking to me in my first language during the exam I'd tell them to f... off and report them.
 
In light of the way this thread is going, I'm guessing I'll get labeled as culturally insensitive but I can live with that. At my school the cheating out of control in the big science classes. There are students who talk in a foreign language (foreign to me at least) during the entire exam. It's completely unfair, and if anyone ever started talking to me in my first language during the exam I'd tell them to f... off and report them.
Is the professor deaf? Who talks during an exam?
 
I lived with two Saudi students in the dorms back in the day. Awesome guys, fun to hang out with, and well-traveled. They were both there because their government realizes that for them to really make a future of themselves and their country, they need to get the best education possible, so they send them here to the States. (Insert running out of oil joke here). Obviously, there's conditions to their stay, as not everyone is able to come to the US for a free education. So yes, their deportation risk is very much real. There's a cultural component to factor in as well. Like someone above mentioned in big bold words, cheating is thought of differently in Asia, where things are just hyper-competitive and your entire family's future hinges on your degree.

In this situation, you have to ask yourself a few questions: Is the cheating bad enough that it ruins the curve for everyone? Are other people's academics hurting because of this? Do you have solid evidence?

I'd approach both the students and the teacher. Tell the students you're sick of working your butt off but I understand you could get deported, but you have seen them cheat and you have told the professor that people are cheating in the class (although no one in particular). Then tell the professor that some people are cheating on tests (although no one in particular). If you want to, do it anonymously at both ends to avoid retribution. And if they threaten retribution, there's always blackmail. 👍