Hello,
Thanks for taking the time to do this. It's great to hear that you and your cohort were successful in your applications. My questions are as follows:
1) How does Scripps compare to other similar programs like Bryn Mawr, Goucher, etc? One thing I've heard is that from Bryn Mawr, med schools look upon the name favorably and it may give you a shot at schools that you wouldn't otherwise consider thanks to the name brand. I was wondering if Scripps has similar, unofficial ties to med schools that could provide a boost, or whether med schools aren't as aware of the Scripps name. If not, do you think there are other factors that make the cost of attending the Scripps program worth it?
2) Speaking of costs, how was the cost of living in the Scripps area? And if I want to volunteer / do research, would I have to have a car? One thing that concerns me is that the Scripps tuition is already $10K+ more expensive than others, and I'm sure adding the COL of LA would increase the difference. I've also heard that the MCAT prep costs extra.
3) How was the advising? Was there a lot of help on applications and interview prep?
4) How did people in your and recent cohorts do in gaining acceptance to the more competitive medical schools, such as the UCs or other top schools? I know there are linkages to Pitt and UMich, but I'm curious about the top schools outside of that. The reason I ask is that I am interested in certain MD schools that have strong research, and some of them seem to belong in the competitive category.
5) Overall, what are your overall impressions of the program and your classmates?
Thank you again for your time and sharing valuable insight.
Hey, sure thing.
1. When it comes to the somewhat esoteric world of premed career changer postbaccs there are a handful of prestigious options. The most successful postbaccs are Bryn Mawr, Goucher, Scripps, and Johns Hopkins. Johns Hopkins is prestigious but brutal. They pit the classmates against each other, and it caters to gunners, but if that’s an environment that you think you can do well in then go for it. They have very successful graduates that go on to get accepted to great medical schools. Scripps, Bryn Mawr, and Goucher are all about equal in prestige. Some people argue that some are better than others. I always thought that Bryn Mawr felt a little more prestigious but my classmates in medical school who went there thought that Scripps was more prestigious (small class size). Honestly, it’s neither here nor there. All three of those programs are well regarded and have very good relationships with medical schools all over the county. They are tantamount to the Ivy league and Stanford of postbaccs.
As far as Scripps specifically goes, yes there are numerous official and unofficial ties. Deans of admission at top medical schools (Duke, Rodchester, BC, Vanderbilt) all visited and gave presentations, and then would have lunch with the class afterwards. Since the class is only about 16 people you really get one on one time with them. When it came time to interview, the dean of admission at my medical school knew me by name. The linkage agreements are evidence of strong ties to medical schools. Any program that has linkage agreements means that they have a close personal connection with medical schools. Linkage agreements are pretty opaque and difficult to understand from the outside. There are a lot of subtle things that you can’t read about from a program’s website. For example, Scripps has less linkage agreements than Bryn Mawr but they also have less students. At Scripps there will be years that no one applies through a linkage, and years where there are two or three students applying to the same linkages. However, at Bryn Mawr you can have up to 10 students competing for the same linkage spot. There are also minimal restrictions to the linkages at Scripps. I think most of the people who linked in my class had at least an A- or two when they applied. I was surprised to learn from my Bryn Mawr friends that an A- there disqualifies you from applying for a linkage.
2. Cost of living was honestly not that bad. I found a place through the 5Cs housing website. It was a room in a nice house with a bunch of med students. I shopped at Walmart and El Super and tried not to eat out a lot. It really wasn’t bad, especially for LA area. But Southern California being Southern California, you will need a car. I had a few classmates who went it without one. They rode their bikes or lived within walking distance, but pretty much everyone else had a car. One guy tried taking the bus every day, and after summer chemistry he was so exacerbated he broke down and got a car.
I’m not sure what other program costs are now; I think most of them are pretty similar. Last I looked Scripps was like 3 or 4 thousand more than Bryn Mawr. The MCAT course sort of depends, you can choose not to take it but it’s highly recommended that you do. It’s like an extra thousand, but last I heard all the postbaccs pitched in and got Kaplan to hand design them a postbacc MCAT course. So, you’ll be facing the same situation now wherever you go.
The big thing you should take away about cost is this. Postbaccs are expensive, medical school is MUCH more expensive. Don’t make a big financial decision based on three thousand dollars in difference over a postbacc. Make yourself competitive and use that to get scholarships in medical school. I got a 60% scholarship for where I went, and I don’t think I could have done that without having gone to Scripps. The way I looked at it going in was: I can try to save money and go to a cheaper postbacc/ community college and risk not getting into medical school at all, or I can make sure that I get into medical school and just spend the extra cash. I’m very happy I did the latter.
3. The advising was amazing. I don’t think I’ve ever had as much help as I got at Scripps. The class size is very small on purpose. It’s all overseen by the director, DeEttra. She is fantastic. She’s nice, gentle, and blunt when she needs to be. She will tell you what you need to do and what you should not do. She walked me through courses I was struggling in, MCAT prep, and applications, and on top of that she reaches out to the contacts she has at every medical school you apply to and makes them aware that you are a Scripps student and they should keep an eye out for you. I remember a few years ago there was a student who had a really rough semester in college that was caused by a family situation, but they had concealed that situation from Scripps and the medical schools they were applying to. They were having a rough application cycle, and the director sat down with them and got them to tell her the story about what had happened. She sent out an email to her contacts at the medical schools that the student was applying to, and relayed the story to them. Within a month the student had multiple interviews and an acceptance.
That’s the reason that you pay the extra money to go to one of the reputable postbaccs, because you have advisors that can do something like that.
4. I would say that recent classes have done pretty well. Every year they send about a quarter/half of the cohort to UC schools. The last two years each sent a student to USUHS. Off the top of my head I can think of students who went to Georgetown, Emory, Vanderbilt, Duke, some others. This past year had a student who got a full ride to UCLA. The year before had a full ride to Michigan. The tricky part about research is that big research schools typically don’t like postbaccs as much because you are probably going to lack the research experience they’re looking for. If you’re kind of set on that then you’ll probably have to put in some extra work to round that out wherever you end up going. A good option might be going to Scripps and linking to Pitt (Pitt loves research).
The thing about being interested in going to more competitive medical schools is that frequently people don’t take things into account. It’s not like choosing an undergrad school. When you apply to medical school the medical school chooses you. Weird things come out of medical school application cycles. I had a friend who wanted to go to a low ranked state school. They didn’t even interview him, but he got accepted to an Ivy League school….
Scripps has a lot of Californian students (obviously) and there is a huge bias against Californians in medical school admissions. They got burned by too many applicants sitting on acceptances and then turning them down at the last minute to stay in California. So, the majority of competitive schools that Scripps graduates go to are UCs. If you are trying to go to a UC, then Scripps is your best bet. If you are looking at something in the Pitt/ Michigan range, then any program with linkages to those kinds of schools is a good option. If you are trying to go to an Ivy League, then any of the big post baccs will be the best thing you can do (Bryn Mawr or Johns Hopkins might be better, but I really don’t know). But overall, I would caution you against aiming too high. Applying to medical school is different than applying to undergrads and being a nontraditional applicant or a Californian does weigh into those admission decisions. You should also note that many postbaccs who get into competitive schools have other things going for them besides just going to that postbacc. My program had students with law degrees, PhDs, Ivy League grads, Fulbright scholars, and high ranking officers in the military. These things make those applicants jump out of an application when applying to competitive schools. A big name postbacc just supplements it.
The last piece of advice I would give you is that it doesn’t matter where you go to medical school. Nobody cares once you are out. An MD is an MD is an MD. Unless you are trying to run the CDC then all of it is the same once you are in residency. Some may disagree, but I would go to medical school wherever you can minimize your debt the most.
5. I loved the program and I loved my classmates. You form a very close bond with each other because of the high stress nature of the year, as well as how small the cohort is. I still keep in touch with my classmates even now that we are scattered all over the country. A one-year postbacc is a very difficult thing. It transforms you into the kind of student that you need to be to get through medical school and introduces you to the kinds of sacrifices that you will need to make as a physician. I was not the same student coming out as I was going in, and I don’t think that I could have handled medical school without having done this.
A lot of postbacc programs know how much the workload is and they don’t care. They take your money and throw you to the wolves. They are not concerned with their reputations or success rates, and they only use the program as a source of revenue. Scripps was not like that for me. I felt helped and supported the entire way through. On the most stressful days I was able to pause and remind myself that essentially everyone who went through this came out the other end and went to medical school. It was comforting to know that this was a tried and true process and I had guidance along the way.
I hope that answers your questions. Feel free to ask me anything else and best of luck interviewing.