SDN WW Thread

[Chillbo Baggins]

Advertisement - Members don't see this ad

There's a whole lot of smoke in here. But instead of being a fire, I think it's just a fog machine.

I have no strong leads or convictions one way or the other. I will go with

Lynch SnS

 

[Chillbo Baggins]

36 minutes until deadline!


Unofficial Lynch Tally

SnS - 3 (Dwin, DocE, Chillbo)
Philliab - 1 (TRH)
TRH - 2 (WS, DVMD)
Chillbo - 1 (Lupin)
Dwin - 1 (MrsSOV)
jdh - 2 (dyachei, devyn)
devyn - 1 (EC)
TV - 1 (SnS)
Lupin - 1 (Philliab)
Haxx - 1 (Lissa)
SOV - 1 (LIS)
Lissa - 3 (FFM, SOV, allieh)
MrsSOV - 1 (TV)
LIS - 1 (Haxx)
FFM - 1 (Cyndia)

21/28 votes cast

Role call: @hedgiehog @SummerTheLynx @swingnsave @kaydubs @Abney @WhtsThFrequency @jdh71

 

[Lissarae06]

Unlynch haxx, lynch sns

 

[kaydubs]

Aw man, Chillbo. I was just working on the tally. Lynch MrsSOV

 

[Cyndia]

Newbieness or Cyndia playing a newb? My radar is confuzzled.

Nah mannn I've been around for a while so I'm not really a noob, I just didn't have an account because I was too shy to post. I prefer to just read what others have to say y'know.

 

[DVMDream]

unlynch TRH, lynch Lissa

This somewhat quick jump to SnS feels off. Especially when there really is little explanation of this whole thing going on with hSDN. So the one group blocked the other group's ability. And DocE is mentioning some crap from the mod that makes zero sense and to be perfectly honest I am not sure I believe since he makes ****e up out of thin air all the time, just to get people to vote his way. So until there is better explanation, I find the lynch to be odd as of right now.

 

[Philliab]

I have no clue if SnS is a wolf or not.....no clue of her role. But in this game, wouldn't the person with the role of SnS be the wolf and not necessarily SnS? That seems way too easy.

 

[thedrjojo]

This is too much fun guys. Even if the rest of the game sucks, it's already a success

 

[WhtsThFrequency]

I have no clue if SnS is a wolf or not.....no clue of her role. But in this game, wouldn't the person with the role of SnS be the wolf and not necessarily SnS? That seems way too easy.

I'm on this wavelength. And if there is evidently a chaos character, I bet it is whoever is WTF, heh.

 

[StartingoverVet]

Hey Doc,
Time is always fleeting….

I personally am confused by the lack of defense put up by any of the candidate… SnS, Lissa, and LIS.
SnS has not been feeling well but she did check in

SnS told me her role name. Have no idea of any abilities. It is definitely someone in the game.
Could it be a wolf? Why not?

I am inclined to leave my vote as it is…. They both seem so blasé, it seems artificial to me.

That is all I have to teach you today.
Good luck at the tourney. Remember to breath.

 

[StartingoverVet]

I'm on this wavelength. And if there is evidently a chaos character, I bet it is whoever is WTF, heh.

Hidden meanings are always rife in life.

 

[that redhead]

I'm on this wavelength. And if there is evidently a chaos character, I bet it is whoever is WTF, heh.

Either WTF or FFM as chaos, I think.

And yeah, the lynch of SnS seems too quick and easy. I think the person whose role is SnS would be the wolf. SnS could still be a wolf, of course, but my feeling is not.

 

[WhtsThFrequency]

Hmm. Think both the Sns and Lissa ones seem a bit forced and/or quick. Lynch Phil.

 

[wolfspeaker]

I'd be up for lynching the Chaos person.

 

[that redhead]

I should say, the person whose role is SnS seems like they would be a wolf. Until we get our first one, we're kind of in the dark as to who would be a wolf.

 

[DocEspana]

our groups power implies that it should block the entire group. aka, all the players. SOV's claim that it only blocked the group power is the first we heard of it, and sort of seems odd in the total lack of anyone from that group backing him up, and him admittng that his power was blocked "coincidentally"

 

[Lupin21]

Hey Doc,
Time is always fleeting….

I personally am confused by the lack of defense put up by any of the candidate… SnS, Lissa, and LIS.
SnS has not been feeling well but she did check in

SnS told me her role name. Have no idea of any abilities. It is definitely someone in the game.
Could it be a wolf? Why not?

I am inclined to leave my vote as it is…. They both seem so blasé, it seems artificial to me.

That is all I have to teach you today.
Good luck at the tourney. Remember to breath.

Now look here. "Lissa" has been working her a$$ of in clinics, publishing papers, and taking care of you two problem children all day. All she wants to do is enjoy her steak dinner with her man in celebration of another successful day.

 

[DocEspana]

Hey Doc,
Time is always fleeting….

I personally am confused by the lack of defense put up by any of the candidate… SnS, Lissa, and LIS.
SnS has not been feeling well but she did check in

SnS told me her role name. Have no idea of any abilities. It is definitely someone in the game.
Could it be a wolf? Why not?

I am inclined to leave my vote as it is…. They both seem so blasé, it seems artificial to me.

That is all I have to teach you today.
Good luck at the tourney. Remember to breath.

It is for wisdom like this that I have sworn to turn over a new leaf and turn over all my trust to you (haha. should lynch myself for that).

You speak amazing words of wisdom sensei. I must meditate on them.

 

[DVMDream]

I have good reason to believe the SnS role is NOT a wolf in this game.

 

[Philliab]

our groups power implies that it should block the entire group. aka, all the players. SOV's claim that it only blocked the group power is the first we heard of it, and sort of seems odd in the total lack of anyone from that group backing him up, and him admittng that his power was blocked "coincidentally"

I did back his claim! The mod PM clearly stated that only the group action was blocked.

 

[DVMDream]

our groups power implies that it should block the entire group. aka, all the players. SOV's claim that it only blocked the group power is the first we heard of it, and sort of seems odd in the total lack of anyone from that group backing him up, and him admittng that his power was blocked "coincidentally"

Nobody from that group is saying much of anything except SOV. So how can you say that no one is backing him up. No one is contradicting him either. I don't know, not saying it isn't right, but it is still like stabbing a knife somewhere in the dark amongst that group and hope it sticks. I know other people were blocked. There is also protection out there. Also, I would think for the wolf kill to be blocked the wolves would have to pick one person among them to do the killing, which does not happen in every game.

 

[wolfspeaker]

Nobody with the Chaos? Yes, no maybe so?

 

[DocEspana]

I did back his claim! The mod PM clearly stated that only the group action was blocked.

This is what I was waiting for. Did I miss it before?

 

[Lupin21]

It is for wisdom like this that I have sworn to turn over a new leaf and turn over all my trust to you (haha. should lynch myself for that).

You speak amazing words of wisdom sensei. I must meditate on them.

While I love that you two are getting along, you will be going to bed soon and reading Dr. Freud's literature to gain wisdom from him, not SOV.

 

[StartingoverVet]

our groups power implies that it should block the entire group. aka, all the players. SOV's claim that it only blocked the group power is the first we heard of it, and sort of seems odd in the total lack of anyone from that group backing him up, and him admittng that his power was blocked "coincidentally"

Grasshopper, our GROUP message from the mods said the group power was blocked. That has been confirmed by Phil and mrssov can chime in (she is eating next to me right now as I write this).. not sure why the other 2 are not saying anything.

It said, my blocking was by A MODERATOR! I was put on post hold, so I can't PM. That is where my suspicion of moderators comes from.

Between Phil and SnS. I would be more suspicious of SnS

 

[DocEspana]

Nobody from that group is saying much of anything except SOV. So how can you say that no one is backing him up. No one is contradicting him either. I don't know, not saying it isn't right, but it is still like stabbing a knife somewhere in the dark amongst that group and hope it sticks. I know other people were blocked. There is also protection out there. Also, I would think for the wolf kill to be blocked the wolves would have to pick one person among them to do the killing, which does not happen in every game.

as I said. No one is *backing him up*. Until Philliab right now. Stark and total silence on something is as relevant as a rebuke when at least two people have asked multiple times for anyone to corroborate and its been a constant topic brought up all day.

 

[StartingoverVet]

This is what I was waiting for. Did I miss it before?

Yes you did grasshopper. Concentration.. you must learn focus.

 

[DocEspana]

as I said. No one is *backing him up*. Until Philliab right now. Stark and total silence on something is as relevant as a rebuke when at least two people have asked multiple times for anyone to corroborate and its been a constant topic brought up all day.

I should stress.... phil speaking up shuts me up.

As always, you are a step ahead, sensei

 

[Philliab]

SOV mentioned it, but it's worth repeating. Only the hSDN group action was blocked per the mod's PM. (I had to double check that myself.) So just because the group was blocked doesn't necessarily point to a wolf being in the group, because nothing the mod said made me believe that individual night actions were blocked. (I'm sure other group members can confirm that.)

This is what I was waiting for. Did I miss it before?

There you go.

 

[dyachei]

Grasshopper, our GROUP message from the mods said the group power was blocked. That has been confirmed by Phil and mrssov can chime in (she is eating next to me right now as I write this).. not sure why the other 2 are not saying anything.

It said, my blocking was by A MODERATOR! I was put on post hold, so I can't PM. That is where my suspicion of moderators comes from.

Between Phil and SnS. I would be more suspicious of SnS

blocking isn't usually wolfy...

 

[MrsSOV]

as I said. No one is *backing him up*. Until Philliab right now. Stark and total silence on something is as relevant as a rebuke when at least two people have asked multiple times for anyone to corroborate and its been a constant topic brought up all day.

I got the same message from Jojo saying the group's action on DocE was blocked.

 

[Lupin21]

blocking isn't usually wolfy...

I disagree, but the problem is there is usually one on both sides of the table.

 

[DocEspana]

blocking isn't usually wolfy...

There is pretty much always a wolf blocker nowadays.
And, not that anyone but jdh or jojo cares, but except in the very end game, a blocker (even as a villager) hurts the villagers. When balancing games you add blockers to the villager side to help the wolves out.

 

[Dwindlin]

I will happily switch if someone else has a better lynch to put forward.

 

[dyachei]

There is pretty much always a wolf blocker nowadays.
And, not that anyone but jdh or jojo cares, but except in the very end game, a blocker (even as a villager) hurts the villagers. When balancing games you add blockers to the villager side to help the wolves out.

nah, there is almost ALWAYS a villager blocker and not always a wolfy one. So I stand by the fact that usually, not wolfy. And blockers can be very beneficial to villagers.

 

[Flim Flam Man]

Hey Doc,
Time is always fleeting….

I personally am confused by the lack of defense put up by any of the candidate… SnS, Lissa, and LIS.
SnS has not been feeling well but she did check in

SnS told me her role name. Have no idea of any abilities. It is definitely someone in the game.
Could it be a wolf? Why not?

I am inclined to leave my vote as it is…. They both seem so blasé, it seems artificial to me.

That is all I have to teach you today.
Good luck at the tourney. Remember to breath.

*breathe

Had to do it. It was bugging me.

 

[wolfspeaker]

I will happily switch if someone else has a better lynch to put forward.

Too late. It's deadline.

 

[Chillbo Baggins]

Unless JoJo is feeling very generous, votes are locked in. By my count, we have a tie between Lissa and SnS.

 

[DocEspana]

nah, there is almost ALWAYS a villager blocker and not always a wolfy one. So I stand by the fact that usually, not wolfy. And blockers can be very beneficial to villagers.

Ive already made games without a villager blocker but with a wolf blocker. And I think you would be hard pressed to find a recent game without a blocking wolf

 

[StartingoverVet]

blocking isn't usually wolfy...

Like my student says.. it goes both ways.

but it is the wording that makes me think it.
why say "a moderator" blocked you? Why tell me the person's "position'? Maybe it was meant to mislead, but it wasn't just, you were blocked. I
And I was put on "post-hold" which is what SDN moderators do (it said I posted dirty pictures or something…sound familiar? )....

 

[dyachei]

Ive already made games without a villager blocker but with a wolf blocker. And I think you would be hard pressed to find a recent game without a blocking wolf

yes, but just because you've made a game without one doesn't mean that it is standard for these games...

 

[Lissarae06]

I have been with my parents the lat couple hours. When your dad says he wants to but you clothes, you quit playing ww and shop!

 

[DocEspana]

yes, but just because you've made a game without one doesn't mean that it is standard for these games...

Just sort of commenting on game mechanics; lets put the odds of a blocker being a wolf aside (I argue its 50% or ever so slightly more, you argue slightly less. We both agree that honestly.. its probably very close to 50% anyway). Even 'villager' blockers will hurt the villagers chances of winning over time*. Thats the math of the game

*= versus killing a random villager. Obviously who dies instead matters, but generally its better to be wrong and kill a villager blocker than defend someone who is a blocker since they arent actually helping the villagers all that much anyway

 

[Lissarae06]

unlynch TRH, lynch Lissa

This somewhat quick jump to SnS feels off. Especially when there really is little explanation of this whole thing going on with hSDN. So the one group blocked the other group's ability. And DocE is mentioning some crap from the mod that makes zero sense and to be perfectly honest I am not sure I believe since he makes ****e up out of thin air all the time, just to get people to vote his way. So until there is better explanation, I find the lynch to be odd as of right now.

The lynch against me formed a lot quicker than the SnS lynch

 

[dyachei]

Just sort of commenting on game mechanics; lets put the odds of a blocker being a wolf aside (I argue its 50% or ever so slightly more, you argue slightly less. We both agree that honestly.. its probably very close to 50% anyway). Even 'villager' blockers will hurt the villagers chances of winning over time*. Thats the math of the game

*= versus killing a random villager. Obviously who dies instead matters, but generally its better to be wrong and kill a villager blocker than defend someone who is a blocker since they arent actually helping the villagers all that much anyway

eh. blockers can choose not to block though. so villager number wise, I do find fault with that.

 

[WhtsThFrequency]

Unless JoJo is feeling very generous, votes are locked in. By my count, we have a tie between Lissa and SnS.

Man, first day on the job and looks like I'm already gonna have to choose between two **** sandwich options....not particularly comfy with either of them.

 

[wolfspeaker]

So, if there is a tie i think both you @Lissarae06 and @shortnsweet can still plead your case. I believe there may be a tie-breaker out there.

 

[wolfspeaker]

Man, first day on the job and looks like I'm already gonna have to choose between two **** sandwich options....not particularly comfy with either of them.

Wait, are you saying you break ties now?

 

[WhtsThFrequency]

Actually, I only assumed I break ties, wasn't explicitly told....will wait for Jojo.

 

[devyn]

SnS is in bed sleeping most likely... so she will not be able to - it is late over here.....