whatchamacalit,
your biggest backlash seemed to be against me saying that pitt was a "wonderful school" which you quoted me on, despite the fact that I never said anything like that. The closest I came was "I have gotten the impression that pitt has a very coherent and forthcoming philosophy," skewing that to "wonderful school" is, at best, quite a reach.
About the numbers I used, this time I'll site them, out of this years MSAR pitt intervied 1016 total of 4786 applicants, including 793 out of staters. Also we agree about 100 interviews given out is a fair estimate, but you count that as 100 acceptances, which I think is hasty.
I did receive an interview from pitt, and it was based on my numbers (since I hadn't gotten a secondary yet), I don't deny that. Further, you may very well be right, I have not interviewd at pitt yet, I don't know how true their propaganda will seem when I can evaluate it in person. However, you have not interviewed their either (correct?). And thus your opinion is as uninformed as mine. The difference is that I have not jumped to any conclusions, one way or the other. I think that the manner in which pitt presents itself is unique and clearly makes it stand out. I think that some of those stories on interviewfeedback.com are clearly very sketchy (esp. the one about the dean offering admission if he/she dropped all other apps.). If I get this slimy impression when I go to pitt then that will obviously outweigh their biased propaganda.
You seem to be on a crusade against pitt, and while you like to scrutinize my knowledge of the school (which I admit to be quite small), you refuse to examine your own knowledge. Do I think it's odd to give some interviews based soley on numbers? of course. But is that really enough information to condemn the school as only concerned with numbers? probably not.
I understand your point, and I was in no way attacking the validity of your application (you don't need to defend yourself saying you have an interview at columbia). But also remember that you don't know why any school is offering you an interview.
ok enough time wasted, I'll let you know what my impression of pitt is after sept 17th, until then, I'll suspend judgement.