Research Papers

Get help with your application

Use all the free resources available to you from SDN: articles, guides, expert advising, forums discussions, and school research.

ghostridermedic

Full Member
10+ Year Member
As part of my organic class, my teacher suggested that anyone interested in going to graduate or medical schools write 2 short research papers. That way, when asked for recommendation letters he will have a good baseline to write a letter based on our classwork and these papers in particular.

Our papers are supposed to be "reviews" of a published research paper. We are also tasked with bringing in outside, referenced sources into these papers. I was graded highly on both however that doesn't mean that a admission committee will agree on their quality.

I want to make sure these papers are on par for submission with my application packets for the 2012 admission. Any opinions on how I did on these?

Any suggestions or comments are welcomed, especially from people with experience in the admission process.

Files are attached below.
 

Attachments

Sorry dude but you can't use SDN for what is basically homework help.

You might go to the research forum to ask a more general question on how to read/interpret/write reviews but I highly doubt you'll get much traction. This is the kind of stuff that you learn from class and from your mentors. Aside from getting someone to generally comment on writing reviews, trying to get them to look at your work and help you with it is beyond the scope of this forum.
 
Sorry dude but you can't use SDN for what is basically homework help.

You might go to the research forum to ask a more general question on how to read/interpret/write reviews but I highly doubt you'll get much traction. This is the kind of stuff that you learn from class and from your mentors. Aside from getting someone to generally comment on writing reviews, trying to get them to look at your work and help you with it is beyond the scope of this forum.

These are not homework papers, they were already submitted as extra credit for my class and my question relates to the quality of the papers to be used as part of my application packet when applying.
 
I'm not sure, so I'll just share my opinion (take it for what it's worth).

I would not submit anything shy of a peer-reviewed paper, meaning one that you actually submitted to a journal.

Agreed, this will not count as "research", although there is a scholarly aspect to it.

Indeed, people do get published in major journals after completing an exhaustive review of the current literature. However, while this is peer-reviewed, it doesn't represent "original research" - which is I believe what most medical school are looking for when they talk about "research".
 
These are not homework papers, they were already submitted as extra credit for my class and my question relates to the quality of the papers to be used as part of my application packet when applying.

Do you mean that you want to cite these in your application similar to the way someone would if they published in a journal? That won't probably work. However, rereading your OP, it seemed to me like the professor wanted to use these reviews as a way for him to write you a better LOR. In that case, the Adcom would never need to see these reviews since it would only be used by your professor.

Sorry for originally misunderstanding 👍
 
These are not homework papers, they were already submitted as extra credit for my class and my question relates to the quality of the papers to be used as part of my application packet when applying.

I understand that. "Support your application" packet is rather vague? "Support" implies there is an argument you are backing-up with these papers (which I have admittedly not read yet). If you are applying to a program that is research-intensive, and requires research experience, then these will not support your application.

If, instead you want to support the argument that you are capable of self-directed and scholarly work, then...maybe. There is a semantics issue here: "research" in the pre-medical admissions world means something very specific. It is reserved for a particular type of research. While not fair, please be aware that there is some danger in trying to call these papers -no matter how well written - "research papers" in your application. This is because there is an expectation that many (if not most) admission folk have for "research papers" - and these do not meet that.
 
good points, I agree that I do not want to present these as "research" papers.

Would the term "academic papers" be more appropriate?

I spent a good deal of time on these and being a sub-par GPA wise I am looking for extra's to help boost up my chance of admittance.
 
good points, I agree that I do not want to present these as "research" papers.

Would the term "academic papers" be more appropriate?

I spent a good deal of time on these and being a sub-par GPA wise I am looking for extra's to help boost up my chance of admittance.

Here are a few quotes from an actual committee member:

Publications are often used as evidence that you have been engaged in research and have seen a successful project through to its logical conclusion: comunication of your results in writing to other investigators.

A review article only shows that you know how to read the literature and synthesize/summarize it. I would not find it as impressive as publication of original research.

What you are doing might be called a review of the literature.... are you using original source material (e.g. journal articles about original research)?

If you were a history major doing library research and using source documents to analyze a historic event or person, then you could call it research... it is more of a stretch in the natural sciences.

I would not recommend putting that on the AMCAS application as a research experience, if that is what you are asking.
 
Even if you wanted to include them, how would you include the papers themselves? You can't really cite them if they're just class assignments (even extra credit assignments).
 
Are you suggesting that you would up-load them as supplemental materials or bring them with you to interviews as other folks might bring a reprint of a journal article?

:nono:

The benefit you got out of these is whatever your professor wrote about them when he wrote your LOR. He was a wise professor who wanted to have something substantial to say about your skills as a writer, and your willingness to take on an additional assignment, and your ability to understand a topic more thoroughly than can be assessed in the usual classroom assignments.
 
As part of my organic class, my teacher suggested that anyone interested in going to graduate or medical schools write 2 short research papers. That way, when asked for recommendation letters he will have a good baseline to write a letter based on our classwork and these papers in particular.

Our papers are supposed to be "reviews" of a published research paper. We are also tasked with bringing in outside, referenced sources into these papers. I was graded highly on both however that doesn't mean that a admission committee will agree on their quality.

I want to make sure these papers are on par for submission with my application packets for the 2012 admission. Any opinions on how I did on these?

Any suggestions or comments are welcomed, especially from people with experience in the admission process.

Files are attached below.

Unless you submit them to a peer reviewed journal they don't really mean anything
 
In the Emergency Department and Pre-Hospital
setting overdosing by patients is a fairly common
occurrence. I have personally witnessed numerous
overdosing patients what usually involves excessive use
of ethanol, and prescription drugs such as barbiturate
(ex. Phenobarbital) , benzodiazepines (ex. valium) or
opiates (ex. morphine ). Acetaminophen overdosing ,
while common, is not as easy to recognize and can be
extremely life threatening . Often it is used in
conjunction with other common medications, as
mentioned above , medications by patients who may
accidently and purposely misuse acetaminophen and
other medications.
The early realization and treatment of an
acetaminophen overdose is key to the patients long
term health and depending on the dosage taken key to
their short term survival.
Acetaminophen is a widespread over the
counter usage drug, designed for relief of headaches,
migraines, fevers, aches and pains. It has very little anti
-coagulation activity unlike aspirin. As it is an over the
counter drug and its wide range of ability to negate
pain, it is a common drug for patients to either
mistakenly or purposely overdose on, giving rise to the
usage of N-Acetylcysteine to counteract the damaging
effects of acetaminophen.

It seems nobody so far has read your papers. I only looked at the first one, and I'll be blunt. It can only hurt you if you show it to anyone. There are many grammatical mistakes and awkward phrases. The document has many typographical/stylistic mistakes like extra space around punctuation. The spacing and fonts of the text, headings, and figures is very inconsistent (you made this in Publisher?), making it look unprofessional. The content of the paper contains information that is largely irrelevant to a review of a clinical research paper, like the molecular formula of glutathione. It does not demonstrate that you have a working knowledge of the clinical literature that's specifically relevant to this paper. Some of the observations you make, such as the paragraph praising the large sample size, are basic, as if directed at an audience with minimal understanding of how research works. It doesn't show that you have an advanced, critical understanding of the study.

Also, you chose a paper from 1988 and did not discuss what the impact of the paper has been on the field (e.g. any of the 162 articles that cite this article).
 
Last edited:
thanks for reviewing some of the paper. Its true that I made the paper easier to digest for non-medically inclined people. I also picked a study from a while back because I didnt find any dissenting articles that would severely contradict the paper itself.

to your point about grammar and sentence structure I actually had it reviewed by english professors at my college and I re-wrote it based on their instructions. Since I am not very good at "proper" grammar etc if it reads poorly then i cant take full credit on that haha..
 
Also to your point about Glutathione, from my research the entire reason why acetomenphen overdosing is so deadly is that it interferes with the production of Glutathione in the liver. This molecule is extremely important to the health of mammals.

"Mice that were born without the ability to produce only the liver version as shown to be dead within 1 month. Scott N. et al. (2007)"
 
Also to your point about Glutathione, from my research the entire reason why acetomenphen overdosing is so deadly is that it interferes with the production of Glutathione in the liver. This molecule is extremely important to the health of mammals.

"Mice that were born without the ability to produce only the liver version as shown to be dead within 1 month. Scott N. et al. (2007)"

my point was that nobody needs to know about how many carbons are in one molecule of glutathione.
 
thanks for reviewing some of the paper. Its true that I made the paper easier to digest for non-medically inclined people. I also picked a study from a while back because I didnt find any dissenting articles that would severely contradict the paper itself.

to your point about grammar and sentence structure I actually had it reviewed by english professors at my college and I re-wrote it based on their instructions. Since I am not very good at "proper" grammar etc if it reads poorly then i cant take full credit on that haha..

I read the first article that you submitted and I have to agree with the previous poster - this is really not the type of writing that is usually looked for. From the style and the tone of your work, it seems as if you haven't had a lot of exposure to medical journals (or any others, for that matter). Journal article submissions are written in a very noticeable way and I think that, with time and exposure, we tend to develop that style.

If you are genuinely interested in doing original research, see if anyone in your department is working in an area you find interesting and ask them if you can get involved. The goal of research shouldn't just be as a way to pad your med school application - if you aren't interested in the work itself, then don't waste the PI or your time. Also, I suspect that admissions officers that ask you about your research in an interview are probably fairly adept at determining whether or not you did the work because you enjoyed it or because you thought you needed to in order to increase your chances of getting into medical school.