I counted about 8 schools on your list you could say going in you had a fair/reasonable etc chance of getting a II at. For a CA applicant, as you saw that's often too low. It would help to get more service with the less fortunate/most vulnerable populations.
There is no point reapplying to Columbia, Northwestern, NYU, Sinai, Pitt, Weill UCSF and Stanford. Probably can put UCSD, Emory, UCLA and perhaps Dartmouth and Boston U in that category as well. You dont fit what Rush is looking for either.
A reapplicant with 3 MCAT scores brings on their own set of risks to some extent. Given that and the CA status, you really want about 15 schools you can go in saying you have a fair/reasonable shot at getting a II at. And you shouldnt be a reapplicant at most.
I might give FAU, Temple, Hofstra, Jefferson, SLU, Tufts, Rochester and Miami another run at it. Impossible to say how the reapp status changes things, but collectively if you are looking at that 15 target number maybe count each of these schools as 0.5(completely arbitrary point more is focus on targeting new schools). Medical College of Wisconsin, Albany, UIC and both Arizona schools really should be on your list. That gets you closer to that 15 number.
Go through MSAR and find some more schools with take at least 20% OOS(preferably <10k apps) and with an MCAT median of 31-32(Oakland as an ex). You can find at least 5 more. Get a rough idea of the OOS app/OOS matriculant ratio as well(ie it's going to be high at GW, Quinnipac, Rush, Drexel types)